Re:SpaceX concludes anomaly investigation, sets return to fl...
by mikeash on Monday January 02, 2017 @02:55PM
(#13303885)
I imagine that there are other ways to accomplish the same goal, as well, such as using other noble gasses. Helium provides the best cost/benefit tradeoff but surely other approaches would be practical if helium becomes unavailable.
Re:SpaceX concludes anomaly investigation, sets return to fl...
by wildcat55 on Tuesday January 03, 2017 @10:13AM
(#13309615)
How would you pressurize the liquid oxygen needed for the methane to burn?
Per the other comment, no other noble gas has a low enough boiling point to remain a gas at LOX temperatures...
Re:SpaceX concludes anomaly investigation, sets return to fl...
by Symmetry on Tuesday January 03, 2017 @10:27AM
(#13309720)
If you need to you can heat up the oxygen to increase it's volume until the pressure is correct. I forget the reason that it's easier to do with methane than oxygen but it's possible to do with oxygen too if you really need to. ULA's new ACES upper stage is planned to use autogenous pressurization for both it's oxygen and hydrogen tanks.
However even if we did somehow run out of Helium entirely, once SpaceX switches to Methane fuel (as they plan to do for the ITS) they won't need it anymore. Currently it's used to pressurize the tanks, but Methane does that for itself. It would mean speeding up development of 'small' methane launch vehicles presumably, but that's it.