News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by paulcole on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @09:42PM (#13068028)
Reddit, a private website, is under no obligation to provide a safe space for free speech.
Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by tux1968 on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @09:45PM (#13068037)
Of course. But then advertise yourself as such, not as a bastion of free speech and authentic conversations. To me that is admitting your side of the argument is weak and fearful.
Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by CaptSpify on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @12:17AM (#13068659)
This is what drove me nuts. HN doesn't at all claim to be a free-speech area. And that's fine. In fact, I'd argue that it's a great way to keep everyone focused, and helps keep the trolls out.

But I've never seen anywhere that HN claims to be about free speech. Reddit claimed that title for a long time, even when they were clearly censoring things. Feel free to tell people to fuck off. There's nothing wrong with doing that on your private site. But don't turn around and tell people you are a free-speech site while doing so.

Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by simonh on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @10:26PM (#13068258)
I agree to the extent that this is about arguments, but this largely isn't about arguments though, it's about threatening and abusive behaviour.
Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by the8472 on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @09:44PM (#13068035)
the entire internet is composed of private entities. following that logic there is practically no free speech on the internet.
Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by bhauer on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @09:57PM (#13068113)
As someone who champions a re-decentralization of the Internet and remembers the era of peer to peer communications, I am saddened by the assumed centralization behind your statement.
Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by the8472 on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @02:28AM (#13069082)
A decentralized internet still needs its pipes and some people will want to colo servers and not operate server farms from home. That means you still need to buy services from private entities.

universal service obligations are not enshrined everywhere.

Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by leephillips on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @09:57PM (#13068110)
I can exercise my right of free speech on my website. What do you mean?
Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by the8472 on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @10:11PM (#13068194)
Hosters and DNS providers can kick you out. This doesn't happen often, but occasionally it does, without court order, when a customer becomes too inconvenient. Some don't even want to deal with DMCA notices, so even when they get fake ones they kick you out after a few.
Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by leephillips on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @10:35PM (#13068292)
That's a good point - so even my own website is not as free as standing on the street corner and shouting. But if my hosting company did kick me out it might be (haven't checked) a breach of contract; and in any case I could be on a new host in a couple of hours.
Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by GabberBots on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @10:15PM (#13068209)
Your having a website assumes common carrier and net neutrality protections.
Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by grzm on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @10:29PM (#13068274)
I hear this argument a lot. From what I've seen, it's clear that ISPs are common carriers. I haven't seen informed legal opinion that this extends to websites. I'd be very interested in learning of some. Do you have any?
Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by GabberBots on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @11:27PM (#13068492)
If ISPs are not bound to CC laws and refuse to carry traffic from your web server, you don't really have much of a website, do you?
Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by grzm on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @11:37PM (#13068527)
Yes. CC laws apply to ISPs. I haven't seen evidence that they apply to websites.
Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by kyledrake on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @10:08PM (#13068178)
Correct.

"Free speech" as enshrined in the US Constitution is designed to prevent the government from making laws against free expression. Any interpretation applying "free speech protections" to private entities hosting other private entities on their private property is either ideological, or an intense misunderstanding of the law.

Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by wallace_f on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @10:19PM (#13068224)
I think reasonable people can agree that technology has paved the way for few exceptions which require special protections to free speech; i.e. Google should not be permitted by law to filter and censor search results for speech, no matter how disagreeable it is to you or the Google CEOs. Edit: In other words, no matter whether I like or dislike the 4chan community, an entire community of various forums such as that should not be filtered by Google.
Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by greglindahl on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @10:54PM (#13068356)
As someone who tried to compete with Google in search, I'm all for Google being permitted to filter anything they like; it's only censorship when a government forces or encourages them to do it. I'm also all for Google having an editorial opinion.... I have my own, and if you like mine better than Google, so be it.

This is the way that free speech has always worked in the US; if you own a printing press, you can print what you like.

Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by kyledrake on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @10:37PM (#13068296)
> I think reasonable people can agree that technology has paved the way for few exceptions which require special protections to free speech

Do you think it should have been unlawful for Reddit to ban Coontown? What would you think to be an appropriate punishment for this proposed crime? A fine? Jail time?

Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by grzm on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @10:55PM (#13068362)
Before moving on to another site (which is a logical move to determine the bounds of the exceptions), what do you think of your parent's suggestion regarding Google? Easier to work from some point of common ground (if there is some).
Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by wallace_f on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @11:04PM (#13068400)
Yea, I think there is a clear distinction. Google inhabits an arguably monopolistic or at least monopolistic-competitive (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopolistic_competition) space.

Google also arguably is approximating a public good. Search is free to use, and you actually have to rely on it and use it to compete in the modern marketplace for educational resources.

There are many things we all rely on to compete and succeed. We need to drink water, and we need to be able to trust that the water is safe to drink. If a private company is in charge of water, they should be heavily regulated for that very reason. While you won't die without search engines, you obviously need to use them to reasonably compete for economic survival.

Google has a majority market share, while Bing and Yahoo trail behind, but they could all easily collaborated with or without government to censor, and it would have extreme consequences for the possibility of free expression, giving these corporations a lot of power. Do we want private corporations to have this much power over free expression?

They can also do this without announcing to you that they are currently filtering search results for political reasons (I would be most people don't realize they are already doing this).

Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by grzm on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @11:10PM (#13068428)
You're replying to kyledrake, correct?
Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by wallace_f on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @11:47PM (#13068551)
To both. I was just expounding on the distinction I see b/w reddit and Google -- the point was trying to make was that I don't think it's completely appropriate to make Google analogous to reddit.
Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by wallace_f on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @03:37AM (#13069291)
Of course not. Everybody relies on Google (or at least, 1 of Google, bing or yahoo) and an argument can be made that they should be regulate because if they do not operate in good faith that can have severe consequences (i.e. effectively eliminating dissenting opinion). Private companies being regulated in the best interest of the public good is nothing new, Sinclairs The Jungle was written in 1906, technology changes but human nature has not and we should adapt regulation to new technology if we're interested in the public's welfare and future.
Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by grzm on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @09:47PM (#13068052)
Another possible comparison: cities are composed of mostly private entities. The free speech limitations in private businesses are comparable to those on line. How does that play out? Is the comparison faulty? Honest question. I'd like to figure out a more real-world comparison that matches our intuitions.
Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by the8472 on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @09:51PM (#13068069)
There are lots of public spaces available, maintained by the government.

Some plazas are larger than all but the largest private gathering places.

Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by grzm on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @10:01PM (#13068134)
Good point. Any ideas on how to create similar spaces online? And how they should be policed? Should we have some government created forums? I'd be concerned they'd succumb to the same issues we're discussing now. One idea that comes to mind is forbidding anonymous posts, but then again, anonymous speech is also protected.
Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by sanswork on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @10:22PM (#13068242)
You create a website and post your thoughts on it.