News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by ehnto on Thursday November 17, 2016 @03:40AM (#12975581)
Holy crap, I didn't realise it was quite like that. I knew it was rare for people to know manual transmissions but why such a preference for automatic?

In Australia pretty much everyone I know can drive manual, most cars come with the option and most cheaper cars are manual. It was somewhat of a masculinity thing too, and still is according to my younger siblings.

To be honest I'm surprised the most that America doesn't have that same psuedo masculinity requirement thing happening. I am not saying it's good to have, just that I am surprised it's not there.

As far as myself, I have always much preferred manual and find myself utterly disillusioned with automatics. No engine braking so you're constantly between pedals, gearbox never in the best gear because it can't predict your actions, and they make even the nicest motors sound like droning slugs.

Even if you don't intend to go racing, a manual is just a bit more interesting and keeps you paying attention the whole trip, in my experience at least.

Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by dcposch on Thursday November 17, 2016 @04:59AM (#12976030)
> Even if you don't intend to go racing, a manual is just a bit more interesting and keeps you paying attention the whole trip, in my experience at least.

I drive an E36 M3, a car almost 20 years old.

It's a musical instrument, and the driving manual is how you play it.

Learning to use a clutch is like riding a bike: at first it's frustrating and you stall a lot, but you learn quickly. Once you've mastered it, it's effortless and fun.

I got it for less than $10k.

It is basically open hardware: you can take most of it apart with standard tools, and there's a robust aftermarket for parts.

Old manuals break down less, and have cheaper failure modes than old automatics.

My car has no embedded sim card, no infotainment dashboard ipad, no nothing.

That gives me confidence that it will never be remotely hacked, letting some 4chan troll a thousand miles away disable my brakes[1]. Nor is the manufacturer collecting a detailed database of GPS coordinates, a log of where I go.

Buy a simple car. Learn manual. Enjoy the speed and control. Be the 3%!

[1] https://www.wired.com/2015/07/hackers-remotely-kill-jeep-hig...

Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by crispyambulance on Thursday November 17, 2016 @07:55AM (#12977007)
Yes, people talk about fuel efficiency but the differences are effectively negligible and more dependent on driving style than manual vs automatic transmission.

The reason lots of people drive manual by choice is simply because of the way it FEELS. The driving experience is more engaging and stimulating. I think people driving manual in the city pay more attention simply because they have to.

Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by shash7 on Thursday November 17, 2016 @06:22AM (#12976419)
E36 BMWs are a dream to drive in manual. Its a shame they are getting increasingly rare to buy in Melbourne.
Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by esw on Thursday November 17, 2016 @07:30AM (#12976842)
The same is true of other older BMWs. I've owned four, and my E30 was still the best.
Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by mgcross on Thursday November 17, 2016 @08:55AM (#12977416)
My daily driver is an 06 mini Cooper S (6 speed), but my weekend car is my old e30. My son will be 16 next May. I've offered him the mini, but he wants the e30. I don't know if I can let go of it!
Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by Broken_Hippo on Thursday November 17, 2016 @05:43AM (#12976219)
> I knew it was rare for people to know manual transmissions, but why such a preference for automatic?

I think this is twofold. First off, most drivers education doesn't teach a manual transmission anymore, nor is drivers education a requirement. While my parents learned on a simulator in school, I learned it from experience (and so happy I did) - my first car was a manual.

But the second part of this is that there tends to be a very small number of cars that even offer a manual transmission: Generally small cars, pickup trucks, and "sporty" cars. I live in Norway now, and have a smallish 4-door sedan with a manual transmission: The same sort of car is difficult to find in the US.

The masculinity still happens, but I think it is simply plays out differently. In a lot of areas, you are just as masculine in a pickup truck as a vehicle.

Sidenote: I am with you with preferring a manual transmission. In fact, knowing how to drive one and understanding the gears helped me with an automatic once.

Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by torrent-of-ions on Thursday November 17, 2016 @06:39AM (#12976502)
> nor is drivers education a requirement

This is it really. Americans aren't very good at driving. In the UK we are taught that it's one of the most dangerous things you'll do in your life, which it is. In America it's just like learning to walk. You have to do it and it doesn't matter how you learn.

Check out the road safety stats. USA is pretty much an outlier amongst first world countries by most metrics.

Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by crispyambulance on Thursday November 17, 2016 @08:11AM (#12977108)
The key figure, I think, is number of fatalities per billion vehicle Kilometers. For the USA that is 7.1. Unfortunately, Americans drive A LOT MORE than most other countries, so raw annual fatality count is very high (~34K). By comparison UK has 3.6 fatalities/billion KM and fatality count of 1.8K. Population ratio is ~6:1 US:UK. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_traffic-r...)

There are other countries where fatalities are much higher.

Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by torrent-of-ions on Thursday November 17, 2016 @08:38AM (#12977273)
It seems that the fatalities per billion vehicle kilometres will be skewed simply by the average trip length being longer in the US. Fatalities per number of trips is probably a better metric since longer trips tend to use safer roads like motorways. It's just not possible to rack up that many "safe" miles somewhere like the UK, while the number of more high risk miles, ie. towns and country roads, is probably more similar. As suspected, that metric is the one the US does the best on in the article linked.

The best metric is probably fatalities per capita. It's not fair to take into account only the number vehicles because the whole population is at risk when it comes to cars. And it's not fair to take into account number of miles travelled due to the difference in trip lengths.

Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by hx87 on Thursday November 17, 2016 @11:38AM (#12978914)
> It seems that the fatalities per billion vehicle kilometres will be skewed simply by the average trip length being longer in the US.

Trip length figures into the denominator (deaths/billion kilometers), so everything else being the same, longer trip lengths won't skew the statistic.

Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by Dylan16807 on Thursday November 17, 2016 @05:23PM (#12982290)
Not that the statistic will be skewed with respect to itself. But that it will be skewed against what really matters. It might be the wrong decision to factor out distance.
Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by strictnein on Thursday November 17, 2016 @01:38PM (#12980098)
> nor is drivers education a requirement

Not sure what state they're referring to, but it's a requirement in every place I know of.

The general process when you're 15-16 typically includes:

- A number of Driver's ed classes that typically end with behind the wheel training

- Learners permit granted that only allows you to drive with an adult (21+) in the car.

- Drive without incident for a certain period of time

- Pass a written test

- Pass a full road course

- Full license granted

Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by Broken_Hippo on Thursday November 17, 2016 @08:48PM (#12983654)
I'm originally from Indiana. All that is actually required is that you hold a learner's permit for a set time and pass the driving and written test.

To actually learn to drive, you just gotta have an adult in the car. In theory, this is to teach you how to drive.

Outside of that, there are a few restrictions on the license after you start driving, mostly on passengers from what I can remember.

Some folks do take drivers ed, which is usually offered at the high school after school or during the summer. When folks do this, they can get their learners permit at a younger age. It is quite common in the rural areas for kids to learn to drive tractors when they are 13/14 or younger.

Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by pc86 on Thursday November 17, 2016 @02:28PM (#12980610)
I went to HS in rural PA in 00-04 and the only "drivers ed" we got was one class a week for a month or two where we just went over the DMV handbook. No practical training or testing, it was expected that your parents taught you how to actually drive.
Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by nommm-nommm on Thursday November 17, 2016 @08:43AM (#12977305)
>nor is drivers education a requirement

This was probably the case when you learned to drive (it was when I did) but many (most?) US States are starting to crack down on this and require formal driver's ed in some cases. There's also a lot more restrictions on young drivers than there was when I was a young driver.

For the non-Americans, in the US each State licenses their drivers and they all have different requirements.

Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by Broken_Hippo on Thursday November 17, 2016 @09:16AM (#12977599)
It has been more than 20 years since I learned to drive and admittedly I'm only really familiar with Indiana laws, save for the last 3-4 years. And you are right, there are some vast improvements in the area, some a little ill-thought out. Most of these I've seen were increases in driving age, Requiring a longer permit holding time, more indepth written tests, and restrictions on either new license holders or teenage license holders.

That said, I wasn't aware of cases where drivers ed was a requirement at all. Everywhere else it doesn't matter so long as one can pass the both the written and driving test.

Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by kjetijor on Thursday November 17, 2016 @12:37PM (#12979528)
Norway is (probably) still a manual transmission holdout, potentially in part because you'll most likely end up being taught driving a manual as there's restrictions attached to your license. If you do your practical on an automatic, you're restricted to automatic, if you do it on a manual you get to drive both manual/automatic.

Anecdotally - early automatic transmissions weren't all that great on the windy mountain roads. My dad had two primary complaints (after having had an automatic rental). Tricking the car into downshifting to maintain speed or accelerate on steep ascents, and passing people on steep ascents, usually involved slamming on the brakes to trick the car into downshifting. (This were in the mid-90ies). My dad held onto the manual transmission until probably 2012-2013.

Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by Broken_Hippo on Thursday November 17, 2016 @05:11PM (#12982210)
The restriction bit is absolutely correct. I'd guess that a good number of folks that learn on an automatic or take the tests in an automatic do so by choice or physical need, however. Folks have to take courses from a driving school, which supplies the car for both the training and the actual test.

I completely understand why it is a manual transmission holdout. Your anecdote confirms the attitude from my spouse (the native Norwegian) and others. A manual is just safer, both because of the mountains and the snow.

Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by johngalt on Thursday November 17, 2016 @09:55AM (#12977908)
There used to be a similar theme in the US, but it slowly disappeared from 1990-2010. Primarily because they are so rare they are now more of a quaint oddity more than a sign of driving competence.

The game theory on why manuals are disappearing is obvious. Drivers who can drive MT can also drive AT, but the reverse is not true.

I love MTs, but buying one means dealing with the following hassles:

1. Finding a dealership that actually has any MT cars. Let alone with the options I want. Often MTs are only available on stripped models or 60k sports cars. There are entire segments of vehicles where manuals are no longer offered. Full size truck with a manual? Nope.

2. Owning a car that only I can drive without becoming a driving instructor to whoever needs to borrow it.

3. Reselling the car when my needs change. I.E. Find someone who both wants the specific car I have, and also can drive an MT.

Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by mjhoy on Thursday November 17, 2016 @10:10AM (#12978041)
Ah, but when you're young and have many carless friends, #2 can be a very good thing!
Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by bosdev on Thursday November 17, 2016 @10:49AM (#12978462)
The Dodge Ram is still available in manual.
Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by mikestew on Thursday November 17, 2016 @02:06PM (#12980366)
Even if you don't intend to go racing, a manual is just a bit more interesting and keeps you paying attention the whole trip, in my experience at least.

I'm confident that the same thing was said about manual spark advance in the 1930s when mechanical and vacuum advance became more common. No one today would argue that we need a lever on the steering column to advance and retard the ignition.

Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by violentvinyl on Thursday November 17, 2016 @05:43AM (#12976224)
I would posit that in the US, new drivers are "grand-fathered" in to automatics. There is no driving license restriction in the US for transmission types, so there is little value in learning to drive a manual before your test (you could always learn later if you wanted to). Couple that with the fact that often a new driver's first car is second hand from a more sensible parent or family member who wanted the ease of use of an automatic, repeat for a generation or two, and suddenly you have very few new drivers who even have an opportunitty to learn how to drive a manual.
Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by _pmf_ on Thursday November 17, 2016 @05:44AM (#12976225)
> To be honest I'm surprised the most that America doesn't have that same psuedo masculinity requirement thing happening.

They have guns.

Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by rmc on Thursday November 17, 2016 @04:34AM (#12975882)
> To be honest I'm surprised the most that America doesn't have that same psuedo masculinity requirement thing happening. I am not saying it's good to have, just that I am surprised it's not there.

Oh there's plenty of masculinity things in the USA. It's just that not every culture/society has the same rules for masculinity stuff.

Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by int_19h on Thursday November 17, 2016 @06:17AM (#12976407)
> Even if you don't intend to go racing, a manual is just a bit more interesting and keeps you paying attention the whole trip

I'd rather pay attention to my surroundings than to the clutch. This goes for both day to day stuff (where it's better for safety), and pleasure road trips (where this lets you enjoy the scenery).

For the most part, the automatic is simply "good enough". And in US there's no peer pressure to drive the stick. Between those two things, it ends up being something reserved for people who really want that extra oomph - and they usually do it in cars specifically designed for it. Well, and immigrants.

Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by calcifer on Thursday November 17, 2016 @07:07AM (#12976688)
> I'd rather pay attention to my surroundings than to the clutch.

Me too, but I've been driving stick for over a decade now and 99% of the time I'm not even aware of the clutch, it's just muscle memory at this point.

Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by ehnto on Thursday November 17, 2016 @08:46AM (#12977340)
I think that is part of the issue though. The scenery really isn't where your mind should be while driving, simply looking to the side for 5 seconds is enough distraction to cause an accident.

http://www.distraction.gov/stats-research-laws/facts-and-sta...

I think for an already attentive driver it might be okay, but I would argue that a manual transmission would force people who are in the habit of being distracted to pay more attention. For one, you can't hold a phone very well while changing gears from a stop.

Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by lfowles on Thursday November 17, 2016 @09:16AM (#12977593)
Related: "Manual Transmission Enhances Attention and Driving Performance of ADHD Adolescent Males" http://jad.sagepub.com/content/10/2/212.abstract
Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by int_19h on Thursday November 17, 2016 @02:36PM (#12980676)
Pay more attention to what, though? The road? Or the car controls?
Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by ehnto on Thursday November 17, 2016 @10:35PM (#12984086)
You eventually don't pay attention to the controls, just like you don't think much about the actual steering wheel. But you do have to be constantly aware of the situation you are in order to have the data to tell your subconcious to select the right gear, or to coast and such. You are constantly paying attention to stop lights for example, because if you don't you won't be in gear and you will get a toot for taking too long to react. The same applies for more complex situations like driving in thick traffic. You can't rely on a quick glance to know to slow down, you have to know ahead of time which gear to be in so you tend to watch what's happening more closely.

I have no studies to link unfortunately so this is of course just an anecdote..

Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by int_19h on Thursday November 17, 2016 @11:48PM (#12984447)
I feel like most of the discussion on this topic is anecdotes, spiced up by cultural stereotypes.

I'm originally from a European country where the stick is prevalent, and pretty much had to learn to drive it (and hated it) - while driving exam could be passed with automatic in theory, there were simply no cars available (and you couldn't supply your own).

That said, people there weren't really particularly opinionated about it one way or another. There was some mild form of sexism, along the lines of "auto is for girls", but I think it was more an extension of the general car-related sexism in that country.

I then lived in New Zealand, Canada and US for a while. All of them have autos dominate - less so in NZ, more in Canada and especially US. But no-one really makes a big deal of it. If you drive the stick, no-one will taunt you for showing off, for example, the way people do with other stuff. It's just a slightly unusual choice.

On the other hand, I noticed that many European immigrants have a decidedly snobby attitude towards auto. They don't just prefer the stick - they're like vegetarians who have to make a point of some innate superiority of their choice, and disparage the other option - not even rationally, but on the level of, "Americans are just too dumb to learn this stuff".

And I think that this, more than anything else, kinda muddies up meaningful discussion (with studies etc) on this subject. It's such a strong part of cultural identity for some, that even starting a conversation on it is inviting flame. Note how my first post in this thread is at 0, even though it was purely about sharing my personal experience as a data point, and not saying that it applies to other people.

For the most part, I think people should just choose what they feel makes most sense for them, and refrain from judging the choices of others. The differences really aren't that big or that important beyond subjective personal experience.

Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by plandis on Thursday November 17, 2016 @03:10PM (#12981001)
If my options are:

1.) I need a car to get around town. First I need to learn how to drive a car

- or -

2.) I need a car to get around town. First I need to learn how to drive a car. I also need to learn how to do the stick-shift part as well

It's obvious why people no longer do manual transmission. It's one more thing to learn that doesn't help me with my end goal of needing to drive around town.

> To be honest I'm surprised the most that America doesn't have that same psuedo masculinity requirement thing happening

Thanks for the negative stereotyping!

Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by alkonaut on Thursday November 17, 2016 @03:47AM (#12975613)
I think part of the masculinity thing might be down to the fact that for the really powerful muscle cars you really want auto again.

The US has no big tradition of sports cars (in another sense than muscle cars). On the other hand, Aussie car tradition is pretty Similar to the American one in terms of big engines etc so I can only explain the difference between Europe and the US, not between Australia and the US.

Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by vanous on Thursday November 17, 2016 @03:50AM (#12975627)
> No engine braking

The DSG [1] is quite nice to drive and uses engine braking.

Careful feel for the throttle is required, but the same applies to operating clutch...

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct-shift_gearbox

Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by fl0wenol on Thursday November 17, 2016 @10:33AM (#12978288)
Agreed. And while using the sequential shifter or paddles is engaging for performance driving or screwing around, I've also found that modern TCUs are scary efficient even in automatic mode, able to respond appropriately (fuel-saving in eco mode for example) to hill grade, corner exits, overtakes, red-light crawls from what I'm guessing are the use of accelerometers on top of existing drivetrain telemetry and just some good heuristics.
Re:Fewer than 3% of cars sold in the U.S. have manual transm... by usaar333 on Thursday November 17, 2016 @12:43PM (#12979594)
> but why such a preference for automatic?

American here. From experience driving both, automatic is just so much.. easier. This is especially true on steep grades; since you can keep one foot on the brake and one of the gas, you avoid any risk of lurching backwards from a stop and parallel parking becomes vastly easier.