News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by grive on Monday December 12, 2016 @07:39AM (#13157612)
A somewhat less popular cultural reference could be The Road from McCarthy.

Human scavengers roaming what's left, true, but mostly famished and trying to find food before anything else.

Maybe this time is the time we will renew the fear of nuclear annihilation. With Trump elected, Europe is turning to itself for its defence, and is already considering a common nuclear deterrence. Depending on its implementation, this could mean the end of the non-proliferation treaties.

Time to watch Threads again.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by arethuza on Monday December 12, 2016 @07:43AM (#13157629)
A few years back I started watching Schindler's List and I decided I wanted to watch something a bit less depressing and stumbled onto an evening on Channel 4 that was showing The War Game, The Day After and then Threads.....

Edit: The War Game is worth watching - the BBC refused to show it as "the effect of the film has been judged by the BBC to be too horrifying for the medium of broadcasting":

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_War_Game

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by partisan on Monday December 12, 2016 @09:45AM (#13158329)
I made the mistake of watching The Day After a few years ago while not wanting to go to sleep one night. Suffice it to say, I didn't sleep well that night and I am still somewhat traumatized by it. It's my go to reference for life will be like after such an event. There's also been a lot of talk of EMPs lately and I have to imagine that the result would be something similar.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by DonHopkins on Monday December 12, 2016 @11:30AM (#13159286)
"The Americans" [1] had an eponymous episode (S04E09 "The Day After") [2] about the broadcast of "The Day After" [3] on November 20, 1983.

As portrayed in that episode, everybody watched it, everybody talked about it, and it changed how everybody thought about nuclear war.

I don't remember a thing about the TV event in the title of the previouis episode of "The Americans" (S04E08 "The Magic of David Copperfield V: The Statue of Liberty Disappears" [4]), but I sure remember seeing "The Day After" in 1983.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Americans_(2013_TV_series)

[2] http://www.avclub.com/tvclub/theres-got-be-day-after-america...

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Day_After

[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Statue_of_Liberty...

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by s_kilk on Monday December 12, 2016 @01:35PM (#13160507)
What a great film.

Radio Announcer: "Warsaw Pact forces are close to announcing a cease-fire along the German border. There are still no eyewitness accounts to substantiate the rumor that low-kiloton range nuclear weapons were detonated this morning during the conflict, resulting in the reported destruction of Wiesbaden and the outskirts of Frankfur..."

[electronic alarm cuts in]

EBS Announcer: "This is the Emergency Broadcast System. All persons currently in transit in the Kansas City metropolitan area are advised to proceed immediately to the municipal shelter facility in the community or township closest to your current location. While there is no immediate danger to the Kansas City area, the Federal Emergency Management Agency urges you to learn the steps to be taken in the event of a probable attack."

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by rebuilder on Monday December 12, 2016 @12:09PM (#13159664)
Don't watch Threads, then. It makes The Day After look sanitized in comparison.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by s_kilk on Monday December 12, 2016 @01:39PM (#13160555)
The money-shot:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MrHoMSRZOS4

(Warning: not for the faint of heart)

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by rebuilder on Monday December 12, 2016 @03:25PM (#13161598)
IMO it got much, much worse after that part.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by JonnieCache on Monday December 12, 2016 @07:44AM (#13157636)
Threads has to be the most upsetting film I've seen.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by andyjohnson0 on Monday December 12, 2016 @10:10AM (#13158536)
I watched Threads last year. Maybe because it is set in the north of England in the 1980s, a region and a era that I grew up in, but I found it very distressing. I don't frighten easily, but I honestly did not sleep well for a couple of nights afterwards.

All national leaders should somehow be legally compelled to watch it. We need them to be as scared as possible of nuclear war.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by arethuza on Monday December 12, 2016 @12:08PM (#13159655)
I don't think it's just you - I found it deeply disturbing as did many other people I knew.

Charlie Stross has a vivid account of his feelings on the subject:

"I'm a child of the 1970s and 1980s; I grew up under the shadow of the mushroom cloud. Prior to the end of the cold war in 1989-91, I don't believe I ever lived more than 10 kilometres from a strategic nuclear target."

http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2013/04/on-the-u...

I think a lot of people who grew up in the Cold War and who contemplated what might actually happen still have that lingering "Lovecraftian horror" from the whole business.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by pmoriarty on Monday December 12, 2016 @02:20PM (#13160961)
The thing is, there are still thousands of nuclear missiles pointed from the USA to the states of the former Soviet Union, and vice-versa. There are other nuclear states as well, which could use their nukes if push came to shove (Pakistan/India, North Korea, China). We are still very much under threat of a nuclear war breaking out, and the cold war is showing signs of starting up again.

Trump is making pro-Russia noises, but anti-China noises, and he could easily change his mind on a dime and go ballistic over some perceived slight from Putin. Many people feel complacent about it because the Soviet Union has collapsed and relations between the USA and Russia are relatively peaceful, but this is a false sense of security.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by kafkaesq on Monday December 12, 2016 @05:33PM (#13162636)
The risk with Trump isn't so much that he might blow his top (which of course he very well might). It's that (if Joe Scarborough's not entirely substantiated disclosure -- he hasn't named the "foreign policy expert" he claimed to have heard this from, which is unfortunate) he apparently doesn't seem to have a solid grasp of what nuclear weapons are for, and what their limitations are -- or even we actually still had them:

He said on his Morning Joe programme: “Several months ago, a foreign policy expert on the international level went to advise Donald Trump.

“And three times he [Trump] asked about the use of nuclear weapons. Three times he asked at one point if we had them why can’t we use them.

http://www.express.co.uk/news/world/696241/Donald-Trump-asks...

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by ars on Monday December 12, 2016 @06:18PM (#13163001)
Presumably you'd be happier if he didn't ask? And he just assumed that he knew?

I assume you think you know what they are for. How do you know you're right if you don't ask?

I don't know the name of it, but there is a fallacy among some people that equates asking for more information with a lack of knowledge. But actually it's the opposite: Ignorant people tend not to ask for information, while those who actually understand ask a lot, because unlike the others they know what they don't know. Foolish people confuse this for ignorance.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by kafkaesq on Monday December 12, 2016 @07:27PM (#13163426)
I'd be happiest if he didn't exist, quite frankly.

But either way -- it's fine for him, as a human being, if he still needs to look up in an encyclopedia, or "ask an expert" what nuclear weapons are really useful for -- or whether the U.S. still has access to them.

But if he's that far out on the "happy-ignorant-foolish" spectrum -- then I'd greatly, greatly prefer that he not be placed in charge of the disposition of such instruments.

Are you with me on this?

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by ars on Monday December 12, 2016 @08:14PM (#13163675)
No, I am not.

I'm not happy with everything he's said and done. But unlike you I'm not so quick to dismiss people as "happy-ignorant-foolish" just because they don't agree with me.

If you are incapable of understanding why people act in a certain way when it differs from yours then that's your failure, not theirs.

PS. It's clear from your reply that you did not understand what I wrote in my previous message, in fact you seemed to understand almost exactly the opposite of what I wrote. Is that my fault for not being clear? Or are you uninterested in understanding Trump any other way?

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by kafkaesq on Monday December 12, 2016 @08:37PM (#13163779)
I'm not so quick to dismiss people as "happy-ignorant-foolish" just because they don't agree with me.

I'm quick to dismiss them in that way based on what they say and do -- for example, running or the office of President of the United states, whilst not possessing even a middle-school level knowledge of whether the country you wish to govern actually has nuclear weapons or not; let alone what they are actually useful for -- not because they "disagree with [me]".

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by andyjohnson0 on Monday December 12, 2016 @12:47PM (#13160010)
I spent the first eighteen years of my life living in a major port city, only a couple of miles from the docks. Everyone, even children, knew the city would be flattened if a war went nuclear.

Its hard to remember now what the constant subliminal awareness of imminent destruction felt like. Seems that we just don't think about it anymore, even though Russia and the US still have ~2000 active nukes each.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by jon-wood on Monday December 12, 2016 @07:55AM (#13157689)
For reasons I'll never understand our biology teacher in secondary school decided to show it to us as the traditional end of term video one year, suitably traumatising a room full of 15 and 16 year olds. There are scenes from that film that will stay with me the rest of my life, I should really rewatch it sometime and see if its quite so powerful to an adult mind.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by pjc50 on Monday December 12, 2016 @08:03AM (#13157738)
> scenes from that film that will stay with me the rest of my life

I bet that's the most persistent thing you remember from that teacher. Effective education! And probably tipped you away from the idea that a nuclear war might be winnable, and towards disarmament.

Our teacher showed us https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edge_of_Darkness for similar reasons, I think.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by arethuza on Monday December 12, 2016 @08:12AM (#13157776)
I think the UK government has always realised that any level of nuclear war was not survivable let alone "winnable" - estimates from the 1950s suggested that it would only take 3 H-bomb strikes to cause a total breakdown in the UK (and some UK diplomat had a drunken debate with Khrushchev over that very point).
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by pjc50 on Monday December 12, 2016 @08:55AM (#13158011)
I think there was significant effort devoted to making sure there could be some sort of "continuity UK" in the event of that happening; the Trident at-sea deterrent, the PYTHON project, all sorts of subterranean bunkers, and so on. It would clearly be pretty desperate, but there was real money spent on it. A bleak version of "thinking the unthinkable", I suppose.

(http://burlingtonandbeyond.co.uk/wp/part-3/ etc)

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by arethuza on Monday December 12, 2016 @10:13AM (#13158566)
I doubt any of the UK bunkers would have survived an all-out attack - their locations were fairly well known and none of them were designed to resist a direct attack. In fact, nobody has bunkers that can resist a direct attack - not even Cheyenne Mountain.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by Declanomous on Monday December 12, 2016 @11:16AM (#13159134)
Alas, Babylon has a good bit about that. One of the characters is stationed at strategic air command in Nebraska. He warns his brother about an impending nuclear war, and that is the last that is heard from him. The other characters speculate about whether he survived, given the fact that strategic air command is sure to have a very sturdy bunker. It turns out the base ended up being a very large radioactive hole. A bunker is, after all, a very static target, and it just ends up being hit by many bombs.

That's my recollection anyways. I read it in 6th grade, so it's been well over a decade since I read it. I really ought to re-read it.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by arethuza on Monday December 12, 2016 @12:02PM (#13159595)
The novel Arc Light has an account of a fairly limited "counterforce" attack by the Russians against the US. Cheyenne Mountain, Omaha and Raven Rock Mountain are all destroyed:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arc_Light_(novel)

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by pmoriarty on Monday December 12, 2016 @02:32PM (#13161098)
Speaking of warnings about a nuclear war, there's a great 80's movie that centers around one such warning and how ordinary people react to it: Miracle Mile.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miracle_Mile_(film)

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by mosdave on Monday December 12, 2016 @03:23PM (#13161572)
that movie traumatized me as a young man and definitely impacted my sleep for years thereafter.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by morganvachon on Monday December 12, 2016 @05:00PM (#13162337)
I read it a few months ago and your recollection is accurate. I think it's one of the best fictional books on the subject.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by BjoernKW on Monday December 12, 2016 @12:20PM (#13159760)
The Dover facility (which in case of an imminent all-out nuclear exchange supposedly would've accommodated the Royal Family as well) was shut down (or never really commissioned) in the early 1970s because someone found out that chalk rock is permeable to nuclear fallout ...

So, I'm sure that despite the effort the UK Government was well aware of its futility.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by ajlburke on Monday December 12, 2016 @11:30AM (#13159281)
'Now, we shall receive four minutes warning of any impending nuclear attack. Some people have said, "Oh my goodness me — four minutes? — that is not a very long time!" Well, I would remind those doubters that some people in this great country of ours can run a mile in four minutes.' - Peter Cook, Beyond the Fringe, 1960
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by arethuza on Monday December 12, 2016 @12:15PM (#13159713)
Part of the UK preparation for nuclear war sound like black comedy - my favourite being that we were too cheap to build a dedicated communication network to allow the PM to launch the V-bombers when out and about so the AA radio network was to be used:

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/this-britain/in-the-eve...

Yes - that AA - the Automobile Association....

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by wolfgang42 on Monday December 12, 2016 @05:04PM (#13162387)
The national air raid sirens were controlled over random POTS lines[1]. The theory was that a dedicated system would need proper upkeep and testing, but when a telephone line goes down the customer at the end of it will notice and file a complaint.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HANDEL

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by pmoriarty on Monday December 12, 2016 @02:36PM (#13161139)
That's almost as bad as US launch codes being all zeroes for 15 years:

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/12/05/nuclear-missile-cod...

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by sjg007 on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @09:49PM (#13173388)
Good thing it changed.. imagine trying to pair a bluetooth keyboard.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by TheOtherHobbes on Monday December 12, 2016 @10:37AM (#13158757)
I think some civil servants realised this. That's not the same as the entire government realising it. It's certainly not the same as specific Prime Ministers understanding it.

There are maps from the early 1950s - pre H-Bomb - which show large areas of the UK reduced to radioactive desert after a relatively small attack.

Unloading tens or hundreds of larger weapons on the UK would do very little to increase its survival prospects.

From that POV, Threads is terrifying but optimistic. It's not clear anyone at all would survive a full exchange. Spending a few years in a bunker would simply delay the inevitable.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by pmoriarty on Monday December 12, 2016 @02:43PM (#13161204)
"Spending a few years in a bunker would simply delay the inevitable."

All of life could be said to be merely delaying the inevitable.

I am reminded of the story of a man running away from a tiger when he reaches the edge of a cliff and falls over, managing to grab hold of the edge and hanging by one hand. Below him is certain death from the fall, above him is death by the tiger. The man notices some sweet dew dripping from a blade of grass by his face. With moments left to live, he licks the dew.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by mkesper on Monday December 12, 2016 @09:19AM (#13158137)
There were preparations for such a case in West Germany: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_bunker_%28Germany%2... The english article also mentions Fallex 66, where for the first time, politicians were involved in a (favorable setting of a) NATO war game.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by zo1 on Monday December 12, 2016 @02:54PM (#13161320)
Sounds more like child-abuse to me. If the video is indeed as shocking as most people here claim it is then it isn't age-appropriate for younger adults and especially children.

As adults, we can choose to not see it. As children, in a classroom, we are generally not. Peer pressure and adult authoritarian rule should not be taken lightly. Especially when used to scare children into compliance and leave them lasting marks into adult-hood.

-Speaking as someone that still has irrational issues with being alone, or being alone in the dark. After watching age-inappropriate movies as a child.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by DKnoll on Monday December 12, 2016 @05:44PM (#13162735)
I can only imagine how coddled your childhood was if you weren't aware of the dark realities of death and war by 15 or 16.

Fear is a choice.

Also many people have overcome much greater trauma than 'age-inappropriate movies'... that's absurd.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by DanBC on Monday December 12, 2016 @03:39PM (#13161699)
> Sounds more like child-abuse to me. If the video is indeed as shocking as most people here claim it is then it isn't age-appropriate for younger adults and especially children.

You'd be amazed at the kinds of films that were shown to young people in an effort tochange their behaviour (with no evidence that it would actually do so).

My favourite example was of a UK tv show Nationwide that got a studio full of young people to watch US style shock films about road and rail safety. The films were so gruesome they couldn't be shown on broadcast tv at that time of the evening. There were shots of young people throwing up and feinting and having to be taken out of the studio, weeping.

(This is mentioned on a TV discussion forum somewhere, but I can't find it. :-/)

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by ipnon on Monday December 12, 2016 @03:33PM (#13161647)
You know what's real child abuse? Entirely preventable nuclear wars that are only initiated due to ignorance of their effects.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by zo1 on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @11:20AM (#13167923)
No, that's called not raising your kids to be good citizens.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by jon-wood on Monday December 12, 2016 @07:43PM (#13163508)
I should probably clarify that the teacher in question hated the film, and spent the entire lesson pointedly not watching it. Some of the other students in my class had heard of it from another teacher and were determined to see it.

I'm pretty sure while it could be considered mildly negligent to give into that pressure, I'm also confident it doesn't constitute child abuse. At least some of us were old almost enough to enlist with the army, I think its good to balance that out with an idea of just what that might entail.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by rwallace on Monday December 12, 2016 @10:49AM (#13158871)
I saw that movie around the same age, back in the day. Good for your biology teacher! There's a really worrying trend in recent years of politicians and the media carrying on like they'd stopped being scared of nuclear war. How the fuck is that something you stop being scared of?
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by kafkaesq on Monday December 12, 2016 @05:36PM (#13162656)
For reasons I'll never understand

Probably to make whatever grain-sized impact he or she could possibly make towards preventing the scenario described in that movie from ever happening.

I miss the Cold War (during which I also had teachers like this).

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by Florin_Andrei on Monday December 12, 2016 @02:19PM (#13160943)
> I should really rewatch it sometime and see if its quite so powerful to an adult mind.

Yeah, I was in my 20s when I saw it for the first time. It's powerful.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by jon-wood on Monday December 12, 2016 @07:39PM (#13163489)
Ok, you've sold me, I'll see if I can find a copy somewhere.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by rmc on Monday December 12, 2016 @07:52AM (#13157673)
And Threads was based on an optimistic Soviet nuclear attack, i.e. fewer weapons.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by pmoriarty on Monday December 12, 2016 @02:48PM (#13161262)
Indeed. There was a great article which I can't find now about all the missiles still pointing from the US to Russia and vice versa, where after the fall of the Soviet Union a General formerly in charge of the Soviet arsenal met his British counterpart and assured him that in the Soviet nuclear war preparedness plans, the entire UK was a complete overkill zone.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by rbanffy on Monday December 12, 2016 @08:00AM (#13157712)
Nuclear war is the one where "everybody dies" is the best case scenario.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by ido on Monday December 12, 2016 @11:45AM (#13159435)
Not really. There are definitely scenarios (likely to more probable one) where the nuclear war is not "USA vs Russia/China nuking the entire planet".

The article itself suggest a nuclear conflict between India and Pakistan would result in 2 billion death (supposedly mostly around India/Pakistan), which means the majority of the worlds population will survive.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by hasslein on Monday December 12, 2016 @10:04AM (#13158491)
Absolutely. When people ask me what the scariest horror film I've seen is, I respond with "Threads."
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by rbanffy on Monday December 12, 2016 @07:59AM (#13157706)
I got depressed by reading the Wikipedia article...
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by Spooky23 on Monday December 12, 2016 @07:53AM (#13157684)
Did you go back to Shindler's List?
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by Pxtl on Monday December 12, 2016 @09:46AM (#13158335)
I'm often disappointed in Fantasy/SF settings that completely ignore the most critical question "what the hell do people eat"?. It's one of the most basic functions of life, but because we're blessed to be removed from the frustrating process of avoiding starvation, so many works just ignore the question altogether when discussing a "life is hard" setting.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by the_af on Monday December 12, 2016 @01:46PM (#13160616)
"The Road" has already been mentioned as a piece of fiction that focuses almost exclusively on food and starvation. Not sure it's explicitly about nuclear war, however. It's also way too hopeless for me. I can't say I enjoyed reading it.

A better -- and recent favorite of mine -- sci-fi book about scarce resources and food is "The Windup Girl" by Paolo Bacigalupi. It's not about nuclear war either, but not only is the actual story very engaging, it focuses on how energy is generated and stored, what people eat, and how food is delivered in a post-oil world. Bacigalupi calls this crisis "the Contraction". Warning: more than a few digs at Monsanto as well, not so much from the "transgenics are bad" angle but from the "copyrights and patents on food oppress people". Strongly recommended!

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by craigyk on Monday December 12, 2016 @02:16PM (#13160921)
Windup girl was an amazingly imaginative extrapolation. I do have a bit of a problem with how fatalistic most post-apocalypse works are. I think what would actually emerge would be very messy, but still far more hopeful than depicted. For example, in a The Walking Dead scenario, the first real settlement they found that was semi-secure would have probably grown into a fairly stable city-state. They work hard on that show to keep the rollercoaster going. IMO, tiring and not very realistic.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by scrumper on Monday December 12, 2016 @02:20PM (#13160962)
You'll enjoy his later book The Water Knife which is exactly about a water-scarce world and the rather grim social sructures that result.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by swombat on Monday December 12, 2016 @06:02PM (#13162885)
Very much loved The Windup Girl and would recommend it too. Powerful book.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by sjg007 on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @09:39PM (#13173358)
We will actually have this problem in 50 years... well the developing world will. Too many people and not enough food.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by anigbrowl on Monday December 12, 2016 @05:02PM (#13162363)
The grimmer your story, the smaller the market. Thus even though famines are often disastrous human events that can mean the death of millions and frequently alter the course of history, hardly anyone makes movies about them because watching people starve unnecessarily is hardly anyone's idea of a good time. At least in war stories someone gets to be winner, even if it's temporary. In a famine everything gets worse and the only people likely to profit are the people who were already winning at the outset, so there isn't really a story arc.

You can do movies like this (The Road, Schindler's List, Dallas Buyer's Club, Hotel Rwanda are all good examples) but if the world of the story is crushingly awful then you're basically reduced to one plot - moral individual risks/sacrifices self to provide glimmer of hope to others. Offhand I'd say you can only put out a truly grim a-list movie about once every 5 years.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by ethbro on Monday December 12, 2016 @07:04PM (#13163305)
I've always thought this is one of the reasons the zombie survival genre is so popular.

For all the dramatic hand wrangling over finding supplies, the survivors are essentially living in a world of plenty -- enough arms, ammunition, canned food, and supplies for a world population, >50% of which presumably no longer have an interest in such things.

It's the antithesis of all that "we should compromise for the good of all, saving the planet, etc" (because how does that sound fun?).

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by anigbrowl on Monday December 12, 2016 @08:49PM (#13163836)
Absolutely. The physical anxiety is more than made up for by the blissful simplicity of the new moral calculus.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by tannhauser23 on Monday December 12, 2016 @12:42PM (#13159969)
I'm reading "Farnham's Freehold" by Robert Heinlein which is basically a thought experiment in how to build a pioneer-like society in a post-nuclear war world. It's not a great book, honestly, but it has a lot of material on building shelter and finding food.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by hguant on Monday December 12, 2016 @01:02PM (#13160173)
Farnham's Freehold was the book that made me lose a lot of respect for Heinlein. I started reading him as a 13-14 year old - books like "Have Space Suit, Will Travel", "Farmer in the Sky", and "Starman Jones" - and ate them up. I got older and my dad recommended "The Moon is a Harsh Mistress" and "Starship Troopers"; I really liked reading him alongside Asimov, who did such a great job of going into __how__ people/societies would exist in the future; Heinlein was much better at going into the __why__. The ideas he put forward in "Starship Troopers" and "Stranger in a Strange Land" formed the basis for some of the best conversations I've had with friends.

However.

Farnham's Freehold was just ubermensch porn coupled with some really weird racism. He used more hackneyed "I can do everything" stereotypes than an Ayn Rand novel, which is something he was always guilty of but it really came to a head here. The multiculturalism and openness that was so explicitly prevalent in Starship Troopers, Stranger, and Harsh Mistress (the main character of Starship Troopers is a bisexual South American) vanishes, replaced with this weird fear of black people - "they seem nice, but they'll turn on you when they get the chance" is the message the Joe character imparts.

Just a very weird book.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by drak0n1c on Monday December 12, 2016 @01:24PM (#13160395)
Freehold was about trying to get into the mind of a post-apocalyptic survivalist - life in lower states of humanity and tribalistic instincts. The other books were about life in higher states of society and humanity. You can't assume that Heinlein was making a value judgement pro diverse militarism or pro racial survivalism in either book. It's science fiction. The only common attitude that his stories seem to clearly reward and respect is grit.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by lsc on Monday December 12, 2016 @04:18PM (#13162009)
Point taken, and yes, that is a big difference, but specifically the actions of the black elites were super weird. More weird than you would expect from someone who just postulates that when the chips are down, we run with our race brothers.

It was the weirdly sexualized race and gender based cannibalism that I think puts it over the line, not the actions of Joe, except in the context of the former.

I mean I see what he was trying to do, but rather than basing his African elites on anthropological evidence, or on real white cultures that were horrible to other races, (which would have gotten his point across better, I think,) he based them on the most disturbing (and to me, last believable or sympathetic) racial fears of the time, and because of that, it is kinda uncomfortable.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by ethbro on Monday December 12, 2016 @07:13PM (#13163363)
Curious to read it now, especially in the context of its time.

1964 was the same year the Civil Rights Act was passed. I imagine ideas of baser racial instincts were different when there were still lynchings and fear of sexual racial mixing. :(

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by hguant on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @09:25AM (#13166958)
Reading this reminded me of another great author who had an episode of weird racial views - Stephan King, in The Stand (which is absolutely one of my favourite books), had a chapter where he's detailing the horrors of society breaking down, and one of the events he catalogued was the mutiny of a bunch of black soldiers who then started killing their white compatriots in a grotesque gameshow. That very explicit fear of militant black men dates the book more than anything else.

As someone born in the very early 90's, it's weird seeing evidence of people taking seriously these thoughts I've only seen caricatured.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by notahacker on Monday December 12, 2016 @08:20PM (#13163696)
Tbf, I viewed Farnham's Freehold as being intended to be as explicitly anti-racist as Henlein said he was (cf. I've never agreed. The racist son is an utter imbecile whose racist comments are repeatedly shot down by the hero protagonist, and the ultra-civilised future black society they run into that assumes that white people are less than human (and tasty!) but are otherwise very congenial is obviously a clunky parody of Jim Crow era America rather than a depiction of impending threat posed by black people (it's been made abundantly clear that the white people wiped their own civilization out, and the Joe character even gets to explicitly point out the enslaved white folks really aren't treated that much worse than a household servant in 1960s Alabama.)

Of course, it's done with the subtlety of a sledgehammer, but somehow it's far more forgivable in its consistently tone deaf naivety than if it appeared Henlein actually had a decent understanding of race relations. (like the District 9 filmmakers ruining their perfect race-relations satire with comedy savage Nigerians...)

The daddy who's such an ubermensch even his own daughter wants to sleep with him, whilst he's actually busy screwing her best friend is much harder to accept, of course.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by kodfodrasz on Monday December 12, 2016 @02:16PM (#13160918)
I'm not sure if Johnny Rico of Starship Troopers was bisexual. I have read the book, and i cannot recall event hints of this. Could you provide some citation/reference? Did i fall victim of some form of censorship?
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by hguant on Monday December 12, 2016 @05:00PM (#13162343)
IIRC there was a throw away line about him not being a virgin - "slept with women and a few men" or something along those lines. I'll look it up when I'm not at work.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by ghaff on Monday December 12, 2016 @04:29PM (#13162088)
It's clearly one of Heinlein's worse books and perhaps his very worst. Many of Heinlein's novels had... quirks. But Farnham's Freehold was just bad.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by angersock on Monday December 12, 2016 @01:25PM (#13160415)
So, I'd suggest a few different books on that topic--Farnham's Freehold not being one of them.

Lucifer's Hammer by Niven and Pournelle goes into a bit of the politics and aftermath of a comet striking the Earth. It talks about survival, civil defense, and a few other things that would be spoilers to mention. That said, it has some points that are weirdly racist when viewed decades after publication--if you can look past those, though, it's a solid read.

One Second After by William Forstchen talks about the aftermath of an EMP first-strike on the US. Perhaps the one of the more interesting things is that he does specifically pay attention to both the food and medicine logistics--specifically, what happens when we lack ability to run refrigerators and move around grain. It's a bit cheerful in the end, but a good read.

Warday by Strieber and Kunetka takes place 5 years after a "limited" nuclear exchange with the USSR. The premise of the novel is that a pair of researchers are traveling through the US and interviewing folks, reading documents, and generally piecing together both the initial conflict as well as the efforts to survive and recover. It's a really good bit of speculative fiction, but is pretty depressing.

~

One of the biggest things that makes nuclear war difficult to imagine today is that we have the Internet and cell phones, things which at once are utterly integral to most of the non-rural folks and which are completely vulnerable to any sort of honest nuclear strike. The lack of books, CB radios, and basic practical knowhow and repairable goods brought by the rise of technology and international trade might well yield a situation where a theoretical 2020s United States would have a more difficult time recovering than a 1980s US.

At least as far as the 'net stuff goes, the short story "When Sysadmins Ruled the Earth" by Doctorow is maybe one of the only ones that treats the tech angle seriously in a modern light.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by tannhauser23 on Monday December 12, 2016 @03:22PM (#13161566)
Good suggestions, will check them out.

Yeah, I'm pretty disappointed with Farnham's Freehold. I picked it up at a used book store for a dollar - Heinlein! Post-apocalyptic society! - but I haven't enjoyed it very much, and yes, it does get weirdly racial as it goes on. The other books you mention sound much better! Heard great things about Lucifer's Hammer - that'll go to the top of the list.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by mrob on Monday December 12, 2016 @03:45PM (#13161741)
I first saw that question in MrBtongue's YouTube video comparing Fallout 3 and Fallout: New Vegas (relevant to discussion of post-nuclear war settings). New Vegas is the better game, and one of the reasons is that it actually does answer the question of what people eat. The rest of the video is also interesting, but "what do they eat?" discussion starts here:

https://youtu.be/wvwlt4FqmS0?t=559

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by gozur88 on Monday December 12, 2016 @08:28PM (#13163741)
From a writer's perspective the problem is a story that mostly consists of people scrabbling for food isn't very interesting, so either you ignore the question or you create a story element that allows you to ignore the question - giant roaches, say, or some kind of food-from-algae technology.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by overcast on Monday December 12, 2016 @08:57AM (#13158025)
The Road was either a super volcano, or meteor impact, given the scale, and description of things.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by jraines on Monday December 12, 2016 @03:56PM (#13161826)
I want to quote the whole section that gives the most info, just because McCarthy's writing is so great & ominous:

"The clocks stopped at 1:17. A long shear of light and then a series of low concussions. He got up and went to the window. What is it? she said. He didn't answer. He went into the bathroom and threw the lightswitch but the power was already gone. A dull rose glow in the windowglass. He dropped to one knee and raised the lever to stop the tub and then turned on both the taps as far as they would go. She was standing in the doorway in her nightwear, clutching the jamb, cradling her belly in one hand. What is it? she said. What is happening?

I don't know.

Why are you taking a bath?

I'm not."

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by s_kilk on Monday December 12, 2016 @09:29AM (#13158204)
Yeah, I can't dig up the source now, but I remember a super-volcano (probably Yellowstone) being widely accepted as the most likely source of the disaster.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by wlkr on Monday December 12, 2016 @10:24AM (#13158646)
That's very interesting, I read the book a few years ago and then watched the film after. Both have stuck with me, particularly some distressing scenes from the book, and yet I never put too much thought into what could have caused the disaster. Given their plight I suppose it didn't matter.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by TheGRS on Monday December 12, 2016 @01:24PM (#13160398)
I remember a scene from the book where he recalls bright lights in the distance? I thought it was a subtle hint that it was nuclear war, but its been awhile. That was my initial interpretation at least.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by s_kilk on Monday December 12, 2016 @01:48PM (#13160639)
You're right, there's a bit about (paraphrasing) the clocks stopping at 11.30, bright lights in the distance and several low concussions in the ground.

Having said that, in the movie the protagonist awakes at night to an orange glow outside, implied to be wild-fires on the horizon. He rushes to the bathroom to begin filling the bathtub with water.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by astrodust on Monday December 12, 2016 @10:38AM (#13158771)
Compared to a super-volcano, even the worst nuclear winter is brief and pleasant.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by brandonmenc on Monday December 12, 2016 @01:17PM (#13160316)
The nature of the disaster was left ambiguous.

Only humans survived. No other life. Not at all realistic, but that wasn't the intent.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by industriousthou on Monday December 12, 2016 @10:01PM (#13164098)
I thought this was pretty realistic portrayal of how some sort of global winter may play out. The sun is blocked by dust or debris or whatever, plant life dies, the rest of the biosphere dies, and all that's left is some humans who scavenge and end up eating each other.

I guess rotting plant matter like trees might provide nutrients for some sort of meager ecosystem composed of fungi and insects for quite some time. Maybe a few small mammals and birds. The book didn't really touch on that, though.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by knowaveragejoe on Monday December 12, 2016 @01:43PM (#13160591)
If I'm not mistaken the movie ends with a group who has children and least one dog, implying they haven't resorted to cannibalism or eating their pets(yet).
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by overcast on Monday December 12, 2016 @02:15PM (#13160901)
I don't remember a dog in the book, however yes, the son does meet up with a group at the end.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by overcast on Monday December 12, 2016 @02:01PM (#13160773)
I'm aware of its ambiguity, I read the book. For something to be on that scale, it definitely was not nuclear.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by industriousthou on Monday December 12, 2016 @09:56PM (#13164080)
I was under the impression it could have been a nuclear winter. There's seems to be some disagreement about how severe and long nuclear winter may be, so maybe McCarthy was making some false assumptions.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by aaron695 on Monday December 12, 2016 @08:48AM (#13157975)
Pretty sure the Road didn't state what had happened specifically because it has nothing to do with a nuclear war?
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by grive on Monday December 12, 2016 @10:08AM (#13158527)
Indeed, it is not explicit, but it is akin to a nuclear winter: soot everywhere that obscured the atmosphere, killing crops and making farming impossible.

It could be other events (supervolcano eruption for example), but a nuclear holocaust would be similar if not too many bombs are used.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by aaron695 on Monday December 12, 2016 @08:08PM (#13163648)
From the film, even the crazies theories of a nuclear winter weren't close.

Nuclear war doesn't do much.

I think a meteor or supervolcano is also impossible from the scenes in the film, not having lots of things growing within a month doesn't fit really, but it'd be an interesting discussion.

Obviously this is why it's not mentioned, so people don't get wrapped up in the details about how it happen but the story.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by stephancoral on Monday December 12, 2016 @11:06AM (#13159035)
It was an asteroid impact event.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by gaius on Monday December 12, 2016 @08:59AM (#13158028)
Also, The Book Of Eli.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by senorjazz on Monday December 12, 2016 @09:32AM (#13158218)
no, just no. This was a terrible film. Does not compare at all to the book or film of The Road
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by madenine on Monday December 12, 2016 @10:07AM (#13158513)
SPOILERS:

The premise revolved around there being no copies of probably the most printed book on the planet, yet there other books. Even a collective, whose mission is to find all the books and knowledge it can (someone read Asimov), can't find a bible. They found a Torah, but couldn't find a bible.

Awful film.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by jlengrand on Monday December 12, 2016 @10:44AM (#13158826)
Because as part of the plot, it is explained that those were specifically burnt for years (if I remember correctly, because religion was what started the war or something)?

Movie's still not great, but there are reasons they don't find Bibles :)

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by gaius on Monday December 12, 2016 @11:30AM (#13159282)
I enjoyed it :-) But in this context I am talking specifically about the post-apocalyptic world, the way the few remaining mass-produced items from before, are now valuable commodities (he says something like, people will kill you now, for something we used to just throw away before The Flash), the barter economy (eg. how he gets his battery recharged), the water, the hand-shakes...
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by derivagral on Monday December 12, 2016 @11:35AM (#13159338)
For anyone curious like me, Threads [1]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Threads

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by Chris2048 on Monday December 12, 2016 @09:01AM (#13158040)
> With Trump elected

> could mean the end of the non-proliferation treaties

So could the US running out of money/power.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by astrodust on Monday December 12, 2016 @10:39AM (#13158772)
Then that leaves China in charge and I'm not sure that's a good thing.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by Chris2048 on Monday December 12, 2016 @01:12PM (#13160258)
Doubt it, China seems mainly interested in its own borders, Russia might be the one to watch...
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by RandomOpinion on Monday December 12, 2016 @01:37PM (#13160537)
>"China seems mainly interested in its own borders, ..."

Yes, clearly they're building those island bases in the South China Sea just because they feel like they don't have enough oceanfront real estate. /s

https://www.google.com/search?q=china+island+bases+map

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by Chris2048 on Monday December 12, 2016 @08:38PM (#13163782)
South China Sea.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by RandomOpinion on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @12:22AM (#13164679)
Didn't even bother to look at the maps, did you? Some of those bases are inside territorial waters allotted to the the Philippines by UN rules, within spitting distance of the main Phillippine islands, and also within easy striking range of Malaysia and Brunei.

Here's a diagram for those who are interested: http://www.abc.net.au/cm/lb/5464158/data/south-china-sea-map.... Note how close the China claim line extends to various other nations.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by Chris2048 on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @06:06AM (#13165999)
Yes, I did look t the map. The South China Sea is near China.

The context of this thread is "China taking over" meaning venturing a lot further from its borders.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by sweetjesus on Monday December 12, 2016 @05:41PM (#13162705)
> With Trump elected, Europe is turning to itself for its defence...

wait, what?... Europe wasn't paying for its own defense before Trump, because why, they just liked the US presidents?! Was it something about them, or were they just these big suckers and Europeans were like "hey free defense!"? Quite frankly, you're making Trump sound better.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by conception on Monday December 12, 2016 @06:50PM (#13163222)
Europe does have its own defense, but Germany does not because of the whole Nazi thing. Also, strategically, the US has lots of valid reasons to be want to be the dominant military player in the area. We much rather be fighting a shooting war on that continent than ours. If you take a very shallow view, we are "paying for" or "subsidising" European defense, when in fact we are doing what we always do - engaging in what's best for us. The dollar cost is insignificant next to the value theater access and regional support.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by Something1234 on Monday December 12, 2016 @11:27PM (#13164432)
I've always liked Alas Babylon by Pat Frank. They focus on food, and it really captures the terror the people were feeling and how a community might end up forming.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by sehugg on Monday December 12, 2016 @12:29PM (#13159866)
Japan has wasted no time in partnering with India (not a member of the NPT) on nuclear energy: http://www.eurasiareview.com/29112016-india-japan-nuclear-de...
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by wbl on Monday December 12, 2016 @03:11PM (#13161474)
Japan also has a plutonium stockpile sufficient for a bunch of nukes.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by rdtsc on Monday December 12, 2016 @08:52PM (#13163847)
> With Trump elected, Europe is turning to itself for its defence,

Wouldn't it have to turn itself more to defense if the other candidate was elected, who didn't seem to mind setting up No-Fly zones for aircraft for a country which has more than 1000 nuclear warheads ready to launch (not counting those in nuclear subs).

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by pmoriarty on Monday December 12, 2016 @02:08PM (#13160827)
Threads was definitely the most terrifying film I've seen about nuclear war. Highly recommended.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by dublinclontarf on Monday December 12, 2016 @03:49PM (#13161769)
"Europe" aka the EU currently has the UK and France. The UK is leaving and France has no appetite to be responsibe for the defence of the EU.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by golergka on Monday December 12, 2016 @09:51AM (#13158388)
> With Trump elected, Europe is turning to itself for its defence

Are you really trying to say that Trump, and not Putin, is the primary reason for this?

Also, I thought that political threads were banned on HN now; aren't they?

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by Florin_Andrei on Monday December 12, 2016 @02:26PM (#13161033)
> Are you really trying to say that Trump, and not Putin, is the primary reason for this?

Not sure why you're being downvoted, it's a good question.

The way I see it, it's an overall pandemic of malaise, a regression to a more primal state, affecting the "West" primarily, but certainly influencing the whole world to some extent.

Brexit is a symptom. The Trump madness is a symptom. Le Pen is a symptom. Putin has been a symptom and an instrument and an agent for a long time. ISIS is an example outside of the West of the same thing.

Fear and lies. Facts don't matter anymore, truth is being trampled into the ground, and the world's state of mind is gradually turning dark. Where violence has an opportunity, it breaks out. Fortunately, not much of this has been translated into material consequences (except for ISIS and so on), but at the psychological level it's really bad. If it stays mostly on that level, then perhaps there is a way out eventually.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by ipnon on Monday December 12, 2016 @03:38PM (#13161694)
How do you alleviate this primal state in people? Give them everything they need to live comfortably and decently? Isn't this the result of the whole post-Cold War project called Capitalism (capital C)? What do people need in order to have them desire peace and cooperation with all of humanity without qualifications? There are so many questions that still need to be answered.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by usrusr on Monday December 12, 2016 @11:31AM (#13159299)
> Are you really trying to say that Trump, and not Putin, is the primary reason for this?

Sure. The NATO of old was facing off against much stronger opposition than Putin today, without even the slightest trace of doubt in commitment coming up. Trump is certainly not the only factor that erodes trust in NATO deterrence (Brexit, Erdogan and NATO overexpansion are other important contributors to the general uneasiness), but he is the most visible one. Visible cracks are bad because there will always be people (on all sides!) who see personal incentive to widen them and if they succeed, the mere thought that limited scope wars could be possible will endanger peace.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by enraged_camel on Monday December 12, 2016 @11:57AM (#13159545)
>>Also, I thought that political threads were banned on HN now; aren't they?

No, the "ban" was temporary, and lifted only a few days after it was put in place.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by pmoriarty on Monday December 12, 2016 @02:54PM (#13161325)
"Also, I thought that political threads were banned on HN now; aren't they?"

The ban has been lifted. See:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13131251

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by dragonwriter on Monday December 12, 2016 @11:35AM (#13159334)
> Are you really trying to say that Trump, and not Putin, is the primary reason for this?

If Trump is part of the mechanism, Putin is still the reason.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by ComputerGuru on Monday December 12, 2016 @11:27AM (#13159249)
I must watch Threads given all the talk about it in this thread, but I guess I'll be the lone dissenter that will come out and say that The Road was an absolutely horrible movie. I found it so drawn-out, boring, interminably long. I realize it was presenting life in a post-apocalyptic future, but that's no excuse to have no plot to truly speak of in its 111 minutes of runtime.

Then again, I hated Mad Max and only sat down to watch it at the theater because of the ridiculously-good critical reviews it had amassed. I found it a pointless exercise in hedonism and a testosterone-fueled car chase filled with gore and nudity for their own sake.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by cjslep on Monday December 12, 2016 @11:35AM (#13159335)
I think many would agree that The Road movie isn't good, which is why I highly recommend reading the book. McCarthy's unique writing style lends itself to the material in a way movies can't capture.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by wcummings on Monday December 12, 2016 @01:17PM (#13160313)
> I found it a pointless exercise in hedonism and a testosterone-fueled car chase filled with gore and nudity for their own sake.

Ironic, since pre-Road Mad Max can only be described as a criticism of consumerism & car culture. After the apocalypse caused by oil wars, the world is littered with cars, they're the only technology anyone understands, so basically everything is hacked together w/ car parts. Everyone is still fighting over oil and acting like macho idiots whose identities' are closely linked with driving to point of being a cult.

TBQH in this context making it about water and not oil doesn't make a lot of sense, but I understand why they would try to update it this way to make it more topical.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by cc439 on Monday December 12, 2016 @05:36PM (#13162660)
>They're the only technology anyone understands

I wouldn't describe personal vehicles in such base terms, it's more that cars, trucks, off-road vehicles, etc are the only form of manufactured goods that are both suitable to the world portrayed in the films and widespread enough to be accessible to everyone.

All complex manufactured goods in such a world would be irreplacable, at least within the lifetime of anyone living in that time period. Radios and other electronics are also widespread and suitable enough to be considered a necessity but they'd be destroyed by the EMP effects of nuclear warfare (hence why every vehicle in Mad Max appears to be from the carburetor/pre-electronics era).

Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistuingishable from magic and although the mechanicals of a car are well understood by laymen, their existence carries an air of magic/reverence as they cannot be replicated by the society which possesses them. IMO, the closest comparison is that of a Cargo Cult rather than an extreme extrapolation of existing car culture.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by pmoriarty on Monday December 12, 2016 @03:00PM (#13161371)
Calling Mad Max movies a critique of car culture is like calling Blaxploitation movies a critique of racism.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by pimlottc on Monday December 12, 2016 @11:36AM (#13159348)
The film was an adaptation; The Road was originally a novel.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by pmoriarty on Monday December 12, 2016 @02:58PM (#13161359)
"I'll be the lone dissenter that will come out and say that The Road was an absolutely horrible movie. I found it so drawn-out, boring, interminably long."

No Country for Old Men was the movie that convinced me that Cormack McCarthy wrote overhyped garbage. I didn't even bother watching The Road, as I expected it would be just more of the same.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by robotresearcher on Monday December 12, 2016 @05:48PM (#13162757)
Cormack McCarthy writes books. He has a particular style of language that many people enjoy. You can't really evaluate his work from the movies. He didn't even write the screenplays.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by pmoriarty on Monday December 12, 2016 @06:03PM (#13162893)
From everything I've read, the film version of No Country for Old Men was pretty faithful to the book, so I think I have a pretty good idea of what to expect from the latter. No thanks.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by macca321 on Monday December 12, 2016 @03:14PM (#13161494)
Wow.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by disconcision on Monday December 12, 2016 @12:14PM (#13159710)
Was there even any nudity in Mad Max?
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by mustacheemperor on Monday December 12, 2016 @01:56PM (#13160717)
Just enough to allow one to criticize the movie on some high moral platform instead of only on the basis of its merits as film.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by wcummings on Monday December 12, 2016 @01:19PM (#13160340)
Very little.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by dawnerd on Monday December 12, 2016 @12:00PM (#13159576)
I'm glad I'm not alone in hating Mad Max. When the credits rolled I was left wondering what the plot even was. It felt like nothing more than an excuse to blow stuff up and chase around cars. Absolutely no idea how it got such high marks.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by groby_b on Monday December 12, 2016 @09:37PM (#13164016)
The movie is all about subtext.

There's a really blatant subtext: about guys blowing shit up, exploiting women, and in general driving the world into total destruction. On its face, it's an exercise in radical feminism.

Except, it isn't. Below that, there is the layer showing that women are equally capable of destruction, and that they in fact need to rely on that destruction to reach "the green place".

And that's flipped on its head again, because that war machine runs on a mixture of fuel and mother's milk. Max is pretty much annointed with it when he uses mother's milk to wash the blood of his face, after a selfless act. There's a huge "war turned into a nurturing thing" there. It's echoed by the fact that part of Furiosa's body is partially mechanized. (Her replacement arm)

Which leads up to what I think is the final message, where the realization strikes that there is no separate, women-only feminist utopia. There is no "women peaceful, men violent" dichotomy. Instead, the world is finally improved by the women reintegrating themselves into the world they left, but on their own terms.

It's pretty much a post-modernist deconstruction of war movies and feminism at the same time. It's incredibly heavy-handed about it - all those things have about the subtlety of a hand grenade as a can opener - but it tackled a topic that was important and little talked about.

That is why it was a good movie. If that message doesn't speak to you, I'm not surprised you didn't like it. You were not the target audience. (Neither were people who like chase-and-blow-stuff-up movies, and they were vocal about the fact they didn't like it)

That doesn't necessarily make it a good movie, but if one liked both the subtext and blowing things up, they had a great time watching it.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by Crespyl on Monday December 12, 2016 @01:36PM (#13160525)
> excuse to blow stuff up and chase around cars.

Is that such a bad thing?

It had a guy playing electric guitar on top of a giant flamethrower, because that's the kind of movie it was.

Maybe not for everyone, but I thought it managed to do what it was trying to.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by pmoriarty on Monday December 12, 2016 @03:08PM (#13161449)
"It had a guy playing electric guitar on top of a giant flamethrower"

I'm reminded of the movie Idiocracy.

Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by TheGRS on Monday December 12, 2016 @01:30PM (#13160465)
I feel a little silly needing to defend it, but the plot is pretty simple IMO. Max himself is more of an observer of the plot than an central character, which is a little confusing, but everything else is a pretty straight-forward hero story. What didn't you understand specifically?
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by dawnerd on Monday December 12, 2016 @01:50PM (#13160649)
That's the thing, I don't know what I was missing. I'm usually a perfect audience for sit back and enjoy the ride kind of movies but in this one, I just didn't connect at all.
Re:Why a Post-Nuclear World Would Look Nothing Like “Mad Max” by pmoriarty on Monday December 12, 2016 @03:06PM (#13161430)
It got such high marks because mainstream audiences love action and violence. This is crystal clear if you consider the content of blockbusters, excluding dramas and comedies. They're virtually all filled with action and violence. That's what most audiences want.