News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Thoughts on Flash by ugh on Thursday April 29, 2010 @09:58AM (#1304380)
Which arguments are FUD?
Re:Thoughts on Flash by not_an_alien on Thursday April 29, 2010 @10:07AM (#1304416)
* Flash websites will have to be rewritten because it relies on 'rollovers', which is not part of Apple's 'revolutionary' touch interface: overblown for two reasons - a) few stuff will have to be rewritten (many videos show desktop Flash content working on mobile phones without a problem); and b) this is not a problem with Flash, as any JS/HTML-based interface that relies on rollovers has the same issues.

* Flash is 'closed and proprietary': Flash is as 'closed and proprietary' as many of the technologies he's trying to portray as open, if not less. H264 is not open. Objective+C++ is not open. Flash (SWF) has a fully published spec and anyone can write tools to create, or play, SWF content, without royalties, or without having to respond to any entity.

* Adobe only wants cross-platform apps, not good apps; generic subjective bullshit.

* Comparing video decompression versus hardware decompression battery gains and claiming that's an advantage over Flash: bullshit, since Flash uses video decompression in most cases.

* Saying Adobe postponed the release dates of Flash 10.1 for smartphones: bullshit. He's repeating a story that has already been corrected on a number of places (that Flash's release was pushed to 2nd half of 2010) as fact. That he's ignoring the fact that the story was misinterpreted by one source, and simply repeating the wrong news, is staggering. FP is still bound for a release in the 1st half of 2010.

* Saying "Adobe has recently added support for h264 playback": gee, I guess 2.5 years is "recently"? h264 support was added with FP 9.0.115, released in December 2007.

There's a lot more, but it tends to get tiring to constantly dispel the most obvious FUD written for the general public and full of misinformation. Mactards will believe whatever they want to believe, so hey... I'll just let the platform speak for itself. In 5 years, let's see how well Apple narrow mindedness business decisions work out for them.

Re:Thoughts on Flash by naner on Thursday April 29, 2010 @10:28AM (#1304491)
> H264 is not open.

There are multiple implementations and Apple can tweak how it runs. It is open enough for their purposes.

> Objective+C++ is not open.

He never said it was. He said Apple has several proprietary products but believed the web should be open.

> Flash (SWF) has a fully published spec and anyone can write tools to create, or play, SWF content, without royalties, or without having to respond to any entity.

Yet Adobe has the only full implementation of Flash and if someone else were to try and implement it, it would always be behind the official release (just like Moonlight). And Adobe got lawyer-happy when open source guys reversed the streaming protocol in Flash so nobody is eager to try this anyways.

> Saying Adobe postponed the release dates of Flash 10.1 for smartphones: bullshit.

The fact is Adobe has been boasting about Flash on smartphones since Android first came out and there have been no working devices out except Maemo which totally sucked in every way Jobs described.

There was spin in this article just like his DRM article but I wouldn't qualify anything as FUD.

Re:Thoughts on Flash by not_an_alien on Thursday April 29, 2010 @10:37AM (#1304546)
> It is open enough for their purposes. Ok great, so Flash is also "open enough": fully published specs, anyone is allowed to use the format (creating, playing) without royalties. SWF is more open than h264.

> He never said it was True. But if he wants to make this conversation an open-versus-closed conversation, I fully expect to compare the platforms in general instead of just a tiny bit of it.

> There was spin in this article just like his DRM article but I wouldn't qualify anything as FUD. Saying Adobe postponed the release date is a lie. Saying they said it would be released before is also a lie, since Adobe never announced a date for public release (it was available for devs as beta). Maybe it's not your definition of FUD, but it's still a lie. I don't expect the CEO of a company this big to be repeating this bullshit.

http://www.webkitchen.be/2010/04/19/flash-player-10-1-for-an...

Is he going to post a correction? Somehow, I don't think so.

Re:Thoughts on Flash by astrange on Thursday April 29, 2010 @11:45AM (#1304811)
> Ok great, so Flash is also "open enough": fully published specs, anyone is allowed to use the format (creating, playing) without royalties. SWF is more open than h264.

But does anyone do this? I see no usable reimplementations of Flash Player, and the spec cannot possibly be complete. H.264 is a real standard with a conformance suite and bit-accuracy, and no scripting languages or multiple versions with different bugs to reimplement.

Flash also includes VP6 and RTMPE, which are proprietary and must be reverse-engineered.

Re:Thoughts on Flash by naner on Thursday April 29, 2010 @01:46PM (#1305301)
> Ok great, so Flash is also "open enough"

This is clearly not true, though. The only implementation is closed and fully controlled by Adobe. Maybe it is more open in spirit but that doesn't mean crap in practical terms. In fact Silverlight is more open (in practical terms) than flash since at least there is a usable open source project. There exists right now a full featured and heavily developed open source h.264 decoder. You can't say the same for Flash. It is either Adobe Flash or spend a bazillion dollars trying to re-implement open flash that doesn't exist yet Flash. That's a non-starter.

Re:Thoughts on Flash by ptomato on Thursday April 29, 2010 @10:18AM (#1304458)
* "Objective+C++ is not open." Yeah? http://gcc.gnu.org/

* "Adobe only wants cross-platform apps, not good apps; generic subjective bullshit." Alright, so point to a single Adobe Air app, for example, that looks & behaves natively.

* "Comparing video decompression versus hardware decompression battery gains and claiming that's an advantage over Flash: bullshit, since Flash uses video decompression in most cases." Did you read the article? "the video on almost all Flash websites currently requires an older generation decoder that is not implemented in mobile chips and must be run in software" But hey, easy to prove wrong. Point to one mobile phone with Flash (not flash lite) support that has decent battery life. ... Oh, wait... Well, one mobile phone that has Flash support period? No?

Re:Thoughts on Flash by gecko on Thursday April 29, 2010 @10:33AM (#1304523)
Whether Objective-C is open is a weird discussion.

The Objective-C compiler is fully GPL'd, so that's definitely open.

Objective-C, though, depends on a runtime, and Apple's runtime is proprietary. While the GNU project has their Objective-C runtime, it performs markedly worse, and misses a lot of features that are available in Apple's version, including blocks, GCD-style multithreading, garbage collection, fast iterators, and more.

Re:Thoughts on Flash by wfarr on Thursday April 29, 2010 @10:39AM (#1304556)
Mono implements a good bit of .NET, but not all of it. That doesn't make it any less of an open platform.
Re:Thoughts on Flash by nailer on Thursday April 29, 2010 @12:03PM (#1304901)
Really? I consider .net a closed platform, as it is controlled by a single vendor, there is no patent guarantee (as Miguel has mentioned) and the alternative implementations (like GNash does with Flash) always lag behind.

(I happen to like .net, by the way, I just think it's closed.)

Re:Thoughts on Flash by wfarr on Thursday April 29, 2010 @02:23PM (#1305429)
.NET is a closed platform — but Mono, which does implement parts of .NET in addition to their own changes, is an open platform. All of Mono's design and implementation is transparent.
Re:Thoughts on Flash by ptomato on Thursday April 29, 2010 @10:57AM (#1304635)
I'd note that blocks at least are open-sourced under the MIT license so there's no excuse not to include them in the runtime.
Re:Thoughts on Flash by not_an_alien on Thursday April 29, 2010 @10:29AM (#1304500)
* If the compiler being open means Objective-C is open, then Flash is open as well: http://opensource.adobe.com/wiki/display/flexsdk/Flex+SDK

* We're talking about mobile applications like games being good enough, not desktop applications using native components. Please don't stray the conversation. Otherwise it's as dumb as me coming and saying iTunes should not be running on Windows.

* "Comparing video decompression" - The article (wishfully) ignores the fact that 'older' (flv) video formats are transcoded on the fly to a format that can be played by hardware. This technology has been present in the player for a while - ever since Flash Lite. Requires more CPU, but it is not the same as full software playback. Also, asking for mobile phones with battery life benchmarks is bogus, since it's still not officially released, so no proof can exist. It's like saying the next OS X is inherently shit just because you haven't seen it yet.

Re:Thoughts on Flash by ptomato on Thursday April 29, 2010 @10:36AM (#1304540)
* Well, I'm not sure what other part of Objective-C that's not "open" you would be talking about, exactly...

* "We're talking about mobile applications like games being good enough, not applications using native components." Except we're not. That whole section was discussing specifically 3.3.1 and why they aren't going to allow cross-compiled apps to run on the iPhone.

* "Comparing video decompression" Oh, that's not gonna have an effect on battery life, nooooo. And so what, you're saying Apple should have included something that isn't even released yet in the iPhone?

Re:Thoughts on Flash by joubert on Thursday April 29, 2010 @10:51AM (#1304614)
Flex is not flash
Re:Thoughts on Flash by not_an_alien on Thursday April 29, 2010 @11:23AM (#1304731)
I won't blame you for the confusion, as the naming is mixed up, but "Flex SDK" is the command-line Flash (SWF) compiler. It's free and open source. It's used to create SWFs or SWCs. It's the same compiler the Flash IDE has built-in.

I create full, rich Flash content with the Flex SDK, and has been doing it for a while. I don't compile with the Flash IDE. Not because I can't or because it's paid, but because using Flex SDK is better.

Re:Thoughts on Flash by joubert on Thursday April 29, 2010 @11:53AM (#1304857)
Maybe im nitpicking, but mxmlc compiles apps written using the flex sdk to flash bytecode. The flex sdk is open source yes, but the flash runtime certainly is not.
Re:Thoughts on Flash by jarek on Thursday April 29, 2010 @02:03PM (#1305375)
> Well, one mobile phone that has Flash support period? No?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/N900

Re:Thoughts on Flash by ez77 on Friday April 30, 2010 @03:15PM (#1309110)
I'm just now reading the article, and as a N900 owner I second this point. Flash does really well on this smartphone.
Re:Thoughts on Flash by teamonkey on Thursday April 29, 2010 @10:13AM (#1304439)
"Fortunately, there are over 50,000 games and entertainment titles on the App Store, and many of them are free. There are more games and entertainment titles available for iPhone, iPod and iPad than for any other platform in the world." Clearly nonsense.

I'm willing to bet that there are many, many more games and entertainment apps written in Flash alone than there are on the app store.

Re:Thoughts on Flash by bradshaw1965 on Thursday April 29, 2010 @12:30PM (#1305000)
"I'm willing to bet that there are many, many more games and entertainment apps written in Flash alone than there are on the app store."

Is that a position for or against keeping flash off the iPhone, iPod and iPad?

Re:Thoughts on Flash by teamonkey on Thursday April 29, 2010 @03:03PM (#1305592)
Neither. It's just pointing out one of many FUD items in Steve's memo.
Re:Thoughts on Flash by veemjeem on Thursday April 29, 2010 @07:44PM (#1306550)
Flash has been around a bit longer than the iPhone has, so no surprise there. Flash has been around since PointCast Network, if anyone actually still remembers that.
Re:Thoughts on Flash by illumin8 on Thursday April 29, 2010 @10:35AM (#1304534)
Wait a minute, how is comparing H.264 hardware support for decoding (I think you meant decoding, not decompression) vs. software bullshit? Shipping versions of Flash still use software for video decoding. The only versions that use hardware are unreleased beta versions of 10.1.

Your post sounds like an Adobe apologist making stuff up.

Re:Thoughts on Flash by not_an_alien on Thursday April 29, 2010 @10:48AM (#1304602)
Hardware decoding of video content has been available since FP version 10, released in October 2008.

I'm not making stuff up. I actually have my history of gripes with Adobe, as if I've been working with their software for more than a decade. If anything, I'm just enraged that this article is making stuff up, and I don't like people taking ideology and fundamentalism into a discussion that should be tech-based only.

Re:Thoughts on Flash by blasdel on Thursday April 29, 2010 @01:39PM (#1305270)
You are making stuff up.

Hardware acceleration for h.264 decoding was introduced in the Windows betas of Flash 10.1 in October 2009. It hasn't shipped yet, and probably won't for another 6 months.

Re:Thoughts on Flash by yuvi on Thursday April 29, 2010 @11:24AM (#1304734)
That isn't hardware decode, that's hardware scaling.

http://blogs.adobe.com/penguin.swf/2008/05/flash_uses_the_gp...

Also, Flash does not use any of the multiple hardware decode APIs on linux yet due to it needing readback support which apparently they don't have yet.

http://blogs.adobe.com/penguin.swf/2010/01/solving_different...

Re:Thoughts on Flash by bobbyi on Thursday April 29, 2010 @12:05PM (#1304916)
http://labs.adobe.com/technologies/flashplayer10/gala/

'Welcome to the Flash Player preview release, code-named “Gala,” which introduces support for H.264 video hardware decoding on Mac OS X 10.6.3, the most recent release of Mac OS X Snow Leopard... The hardware acceleration functionality in the Gala preview release of Flash Player is expected to be included in an update following the release of Flash Player 10.1.'

Re:Thoughts on Flash by Qz on Thursday April 29, 2010 @10:46AM (#1304586)
Your post makes it sound like said beta version will never see the light of day.
Re:Thoughts on Flash by illumin8 on Thursday April 29, 2010 @03:53PM (#1305775)
I'm sure it will see the light of day. I'm using the release candidate on my media center PC right now because it is the first version of Flash that can play Hulu content full screen at 1080p resolution without dropping frames.

Running a beta of a Flash Plugin that kinda supports hardware decoding but still crashes occasionally on a Windows PC is much different than running a production quality release of a hardware accelerated Flash plugin on a mobile device.

Re:Thoughts on Flash by Shorel on Thursday April 29, 2010 @11:36AM (#1304768)
I enjoy flash games and whatnot, but:

We should not NEED flash for reproducing video on the Web, no matter what codec or platform are involved.

Re:Thoughts on Flash by grk on Thursday April 29, 2010 @10:28AM (#1304494)
Objective+C++?
Re:Thoughts on Flash by not_an_alien on Thursday April 29, 2010 @10:49AM (#1304607)
Yeah, that was funny. I'll blame nerd rage.
Re:Thoughts on Flash by cpr on Thursday April 29, 2010 @12:53PM (#1305072)
Why? Apple's compilers support C, Objective-C and C++ in a single source, so you can call it Objective-C++.
Re:Thoughts on Flash by ryoshu on Thursday April 29, 2010 @11:52AM (#1304854)
- "First, there’s “Open”."

SWF is open (http://www.adobe.com/devnet/swf/). ActionScript 3 is open (http://www.ecmascript.org/docs.php, http://www.mozilla.org/projects/tamarin/). Want the Flex SDK? Here: http://opensource.adobe.com/wiki/display/flexsdk/Get+Source+... Want a non-Adobe compiler? http://haxe.org

Adobe still has closed projects like Flash Builder 4 and Flash CS5. But saying that, "Adobe’s Flash products are 100% proprietary" is false. FUD.

- "Second, there’s the “full web”."

h.264 is more modern than Flash's support for...? Oh, right. Flash has supported h.264 for over 2 years. FUD.

- "Third, there’s reliability, security and performance."

Pardon me while I go name a WAP "at&t wireless." Yes, Flash has security issues. Google mobile Safari 0day. FUD.

- "Fourth, there’s battery life."

As mentioned above, h.264 was adopted by Adobe years ago. FUD.

- "Fifth, there’s Touch."

I wrote a multi-touch Flash API for custom hardware shortly after Flash 9's release. Multi-touch works fine in Flash. Rewire some events and it's seamless. FUD.

- "Sixth, the most important reason."

Has Steve Jobs actually ever used Xcode? Beyond the native, crappy tools that Apple offers, some of us developers prefer to choose the tools we like to use when we write software. We like to use various languages based on what works best for us.

Apple is screwing over developers and they are using Microsoft level FUD to convince us its for our own good.

Re:Thoughts on Flash by cpr on Thursday April 29, 2010 @12:54PM (#1305078)
Some of us old-timers (Unix v6!) are using Xcode and think it's a great toolset.

Show me a better-integrated set of editors, compilers and (most important) debugging/performance analysis tools on any platform.