Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand
by snowwrestler on Friday December 09, 2016 @09:13PM
(#13143606)
This is a popular sentiment on HN but I think it is mistaken.
First of all, who gets to determine what is "best"? You? The relativity of perceived product value makes it hard to prove that people are buying the "wrong" things. The whole point of markets is that it is impossible to determine in advance what people really want.
If what you said were true, the biggest marketing budget would always win, but it doesn't--far from it. The economy is littered with the wasted marketing budgets of failed products.
Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand
by WaxProlix on Saturday December 10, 2016 @01:01AM
(#13144298)
> If what you said were true, the biggest marketing budget would always win, but it doesn't--far from it. The economy is littered with the wasted marketing budgets of failed products.
That would be true if ad budget = ad quality, but I don't think it does.
Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand
by Gustomaximus on Friday December 09, 2016 @09:53PM
(#13143728)
David Olgily has a great quote on this: "Great marketing only makes a bad product fail faster"
Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand
by amelius on Saturday December 10, 2016 @06:45AM
(#13145228)
This quote might as well be false.
(In fact, most quotes are a form of marketing, not for products but for ideas.)
Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand
by Terr_ on Friday December 09, 2016 @06:07PM
(#13142663)
It may also be an indirect signal [0] of "our product is so good, we can afford to spend on big ad campaigns".
Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand
by anigbrowl on Saturday December 10, 2016 @08:02PM
(#13148967)
Well get back to us when you have some objective method of determining what's best for people instead f letting them figure it out for themselves. I'm not into throwing the baby out with the bathwater and I don't know a more efficient product/service discovery mechanism than evaluating competing claims and reading reviews by different kinds of journalists/publications.
Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand
by lmm on Friday December 09, 2016 @07:20PM
(#13143090)
Coordination problems are the biggest problems. A lot of market inefficiency happens because participants simply don't know there's a cheaper/better way to get the thing they want. So there's space for marketing to create a lot of value, by telling people what's out there and why they care.
Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand
by OtterCoder on Saturday December 10, 2016 @11:50AM
(#13146477)
But that isn't the function of marketing at all. Marketing, in the minds of the marketers, is about making you believe that there is no alternative but theirs.
But it is dysfunctional, or even anti-functional, for the economy. Because with advertisements we're not buying the "best" product, but rather the one with the biggest associated marketing budget.
It undermines the most important merit of capitalism.