News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AirPods are now available by jjuhl on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @02:28PM (#13169937)
To me these seem pretty stupid. Major features (to me) of ear-buds with wires and 3.5" jack are: 1) being attached with wires means I don't easily lose them when they slip out of my ear/hand/pocket. 2) the 3.5" jack actually keeps them pretty solidly attached to my phone (again, less risk of losing them). Walking around with two loose tiny objects seems less than ideal - at least to me; I'd lose them within days.
Re:AirPods are now available by pwthornton on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @04:37PM (#13171311)
You've never used an entire product category and you want to call it stupid? The first step to building good products is to understand how people use them.

Wireless headphones are about as stupid as wireless Internet.

Just like wired Internet, wired headphones will continue to have a place for people who need certain capabilities or ruggedness or etc., but for most people, wireless headphones are the way to go. Let me walk you through some of the advantages:

1. Working out. Wired headphones constantly get caught on things and sometimes get violently ripped from your ears. 2. Related to point one, any activity or job where you could risk a loose wire being caught is perfect for wireless headphones. It very well may be significantly safer. 3. Wireless headphones have bigger range than wires. You don't have to place your phone in your pants pockets, for instance, to use wireless headphones. You could even have your phone in your bag, and everything will still work. Much of women's fashion either has no pockets or pockets of little value. This is a major reason women carry around purses. But you can't use headphones with a phone in your purse, hence why women are often physically carrying their phones in your hands. With wireless headphones, they can keep their phone in their purse or jacket and still listen to music or respond to calls. 5. Or if you are doing something around the house, you don't always have to have your headphones on you at all times. This could be particularly useful if you are doing something like washing a car where you might get your pants wet and don't want to have your phone on you. 6. With this new class of wireless earbuds that are small and lightweight, you could keep one of two of them in much of your day to answer phone calls or ask Siri or Google questions.

Re:AirPods are now available by sooheon on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @11:54PM (#13173942)
I don't disagree with any of those points. But to me all of them are dwarfed by one thing: sound quality. Listening to the crap quality of apple buds is like connecting to a shitty CRT. Paying $160 for the privilege is just an added insult.

If you cared about watching beautiful movies, would you downgrade to a wireless display with grainy definition, because "no wires"? That's how I feel about audio quality, and why I'm not an apple or beats customer (and why I lament the iPhone7 headphone jack changes).

Of course time will help, and in a few years the sound quality streamed over wireless should be transparent, at which point I'd gladly convert.

Re:AirPods are now available by theshrike79 on Wednesday December 14, 2016 @06:22AM (#13175211)
None of the reviews I've read say the quality is "crap".

Or are you correlating your one experience with half a decade old BT headphones to current top of the line wireless? That's like saying all Wifi is shit because your PCMCI 802.11a Wifi card in 2005 had shit speeds and range.

Re:AirPods are now available by matwood on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @02:35PM (#13170042)
I used to think this way until I bought a pair of JLabs bluetooth ear buds. Now, I hate using wired headphones because the wire is literally always in the way. I hate being forced to keep my phone right next to me, and snake a wire around.

Now, in the gym, I can throw my phone in my gym bag and not worry about it while working out. I'll never go back to wired.

Re:AirPods are now available by seanwilson on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @02:49PM (#13170225)
> Now, in the gym, I can throw my phone in my gym bag and not worry about it while working out. I'll never go back to wired.

Exactly, doing anything active with wired headphones on isn't fun. They keep getting snagged in things and get pulled off your ears.

Re:AirPods are now available by maaaats on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @03:49PM (#13170846)
Don't think one can be too active with these ones, though. Looks like shaking your head will make them fall out. No silicon that shapes it to the ear, no over-ear stuff or anything that should make it sit.
Re:AirPods are now available by davidcelis on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @04:36PM (#13171304)
Many reviews have stated the opposite: that, despite the reviewers feeling like the airpods would fall out when in motions, they stayed in just fine despite shaking heads and jumping up and down.
Re:AirPods are now available by theshrike79 on Wednesday December 14, 2016 @06:24AM (#13175219)
Wired earphones fall out because the wire is pulling them out. These are wireless, so there's no added weight.

If your ears are ill-shaped for this style of earphone, then they might fall out.

Re:AirPods are now available by dragonwriter on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @04:32PM (#13171272)
> Exactly, doing anything active with wired headphones on isn't fun.

I do active things with wired headphones all the time, and they rarely get snagged on anything or pulled from my ear.

That said, not having to carry the device that provides the sound source is a convenience that's worth something (though nowhere near the additional cost of these over wired earbuds.)

Re:AirPods are now available by throwanem on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @03:01PM (#13170368)
I still use my HD558s on a very regular basis, including with my phone, but for mobile use that's actually mobile, I'm right there with you - Bluetooth devices do occasionally misbehave in ways that annoy me, but the enormous convenience of not being festooned with wires more than makes up for the occasional transient signal drop. Especially when I'm bundled up in three layers with my phone in my pocket, gloves on my hands, and a beanie or a balaclava on my head. Routing wires is a complex topological problem in these circumstances, and it's nontrivially convenient to just pop an earbud in my ear, start a podcast playing, and go.
Re:AirPods are now available by seanwilson on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @02:46PM (#13170190)
Bluetooth headphones are great. You don't have to worry about the wire snagging on things and getting in the way. Wires have been progressively eliminated everywhere else e.g. wireless networking, wireless mice, wireless keyboards, wireless phones...I'm not understanding why people are clinging to wireless headphones so hard.

Your risk of losing your headphones is really that high?

Re:AirPods are now available by ishields on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @04:23PM (#13171179)
For me it comes down to a few things. Bluetooth has some major downsides: First, you now have to charge your headphones or you can't use them. This is a HUGE downside when coming from something that literally never needs to be charged, I mean considering nothing else, would you rather have something that needs to be charged daily or something that never needs to be charged? Second, transmitting audio over bluetooth requires digital compression, which affects sound quality. For some this might not matter, but when I listen to music on headphones I want the highest level of quality. This is probably less of an issue for anyone considering airpods, as apple's headphones, even the wired ones, have never been great. Now the classic response to these points is "But just charge them at night, I never have to worry about it!" or "I can't even tell the difference in quality!" and these things may be true, however for me, if I'm sacrificing sound quality (even if it's minimal) and sacrificing unlimited "battery life" (in quotes because there is no battery life for wired headphones but you get the point) I better be getting something well worth it in return. In this case, that something is what, not having to plug my headphones in? Not having a wire connecting me to wherever the sound is coming from that literally never gets in my way except MAYBE very occasionally when working out? I'm sorry but that is absolutely nowhere NEAR worth the tradeoffs. It's not that I'm against bluetooth headphones, it's that the benefits do not outweigh the costs. How many times have you really found yourself genuinely bothered by wires on your headphones? I know for me the answer is almost never (realistically only when working out, which is the only situation where I'd even consider wireless headphones)
Re:AirPods are now available by seanwilson on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @04:34PM (#13171290)
When you can get bluetooth headphones that last 40 hours I don't see battery life as an issue.

Quality sounds fine to me as well. Are there any blind tests that show people can notice differences with Bluetooth? Even if the difference is slightly noticeable I doubt you would notice wearing headphones on the move, at the gym, in the office etc.

> How many times have you really found yourself genuinely bothered by wires on your headphones?

Multiple times a day. Any time you're doing anything active besides just walking (e.g. reaching for things, carrying something) or putting on a jacket the wire gets in the way. Getting them caught on a door handle and having in-ear headphones ripped out of your ears is really unpleasant.

Re:AirPods are now available by ishields on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @04:47PM (#13171408)
Which is better, unlimited "battery" or a 40 hour battery? It may not be a big issue for you, but for me that's a very significant tradeoff. And I haven't looked into studies but I have personally done multiple side by side comparisons of the same headphones/speakers connected via bluetooth vs wired and have yet to find a set where I was not able to notice a difference in the sound quality. For me, that's enough, but I'd encourage you to try it out yourself or seek out some studies (I haven't even bothered looking).

In the end it seems more of a question of which bothers you more:

1. degraded sound quality and drastically shorter (since one is unlimited) battery life or

2. having a wire from your headphones to your audio source.

For me, there's no question that 1. is more of an issue, for others, 2. is a bigger problem. I consider bluetooth an alternative to wired headphones but absolutely not a replacement since both have tradeoffs

Re:AirPods are now available by anonred on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @08:12PM (#13172953)
I think an apt analogy for the transition towards wireless audio is that of desktop to mobile computing. In the same way that mobile isn't an end-all to desktop computing for professionals, wireless headphones aren't meant as a replacement for everyone, such as audiophiles.

That said, I've personally tried a half-dozen wireless headphones over the past few months. I strongly feel that the technology has progressed to where the tradeoffs of battery life and sound quality are minimal for the general consumer.

Right now, price is probably the limiting factor in adoption. However, as the price decreases over the next 3 years, I think you'll find that wireless will become the primary means of audio consumption for the average Joe.

Re:AirPods are now available by sooheon on Wednesday December 14, 2016 @12:03AM (#13173979)
> Quality sounds fine to me as well

I would happily bet any amount of money that I can tell the difference between my nice pair of IEMs and the stock apple ones every time. It's not the bluetooth transmission that's the problem, it's the actual sound producing hardware. Customers like you dwarf customers like me, so Apple and Beats don't bother to produce great sounding phones beyond a certain point--it even appears AirPods have basically stock earphone sound quality.

I would love the convenience of AirPods, just upgraded with nicer drivers, and would be willing to pay $400 for them. There just isn't a big enough market, so I'm left feeling the pain of people that fall outside of Apple's inner circle.

This is even more perplexing to me because Apple consistently puts screen quality as a very high priority. I'm just flabbergasted at how much they could be dropping the ball for audio.

Re:AirPods are now available by dntrkv on Wednesday December 14, 2016 @01:42PM (#13178491)
A deaf person can tell the difference between nice IEMs and the stock apple ear phones. I don't think anyone is disputing that. Now take some nice bluetooth IEMs and compare them to similarly priced wired IEMs, then it gets a little more difficult. Bluetooth transmission is very much a problem when it comes to sound quality, since the audio needs to be compressed to send wirelessly.
Re:AirPods are now available by Cd00d on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @02:52PM (#13170271)
I like wireless headphones for the simple situation that I switch from podcasts on my phone to video on a kindle fire and back during my commute, and pairing with various devices from a variety of manufacturers seems like it would be very slow compared to popping the jack. Though, to be fair, I've never used wireless headphones (other than xbox), so don't know what the pairing process looks like. I just know that in the past cheap bluetooth speakers have been slow to match and sometimes forget that they're friends with my phone.
Re:AirPods are now available by andrewaylett on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @04:19PM (#13171137)
My headphones (Plantronics) will connect to two devices at the same time. The controls interact with whichever was playing more recently, and an existing stream takes priority over a new one. So I can quite happily stop my music from my phone and start up a call from my laptop, then switch back, without re-pairing at all.

If I did need to re-pair, it's as simple as picking the phone from the phone or laptop's recently-used devices list. I usually only have to do that if the phone has decided it wants to keep talking to my headphones while I'm in the car. Pairing from scratch with the phone is as simple as holding the phone to one of the ear cups, but I've only had to do that once and I can't remember which one now.

Re:AirPods are now available by ishields on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @04:26PM (#13171210)
It's less about the process of pairing being painful and more about the amount of time it takes to pair. I also use a plantronics headset sometimes and it usually takes somewhere from like 15-60 seconds to actually pair up and have audio coming through. Vs the 2 seconds it takes for me to plug in a wired pair
Re:AirPods are now available by andrewaylett on Wednesday December 14, 2016 @11:06AM (#13176995)
The Backbeat Pros have a "nice" start-up chime. If you push the play button while it's playing that, it'll start playing music once the chime ends. Less effort and delay than untangling the cable and plugging it in (which is an option: I still keep the cable in my bag).

I'm also enjoying auto-pause when I take the headphones off -- no more fiddling for the pause button when someone wants to talk to me.

Re:AirPods are now available by Eric_WVGG on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @04:29PM (#13171234)
1) I love it when that cord gets hooked on something and damn near rips my ears out.

2) I don't lose things.

This is like a guy leaving a negative review of feminine hygiene products. When a product designed for people with different needs and desires than yours, it’s not necessarily “stupid.”

Re:AirPods are now available by dzhiurgis on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @02:32PM (#13169994)
95% of cases when my headphones fall out is when I snag the cable.
Re:AirPods are now available by TeMPOraL on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @02:36PM (#13170054)
OTOH the cable has prevented my phone from hitting the ground many times.
Re:AirPods are now available by mypalmike on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @03:57PM (#13170919)
You can get a lanyard case if that's the feature you want.
Re:AirPods are now available by djrogers on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @07:26PM (#13172695)
That would be about 5% low for me. I've never had earbuds fall out without the 'help' of a cord...
Re:AirPods are now available by mikestew on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @02:47PM (#13170207)
To me these seem pretty stupid.

So IOW, you just don't like wireless headphones, whether Apple makes them or not. Thanks for sharing.

Re:AirPods are now available by HelloYComb on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @02:36PM (#13170061)
Makes perfect sense to me. I run about 4 days a week with my phone strapped to my arm. The current headphones cable wraps around my arm once or twice, and sometimes gets tangled mid-run.

It's a pet peeve of mine. Wireless is a good thing.

I don't need more than 2 hours tops when running, so the 5+ hour battery life is great.

I never had any problems with the current earphones slipping out of my ears while running - rain, wind, or shine. Airpods seem to follow a similar model, so I don't anticipate issues there either.

Re:AirPods are now available by Fnoord on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @05:37PM (#13171860)
I don't really see what these offer over say my Plantronics BackBeat Go 2 which lasts 4 hours. They're also connected to each other, going behind my neck. You may think that is a disadvantage, but I can easily have one in and one out if required. Besides, these Airpods don't solve the quality Bluetooth lacks. A disadvantage is you can already lose these easily (if disconnect both and keep hanging around). I don't even wanna think about Airpods and how easy they will be to lose.

Try putting your smartphone in a safe place, and have wired or wireless headset, and use some kind of smartwatch to control your phone and receive feedback on your performance. I use a Pebble 2 for that, but there's other alternatives available.

Bonus points is my phone is stored safely without saying to random strangers "rob me".

Re:AirPods are now available by Humdeee on Wednesday December 14, 2016 @01:09PM (#13178187)
I did 4 marathons last year along with 2,000km of running mileage, and if music is a must while you run, then at x4 a week, it's worth looking into for a better setup. Even a basic GPS watch with a separate cheap music player (look for a clipping one) and you'll be much more comfortable. Granted, this won't allow to send/receive texts or calls, but hopefully you can manage to disconnect from the world for 1-2 hours.

I don't come across too many even semi-consistent runners who take their phone with them. Most can't stand a big iPhone 6/7 or Samsung strapped to their arm like a piece of armor. I don't think these AirPods will improve the running-music duo at all. The technology doesn't quite cater to us yet. Lightweight, sturdier earbuds (check out yurbuds) with a cord under the shirt down to the waist isn't noticeable and is hard to beat.

Re:AirPods are now available by dntrkv on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @04:05PM (#13171013)
How do you think you will view this comment in 5 years when 90% of new ear buds sold are completely wireless? I'm guessing it will be similar to how people view Steve Ballmer's comments on the original iPhone.
Re:AirPods are now available by jjuhl on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @05:28PM (#13171775)
I'm fairly sure I won't care.
Re:AirPods are now available by sergiotapia on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @03:56PM (#13170908)
On the other hand, I signed up instantly because I need these things to go to the gym.

Right now I have some cheap headphones I bought at Ross and even if they're wireless, the little rubber headband is uncomfortable when I'm bench pressing.

These things are going to be magic!!!

Re:AirPods are now available by seiferteric on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @02:35PM (#13170041)
Headphones have actually saved my phone from falling on the ground many times :)
Re:AirPods are now available by anonred on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @03:02PM (#13170380)
Using aux cables as a kind of safety harness seems like pretty periphery use-case. Relevant xkcd: https://xkcd.com/1172/
Re:AirPods are now available by agumonkey on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @02:51PM (#13170245)
Can't speak about 1). Can't speak about 2) either; but HNers told me Apple did extensive testing to ensure pods would not fall while being in your ears (the physics hints that earplugs fall mainly because of wires).

Still 1) is a good question. I thought they came with a tiny casket, so they wouldn't fall out of your pocket like that. Still subtle when you remove them from your skull.

Re:AirPods are now available by throwanem on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @03:04PM (#13170403)
They come with a charging case which looks to be about the size of the little plastic spool-box of dental floss with which some here might be familiar. It's not very large, but shouldn't be small enough to easily drop out of a pocket without being noticed, either.

I'm not sure what I expect with regard to staying in ears, though. They appear to be closely modeled on the wired EarPods, which in my experience don't reliably stay in the ear on their own, to the point where they are best worn with the cable wound around the crease of the pinna - both for strain relief, and so that they're easier to recover and less likely to be damaged when they do inevitably pop out.

Re:AirPods are now available by agumonkey on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @03:07PM (#13170436)
Yeah when in that case, they wouldn't bounce randomly or too softly.
Re:AirPods are now available by robotresearcher on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @03:57PM (#13170913)
I like volume control, and play/pause/skip. I like and use them a lot. On these it seems you have to ask Siri to change the volume, which is awful, and ask Siri or take 'em out to pause.

Please someone tell em if this is not the case. I really want it to not be true.

Re:AirPods are now available by glimajr on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @02:36PM (#13170051)
I believe they are designed such that you cary the case around with you, which charges them when not in use. So hopefully, you won't lose them.

Granted, now you have to cary a hard plastic case in your pocket.

Re:AirPods are now available by eggoa on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @03:50PM (#13170861)
Someone just needs to sell accessory lanyards for them.
Re:AirPods are now available by elif on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @04:01PM (#13170971)
They attach magically to your croakies using only a $39 dongle.
Re:AirPods are now available by dionidium on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @04:23PM (#13171177)
Being attached with wires means they catch on something and are violently ripped from my ear at least a couple times a week.

I cannot overstate how angry this makes me. It's a very uncomfortable feeling. It can literally ruin an hour. I'd rather be randomly slapped by a stranger.

Re:AirPods are now available by ishields on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @04:29PM (#13171237)
Just out of curiosity, what type of situations cause this to happen to you? This literally has never happened to me except while working out, and workout time amounts to probably 5% or less of my headphone usage
Re:AirPods are now available by dionidium on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @04:56PM (#13171489)
Most commonly? Drawer handles in the kitchens at work and at home.

Second place: the corners of my desk (or maybe doorknobs). Basically, any protruding object in a tight space.

It's pretty unlikely to happen if you're sitting still, but it's routine if you wear them while moving around inside.

Re:AirPods are now available by dionidium on Wednesday December 14, 2016 @06:13PM (#13180657)
They got yanked out by the emergency brake as I was getting in my car earlier today. This can't just be me.