But it is dysfunctional, or even anti-functional, for the economy. Because with advertisements we're not buying the "best" product, but rather the one with the biggest associated marketing budget.
It undermines the most important merit of capitalism.
First of all, who gets to determine what is "best"? You? The relativity of perceived product value makes it hard to prove that people are buying the "wrong" things. The whole point of markets is that it is impossible to determine in advance what people really want.
If what you said were true, the biggest marketing budget would always win, but it doesn't--far from it. The economy is littered with the wasted marketing budgets of failed products.
That would be true if ad budget = ad quality, but I don't think it does.
(In fact, most quotes are a form of marketing, not for products but for ideas.)
But I am with you in that, that for all the money marketing people are getting, they could be more creative how to get our attention and how to reach us. Most of them just repeat over and over same old stuff, whether it is direct mail, spamming your inbox or retargeting.
Then a year or two back someone tried to launch a startup here - without much success, thank heavens - that paid people (poorly) to actually write out addresses and even letters by hand, so that people could receive 'genuine' hand-written mail from businesses they were dealing with, which would appear to be a personal thank-you note from the CEO or whatever. Happily most other HN readers were similarly dismayed and the founder was excoriated, though I'm sure the business lives on and is probably profitable given the economic incentives.
Living in the US, I really don't think that full first amendment protections should extend to corporations or commercial speech. Sure, corporations are legal persons (for some very valid reasons), but that personhood should be severely limited - after all, we wouldn't allow corporations to start launching artillery shells at each other on the theory that they deserved second amendment rights (in the USA obviously).
I don't favor pre-emptive censorship, but I do favor the idea that deceptive commercial speech should expose the dishonest speaker to severe civil damages as punishment for seeking to exploit public trust mechanisms for private asymmetrical gain.
For years and years we've been telling everyone that software is eating the world, and that everyone needs to be more data driven. This is one of those results: software-mediated marketing outreach, measuring various response actions and using them as signals to determine further outreach.
I also think it's perhaps a bit unfair to blame marketers in isolation. They are just chasing the best conversion rates, and if they ceased doing so, their bosses would fire and replace them.
Honestly, the solution here is to introduce a concept to the software industry that exists in more mature industries: brand management. The second you develop an internal notion of your own brand, you start to develop a mental framework for how customers (and people in general) perceive that brand, and how actions like optimizing marketing automation can have negative consequences on brand perception. You learn to treat marketing strategically, and not just tactically.
Brand marketing is the counterbalance that keeps outbound marketing honest.
But a lot of marketing people seem to think that the best way to do this is to annoy potential or existing customers, so that their employer's brand will always come to mind first, even if it is tainted with somewhat negative feelings about the product. In one way, I don't blame them - that technique is empirically proven to work, marketing people want to meet their targets, get paid, and go home like everyone else does, and the uncertain nature of business communication makes it difficult to adjust to the information preferences of each individual consumer.
But in another way, I do blame them, for two reasons. One, because they are deliberately choosing to clutter up people's lives with unwanted solicitations of attention, often despite specifically being asked not to. One thing I really miss about living in the Netherlands is that the post office there gives you stickers you can put on your mail box/slot to indicate whether you are willing to accept different kinds of commercial mail, both generic and personal.
Two, because a great deal of marketing material goes beyond a solicitation and description of goods and services and into bullshit and deception. Almost every marketing professional I've ever met seems to think that some dishonesty in commercial matters is OK. It's understandable, as they're partly backed by a legal system that historically regards many false claims in advertising as 'mere puffery' - essentially saying that because consumers are exposed to a lot of bullshit anyway, it's OK to bullshit them.
I disagree, and the greater the degree of bullshit I receive from any given business, the more likely I am to retaliate against them in some fashion, by adding them to spam lists, badmouthing them within my social circle, or occasionally responding with bullshit communications of my own designed to waste their time - followed up with helpful comparisons to their own marketing materials so they understand that deception doesn't pay.