News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Theranos Sued for Alleged Fraud by Robertson Stephens Co-... by jpeg_hero on Monday November 28, 2016 @04:12PM (#13058467)
I think not bankruptcy...

It's been reported that Theranos still has $400M in cash. And the founder has majority control.

So this is a very rare condition, where there is still assets in the company (so a judgement can be paid) but the company has no business plan. So you have a founder who's best play now is sit around for the next 10 years spending down that $400M on new business plans to see if something hits.

Re:Theranos Sued for Alleged Fraud by Robertson Stephens Co-... by Naritai on Monday November 28, 2016 @04:53PM (#13058759)
400M isn't that much. Per Glassdoor Theranos has 790 employees; assuming that was before layoffs and the numbers in the news (~340 layoffs) are accurate, that's 450. Since it's an R&D company in Palo Alto, average total comp is likely north of $250k per person, but even at that it's $110M a year in payroll alone. And medical research isn't exactly cheap, I bet it easily spends over $100M in research costs. So at that burn rate Theranos has 2 years to keep the lights on. It takes more than 2 years for a medical company to bring a new product to market.

Go ahead, halve all my numbers and argue that Theranos actually has a burn rate of 4 years: It still doesn't matter, there is no way they'll get something through the FDA (especially given recent history) in 4 years.

Re:Theranos Sued for Alleged Fraud by Robertson Stephens Co-... by ghaff on Monday November 28, 2016 @05:21PM (#13058930)
Honest question. Why isn't the board just shutting everything down rather than let it continue to burn through cash? Are there sufficient insiders tin whose interest it is to continue their payday?
Re:Theranos Sued for Alleged Fraud by Robertson Stephens Co-... by kooshball on Monday November 28, 2016 @05:36PM (#13059035)
Board can't make that decision if the CEO has majority voting rights.
Re:Theranos Sued for Alleged Fraud by Robertson Stephens Co-... by nerfhammer on Monday November 28, 2016 @05:52PM (#13059142)
Honest question: what's the point of having a board then?
Re:Theranos Sued for Alleged Fraud by Robertson Stephens Co-... by exhilaration on Monday November 28, 2016 @06:08PM (#13059237)
It's valuable to have prestigious board members when fundraising, even if they're essentially powerless and have no experience in your industry, like a retired United States Marine Corps general [1]. It give you legitimacy and credibility.

[1] https://www.theranos.com/leadership/board-of-directors

Re:Theranos Sued for Alleged Fraud by Robertson Stephens Co-... by aswanson on Monday November 28, 2016 @08:04PM (#13059873)
Why should an old military figure lend credibility to a biotechnology firm?
Re:Theranos Sued for Alleged Fraud by Robertson Stephens Co-... by Trundle on Monday November 28, 2016 @11:27PM (#13060787)
Because you're being pitched on the biotech firm being able to land fat military contracts.
Re:Theranos Sued for Alleged Fraud by Robertson Stephens Co-... by zzleeper on Monday November 28, 2016 @08:58PM (#13060096)
That's the question we all asked.
Re:Theranos Sued for Alleged Fraud by Robertson Stephens Co-... by b2600 on Monday November 28, 2016 @10:17PM (#13060483)
Generally speaking, it is for their contacts
Re:Theranos Sued for Alleged Fraud by Robertson Stephens Co-... by CPLX on Monday November 28, 2016 @06:08PM (#13059235)
To represent the owners of the company. The founder is over half the owner of the company. So the system is working as intended.

In all fairness, though generally lawsuits represent a failure on some level, this kind of situation is kind of why we have courts. That's a proper venue to determine what to do next in this unusual and extraordinary situation.

Re:Theranos Sued for Alleged Fraud by Robertson Stephens Co-... by bosdev on Monday November 28, 2016 @05:35PM (#13059026)
I believe the founder has a controlling interest. The board can't do much without her say so.
Re:Theranos Sued for Alleged Fraud by Robertson Stephens Co-... by SomeStupidPoint on Monday November 28, 2016 @07:45PM (#13059777)
I was on a small company board, was an officer, and was the (vast) majority shareholder, at least for voting rights.

Technically, the board could have fired me, and it would taken something like 2 or 3 months to have forced my way back on. (Calling a major shareholder meeting to elect the board out of cycle, plus calling a new board meeting to vote myself in, takes time and organization.) The political cost of overruling the board in that manner also wouldn't be null for me, and likely would've caused key staff to quit and key backers to stop supporting the project. I definitely would have had to do a lot of explaining for such a power play, and it's likely my reputation never would recover at the company.

As a lot of kings have learned: your word may be law, but nobles pay the taxes, provide the swords, etc. You can't make enemies of everyone.

Re:Theranos Sued for Alleged Fraud by Robertson Stephens Co-... by jpeg_hero on Monday November 28, 2016 @06:23PM (#13059301)
That's why we are pivoting into the exciting unregulated area of medical document management with: The Thernos Wellness Document Platform!

Keeping only the "best" 50 engineers of course.

that's what complete voting control means!

Re:Theranos Sued for Alleged Fraud by Robertson Stephens Co-... by flylib on Monday November 28, 2016 @09:33PM (#13060284)
or she go could extreme, cut down to 50 employees (250k total comp per person) get down to a 20 mil a year burn rate which would give her 20 years or she could go even more extreme and be more or less set for life
Re:Theranos Sued for Alleged Fraud by Robertson Stephens Co-... by Trundle on Monday November 28, 2016 @11:29PM (#13060799)
Nothing about her being able to pick a new business plan as she pleases implies that she'll retain all (or any) current Theranos staff, equipment, or offices.
Re:Theranos Sued for Alleged Fraud by Robertson Stephens Co-... by trhway on Monday November 28, 2016 @07:12PM (#13059576)
>the company has no business plan.

i'd not say so. Originally they tried to sell their tech to DoD (in 2012), and Mattis, a 4 star general back then, was the key figure in trying to push the deal through (no surprise that he ended on their board :). Given that he may become new defense secretary under Trump this old plan becomes new and shiny again. Also consider how FDA actions toward Theranos may be spun out in the new political regime as an example of egregious regulation overreach strangulating revolutionary innovations and entrepreneurship ...

So Theranos need to survive only until the January 21st.

Re:Theranos Sued for Alleged Fraud by Robertson Stephens Co-... by ChuckMcM on Monday November 28, 2016 @05:19PM (#13058908)
One judgement could wipe that out, especially if it was eligible for treble damages.
Re:Theranos Sued for Alleged Fraud by Robertson Stephens Co-... by dekhn on Monday November 28, 2016 @04:36PM (#13058641)
It seems unlikely Ms. Holmes is going to have the opportunity to pursue that strategy. She has been personally banned from running a diagnostic facility, her company is being sued for fraud, and pretty much all their claims have vanished in smoke. Who would buy a product with a company with a history like that?
Re:Theranos Sued for Alleged Fraud by Robertson Stephens Co-... by nihonde on Monday November 28, 2016 @07:25PM (#13059651)
It isn't at all rare for a bankrupt company to have many millions, even billions, in assets. It might be more unusual to have hundreds of millions in cash on hand, though.
Re:Theranos Sued for Alleged Fraud by Robertson Stephens Co-... by iaw on Monday November 28, 2016 @05:17PM (#13058896)
I expect their debts to run into the multiple-billions.