News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lego Is the Perfect Toy by agumonkey on Thursday December 08, 2016 @12:58PM (#13132411)
The generic was part of the appeal. It seems to have peaked in the 90s, now LEGO is milking dedicated shapes. Expected, that's how "progress" evolve. Even my father complains.
Re:Lego Is the Perfect Toy by mcphage on Thursday December 08, 2016 @01:12PM (#13132559)
> now LEGO is milking dedicated shapes. Expected, that's how "progress" evolve. Even my father complains

I think most of the people who make these complaints simply haven't shopped for Lego in a while and so are operating on a lot of feeling but not much data. Stroll down the Lego aisle(s) at Target, you'll see plenty of free-form sets and traditional pieces like these entire product lines: https://www.lego.com/en-us/classic?icmp=COUSFRClassic and https://www.lego.com/en-us/creator?icmp=COUSFRCreator

Re:Lego Is the Perfect Toy by agumonkey on Thursday December 08, 2016 @01:22PM (#13132662)
It's indeed a reflex based on the new sets I saw since a few years (lots of franchise). I still feel something missing from how sets were designed in the 80s-00s era. Something of that period I miss, half nostalgia, but not only. A balance between surface and simplicity. Kinda like pixel art.
Re:Lego Is the Perfect Toy by timcederman on Thursday December 08, 2016 @02:15PM (#13133181)
The sets I remember having in the 80s and 90s had lots of custom pieces. My son's Lego seems to have less custom pieces than I remember having when I was growing up. It is amazing watching what he creates after he gets bored of the original creation.
Re:Lego Is the Perfect Toy by mcphage on Thursday December 08, 2016 @03:00PM (#13133728)
> A balance between surface and simplicity. Kinda like pixel art.

Check out the architecture series: https://www.lego.com/en-us/architecture

They use mostly basic shapes, and not many colors, but I think have found a nice balance between representation & abstraction for the buildings they model.

Another thing going on is, I think their model designers have gotten a lot more skilled at using pieces in novel ways in their models. They've gotten better at representing details, so more details show up.

Re:Lego Is the Perfect Toy by agumonkey on Thursday December 08, 2016 @03:02PM (#13133748)
Good point, they have part of what I mentionned, but these are restricted less playful sets.
Re:Lego Is the Perfect Toy by mcphage on Thursday December 08, 2016 @06:23PM (#13135278)
They're not playful, I agree, but they're not restricted. They're made up of primarily generic pieces.
Re:Lego Is the Perfect Toy by prawn on Thursday December 08, 2016 @05:04PM (#13134721)
When I've looked, there've been dozens of co-branded products and far fewer classics/free-form sets. Some of the bulk brick buckets have been unavailable when I've shopped for my son locally.

But yes, that Creator line is great. I think the 3-in-1 sets especially are very good. My 3-4 yo son loves those. e.g., https://shop.lego.com/en-AU/Vacation-Getaways-31052

Especially when the 3 options are quite diverse; in this case a campervan, a house and a boat. The campervan is particularly clever.

Re:Lego Is the Perfect Toy by mcphage on Thursday December 08, 2016 @06:26PM (#13135296)
There are definitely a lot fewer Classic sets, but like... the point of them is that they're just a bunch of generic pieces. You don't need that many different sets, just sets of different sizes.

Of course, a just-pieces set of Lego technic would be amazing :-(

Re:Lego Is the Perfect Toy by douche on Thursday December 08, 2016 @01:44PM (#13132898)
They screwed up the formula in the early 2000s, with what is commonly known in AFOL circles as "Juniorization" - lots of big specialized pieces replacing what used to be made out of multiple pieces. Think an entire car chassis, in one piece.

They turned things around again in the late 2000s, and in some cases, have gone a bit too far in the other direction, in my opinion. Some sets are overwhelmed with tiny 1x1, 2x1, etc pieces where larger ones (though still from the basic brick set) would be stronger structurally, and wouldn't inflate the piece count as much.

Re:Lego Is the Perfect Toy by agumonkey on Thursday December 08, 2016 @02:01PM (#13133044)
There's a necessary evolution toward these, to differentiate and "improve" over the past. Maybe before realizing the past was just fine ?
Re:Lego Is the Perfect Toy by Retra on Friday December 09, 2016 @01:08AM (#13137014)
"The past" where LEGO was hemorrhaging money like crazy?
Re:Lego Is the Perfect Toy by agumonkey on Friday December 09, 2016 @06:11AM (#13138053)
I meant the design mind set, obviously not the financial health of the company. Most people understand the reasons why LEGO did what it did with franchise and new sets.
Re:Lego Is the Perfect Toy by moderateAFOL on Thursday December 08, 2016 @06:57PM (#13135507)
Yeah, if anything, the peak of "special pieces" LEGO was in the 90s.

If you want to complain about the current direction of lego, at least pick something that's still going on, like lego's increasing commitment to IPs. These used to be all licensed (Star Wars) but now there are a lot of sets that are on lego-owned IPs like Bionicle.

What there is is much less emphasis on traditional lego lines like "city". There is, if anything MORE availability of basic pieces at different prices. Other than size, why would you need lots of basic sets? The point is that they are basic.

Also, inflation adjusted, bulk purchase of lego basic pieces is historically very low right now, because it mostly seems to track the price of raw materials (mainly oil). I'm not 100% sure of this but I read someone making this case with some analysis on one of the lego collector boards.

Anyway, if you like plain, generic lego, this is probably the absolute best time to be into lego: extremely cheap basic lego in the constructor sets, very reasonable priced SPECIFIC lego in the bulk orders, ability to export from lego cad, the best range of technic parts and computer integration of all time...

lego is in much better shape than it was in the dark days of 2001.

Re:Lego Is the Perfect Toy by homarp on Friday December 09, 2016 @07:59AM (#13138482)
Re:Lego Is the Perfect Toy by PhasmaFelis on Thursday December 08, 2016 @09:02PM (#13136103)
As others have said, this is a constant resounding complaint about modern Lego, and I don't think there's much truth to it right now, if there ever was. I agree that very large, single-purpose piece like large molded rocks or entire wall sections aren't great, but in my experience most of the smaller "dedicated" pieces aren't single-purpose at all, and really encourage creativity.

Personally, if I have a big pile of mostly plain bricks, I tend to make a few generic things like a stick figure and a car and a rocketship and then run out of ideas. But give me a piece with a weird angle, or a bar sticking out of it, or a weirdly-shaped socket, or an engraved texture, and I start thinking, "What else could this be? What could I attach to this and how?"

Online Lego galleries (and official sets!) are full of designs that use apparently single-purpose pieces--handheld items for minifigs like weapons, tools, food, and flowers; larger components like doors, radar dishes, and wheel wells; even minifig limbs that were never even designed to be popped off of the torso or pelvis piece--to build weird new joint assemblies or imply small details or represent all sorts of objects. Limitations foster creativity.