Re:The Manhattan Project Fallacy
by SilasX on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @10:26PM
(#13027782)
The problem is that once you make it free (or underpriced relative to replacement cost) people find new uses for the water, and your previous assumptions about how much people need, become huge underestimates.
Without those prices, you're back in the commissars dilemma of either a) restricting people to a one-size-fits-all amount or b) maintaining a master list of acceptable uses, either of which have absurd consequences.
There's a similar fallacy in thinking that energy efficiency tech by itself is enough to reduce fossil fuel usage. In reality, people just keep finding
(It would be more correct to say that improved energy efficiency will make the required e.g. carbon taxes less painful to implement.)
Without those prices, you're back in the commissars dilemma of either a) restricting people to a one-size-fits-all amount or b) maintaining a master list of acceptable uses, either of which have absurd consequences.
There's a similar fallacy in thinking that energy efficiency tech by itself is enough to reduce fossil fuel usage. In reality, people just keep finding
(It would be more correct to say that improved energy efficiency will make the required e.g. carbon taxes less painful to implement.)