News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook's Zuckerberg discloses steps to fight fake news by mirekrusin on Monday November 21, 2016 @06:39AM (#13004624)
I wonder how labelling would work with news like saddam hussain's weapons of mass destruction - reported by cia, backed by the goverment as truth, but turns out it was all fake.

Labels will probably have to change retrospectively. Maybe they should also include "according to ..." reference? I can imagine that some statements will be flagged as truth by one side and as fake by the other.

If you play this game further with creating graph of dependencies and recorded switches from truth to fake you can even get "accuracy score" for source reference - I wonder how CIA as source ref would score in this game - hopefully not somewhere in the area of "compulsive liar"?

Re:Facebook's Zuckerberg discloses steps to fight fake news by TulliusCicero on Monday November 21, 2016 @07:05AM (#13004731)
> I wonder how labelling would work with news like saddam hussain's weapons of mass destruction - reported by cia, backed by the goverment as truth, but turns out it was all fake.

That has nothing to do with the kind of 'fake news' being discussed. There's nothing 'fake' about reporting "Government claims WMDs in Iraq" while elaborating on what evidence the government has or claims to have, even if it turns out there were no WMDs.

The fake news is question comes from sites that just make up random crap to get page views, not websites that are making a good faith effort to report on what is real.

Re:Facebook's Zuckerberg discloses steps to fight fake news by dilemma on Monday November 21, 2016 @07:11AM (#13004749)
The Iraq war was preceded and enabled by a massive propaganda campaign where close to 100% of American outlets went along with the WMD claim and were for an invasion (FAIR.org).

You don't get to say a propaganda campaign that ruined a country and killed hundreds of thousands wasn't fake news. It was - complete and utter fabrication on an industrial scale, and it had devastating effects.

Re:Facebook's Zuckerberg discloses steps to fight fake news by TulliusCicero on Monday November 21, 2016 @07:14AM (#13004766)
You seem to be confused about the difference between real/fake news vs correct/wrong news. The claims by the Bush administration about WMDs were real news. That the claims turned out false is another matter entirely.

Your problem is that you're interpreting it in terms of "is wrong/is right" instead of "deliberately lying/trying to be accurate". Perhaps news publications should've been more skeptical, but they themselves weren't trying to make things up.

Re:Facebook's Zuckerberg discloses steps to fight fake news by dilemma on Monday November 21, 2016 @07:21AM (#13004799)
No, they supported a narrative that was false by refusing to investigating claims by officials - that's planted fake news, and that news was created at publication. News don't exist if it isn't published, that is its definition.

Officials supplied the false information which served as the raw material the media's fake news was produced with.

Re:Facebook's Zuckerberg discloses steps to fight fake news by 75j on Monday November 21, 2016 @07:59AM (#13005012)
I tend to agree with you. I'm looking at the NYT archives right now and finding examples both of uncritical quoting of official sources and straight up assertions about WMDs in Iraq.

This is a famous quote from Judith Miller and Michael Gordon, from an article that includes many hawkish quotes from anonymous sources.

"Mr. Hussein's dogged insistence on pursuing his nuclear ambitions, along with what defectors described in interviews as Iraq's push to improve and expand Baghdad's chemical and biological arsenals, have brought Iraq and the United States to the brink of war."

http://www.nytimes.com/2002/09/08/world/threats-responses-ir...

Here's a quote from an opinion piece by William Safire:

"Two terrorist-sponsoring nations are racing to acquire nuclear weapons. One is Iraq, whose scientists already have the know-how..."

http://www.nytimes.com/2002/01/10/opinion/arafat-s-implausib...

Is this fake news? I'd say so. But, I have an even lesser criterion for fake news -- I think the most insidious type of fake news doesn't necessarily tell a single lie, but rather selectively reports the truth.

I am also 100% certain that it's impossible to filter out "fake news", whatever your definition is, without suppressing some true but fringe information.

Re:Facebook's Zuckerberg discloses steps to fight fake news by Tepix on Monday November 21, 2016 @07:20AM (#13004795)
I agree that there is a difference, but "deliberately lying" isn't it in this case.

The politicians involved knew that their claims were not backed up by facts.

Re:Facebook's Zuckerberg discloses steps to fight fake news by acdha on Monday November 21, 2016 @07:37AM (#13004874)
The point is that the media did not: they assumed that the administration, CIA, etc. weren't completely making it up and a common assumption at the time was that details and corroborating evidence were being withheld to protect intelligence sources and techniques.

They arguably should have been more skeptical but it's very different from the situation where some place like Breitbart runs a propaganda piece which is easily debunked using public information, like the fake electoral map they printed which flipped entire states to maintain the “coastal elites” narrative they're selling.

The mainstream media has some serious blemishes from that era (Valerie Plame comes to mind) but they have editors, publish corrections, etc. and it's a monstrous exaggeration to try to equate the two.

Re:Facebook's Zuckerberg discloses steps to fight fake news by makomk on Monday November 21, 2016 @07:50AM (#13004938)
Except that one of the examples of fake news that the media have leapt on was just some random person making an bad assumption and it going viral: http://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/20/business/media/how-fake-ne... The main thing that seems to make something a good example of "fake news" is that it's pro-Trump in some way.
Re:Facebook's Zuckerberg discloses steps to fight fake news by acdha on Monday November 21, 2016 @09:20AM (#13005529)
That's because the Trump campaign was literally built on propaganda starting with the claims about Obama's birth certificate which really started getting him supporters. He didn't need to invent the story to take advantage of it as one of the most prominent voices spreading it, and sites like Breitbart or abcnews.com.co profited enormously from people who believed there was a real story that the real news organizations wouldn't cover.

The paid protesters story is a great example: the campaign benefited from and recirculated rumors about that which started on random blogs, conspiracy sites like InfoWars, and outright fakes like abcnews.com.co throughout the election. The guy who tweeted that photo might have been a Republican acting in what he believed was good faith but he was primed to think of that as likely by the prior months of unfounded accusations and as soon as he shared that photo, it was widely circulated by supporters including Corey Lewandowski, who was Trump's campaign manager before becoming CNN's commenter representing the campaign.

Re:Facebook's Zuckerberg discloses steps to fight fake news by return0 on Monday November 21, 2016 @07:49AM (#13004936)
You're crossing a line when you decide which propaganda is censored.
Re:Facebook's Zuckerberg discloses steps to fight fake news by 75j on Monday November 21, 2016 @08:21AM (#13005131)
I could not agree more.

Plus, is it really a good idea to suppress a meta-discussion about propaganda and false information? Those "fake news" articles and their corresponding beliefs will still exist, even if Facebook manages to filter them out, but proponents of those ideas will either never see critical discussion or they'll just move to other platforms. It seems like a great way to further fracture our already divided society.

Re:Facebook's Zuckerberg discloses steps to fight fake news by 75j on Monday November 21, 2016 @08:07AM (#13005057)
To take a more recent example, when Chris Cuomo stated recently on CNN that it's illegal to view the Wikileaks Podesta emails, should something like that be censored if it's posted to Facebook? It's plainly false, and given that Cuomo has a law degree and a family full of politicians, he was almost certainly deliberately lying.
Re:Facebook's Zuckerberg discloses steps to fight fake news by macspoofing on Monday November 21, 2016 @07:35AM (#13004865)
>You don't get to say a propaganda campaign that ruined a country and killed hundreds of thousands wasn't fake news.

You're getting hung up on the term 'fake news'. In this context this term has a specific meaning, different than what you're referring to. 'Fake News' are sites with content that is purposely false (though it could plausibly be true) that is also usually outrage-inducing. At the same time they attempt to pass themselves off as credible news organizations. Their business model involves getting their fake content to go viral, increasing views and their advertising revenue.

Re:Facebook's Zuckerberg discloses steps to fight fake news by thecatspaw on Monday November 21, 2016 @07:13AM (#13004764)
it is fake news, but its not faked by the newsorganizations, which is what they are trying to prevent.
Re:Facebook's Zuckerberg discloses steps to fight fake news by supergreg on Monday November 21, 2016 @07:20AM (#13004797)
Should a tool trying to fight fake news make any distinctions?
Re:Facebook's Zuckerberg discloses steps to fight fake news by intended on Monday November 21, 2016 @09:04AM (#13005409)
Insufficient resolution to Question, scope too broad.

There's several levels to "truth".

What happened.

What an eyewitness/machine reported happened

Whether the witness maliciously lied/mistakenly reported the event

Was all of this reported faithfully

Separately was reporting done to verify the facts.

And do note, we've (coders) created the world where most newspapers have already gone out of business, and they have to in turn compete with everything and everyone for what remains of human attention spans.

So the new question I would append to that list is - does it even matter anymore ?

ProPublica for example tries very hard to do good in depth reporting. There have been reams of leaks with more data than what most people know what to do with.

This has to compete for human attention bandwidth against documents/content designed to press buttons, elicit emotions and thus propagate (generating more page views, and so revenue)

My point is simply that truth is a narrow view on the scope of the problem.

In a year or two this will die down and a new generation of coders will parrot "move fast and break things."

The larger system at play her must be front and center.

Ideally people would have more time to reflect on their own - see more news that causes dissonance - hopefully causing people to check their opinions and beliefs.

And of course the tool to Achieve this should itself not create a worse problem

Re:Facebook's Zuckerberg discloses steps to fight fake news by cdubzzz on Monday November 21, 2016 @07:57AM (#13004993)
This is precisely the problem with attempting to categorize "fake" news - individuals each have their own nuanced definition of both "fake" and "news" that may be entirely contradictory to someone else's definitions. All these efforts (Facebook's solution and third party ones) will do is create even deeper echo chambers.
Re:Facebook's Zuckerberg discloses steps to fight fake news by quonn on Monday November 21, 2016 @07:05AM (#13004732)
I think there are two levels: One is if the information is ultimately true. The other is if the information is correctly reported according to the impression a journalist would get (at press conference for example). In other words, is the website deliberately lying? I think this is the problem that FB is trying to address here.
Re:Facebook's Zuckerberg discloses steps to fight fake news by return0 on Monday November 21, 2016 @07:40AM (#13004895)
That's hard to tell. Were the reports of hillary's imminent win false? of course they were. Were they deliberately lying? Probably not . Could they have lied less if they had done some actual research? Probably yes. Did it matter that they lied? definitely yes.

And every situation is even more peculiar. This is a futile exercise.

Re:Facebook's Zuckerberg discloses steps to fight fake news by brlewis on Monday November 21, 2016 @07:43AM (#13004909)
Getting a good accuracy score sounds really hard to do, but if done it would be super valuable. Right now there's no economic incentive for accuracy. All news outlets, old big ones and new small ones, draw in eyeballs to advertise to using drama and controversy, not accuracy.
Re:Facebook's Zuckerberg discloses steps to fight fake news by MK999 on Monday November 21, 2016 @10:33AM (#13006092)
Not to mention the 'Incubator babies' lie. 'Atrocity Propaganda' is the operative term.
Re:Facebook's Zuckerberg discloses steps to fight fake news by chronic6l on Monday November 21, 2016 @06:50AM (#13004681)
> I wonder how labelling would work with news like saddam hussain's weapons of mass destruction - reported by cia, backed by the goverment as truth, but turns out it was all fake.

There's no need to talk technical about graph nodes and machine learning. It's very simple - the fake news labels are, and will always be biased in favor of the liberal/progressive/Democrat agenda. Objective news is a lie. No one wants to hear it. We want echo chambers that make us feel good. The labels will shift to accommodate this desire.

Re:Facebook's Zuckerberg discloses steps to fight fake news by nunobrito on Monday November 21, 2016 @07:15AM (#13004774)
Indeed we'll keep seeing the mass stream media biased to omit objective news.

Otherwise you would see the US population asking themselves why on earth are their armed forces so deep involved in Syria, just short of military invasion. They get spoon-fed that the country is ruled by a dictator and their population needs to be freed, but so is Saudi Arabia with a far worse regime where people get their heads cut on monthly basis, which are praised as critical ally in the region.

"Fake news" is a way to block the things deemed as dissident from the main stream, effectively blocking the room for logical argument and exposing the facts.

Re:Facebook's Zuckerberg discloses steps to fight fake news by mirekrusin on Monday November 21, 2016 @07:15AM (#13004776)
I think there are many people who are interested in truth - whatever it is, without feeling the need to associate their position with any red/blue person (politician).

There was no mention of machine learning (no predictions of any kind) - the idea is to keep track of history of raw data (labelling and it's changes) and report on "reliability score ..." (how many times labelling itself was false).

The thing is it doesn't need to be biased at all. You just keep all data for all sources. There's no "objective truth" per se, there are only true/false labels according to source.

Of course you can create your own "beyond reasonable doubt by xyz" or "government xyz pov" source and assume that this is going to be your objective truth reference. But, just like any other sources, your source will just have reliability rating in context of any other source.