E.g.
* The tax payer in Germany is picking up most of the estimated 100+ billion Euro cleanup of their reactors over the next 100 years.
* Sellafield cleanup alone is going to be £120 billion [1].
* New reactors in Europe are 2-3x over budget and not finished yet. So if we started constructing immediately then 2030 is optimistic [2].
* The chunk of Japan that's a no-go zone isn't that small. Have a look at Google maps some time.
I'd rather spend the 200 billion that new reactors will cost us on energy storage and many lower-risk, known-good providers like wind, thermal to spread risk.
[1] https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachm...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Olkiluoto_Nuclear_Power_Plant#...
I did look at the Google map you're referring to and I converted the scary colors to numbers using the hard-to-find scale and was shocked to learn that the numbers were well within the safe zone. Even the orange.
European reactor constructions are looking rough. But that doesn't have to be the only case. In UAE, the South Koreans are building 4 huge PWRs on budget and schedule. The South Koreans somehow consistently deliver on nukes. The Americans and Europeans could hopefully learn from them how this is done.
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0301421516...
Indeed, because it's cleanup of political, not nuclear fallout.
Energy policy is Germany has always been a political issue. The government decides what gets done, who does it, how it is cleaned up, and who makes money from it. That can work, except it doesn't if politicians are fickle.
The fast breeder at Kalkar (SNR-300) had been planned and construction had started. Then the government changed (from CDU to SPD), the new government didn't like the idea of the reactor and added new ridiculous requirements, for example a cooling device for the ground under the reactor already in construction. You can probably guess how expensive it is to install anything under an existing building. In the end, the whole power plant was constructed, but never fuelled, and finally demolished. Now it serves as an example for how expensive nuclear power is---but really, the expense is all due to politics.
Decommissioning of the current light water reactor fleet is just the same thing. They got shut down prematurely because one particular reactor in Japan was flooded by a tsunami (and everybody knows Germany gets inundated by tsunamis all the time), which makes decommisioning relatively more expensive. It is obvious that the operators don't want to pick up the cost for this purely political decision. Given the political landscape right now, it's likely they aren't able to, either. In addition, the government promised to take care of the waste, but isn't actually doing it. (The original plan involved recycling in fast breeders, which isn't happening, thanks to politics.) Since there is no plan for the waste (thanks to politics) and the industry isn't allowed to come up with a plan themselves (thanks to politics), the expected cost for waste disposal is infinite. Decommisioning of the plants should have been funded by the operators. But the rules have been changed for no good reason. Effectively, everything has to be decontaminated to ridiculously low levels, and the workers doing it must not be exposed to anything. This is impossible, so it's infinitely expensive. Thanks not to technical difficulties or health concerns, but politics.
So yes, the needed money is stolen from everyone ("the tax payer picks it up"), but that's not the fault of the nuclear industry, it's the fault of incompetent, technically illiterate politicians.
> Sellafield cleanup
Military facility. (It was purely military when it was still called Windscale, and that's when it got contaminated.)
> New reactors in Europe are 2-3x over budget
Everything in Europe is over budget. Berlin Airport, Stuttgart central trainstation, Elbphilharmonie in Hamburg... Europe, but especially Germany, lost the ability to get anything done. Sad, but true. The Energiewende (German energy turnaround) is also over budget, and underdelivering.
> The chunk of Japan that's a no-go zone isn't that small.
If that chunk is a no-go zone, then so is Denver, Colorado. The customary limit of 1mSv/a is below natural background! And people live in areas that "badly contaminated" all over the world with no ill effects. Calling something that radiates that weakly a "no-go zone" is another political hatchet job.
> I'd rather spend the 200 billion... on energy storage
Go ahead. Do that and get rich by buying electricity when the sun shines and selling it when it doesn't. If you can do that, more power to you! The practical problem with that plan is---you can't. And if you could... well, you'd probably be buying nuclear electricity at night and selling it during the day.
The 60% figure is also off as it excludes a lot of small scale off grid solar power.
Off-grid power is very small compared total energy used in the USA.
So sure, grid connected PV solar is a very useful comparison point, but the others are used to fulfill our energy demands.
Can Molten-salt reactors be used with uranium too or do we need to develop a Thorium based industry from scratch?
Also, as far as the "no-mans land" comment, there's only been two incidents in our entire history of using Nuclear energy that did this: Chernobyl and Three-Mile Island. Both of which are horrible losses, but Fukushima is not anywhere near as disastrous. The region will be essentially uninhabitable for 30 years, but after that the half-life of the longest-lived element from the disaster will have decayed naturally. Not great, but considering the much longer impact global warming will have a 20Km radius of land being unusuable for 1/3 of a century doesn't seem so bad in comparison - of course, with modern reactor designs (Fukushima was built in '67!) this whole thing could have been avoided entirely even though it was in a Tsunami zone (although a MSR could have had negative consequences, there would have been no issue just pumping seawater in immediately to cool the reactor and stop the reaction - it would have contaminated the water and possible corroded the containment, all of your critical reactor would be dead stopped and the rest of the radioactive material sealed in a giant chunk of salt instead of blown/washed away ending up in the soil).
I dont these reactors are practical immediately. Which changes the whole argument IMHO. [1] https://www.technologyreview.com/s/542526/china-details-next...
[2] http://www.zdnet.com/article/son-of-chinas-ex-president-thor...
Chernobyl was a massive fuck-up that IIRC wasn't even possible in Western plants of the time, let alone afterwards.
Fukushima demonstrates the risks of building a power plant in a tsunami zone, but its death toll is zero, and even the worst estimates of cancer deaths are only in the hundreds. A single coal mining disaster kills more than that, and we have them fairly regularly.
In short, the risk can be dismissed, especially if you factor in the risks of things like coal mining and emissions.
CDO only blew up during the financial crisis because of investors overleveraging. If investors had not fucked up, the financial crisis wouldn't have been that bad.
Bophal only happened because industrials fucked up, improperly storing chemicals close to a populated area.
The problem is rather that overleveraged financial products and chemical products are dangerous. They are safe if handled with care by responsible people who understand what they are doing. But they are inherently a danger because sooner or later someone who doesn't know or doesn't care ends up handling them.
You can and you should. You need to work the numbers, and the numbers will tell you that indeed chemical plants are a problem and financial industry is a problem. But nuclear energy? Not really.
sigh (I hear this too often.)
No, it doesn't. Thorium in conventional, solid fuel reactors is useless. Also, conventional, solid fuel reactors are a relatively dumb idea.
We need better reactors. We have known that since around 1954. One particular design of a more efficient, safer, and likely cheaper reactor would benefit from being fuelled with Thorium. But it's about the reactor, not the Thorium!
By the way, Chernobyl and Fukushima were very different events. Different reactors, different physics, different ourcome. Don't get hung up on Thorium, learn something about reactor physics instead.
However, the rather large exclusion zones are another large risk. The cost of insurance to pay for such events is very significant.
That's assuming the raw materials have the same concentration and accessibility. I would naively assume that just pumping oil up requires no stripping of overburden while some surface uranium mining would. Not saying that oil is great, it's just that the comparison is not as straight-forward as you make it out to be.
It seems more likely that the opposite is true:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Olkiluoto_Nuclear_Power_Plant#...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hinkley_Point_C_nuclear_power_...
> * Nuclear scales well (demonstrated in France)
You mean except in Summer when the rivers are too hot to use their water as a coolant or in Winter when it's getting to cold and France needs to import electricity: http://www.renewablesinternational.net/german-power-exports-...
> Also recall that wind and solar are collecting a very non-dense (but free) energy so they need lots of material and land footprint.
Still lifecycle CO2 emissions are very similar. Building nuclear power stations and mining is also extremely resource-intensive.
The thing is that we need to build low-CO₂ plants now and at least in the west solar and especially wind seem to be the way to go currently.
Even best coal plants given perfect fuel produce a lot of CO2 per MWh. This not counting mining and energy required to purify coal.
Oil is even harder to clean up and there is just not enough natural gas.
Considering the volume of non-recyclable regular waste we produce as northerners, this actually look pretty small. Of course this soda can must be stored with more precaution than our other wastes. And we cannot just assume that future generations will be able to recycle all nuclear waste using futuristic engineering.
But from a practical standpoint it's seems, as of now, more easy to manage some precisely located wastes than to disseminate CO2 in vast quantity and expect that our kids can catch them using futuristic engineering.
> Over the past four decades, the entire industry has produced 76,430 metric tons of used nuclear fuel. If used fuel assemblies were stacked end-to-end and side-by-side, this would cover a football field about eight yards deep.
Obviously you can continue to argue about environmental damage and cost of the land being unusable for many years as well. I actually felt a bit better about nuclear safety though - if old reactor designs that are poorly managed can be hit by tsunamis, melt down and still not result in many deaths, the safety looks better than expected. Possibly the risk model changes for a determined attacker?
EDIT: current state of Wikipedia is pretty much in agreement with the above, but it's an article with a lot of edits and some points have no references. The number of deaths "due to evacuation conditions" is much higher than I remembered (~1500).
For wars it's another story, most militaries could bomb the hell out of a nuke and cause some grief. One rather crazy idea to deal with this is to build nukes on large ships, 10 miles offshore. Worst case, they retreat as designed into one of the most unaccessible places on the planet (the bottom of the ocean), where they stay cooled and avoid releasing radiation until things calm down and the planned recovery operation begins.
Other pluses in this scenario include possible shipyard construction (could be cheap), ability to use power purchasing agreements to get nuclear power to countries that don't have nuclear regulatory infrastructure (the NRC could regulate plants worldwide), and enhanced safety since you're always coupled to a great heat sink and there are 0 people living within your evacuation zone. Anyway that's a bit far-fetched but I love the idea.
If you mean that people wouldn't escalate that far, that's a fickle thing to depend on! Saddam used nerve gas, even though there's treaties against that stuff. I guess it's a good thing that a lot of us live in a part of the world where the thought of war on the homeland is inconceivable, but I don't think it's that remote an idea. I'm from Turkey, which is a semi-developed country where conflict and bombings happen with some regularity, and nuclear power plants are being seriously discussed. So I hope that gives a bit more context to my concerns.
My bet is that dust inhalation during coal mining caused an order of magnitude higher number, that is not even counting accidents such as groundwater pollution.
Human body is quite good at dealing with radiation damage, compared to chemical damage, chronic physical irritation or other sources of inflammation.
Anyway, the nuclear scorecard is:
* Nuclear is currently producing 60% of the USA's carbon-free electricity (the article nailed that one)
* Nuclear worldwide has saved 1.8 million lives net by displacing air pollution
* Nuclear worldwide has prevented the emission of 65 billion tonnes CO2-eq
* If you got all your energy for 80 years from nuclear you'd make 1.3 soda cans of waste
* Advanced nuclear makes additional advances in already-fantastic safety and can improve cost
* Nuclear scales well (demonstrated in France)
* Nuclear is great for regions that get winter storms, lots of darkness, hurricanes, hail, very little wind, etc. while wind and solar are good in places that do not have those. Also recall that wind and solar are collecting a very non-dense (but free) energy so they need lots of material and land footprint.