News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by dmfdmf on Monday December 05, 2016 @01:40AM (#13103780)
<During a routine test on April 26, 1986, reactor Number 4 at the Chernobyl Nuclear Power Plant experienced a power surge that triggered an emergency shutdown.>

Not routine. Operators disabled numerous safety features to perform a turbine spin-down test before shutting down the reactor for scheduled maintenance. The power surge was due to putting the reactor in an unstable state before shutdown. The safety features they bypassed were designed to keep the reactor out of the unstable operating region.

Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by std_throwaway on Monday December 05, 2016 @06:34AM (#13104766)
Nuclear power is very safe if run by sensible humans without external pressure.

I just don't trust humans to accomplish this for the next thousand years without fail. Even less if a nuclear power plant is run for profit. Even less if storage of nuclear waste does not give off any profit and safe storage needs to be ensured for thousands of years.

Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by wojt_eu on Monday December 05, 2016 @07:29AM (#13104957)
In the mean time coal power plants kill more people than Chernobyl disaster every year.

"A United Nations study estimates the final total of premature deaths associated with the disaster will be around 4000, mostly from an estimated 3% increase in cancers which are already common causes of death in the region." - http://www.who.int/mediacentre/news/releases/2005/pr38/en/)

"Air pollution from Europe's 300 largest coal power stations causes 22,300 premature deaths a year"

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2013/jun/12/european...

[Edit] I just took top results from Google, without much research. My point is that even though I fear nuclear disasters too, we should try and compare numbers and trade-offs.

Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by mikeash on Monday December 05, 2016 @09:51AM (#13105642)
It's true that coal kills more than Chernobyl ever did, but that vastly understates it. Coal kills more people each year than all nuclear technology has killed in its entire history, including the bombs dropped on Japan. Coal kills in the neighborhood of a million people a year. Granted, most of those deaths are from dirty plants in less developed countries, but on the other hand Chernobyl was not exactly a shining beacon of safe nuclear plant design either.
Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by pvaldes on Monday December 05, 2016 @10:06AM (#13105742)
Sharks kill people also every year, but this fact do not makes Chernobil more safe.
Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by mikeash on Monday December 05, 2016 @10:16AM (#13105810)
What's your point?

My point is that concern should be at least vaguely proportional to danger. Freaking out about thousands killed by nuclear accidents while ignoring millions killed by properly operating coal plants is not sensible. And if nuclear displaces coal, then it will save many, many lives.

Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by pvaldes on Monday December 05, 2016 @11:48AM (#13106732)
This recurrent thing about how nuclear only killed one or two people or maybe five (all in Nagasaki), is getting really tiresome.
Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by mikeash on Monday December 05, 2016 @11:51AM (#13106768)
Are you saying we should stop discussing nuclear power's actual safety record because it's too annoying?
Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by pvaldes on Monday December 05, 2016 @12:02PM (#13106898)
I'm saying that discussion must stop cherry-picking and hiding variables at will. Like breast cancer rate increased for decades, value of wipping entire cities, billionary damage to economy, making the country easily vulnerable and a slave of security measures, agriculture and ecological problems. The only answer from this guys are "but coal is worse and sun can make you blisters", you don't care for guys that also die by X! and this is a red herring. Yes, everybody knows that cars kill a lot of people each year. Can we focus again in the elephant foot's problem?
Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by mikeash on Monday December 05, 2016 @12:17PM (#13107044)
What's being cherry-picked or hidden? I even tossed in casualties from nuclear weapons just to be generous.

Comparing with coal is highly relevant, since nuclear substitutes for coal. If coal is significantly more dangerous (as the numbers would indicate) then fear of nuclear power has ultimately killed a lot of people by preventing nuclear from further substituting for coal.

If you'd rather just talk about the dangers of nuclear power without that context, that's entirely fair. But that's a rather different complaint from what you've made so far. And if that's what you don't like, might I gently suggest just clicking the little [-] next to the comments that talk about coal? There's plenty of other discussion to be had here.

Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by perlpimp on Monday December 05, 2016 @07:48AM (#13105012)
Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by walkingolof on Monday December 05, 2016 @07:49AM (#13105017)
Nuclear disasters are more permanent and thus a bigger risk, I live in a place where it rained on that day in -86, we still have not gone back to normal, fishing, hunting etc
Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by mikeash on Monday December 05, 2016 @07:54AM (#13105033)
How long will it take for the mercury emitted by coal plants to leave the ecosystem?
Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by tobltobs on Monday December 05, 2016 @08:08AM (#13105082)
One of the standard arguments of nuclear power supporter is that radioactive materials exist naturally in soil and rock, therefore the additional radiation caused by by nuclear waste is neglect able. Is there any reason why nuclear power supporters do not apply the same logic to other energy sources?
Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by mikeash on Monday December 05, 2016 @08:19AM (#13105123)
I would never make that argument nor have I even seen it before now, so please don't hold me to that standard. It's a completely ridiculous argument, false on its face, so not something even worth discussing.

Edit: in case the sporadic downvotes indicate some confusion, let me elaborate.

Certainly there is a common argument which involves comparing artificial radioactivity to natural sources. The infamous "banana equivalent dose" is an example of this. But that's fundamentally a quantitative argument about accepting small doses. It's not a general argument for neglecting the danger of nuclear waste in general.

The argument that you should, say, not worry about the dose you get from the americium in your smoke detectors, or the ocean contamination from Fukushima, can be made based on this. That argument is fundamentally sound. But it does not imply that you should go swim to the bottom of a spent fuel pool and hug the canisters, or that it would be a good idea to have a play in the mud next to Chernobyl.

There's nothing fundamentally wrong with making similar arguments for coal. For example, if the amount of mercury contamination in seafood was small compared to the amount of mercury naturally present, it would be quite sensible to argue that coal is not a major problem when it comes to mercury pollution of the ocean. The problem, of course, is that it's simply not true: the natural level of mercury is pretty low, and the contamination from coal power is substantial. When the FDA recommends limiting the intake of seafood for young children and pregnant women, it's not because of the naturally occurring levels, it's because of contamination due to human activity, of which coal is the largest part.

Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by saalweachter on Monday December 05, 2016 @09:17AM (#13105441)
So there are two extremes to radioactive waste / leakage.

One extreme is the "ideal dispersal" leak, like the Fukushima leaks into the ocean. In this case, the radioactive material does not "clump up" enough to be dangerous -- it's not that some cubic meters of ocean are fine and some contain deadly, deadly poison, it's that each cubic meter of ocean contains the same minuscule amount of radioactive material, too low to be a threat.

The other extreme is the "immobile clump" of radioactive material, like the Elephant's Foot at the heart of Chernobyl. Here you have enough radioactivity to cause serious harm or death if you get too close for too long. It's scary, but it's also pretty stationary. It's scary like a hole in the ground. You stay away, you warn people not to fall in, but it's not going to creep up on you without warning, like a sinkhole in Florida.

The really scary kind of radioactive waste isn't either of these two extremes, but a dangerous middle-ground: radioactive waste which is clumpy enough to give off deadly amounts of radiation, but mobile enough to get everywhere. You occasionally get this from reactor leaks (that's the primary reason for the exclusion zone around Chernobyl; on the other hand, they could never find any evidence of this sort of leak after Three Mile Isle). You also see it in non-power-plant nuclear accidents, like the Goiânia Accident, which involved a radiation source used in medical imagine.

You also worry about it in coal ash, because the ash can be blown and scattered but is clumpy enough that the radioactive particulate doesn't disperse.

Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by rimantas on Monday December 05, 2016 @08:20AM (#13105124)
Nuclear power supporter should point out, that radioactive emmisions of the power plant are lower than those of coal plant.
Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by tobltobs on Monday December 05, 2016 @08:23AM (#13105136)
I guess you mean in the best case scenario and with a solved ultimate disposal problem for the nuclear waste.
Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by ucaetano on Monday December 05, 2016 @09:20AM (#13105463)
No, in the normal case. Coal has trace amounts of radioactive elements (such as uranium and thorium), burning it in large quantities concentrates those elements and release them into the atmosphere.

And that's true even when you account for the risk of nuclear power plants and spent fuel. Coal ash is produced in gigantic quantities, and often stored in an open environment, while spent fuel is vitrified and far easier to contain.

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/coal-ash-is-more-...

Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by triplesec on Monday December 05, 2016 @09:50AM (#13105636)
Thank you for the link: I had no idea about this. A failure in science energy education i the media, again, it seems.
Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by crdoconnor on Monday December 05, 2016 @08:53AM (#13105313)
>In the mean time coal power plants kill more people than Chernobyl disaster every year.

In the mean time, solar/wind is just as cheap to build as coal whereas nuclear (when built safely) costs more.

Nuclear also benefits from government subsidized insurance (the nuclear liability cap).

Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by ucaetano on Monday December 05, 2016 @09:21AM (#13105464)
But you can't use solar/wind as base load. At least not yet.
Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by crdoconnor on Monday December 05, 2016 @09:32AM (#13105529)
https://theconversation.com/baseload-power-is-a-myth-even-in...

The old myth was based on the incorrect assumption that base-load demand can only be supplied by base-load power stations; for example, coal in Australia and nuclear in France. However, the mix of renewable energy technologies in our computer model, which has no base-load power stations, easily supplies base-load demand. Our optimal mix comprises wind 50-60%; solar PV 15-20%; concentrated solar thermal with 15 hours of thermal storage 15-20%; and the small remainder supplied by existing hydro and gas turbines burning renewable gases or liquids. (Contrary to some claims, concentrated solar with thermal storage does not behave as base-load in winter; however, that doesn’t matter.)

Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by ucaetano on Monday December 05, 2016 @09:38AM (#13105570)
The article talks about renewables in general, not just the current wind and solar technologies widely available in the market.

Hydro can easily be used as base-load, as it is in Brazil and Switzerland.

Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by CmdrSprinkles on Monday December 05, 2016 @06:52AM (#13104818)
This is also a largely solved problem in the form of self contained plants

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Small,_sealed,_transportable,_...

Basically, the idea is that you remove the human factor where possible (and modern robotics/drone technology can handle where humans ARE needed... to a degree) and build it with the focus on protecting that valuable waste from bad folk.

There are definitely some concerns still, but this combined with much safer reactor technology gets rid of a lot of the concerns.

One of the big problems is that even a lot of existing tech is still very old because people are terrified of nuclear energy and don't want to build new stuff. Which leads to making do with old stuff and finding ways to retrofit. Which is basically NASA's problem just with fear instead of apathy leading to crap budgets.

Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by kalleboo on Monday December 05, 2016 @07:28AM (#13104956)
I also don't trust humans to handle nuclear power safely.

But the types of grids and storage systems needed for renewables are not quite on the horizon, and right now the alternative is fossil fuels which have a far worse track record than nuclear. Nuclear worst case is a localized area is poisoned for generations. Fossil fuels best case is the whole planet becomes a struggle for human life. Can't we hedge our bets?

Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by ageofwant on Monday December 05, 2016 @09:14AM (#13105422)
The area directly surrounding Chernobyl is a lush green wildlife haven. Its paradise compared to say, Sydney CBD.
Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by pvaldes on Monday December 05, 2016 @01:23PM (#13107798)
New York was a green forest and a nice river before people came and will return to this original state if people leaves for any reason.
Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by kalleboo on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @08:53AM (#13114543)
Obviously the planet would be better off if humankind was wiped out. I'm not convinced that should be our goal though.
Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by hueving on Monday December 05, 2016 @07:47AM (#13105005)
Classic irrational fear. Even with the old reactors included, how many deaths has nuclear caused compares to coal/natural gas?

I would rather have us running on 100 fukushima era plants than the stupidity of continually burning dinosaurs until we ruin the environment.

Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by rimantas on Monday December 05, 2016 @08:24AM (#13105141)
You can include hydro too. Banqiao Dam. Or Sayano–Shushenskaya power station accident in 2009 if you want more recent one.
Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by ceejayoz on Monday December 05, 2016 @09:52AM (#13105649)
Banqiao Dam killed one hundred seventy one THOUSAND people, for anyone who's skimming past. If a nuclear plant killed that many it'd be the end of nuclear power.
Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by makomk on Monday December 05, 2016 @03:54PM (#13109428)
As I understand it, Banqiao Dam was primarily intended as a flood defence scheme. Even if China had abandoned hydroelectric power they'd still have had to construct the dam for that reason. If they'd used nuclear power (which I don't think existed back then) instead, you'd still have had all the deaths from the dam failure plus however many people they managed to kill from applying the same inadequate construction standards and mismanagement to nuclear power plants.
Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by JoeAltmaier on Monday December 05, 2016 @09:57AM (#13105688)
But nuclear power can kill slowly over decades. Can we come up with the true number of deaths (or shortened lives) from radiation? Its hard to compare.
Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by ceejayoz on Monday December 05, 2016 @10:21AM (#13105847)
> Can we come up with the true number of deaths (or shortened lives) from radiation?

Yes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nuclear_and_radiation_...

Estimates will range a bit, but we can say with complete confidence that all nuclear accidents thus far haven't come anywhere near that one dam failure.

Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by JoeAltmaier on Monday December 05, 2016 @04:05PM (#13109560)
Reading that page, I see estimates from 1/10 to 10X the dam failure. I can't see how it could be said "haven't come anywhere near"
Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by ceejayoz on Monday December 05, 2016 @10:53PM (#13112110)
> I see estimates from 1/10 to 10X the dam failure.

What? Banqiao Dam killed 171,000 people. There's zero reputable evidence (or even reasonable speculation) for nuclear accidents killing 1.7 million. Even Greenpeace caps out at 200k, and UN/WHO come in in the dozens-to-thousands range.

Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @08:49AM (#13114519)
I can only say, read the article just quoted? It wasn't me that put that up there.
Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by PolLambert on Monday December 05, 2016 @07:03AM (#13104859)
New nuclear power plants are designed to be safe even when run by unsensible humans (up to 72h) Any nuclear storage has to designed to be safe and secure from the second you close it up, irrespective of what humans will be doing the next thousands of years. (except of course, deliberately opening said storage)
Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by edblarney on Monday December 05, 2016 @08:44AM (#13105238)
CANDU reactors in Canada, I think are designed to be run by nobody at all.

They require heavy water to keep the reaction going. No heavy water, it just cools down.

If anything 'breaks' - no heavy water, no chain reaction.

I'm grossly oversimplifying, but you get the idea.

I suggest that if we actually put our minds to it, we could develop a kind of 'dumb reactor' that didn't require any kind of intervention at all, other than maintenance.

Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by CmdrSprinkles on Monday December 05, 2016 @09:06AM (#13105384)
Already done and has been for a while. Here is a quick wiki article on the subject/an example https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Small,_sealed,_transportable,_...

Plenty more can be found if you have access to read actual articles and not just wikipedia

Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by std_throwaway on Monday December 05, 2016 @07:25AM (#13104947)
I'm not aware that we have such storage and I'm very sure that we have not tested such storage for long-term stability.
Re:Chernobyl’s Hot Mess, “the Elephant’s Foot”, Is Still Let... by mikeash on Monday December 05, 2016 @09:54AM (#13105664)
I question the generally-accepted necessity of such storage. Yes, nuclear waste remains dangerous for thousands of years. But chemical waste such as arsenic and mercury remain dangerous forever, but we don't take anything like those precautions when disposing of those.