News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by nodesocket on Saturday November 19, 2016 @10:24PM (#12997082)
Great writeup and detail. However:

> Even if it weighed 10 kilos and cost $10k I would still buy it.

> (To show you exactly what I mean in terms of personal needs, I recently rendered a music video in HD using a neural net called Style app. Due to the 16GB RAM limitation it took several days and wrote 20.44 Terabytes to my drive in swap space (yes, over 20,000 gigabytes). This would have been an order of magnitude faster on a system with 32GB of RAM).

If your rendering video and can afford a $10k computer, then you should be using a Mac Pro. You can get a 2.7GHz 12-core with 30MB of L3 cache and 64GB of memory for around 8.5k.

Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by lolive on Saturday November 19, 2016 @10:39PM (#12997136)
Why not rent a supercomputer on the cloud just for the time of such an experiment?

I rent a 16 core/128GB machine at a cloud provider. I use it for heavy database treatments. And my laptop merely became a tmux terminal ever since.

Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by nodesocket on Saturday November 19, 2016 @10:43PM (#12997144)
I don't know of a cloud provider that rents OS X machines do you? OS X is needed for Final Cut Pro, etc. If you're using Adobe Premier then you could use Microsoft Azure or another cloud provider that supports Windows.
Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by Laforet on Saturday November 19, 2016 @11:17PM (#12997240)
Depends on how the workload is split and such. Using AWS for video encoding is actually quite viable as long as Amazon don't charge for incoming bandwidth and dirt cheap spot instances could be found at the right time of the day.
Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by TheOtherHobbes on Sunday November 20, 2016 @12:21AM (#12997402)
Cloud render farms have been a thing in CGI for nearly a decade now. It can - sometimes - be cheaper to buy time than to buy hardware.

But there are a lot of disadvantages. The process only really works for final renders. All the creative work needs to be fast and local, but thumbnail renders don't always give you enough detail to make good decisions.

It doesn't work for audio, because audio isn't great with low-quality previews and often needs hands-on changes.

It doesn't work for many kinds of ML - not unless the render machine has the latest graphics cards.

It doesn't work for renders with huge asset libraries spread around a LAN.

And so on. Basically there is a list of use cases, but it's not even half of all possible use cases.

Meanwhile dual-Xeon servers have really started to kick ass. These are workstation grade machines with high four and low five figure prices. You can have up to 48 independent cores on a dual-CPU board, which is excellent for video rendering.

Or you can get a blade rack. Depending the project, they can be better value than an off-prem cloud account. (Sometimes).

Apple has turned its back on this space. I don't entirely understand why. Xserve had real potential, but they decided to go dumbed-down consumer instead.

Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by nodesocket on Sunday November 20, 2016 @02:50AM (#12997806)
In terms of Xserve, I think it made sense to drop it. If you're buying a server, nearly all applications make more sense using Linux and commodity hardware. The exception are desktop based (GUI) applications which Mac Pro targets. There really is no viable market for a Mac Server.
Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by colejohnson66 on Sunday November 20, 2016 @12:41AM (#12997469)
Is more CPU cores really better? I thought a bunch of graphics cards would be better. Isn't that the whole point of Nvidia'a Quadro line?
Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by disordinary on Saturday November 19, 2016 @10:53PM (#12997169)
I'd imagine the latency of running a video editor in the cloud would be a pain, also transferring hundreds of gigabytes of raw video information into the cloud isn't insignificant.
Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by elastic_church on Saturday November 19, 2016 @11:04PM (#12997209)
transfer hundreds of gigabytes of raw video, or mail the hard drive to the data center.

use proxy videos in your project, transfer the split instructions and composites, and let the server do the rendering

no latency at all

Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by jlgaddis on Saturday November 19, 2016 @11:18PM (#12997244)
> ... mail the hard drive to the data center.

> no latency at all

Um...

Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by elastic_church on Sunday November 20, 2016 @01:34AM (#12997602)
I mean, after they get to the data center lol. just a few days mailing while you are busy editing the local files
Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by tdkl on Sunday November 20, 2016 @06:12AM (#12998271)
You should probably apply for work in the Apple PR team for "Pro"fessionals.
Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by elastic_church on Sunday November 20, 2016 @12:43PM (#13000011)
but I never said you needed a mac to do that, so why?
Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by disordinary on Saturday November 19, 2016 @11:42PM (#12997313)
Yeah, but if you're using proxies your fine on a macbook pro. It's only the final render that needs the original files.
Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by comex on Sunday November 20, 2016 @02:06AM (#12997708)
Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by hairyhenderson on Saturday November 19, 2016 @10:51PM (#12997162)
I doubt video editing would go very smoothly over an RDP connection to a Windows VM in the cloud ;)
Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by brazzledazzle on Saturday November 19, 2016 @11:11PM (#12997227)
You might be surprised. It wouldn't be ideal but you can do some amazing stuff these days with low enough latency to the data center.
Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by chx on Sunday November 20, 2016 @01:07AM (#12997532)
xcloud.me? macincloud?
Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by lolive on Saturday November 19, 2016 @10:46PM (#12997149)
That reminds me of the trend of switching from a laptop to a tablet. cf: http://bergie.iki.fi/blog/six-weeks-working-android/ http://yieldthought.com/post/31857050698/ipad-linode-1-year-...

I know some of these people switched back to a laptop. And I wonder why they did.

Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by WhitneyLand on Saturday November 19, 2016 @11:09PM (#12997225)
How much does it cost you for a typical run?
Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by lolive on Saturday November 19, 2016 @11:42PM (#12997308)
It suited my needs so well that I switched to a monthly rental. 100E/month. Then it suited my needs so well that I switched to a yearly rental. 1000E/year. (taxes included)
Re:Why the MacBook Pro Is Limited to 16GB of RAM by Dylan16807 on Saturday November 19, 2016 @11:28PM (#12997281)
That's within the weight limit, but for a post focused so much on battery life it's a bit odd to suggest something with 0 minutes.