Furthermore these pensions are gold plate: linked to inflation and guaranteed for life. We have 100s of thousands of middle tier public sector workers like teachers and council workers retiring every yesr with a guaranteed income stream that would cost millions if you were to buy the equivalent annuity.
How anyone thought this was sustainable or sensible blows my mind. It needs to stop.
you might think that the people responsible for providing the pensions would have taken the contributions that the workers made during their working life and invested that money for the future!
Unfortunately, that didn't happen. The UK government (who was the responsible party) made the decision to pay pensions out of future income rather than saving anything. It looked great on the balance sheet, since they could reduce taxes today and let somebody else look bad in the future.
One is the number of years people live after retirement. Another is that pensions (due to their terms) have outpaced wage growth significantly so current contributors can't fund them. Finally, a pension relative to final salary is difficult to fund from a percentage of mostly from early-mid career wages.
In the UK, many public sector organizations have been privatized. Early privatizations often took the pension liabilities with them. As the employees who were members of such schemes leave the scene and current organizations must choose between meeting obligations and making a profit, I expect to see the companies look to duck out of obligations perhaps by packaging obligations into a spinoff company and then watching it go bankrupt.
A lot of retirees I know are pulling money out of these schemes using the new option to take the money as cash. They then put the money into buy to let as a kind of annuity on the basis that even if they'd get more money from the scheme in the long run, they aren't a position to take that kind of a risk. Hope they have insurance.
Deciding on the breakdown of what percentage to allocate to each bucket and how many stocks from each category to use in your index would be an interesting debate to have though.
> Invested the money in what exactly?
Buying government debt seems a pretty safe bet. > There are police forces in the UK where 50%
> of their annual budgets is going to people
> who no longer work there
Source? In 2009 20% of policing costs in the UK went to pensions[0], which doesn't seem that particularly insane; has it really risen so much, or are there certain police forces that aren't representative due to shifting demographics? > Pensions should be funded from savings
> / investments made during working life
Perhaps, but I don't see the relationship between this and your previous point. > these pensions are gold plate: linked
> to inflation and guaranteed for life
So ... an inflation-linked annuity? How does that differ from most private pensions? Is there anything stopping you purchasing one? > teachers and council workers retiring
> every yesr with a guaranteed income
> stream that would cost millions if you
> were to buy the equivalent annuity
This also needs sourcing, as it also fails the sniff test and some simple Googling. Taking the example here[1], a relatively senior teacher, looks like she'll get an annual pension of ~£20,000 if she retires at 60, which is probably equivalent to a private annuity of £500,000.I for one welcome our post-truth overlords...
[0] https://www.moneymarketing.co.uk/lib-dems-reveal-police-pens...
[1] https://www.moneymarketing.co.uk/issues/29-october-2015/case...
There is the problem. I've had a 8% pension in the programming sector since I was 20, my projections are for £300,000 by age 67 and £10,000 retirement income.
Teachers get 12 weeks off a year and to retire 7 years earlier on double the pension.
Personally, I'm retraining to be a teacher.
Pension calculators from the likes of legal and general show that you need vast pension contributions to match public sector employees. To match a teacher it recommended I made a 15% contribution, is any private sector company offering that?
http://www.legalandgeneral.com/calculators/contributionCalc-...
There are very, very few people retiring from the private sector with pension pots worth this. And those that are probably fall into the "fat cat 1% elite" so derided by the left.
But I agree, "defined benefit" pensions are a thing of the past. There is a good BBC Radio Money Box show about it: http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b0713p7s
There's an easy way around that. "All existing pension-holders will continue receiving benefits as defined. All new public employees will receive investment-based retirement plans funded during their employment." Then existing pension-holders have no reason to vote against it. This also seems far more ethical, as it retains the guarantees given to existing recipients.
The company I worked for phased out its guaranteed-minimum-benefit retirement program, in favor of its standard investment-based retirement program, by doing exactly this: limiting eligibility based on initial hire date.
I agree though - cancelling plum benefits while grandfathering existing recipients is the only politically tractable approach.
How about the approach that was used in the 80s ? 20% year-on-year inflation for a while with the government lying about it saying it's 5% ? That "reduces" liabilities by 15% per year.
Also, many state pensions aren't that great compared to California, etc. Employees only get 40 to 50 percent of their former salaries under a lot of pensions. I've never understood how California can do 80% pensions. The Federal pensions have some very high percentage too (not sure what it is).
States that don't steal from the future (New York, Wisconsin, Oregon, the dakotas, Idaho, Tennessee) fund their pensions. States like Illinois, California and Massachusetts do not.
Pensions aren't a problem, bad governance is. It's easy to say that it is "obvious". But the obvious solutions come with non-obvious blowback.
What do you do when a 50 year old fireman throws out his back dragging a hose and ends up on disability for 15 years?
What do you do when a burned out policeman shoots someone accidentally or has a heart attack and gets a fellow Officer killed.
Alternatively if there are too many physically demanding posts make it more like the armed forces and get rid of most people between the 10-20 year mark with a smaller pension and assistance with finding new work. 50 is a terrible time to push people into a new career.
The usual scheme is that you are not punished for not showing up to work, but are paid overtime for taking someone else's shift. As a result, swapping shifts with someone results in a 50% pay increase for both of you. Together with other scams, the result may be even greater.
Furthermore, this would only address current employees and not the prior employees who never paid into social security and have nothing but their local pension to fund their elder years.
Washington does levy sales tax on clothing, but apparently so do most states.
So the sales tax is a bit above median, but doesn't seem any more regressive than other states per se. And is lower than California's.
Property taxes have more to do with it, I suspect, especially given the mess in California with those.
Do you mean the tax rate on new properties? Or the effective rate actually collected, given the restrictions on how much property taxes can rise, etc? I thought one problem in California was that the latter figure, which is the more relevant one, was very low as a result of Prop 13.
The other problem in California is that it just seems to not spend money very well, as far as I can tell...
CA basic rate is 7.5%, with many local add-ons (making San Jose 9% and San Leandro 10%, for two Bay Area examples)
'folly asked how Washington state raises revenue without income tax. 'redx00 and I answered. Do you disagree that sales (and real estate, and other taxes and fees other than income taxes) are how Washington state raises revenue?
Mostly spend it on Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid.
Paying for roads, teachers, police, freeways...
... $7 billion bridges...Right. Future generations are the ones paying the interest on them (and other government-issued debt).
> 2) Trying to make a moral case for stealing money from pensioners and giving it to the wealthy in the form of tax cuts is hard, but you tried your best.
I imagine you already know it, but I didn't say anything to this effect at all.
He did not say that, as you know. The usual argument in these cases is not to take away pensions from people who have earned them, but rather to cease offering this benefit going forward to new city employees.
One problem with government that is usually true is that it can grow, but it can't shrink. This applies to cost, workforce size, and benefits.
We're at a strange turning point right now. Pensions in the private sector have all but disappeared. Pensions in the public sector are alive and well because it doesn't need to be self sustaining, and by running huge deficits it can steal the money it needs today from future generations.
It's pretty obvious that cities and states should start eliminating pensions, but the beneficiaries of those same pensions are the people that need to do that. I'm not holding my breath for the right thing to happen here.
[1] Sorry if you're not in California. Your state/country may have similar open information.