News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by aftbit on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @04:53PM (#13026067)
My fundamental hope for humanity is that someday, rather than having to confront social challenges around distribution of resources (who gets more water? who gets more land? who gets more oil? do we need to raise energy costs to capture the extrinsic costs of polluting the air?), we will just have enough and more of everything.

The Central Arizona Project and the Navajo Generating Station are my favorite examples of this. The Navajo Generating Station is a giant coal-fired power plant, which provides energy used primarily to pump water up into Arizona. The station substantially degrades air quality in the surrounding areas, and the water that is "stolen" from the Colorado is a part of the West's growing water concerns. Right now, there are two sides to the issue: those who think it is worth the cost to bring water to Arizona, and those who believe the environmental issues are too big. We could solve that like a social problem, using politics and ethics to try to make the decision... or we could just get on making energy cheap and clean, and suddenly a huge part of the cost disappears. If there was no fly ash issue, no NOx issue, no CO2 issue, then we're back to just worrying about the water flow. But if we have cheap energy, desalination suddenly looks a lot more palatable, which would reduce a lot of water pressures in the US. Los Angeles could switch to 100% desal water and the Colorado river would have a surplus of water again.

Cheap (and preferably clean) energy, solving climate change, and cheap access to space (this one is more dubious) would all broadly boost the quality of life for humanity.

Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by moyta on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @05:10PM (#13026190)
Los Angeles could also recycle its water for a much lower cost than desalination, but due to campaigns that claim it is unsanitary (ass to glass, etc) it is not an option politically.

Another angle on this is why are we scrutinizing only where 10% of California's water usage is, while ignoring 90% (farms)? Why do California's farmers have the right to the majority of the water while paying next to nothing for that water as compared to the rates the other users of water pay?

Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by WalterBright on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @09:27PM (#13027533)
There was a photo a while back of somebody urinating in a reservoir, and there was subsequent outrage and calls to put an enormously expensive cover over the reservoir (i.e. lake), etc.

Never mind that all the wildlife that urinates/defecates in it, the dead animals in it, etc., which nobody minds.

Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by Terr_ on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @10:13PM (#13027717)
Minor devil's-advocacy: It's reasonable to score the risk from human material/pathogens higher than animal ones.
Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by Spooky23 on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @11:29PM (#13028097)
Not really, it's pure hysteria.

Urine is generally sterile, it's actually an accepted first aid practice to urinate on a bandage or create a urine paste to treat a wound in the field in emergency conditions.

Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by niels_olson on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @11:46PM (#13028184)
What this really ignores is all the inland cities that use the same water source, one down-stream from the next, from the great lakes to the gulf of Mexico. I toured one of those sewage treatment plants in 1993 (1). It remains one of the most beautiful visions of my life: clear water flowing over algea-covered wooden beams, glowing in the natural sunlight, no odor whatsoever.

You can't make this stuff up. Civil engineers are amazing.

Edit: also, as per my other comment, urine, in the voided stream, is not sterile, and even if it were, certainly contains all the building blocks for bacterial growth.

(1) https://encrypted.google.com/maps/place/Johnson+County+Waste...

Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by pitaj on Friday November 25, 2016 @12:25AM (#13034569)
Is it civil engineering? I thought that hydraulics was a mechanical engineering field.
Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by mgkimsal on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @11:21PM (#13028050)
it might be reasonable to start with that assumption, but actually do tests to determine what's more dangerous. then put processes in place to clean the water from the dangerous stuff (from both humans and animals)
Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by moultano on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @11:31PM (#13028106)
Urine is sterile.
Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by niels_olson on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @11:47PM (#13028193)
As a pathology resident, I assure you, the voided stream is not sterile, and definitely has all the building blocks necessary for bacterial growth.

That said, inland cities all recycle water. And they generally return water into the rivers that is cleaner than what they took out.

Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by Terr_ on Thursday November 24, 2016 @12:20AM (#13028336)
Only before it starts leaving the body.
Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by cestith on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @05:28PM (#13026298)
I grew up in a town along the Mississippi River. It's "ass to glass" all the way from Minnesota to Louisiana. Basically every city, town, and village on both banks treats its drinking water and its wastewater, then releases its treated wastewater downstream.

Are the farmers paying so much less for treated, potable tap water delivered through municipal water mains? I think you'll find the cost of the water itself is pretty small. You may find that treating it, transporting it, and distributing it pretreated to all those people are the real economic costs even during most stages of a drought.

Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by hueving on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @05:56PM (#13026468)
The farmers are consuming the majority of the water and there is no way to even get them to pay for their usage. Many have grandfathered old school water rights. Meanwhile, they pass idiotic laws like the ban on unsolicited table water in restaurants to pretend like they are doing something.
Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by JoelBennett on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @05:35PM (#13026348)
Funny thing is, most waste water treatment plants I've seen - the water coming out of the waste treatment plant is cleaner than the water removed from the river for drinking (which is then treated).

Wait until people learn that they air they breathe has likely already been breathed by someone else...

Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by tonyarkles on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @08:21PM (#13027177)
Or that it's got particles from other peoples' farts!
Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by SticksAndBreaks on Thursday November 24, 2016 @06:51AM (#13029845)
Sorry, Sir, but we got to dialyse your blood- there is t-rex urine in it
Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by bsder on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @09:57PM (#13027662)
> Los Angeles could also recycle its water for a much lower cost than desalination, but due to campaigns that claim it is unsanitary (ass to glass, etc) it is not an option politically.

Unsanitary isn't really the problem. Laden with organically active toxins is the problem.

We don't have a good way of dealing with most toxins other than simply diluting them and letting nature break them down.

This is why treatment plants take water from rivers and pump treated water back into the river rather than immediately recycling outflow back to inflow.

Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by skybrian on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @06:42PM (#13026729)
I wouldn't say that water recycling is not an option, just that it's happening slowly. See [1] for example.

[1] http://www.mercurynews.com/2014/07/16/california-drought-san...

You can

Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by SilasX on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @10:26PM (#13027782)
The problem is that once you make it free (or underpriced relative to replacement cost) people find new uses for the water, and your previous assumptions about how much people need, become huge underestimates.

Without those prices, you're back in the commissars dilemma of either a) restricting people to a one-size-fits-all amount or b) maintaining a master list of acceptable uses, either of which have absurd consequences.

There's a similar fallacy in thinking that energy efficiency tech by itself is enough to reduce fossil fuel usage. In reality, people just keep finding

(It would be more correct to say that improved energy efficiency will make the required e.g. carbon taxes less painful to implement.)

Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by adamsea on Thursday November 24, 2016 @02:57AM (#13028942)
As our ability to extract resources has risen, over time, so has our perceived "requirements" of consuming those resources, i.e. America's current rate of consumption (of electricity, fossil fuels, etc), is required by nothing else other than a series of collective choices.

TL;DR - Technology will never eliminate Politics, People are inherently Political.

Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by nixos on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @05:01PM (#13026128)
> Cheap (and preferably clean) energy

This is the difficulty.

Right now, the only cheap and clean energy somewhat on the horizon is fusion, which is 50 years in the future for the past 50 years.

Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by atemerev on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @05:39PM (#13026368)
Nuclear is clean. Cleaner than solar, at least.
Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by ljf on Thursday November 24, 2016 @08:01AM (#13030078)
The waste is not simply the spent nuclear fuel, but much of the machinery and systems around it, plus the discarded items used daily in the management of a plant (clothes etc). This low level nuclear waste while 'only' dangerous for 100 to 500 years, is huge - vastly bigger than the 76000 metric tons of spent fuel: http://www.nei.org/Knowledge-Center/Nuclear-Statistics/On-Si.... I don't have the tonnage of the low level waste to hand, but it is certainly much larger than the high level waste.
Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by ljf on Thursday November 24, 2016 @11:54AM (#13031266)
Sorry copied link in correctly: http://www.nei.org/Knowledge-Center/Nuclear-Statistics/On-Si...

Rough estimate of low level waste is 360000 tons

Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by __jal on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @07:26PM (#13026949)
It normally is! But. It has catastrophic failure modes. (Yes, pebble beds. Let's talk about realities, not if-onlys.)

Because of those catastrophic failure modes, nobody except governments want to assume the risk. And governments only do it because they have sovereign immunity from those whose interests they're supposedly representing.

I firmly believe that any interested parties who want to go nuclear, should, and reap those rewards. If you can't find an insurer, go find wealthy people who believe in your design to indemnify you.

Just don't pick my pocket to build it and then poison me.

Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @09:54PM (#13027651)
> Because of those catastrophic failure modes, nobody except governments want to assume the risk.

That would be a fine if it was a level playing field.

Lots of things have catastrophic failure modes. Dams[1], supertankers[2], chemical plants[3], oil drilling rigs[4], coal mines[5], etc. To say nothing of climate change.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banqiao_Dam [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exxon_Valdez_oil_spill [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bhopal_disaster [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deepwater_Horizon_oil_spill [5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benxihu_Colliery

The reason those things have no trouble being built anyway is that they aren't required to carry billions of dollars in insurance coverage to begin with.

And maybe they should, but you can't single out nuclear for a requirement to carry that much insurance and then fault it for not being able to satisfy that requirement when its competitors don't.

Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by bsder on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @10:00PM (#13027675)
> Just don't pick my pocket to build it and then poison me.

Yet that's exactly what we're doing with coal and petroleum.

Let's remove the subsidies for those and then you can get back to me about the cost effectiveness of things like nuclear.

Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by coldtea on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @11:30PM (#13028103)
>Yet that's exactly what we're doing with coal and petroleum.

Only coal and petroleum is mined thousands of miles aways from me, and even if e.g. there's an oil spill, it won't kill thousands in hundreds miles radius.

Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by bsder on Thursday November 24, 2016 @02:31AM (#13028846)
Coal is mined where I grew up and they rip entire mountains apart, throw the dross back, and leak sulfur into the streams for the next 50 years.

In addition, in California, the radioactive sulfur in pollution from the coal burning plants in China SWAMPS the radiation release from Fukushima by several orders of magnitude.

I'm going to stop here, because any relevant adjective I would use to describe people like you would just get me banned.

Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by coldtea on Thursday November 24, 2016 @03:18AM (#13029008)
>I'm going to stop here, because any relevant adjective I would use to describe people like you would just get me banned.

The main word I'd use to describe "people like you", given the above, is rude.

The ad-hominem doesn't add anything to the case. And who would "people like me" be? Anybody that has concerns or might be against nuclear power? Because they are necessarily ignorant luddites, and only those for it are the level-headed ones, right?

Well, nuclear reactors and energy production is not science (the science part is done at the academic level), it is applied technology. And technology mingles with private interests, politics and bad actors all the time (e.g. constructors who don't install enough safety measures, governments who don't give a shit about global environmental treaties, loonies who might want to blow up reactors or get their hands to the by products, human errors, political ass-saving, tons of money to be made, higher profit margins by not properly taking care of by products, etc.),

Now to answer the specific points:

"Leak[ing] sulfur into the streams for the next 50 years" doesn't even compare to having to take care of radioactive materials for the next millennia, neither in the extend of time, nor to the potential impact.

Your answer also seems to imply that e.g. uranium mining doesn't have an environmental impact, and it's only coal that "rips entire mountains apart"...

>In addition, in California, the radioactive sulfur in pollution from the coal burning plants in China SWAMPS the radiation release from Fukushima by several orders of magnitude.

All caps "swamps" aside, this would be only relevant if Fukushima was the epitome of nuclear disaster and the "radiation release from Fukushima" was the highest level of tradition release possible (or close).

Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by saint_fiasco on Thursday November 24, 2016 @03:45AM (#13029107)
> this would be only relevant if Fukushima was the epitome of nuclear disaster

Isn't it? I thought what happened at Fukushima was the worst case scenario for a nuclear power plant of its type. What is the worst that could have happened?

Aren't new designs even safer than that?

Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by legulere on Thursday November 24, 2016 @04:47AM (#13029361)
Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by ch4s3 on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @06:06PM (#13026516)
clarify please. Are you referring to construction, mining, installation, storage, or just trolling?
Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by motoboi on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @06:25PM (#13026643)
Nuclear is very clean. What most people came to hate is the waste, which is surprisingly little (per kW). Also the danger in case of failure, which is massive.
Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by nixos on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @07:28PM (#13026958)
Also, there's literally no way to clean it up in case of accident and you have to keep it out of harms way for thousands of years.

Theoretically, we can put CO2 back in the bottle. Practically, we can do it now, just not with enough efficiency and scale to make it worth it.

Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by dpark on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @07:51PM (#13027036)
We have no practical way to clean CO2 from the atmosphere and we don't need catastrophe for it to be a problem. We're poisoning the planet with real carbon dioxide while we fret about the hypothetical risks of hypothetical nuclear waste.
Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by nixos on Thursday November 24, 2016 @02:22AM (#13028811)
>hypothetical nuclear waste.

Chernobyl isn't hypothetical. And neither is Fukushima. And those weren't as bad as they could have been.

And we still don't know what to do with all the waste we have.

Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by closeparen on Thursday November 24, 2016 @03:30AM (#13029053)
We could replace coal with nuclear yesterday if the anti-nuclear activists would stand down. Instead, they have fought to continue a status quo whose death toll we start couting at 25,000 people per year lost to black lung [0]. No serial killer or terrorist could dream of effecting mass casualites as efficiently as the proponents of this viewpoint do when they take action that results in the continued and expanding operation of coal power generation, despite an alternative which is actually viable in every respect but their opposition.

Yes, nuclear power has problems. But even if it killed 24,000 people per year, blocking the replacement of coal by nuclear would still be a willful choice to cause the deaths of 1,000 people (it's getting really hard not to say murder).

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coalworker's_pneumoconiosis

Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by adrianN on Thursday November 24, 2016 @03:33AM (#13029064)
Of course we know what to do with the "waste": Keep it close, it's precious fuel for breeder reactors.
Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by ljf on Thursday November 24, 2016 @08:06AM (#13030097)
The waste isn't just the spent fuel though - see my other comments...
Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by ageofwant on Thursday November 24, 2016 @09:55AM (#13030594)
The total volume of which would fit in an apartment block. That block could be dropped into the marina trench if you really are that paranoid, total cost a few million dollars.

There is no conceivable way of removing even daily worldwide human carbon waste from the atmosphere for that kind of money.

Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by ljf on Thursday November 24, 2016 @11:54AM (#13031262)
72000 metric tons - would that be safe to place together in a single container? http://www.nei.org/Knowledge-Center/Nuclear-Statistics/On-Si...

Sure the physical size of a spent fuel might be 'small' but this is not the only issue.

And the low level waste - of which there is approx 360000 tons? Would the Mariana Trench would be a good/safe place to place this? Based on what reckoning?

Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by ageofwant on Saturday November 26, 2016 @02:02AM (#13042215)
No you can dump low level waste under 1m of topsoil, and build a hospital or school or kindergarten on top of it. That's why its called low-level waste.

>> And the low level waste - of which there is approx 360000 tons? Would the Mariana Trench would be a good/safe place to place this? Based on what reckoning?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ocean_disposal_of_radioactive_...

Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by atemerev on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @06:30PM (#13026670)
Solar panels production. Currently, they are mostly produced from scraps of semiconductor industry, and it's already close to capacity. This process is energy inefficient and environmentally unfriendly (silicon tetrachloride is an intermediate stage).

Pushing for more silicon solar panels beyond what's possible as semiconductor industry byproduct is unsustainable, both economically and environmentally.

Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by philipkglass on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @08:06PM (#13027106)
Most high purity silicon is now destined for solar PV; PV's "scraps of semiconductor industry" phase was a decade or more ago.

http://www.upi.com/Business_News/Energy-Industry/2007/05/22/...

"In 2006, for the first time, more than half the world's polysilicon was used to produce solar PV cells."

It's true that the intermediates in silicon refining like are quite hazardous, but in a well-run production facility those intermediates don't get released to the biosphere. They affect the toxicity of the end product no more than the intermediate use of acetic anhydride in aspirin production, or the intermediate use of uranium hexafluoride in nuclear fuel rod production. There was a famous story in 2008 about a Chinese silicon production facility that was illegally dumping SiCl4, but if you're going to pick the most horrifying Chinese examples you'd think that nothing at all can be made safely.

Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by atemerev on Thursday November 24, 2016 @05:27AM (#13029531)
It is not that it is impossible to run photovoltaic panels production de novo (and it is done in large scale these days, as you have correctly stated). The problem is that it is economically unsustainable and have to be financed by government subsidies (or, alternatively, moved to cheap Chinese factories disregarding environmental costs completely).

Photovoltaics: scalable, green, economically sustainable (choose two).

Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by CountSessine on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @10:20PM (#13027752)
There was a famous story in 2008 about a Chinese silicon production facility that was illegally dumping SiCl4, but if you're going to pick the most horrifying Chinese examples you'd think that nothing at all can be made safely.

There are some interesting moral gymnastics required there, no? The Chinese lead the world in PV manufacturing right now. Is this PV-revolution necessarily built on dirty manufacturing? Would we still have a PV-revolution if we weren't so accepting of an environmental disaster that takes place in a distant country?

Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by philipkglass on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @11:01PM (#13027949)
My guess is that there would still be a PV revolution even without the Chinese factories, though the cost drops might have a come a bit slower. Costs were dropping at about the same year-over-year rate for decades before China leapt to the top of the PV manufacturing ranks.

Silicon refiners in the US actually had lower production costs than Chinese refiners even with the extra labor and environmental costs in the US. Unfortunately, a few years ago China imposed punitive trade barriers against silicon imported from the US. It was in retaliation for trade barriers the US put up against imports of Chinese solar modules. Until both sides erected their dueling trade barriers, the value of US-to-China silicon exports just about balanced the value of China-to-US modules. It was like a textbook example of comparative advantage. Now Chinese manufacturers get higher priced silicon made with fewer environmental protections, and US buyers get higher priced modules :-/

Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by xg15 on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @07:34PM (#13026977)
My impression is that most large-scale clean energy projects go for wind power, indirect solar energy (use sunlight to heat up some medium which then drives turbines or rotors) or bio fuel - with more exotic stuff like geothermic energy where it's applicable.

Solar panels seem to be one of the most inefficient clean energy solutions - so are they actually relevant here?

Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by legulere on Thursday November 24, 2016 @04:49AM (#13029375)
There is no reason to believe fusion will be cheap. It has the same problem of nuclear power plants that building things is expensive.
Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by pitaj on Friday November 25, 2016 @12:29AM (#13034582)
Haha what? It doesn't have nearly the same issues. Building a nuke plant is easy, it's the safety measures that make it expensive.
Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @05:28PM (#13026296)
You're talking about Arizona. Hello, solar...
Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by sskates on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @07:58PM (#13027076)
We've done it with food thanks to the Green Revolution in the 70's. The need to "not waste food" is an artifact from before food was abundant. I'm hopeful like you that we can do it for energy as well.
Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by erikpukinskis on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @09:37PM (#13027576)
This is not true, there are many people in my neighborhood who can't always afford food when they need it.
Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by fulafel on Thursday November 24, 2016 @12:54AM (#13028482)
The ingredients of food are nearly free, the US average income per capita buys 700+ kg of wheat per day. The distribution/availability problem is political.
Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by erikpukinskis on Monday November 28, 2016 @01:20PM (#13057297)
You can't really eat ingredients. It's not just distribution there is other labor, equipment, facilities, and resources involved.
Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy by verbify on Thursday November 24, 2016 @05:03AM (#13029432)
Wheat doesn't have proteins and fats - those are more expensive. And processing wheat is fairly laborious, you'd have been better off comparing it to flour (about 12kg of flour a day for the median US income after taxes). And there is also the other costs of living - like shelter (more costly if you want shelter with access to jobs).

Food costs can be quite cheap and still be nutritious with the right choices, but not 700kg of wheat a day cheap.