News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by lingben on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:01AM (#12957993)
not to be glib but the best way to fix windows 10 privacy issues is to stop using windows 10 and switch to linux, there are many user friendly, mature distros out right now and they are only getting better: ubuntu, linux mint, arch, manjaro, openSUSE, centOS, etc. as well as up and comer new distros like elementary
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by criddell on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:10AM (#12958062)
Who picks their operating system first? IMHO, the OS is only there to support the applications I need to use. If those applications are available only on Windows, then your advice isn't very useful.

So I would say your advice isn't helpful. Microsoft has a financial relationship with their users (especially their business users) and despite what many people think, they do listen to their customers. So I would say the best way to fix Windows 10 is to continue to let Microsoft know that you aren't happy with specific changes they've made.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by NTripleOne on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:12AM (#12958083)
And here come the "b-but you can use wine" comments, which of course everyone who would be a proponent of such would understand that it is not perfect, does not run everything and is far from user-friendly.
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by pdkl95 on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @10:41AM (#12958867)
> does not run anything

Have you actually tried it in recent years? Wine runs a lot of stuff just fine.

    grep --files-with-matches wine ~/opt/win32/*/launch.sh | wc -l
    71
The most obvious incompatibility right now is probably DX11-only software. Aside from that kind of known compatibility problem, wine has worked well for several years now.

> far from user-friendly.

While I agree that wine can get nasty if you need to debug anything or if you have unusual requirements, but the standard "just run this win32 binary" case has also been trivial for years. I believe some distros even enable the kernel feature that launches wine automagically when running a .exe file.

> it is not perfect

Of course it isn't. It is, however, worth trying.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by NTripleOne on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @10:48AM (#12958963)
Sorry, that was supposed to be everything, not anything.
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by criddell on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @11:41AM (#12959599)
I've always been afraid that DRM-encumbered games aren't going to work on wine. Is that an unfounded fear?
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by NTripleOne on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @11:49AM (#12959704)
No. Games that utilise the Denuvo DRM (which is gaining popularity, unfortunately) will not run on Wine.
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by jsight on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:20AM (#12958158)
Yeah, Wine is amazing for what is is, but is never quite good enough for current, big desktop applications.
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by jsight on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:19AM (#12958142)
I pick the OS first, but most of the tools that I use are cross platform. If I did need applications that were only available on one, I would likely use a VM. Of course, if the main applications that I needed (maybe ones that I use 80% of the time) were only available on one, that would be different.

I think his advice is perfectly reasonable, it just doesn't apply to everyone. I bet that it applies to a lot of people in a technical audience, though.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by pdimitar on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:28AM (#12958217)
Aren't you people EVER gaming though, programmers or not? I am doing it a lot less compared to only 5 years ago but I want the opportunity to be there the second I figure I want to game a bit, and no, dual-booting is not a way of addressing this at all.

Elaboration: when I have 3 Chrome windows, 2 work VMs fired, a separate Chrome window for the work services, several consoles outside of the VMs, and a live Twitch stream running on the TV hoooked to my PC then no, I am not willing to reboot only to play a game.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by gpderetta on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @10:18AM (#12958664)
After many years away from gaming, I built a linux-based gaming machine recently. A surprisingly large number of games, from GOG and Steam, work natively on Linux today; many others (most dx9 games) works near flawlessly under wine.

I had actually planned to setup GPU bypass on the box and run Windows in a VM, but I have more games now to last a long time, and I haven't actually bothered.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by coldpie on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:48AM (#12958394)
> Aren't you people EVER gaming though, programmers or not?

Frankly? Not much. What gaming I do do is either on the PS4 or is indie gaming, which largely works on Linux or Wine.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by pdimitar on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @10:37AM (#12958834)
Last several months I probably have like 4 hours a week at maximum. My point is, I want all the games in my Windows 10 machine to be there and ready the moment I figure I want to get into them.

Convenience > all, including for some of us the programmers. =)

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by module0000 on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @12:40PM (#12960253)
> Aren't you people EVER gaming though, programmers or not?

Yes, maybe on my phone once in a blue moon? Otherwise, that went out the door(at least for me) sometime in my 20's.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by pdimitar on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @01:16PM (#12960592)
36 here, and a well-paid programmer too; still gaming occasionally although it's times less compared to in the past. I suspect you're not in the majority, having in mind the statistics about adoption of user-level OSes. :P
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by Nullabillity on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @02:51PM (#12961547)
WoW runs fine under Wine. Most games worth bothering with do, and/or have a native port available.
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by dingaling on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:41AM (#12958329)
From a web search the best-selling PC game in history was Diablo III with 5.15 million copies sold. That's barely a blip given 2.5 billion people online. Gaming is a niche activity.
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by nicolapcweek94 on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:54AM (#12958454)
According to Wikipedia [1] the top selling PC game is Minecraft, with 24 millions sold, followed by World of Warcraft that got to around 14 million subscribers, while Diablo III is in third place with 12 million copies sold...

Sure, that's still not much compared to 2.5 billion, but that's also 5 times what you said.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_best-selling_PC_games

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by cptskippy on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @10:15AM (#12958630)
According to World Bank, the earth's population exceeds 7 billion people and 65% of those people are between the ages of 15 and 65. So let's say there's 4.5 billion people of driving age on the planet.

The Toyota Corolla is the best selling car of all time and has only sold 37.5 million units.

By your measure, driving is clearly a niche activity as well.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by tinodotim on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @10:24AM (#12958737)
League of Legends has over a 100 million monthly players. Overwatch 20 million. CSGO and Dota 2 around ~15 million / month, each.

So... adds up ;)

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by viridian on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @10:34AM (#12958800)
League of Legends has over 100 million active players a month. Dota 2 has around 39 million. Steam has over 125 million active, with 9 million concurrent users during peak hours. The free to play games market is enormous.
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by dllthomas on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:45AM (#12958362)
> Gaming is a niche activity.

Define "gaming". There is a sense in which the best selling PC game is almost certainly solitaire.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by criddell on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @10:26AM (#12958750)
AFAIK, macOS runs more software than any other operating system simply because you generally can't run macOS in a VM (I believe you can iff you are running on Apple hardware). So that's probably the safest choice.
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by ChoGGi on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @01:30AM (#12964968)
I'm not sure about Sierra, but El Capitan works fine under VirtualBox/VMWare (you do need to be running an Intel CPU).
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by static_noise on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @10:18AM (#12958665)
This is why I have a strong preference for free software that is available for the dominant three operating systems. Only if free software doesn't satisfy my needs I look for nonfree software and then I first look for commercial software which supports free operating systems. If all that fails, it's time for a Windows 7-VM to run that program.

I'm only one customer but I'm letting Microsoft know that I'm not happy with the way they go with Windows by not using Windows 10.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by criddell on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @10:32AM (#12958785)
I have a strong preference for using the best software available to me. IMHO, all of the major operating systems are good enough although none are perfect.

These days, hardware and software is very inexpensive compared to time. I love the idea behind free software, but sometimes it's just too expensive to choose.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by static_noise on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @12:47PM (#12960308)
The "best" depends on the context. I don't want to argue what's best for you.

In the university context I've found that there is a lot of free software that works good enough or sometimes even better than commercial products. If you factor in that you still can use that particular program after you leave, it becomes a big plus.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by criddell on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @01:41PM (#12960886)
> The "best" depends on the context.

That's very true. For example, if I need to use an image editor, Photoshop is the only thing I would consider. It's inexpensive ($35 for a month subscription), but more importantly it's easy to hire people that know it well. It's also well supported and documented.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by floopidydoopidy on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @11:39AM (#12959571)
Exactly, financially support Linux devs and your tools will follow.
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by calferreira on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @10:45AM (#12958916)
Please stop it. Seriously.

When the subject "Windows 10 Privacy" comes up, linux folks come running offering linux as a magic pill, it's not.

As mature as linux distro's can be there's always the hardware variable in the equation, specially on laptops using nvidia optimus, the experience still sucks. It's the truth.

I have nothing against linux, i actually tried it very recently (you can see it here:https://calbertoferreira.blogspot.pt/2016/10/moving-from-win...) and got a nice initial impression of it, but i will be moving to Windows again very soon.

Want to know why ?

- Creating a virtual machine on virtualbox freezes my machine (excessive IO ? i have an ssd);

- Battery life sucks even with powertop and such;

- My wired internet connection had the same speed as my wireless connection (i disabled wireless to make sure);

- Hdmi audio simply doesn't work and when i asked for help on askubuntu i was even downvoted (http://askubuntu.com/questions/845996/how-do-i-make-hdmi-sou...)!

I tried, i really did but it's a no go for me.

And i feel sorry for it, because i recognise that there are advantages in linux , but until nvidia fixes the damn optimus issues, linux will be held back.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by pdimitar on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @11:57AM (#12959815)
Even though you're downvoted, I mostly agree with you.

Most Linux proponents are people with older hardware and trivial setups: 1-2 monitors, 1 sound card and a pair of normal speakers (without subwoofer), 1 ethernet or wireless card, only 1 ISP, etc.

We get it, for very regular setups Linux works fine. But there are many people who have more requirements outside the warm little box that Linux serves and I cannot understand why do these people come here convincing us this is not the case; and why are they downvoting the people who are outside this bubble.

Linux is not a magic pill on the desktop. For all its strengths (and I do use it in my work every day) it's still a lousy desktop OS and this hasn't changed for 10+ years now.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by module0000 on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @12:59PM (#12960413)
It's a magic pill if you can RTFM. Not everyone can.

Try to keep in mind that the vast majority of internet provided services are served on linux. A large portion are developed on linux, by people that don't seem to be hindered by the parents problems.

edit: typo

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by pdimitar on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @01:12PM (#12960552)
Why should people be interested? They get an advertisement that they buy something and "it just works". Are you by any chance interested in the intricacies of the process needed to guide your sh*t to a dump or a cleaning station? I'd bet you are not.

Don't be bitter. The fact that most of the internet infrastructure is served by Linux doesn't make it a user-grade OS. Unrelated areas.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by calferreira on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @01:16PM (#12960595)
That only proves that Linux is used for critical stuff where people require a specific knowledge. It's not for everyone.
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by justratsinacoat on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:12AM (#12958082)
>ubuntu

Look, if we're trying to avoid OSes that call home with telemetry about what you've been doing...

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by akerro on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:19AM (#12958144)
Afaik Ubuntu removed that module like 2-3 years ago. It still reported like 1/100000 of what Win10 does daily.
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by justratsinacoat on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:43AM (#12958349)
>It still reported like 1/100000 of what Win10 does daily

Oh, absolutely, but if we're going to advise would-be Linux converts who are concerned with data leakage, may as well advertise actually-telemetry-free distros.

>Afaik Ubuntu removed that module like 2-3 years ago

Hey great! Link? Trust but verify...

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by ThatGeoGuy on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @12:08PM (#12959922)
For those out there that haven't bothered to do a quick search, one notable story about the issue can be found here [1]. Note that the date on that article is from 2014, and only refers to the Unity service for searching from Amazon. A later article [2] shows that Ubuntu has changed directions, but it certainly hasn't been 2-3 years. Needless to say, while it took Canonical some time, at least they dialed back what they were doing with online searches and made them opt-in. I've yet to see Microsoft, Google, or Apple dial back their telemetry services regardless of what criticism they may have faced (fair credit here, at least Apple is opt-in for the most part, though not entirely).

[1] http://www.pcworld.com/article/2840401/ubuntus-unity-8-deskt... [2] http://www.omgubuntu.co.uk/2016/01/ubuntu-online-search-feat...

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by warcode on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:03AM (#12958011)
Please write the tutorial to run all windows games (at the same performance level) on linux and we're talking.
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by nilved on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:07AM (#12958040)
No need, someone else has done so: https://www.reddit.com/r/pcmasterrace/comments/3lno0t/gpu_pa...

Furthermore, native Linux games are only becoming more popular, and one way to make them more popular is to use Linux.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by NTripleOne on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:13AM (#12958095)
He said at the same performance level, which will never be achieved in linux until the GPU drivers are not fucking awful.
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by SparkyMcUnicorn on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:20AM (#12958155)
~3% performance loss is barely anything.

I'd say that's plenty efficient enough.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by CaptSpify on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @10:33AM (#12958794)
But ~3% is also what that tutorial found, and IME, is not the norm. Most other video cards that I've tried get much less than that. I'd love some kind of stats that show what the average performance difference is.

Additionally, video-card drivers are still buggy and fragile. And it's not just video cards, but wifi and sound as well.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by NTripleOne on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @11:22AM (#12959349)
You need 2 GPUs and one of them isn't utilised at all in the guest, so I'd say that's more than a ~3% performance loss.
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by kawsper on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:20AM (#12958147)
This solution passes the GPU to the Windows OS, running inside the VM, so it will use the Windows GPU drivers.
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by tscs37 on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:13AM (#12958098)
GPU passthrough.

Requires a recent or non-K intel CPU with IOMMU though and the chipset has to play nice.

I'm using it on my machine in conjunction with Synergy to passthrough keyboard and mouse between host and VM seamlessly.

Performance hit: somewhere between 5% and -2% (some games actually run faster in the VM than on baremetal, most notably KSP and CSGO)

Setup is not trivial, as it will probably require an ACS-patched kernel if your CPU is older and also needs VFIO kernel parameters to be maintained.

If you do this, I recommend Arch, as the performance on the newer kernels is sometimes better (due to KVM/Xen and QEMU improvements)

Also lots of RAM and Swap. You're gonna need lots of it.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by trendia on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:14AM (#12958101)
Many newer Steam games work on Linux
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by jhasse on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:04AM (#12958016)
Dual-boot ;)
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by pdimitar on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:33AM (#12958256)
People suggesting dual-boot make me think they only switch on their PC for maximum of 1 hour a day and have no idea what it's like to have dozens of programs started (and you needing all of them) and what kind of inconvenience is to start them all manually or wait your OS 2-3 minutes to start most of them automatically.

You also probably don't realize that many of us stream video and music 24/7 and your main PC is de facto a programming + gaming + home entertainment server.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by jhasse on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @10:01AM (#12958519)
> have no idea what it's like to have dozens of programs started (and you needing all of them) and what kind of inconvenience is to start them all manually

You can hibernate one OS and still start the other one. This way all your apps will reopen the next time you boot the OS.

> You also probably don't realize that many of us stream video and music 24/7 and your main PC is de facto a programming + gaming + home entertainment server.

You're right, most people will have to use Windows at some point :(

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by invokestatic on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:06AM (#12958038)
That doesn't solve the privacy problem, then.
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by crdoconnor on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:32AM (#12958247)
If all you're doing on the OS is playing games there's not much privacy to violate.
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by johncolanduoni on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:16AM (#12958123)
It helps a lot if you encrypt the other OS's drive and use Windows as little as possible. If you have a computer with an IOMMU and a virtualization-friendly graphics card you can do even better.
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by homarp on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:18AM (#12958139)
yes, it helps by sending a signal: it gives to microsoft the information that you are only using Win10 for playing. And 'something else' the rest of the time.
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by kawsper on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:19AM (#12958141)
You can start following here: https://www.reddit.com/r/VFIO/ it is a subreddit dedicated to hardware passthrough.

They run Windows in a virtual machine, and pass a dedicated GPU into the VM, the results are very impressive, but the installation is very complicated, and you won't get rid of Windows.

As VFIO matures, and the API stabilizes a bit more, I think we will see distros offering an easy "install and play" experience.

There is a complete guide here: https://davidyat.es/2016/09/08/gpu-passthrough/ And as you can see, it involves all kinds of steps.

One day, hopefully Windows will be just a shell to play games on :-)

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by 6DM on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:11AM (#12958077)
I've tried many times to run linux, it usually ends 3-4 hours later in frustration. I tend to run older hardware so a lot of times support isn't there. I will admit that it's getting noticeably better (or I'm getting luckier).
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by reacweb on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:45AM (#12958367)
After using exclusively linux at home during a couple of years, I have bought a laptop to my wife. I wanted to experience windows 8 (new at that time). It was a complete week of frustration. Almost no application are present by default, the video player complains about all file formats, installation of visual studio express succeeded only at the third try for no obvious reason. The ergonomy was a nightmare (it became usable after discovering many keyboard shortcuts that existed already in win7).

Linux is fast to install (when no problem occurs). Software installation (and deinstallation) is a breeze. Everything is available out of the box. I maintain a diary with a list of non default packages to install: apt-get install nfs-common wine gnome-media openssh-server squid curl filezilla curlftpfs ethtool docker.io xtightvncviewer x11vnc tmux whois git wakeonlan youtube-dl npm sshfs

Concerning support for old hardware, it was the main reason that made me switch to linux: vista64 had no support for my printer and my scanner.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by pdimitar on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @11:44AM (#12959641)
Windows 8 is a horrible example. Windows 10 is miles ahead of everything Microsoft ever had. It's basically a much better Windows 7, in all regards.
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by kminehart on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @10:08AM (#12958584)
That's weird. Older hardware is usually what works best on Linux.

The only hardware-related issues I've ever had have been trying to run a brand new graphics card or on the latest macbook.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by marcelluspye on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:14AM (#12958102)
How old is older? There are a lot of distros designed with the purpose of making old hardware useful, up to definition of old.
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by 6DM on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:20AM (#12958154)
Probably 2007-2010 range, I still have my budget desktop that I put together in 2008 if that gives you an idea. These were never top of the line machines so they don't get much love.

I usually just went with Ubuntu because at the time it seemed like it was user friendly. I tried openSUSE at one point. If you can name a distro better aimed at supporting these types of devices I'm game.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by Nursie on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @10:16AM (#12958650)
At this point if you can't get linux of some sort running on PC hardware it's probably you that's the problem.

Back in the 90s, sure, there were a hell of a lot if blocking issues. But now?

Frankly anyone posting on a tech site that can't get it up and running adequately should be embarassed.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by CaptSpify on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @10:44AM (#12958908)
> Frankly anyone posting on a tech site that can't get it up and running adequately should be embarassed.

And this is a big reason why so many people still don't want to use linux. The "Why aren't you as smart as I am" attitude isn't as strong as it used to be, but it's still there. It turns off users. Nobody wants to use software when the other users are going to treat them like idiots. There are still many complicated problems to get linux up and running, and being a jerk ignores those problems, rather than helps solve them.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by Nursie on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @11:37AM (#12959544)
I'm not asking why people aren't as smart as I am. I'm not even trying to be controversial here. This is not a "user" we're talking about, this is not beginners help on reddit somewhere, this is HN.

If you can't install linux on some reasonably generic pc hardware in this day and age, and you consider yourself a hacker or coder, you probably ought to be a little embarrassed. Certainly not proud as some seem to be.

If I was interviewing someone for a role and asked them for their thougts on using linux and got "well I usually give up after a few hours trying to install it" I'd look elsewhere.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by pdimitar on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @11:51AM (#12959744)
You are missing something very important here. I can setup almost every Linux I can think of for desktop / everyday usage. My relevant question is: "Is it worth my time?", and most of the time, it's not.

Look, it's fine if you breathe Linux in your free time and you don't watch movies or play games, or nail your girlfriend, or even watch the ceiling in half-meditative state with all lights out. That's not sarcasm. Everyone has the right to do what they want with their free time.

But many of us are hackers / coders AND have a happy personal life and don't want to bring their work to their free time. And want to make the best use of their work time, too.

Linux gets the job done and I very much like my XFCE 4.x on my virtual Debian, but it's still far away from a full-blown user OS on the desktop. Numerous articles agree with this fact.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by Nursie on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @05:27AM (#12965849)
Hey, I never said you have to like it, never claimed it would meet your needs, never claimed you should convert, never claimed it was better than windows, never claimed you need to spend your free time doing anything.

It's a simple comment - if you're working in tech in any capacity and you can't install linux satisfactorily, that really is nothing to be proud of in the modern day and age.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by CaptSpify on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @01:02PM (#12960431)
> I'm not asking why people aren't as smart as I am.

Not directly, but you are being condescending to someone who has legitimate issues. Just because someone is on HN doesn't mean they are great with linux, or that they are even a technical person. Maybe he's got a different skillset, and doesn't like dicking around with shitty config files, obscure error messages, and jerks that tell them they should be "embarrassed" for not being omniscient.

Can you tell me the best way to pull HE levels from a GE MRI's MM? If not, are you going to spend a lot of time looking it up just because? Why aren't you embarrassed that you don't know that?

> If I was interviewing someone for a role and asked them for their thougts on using linux and got "well I usually give up after a few hours trying to install it" I'd look elsewhere.

Depends on the role. If it was a linux-admin job, absolutely. If it was for a job in HR, then I wouldn't care at all.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by Nursie on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @05:29AM (#12965857)
Actually I would say that being on HN does mean that someone had a claim to be a technical person or in the tech industry, and that being able to install linux is now so easy and so common that it's more like the fizz-buzz test - if you can't do that we shouldn't even be talking.
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by CaptSpify on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @01:17PM (#12969721)
So what technical test did you take to sign up for the website to prove that you were technical? I know I never took one.
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by module0000 on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @01:07PM (#12960487)
We just want you to read the manual - we did. Summarizing knowledge to people that can't be bothered to read the manual is not a good use of my time. Please don't take that as mean spirited, it's just a fact.

"Giving back" to the open source world in my case is done by committing code and documentation, not free support. So when you hear "go read the manual" or RTFM - we aren't insulting you or being jerks. We genuinely want you to better yourself and acquire education, and are pointing you in the right direction to do so.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by CaptSpify on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @01:26PM (#12960731)
If that's the attitude you have (which I don't think is necessarily wrong), than that's fine. But people aren't going to adopt linux if that's the case. Frankly: The manual sucks. If mass adoption isn't your goal, then great, nothing more to discuss here. But the point of the conversation is comparing linux to win10. I've never used win10, but from what I understand it doesn't require you spend hours pouring over man pages, so there's a lot of friction to transition from win10 to linux.
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by 6DM on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @11:37AM (#12959550)
The only thing embarrassing here is this comment. I can get linux "some sort of running" but that's frankly not good enough for me. I need both proper screen resolution AND audio working. I need logins without errors and networking that actually works. These are my experiences and no amount of an attempt to shame me will get rid of them.
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by module0000 on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @01:03PM (#12960441)
Linux isn't for everyone. It's not that us happy-linux-users don't have any of the problems you describe, but rather that we are capable of fixing them and preventing their future appearance. If that doesn't sound like something you would enjoy or be willing to do - then it might not be for you.
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by Nursie on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @11:42AM (#12959616)
I have had no issue with any of that for years now. Unless you have some really exotic hardware, it's hard to empathise here.

Linux is an industry standard, I think this sort of brag about how much trouble you have with just getting it running reflects much worse on the complainant than the system.

20 years ago? Sure. Now not so much.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by 6DM on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @11:52AM (#12959758)
> I think this sort of brag about how

If anyone is bragging here, it's you, so no need to be a hero. If you're hearing this a lot, maybe it's not us and instead it's people like you. The whole point of a good UI is to make it easier for people that don't regularly use your system. So if you're hearing this a lot then maybe it really isn't good.

> Linux is an industry standard

On servers it is, on desktops Windows still rules and that's for a reason. Common users don't need to hit up a Reddit beginner forum or spend hours pouring over documentation to learn the command line and all the various utilities for their chosen distro.

On the server, yes it's rock solid and I've had a pretty good experience with it. On the desktop, no. Also, my experiences are not from 20 years back, try 2.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by Nursie on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @05:31AM (#12965866)
I see it on HN every so often, and I see it used as a way to say "linux is bad and complicated".

Installing it is not complicated, with a live CD it's arguably easier than windows these days. It reflects badly on you as a person working in tech if you can't do it.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by cptskippy on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @10:03AM (#12958536)
Linux's greatest strength, freedom of choice, is also it's biggest weakness. Instead of a clear vision and focus, you have a million developers getting frustrated with half baked implementations and rolling their own half baked implementations. Because of this there's a constant churn and things can change radically from one version of a distro to the next.

A user can live on the same LTS version of a distro for years but eventually they'll need to upgrade. I have yet to see anyone successfully upgrade major releases of any distro without serious issues. The process is basically format and start over. That's unacceptable.

Sure Windows and macOS have their own set of problems but for the average user they just work. You don't have to dive into the bowels of the registry or modify ktext files to get most things to work and the majority of users don't even know about the CLI.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by jlgaddis on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @06:03PM (#12963132)
While I agree with you (for the most part), I do want to say that Debian is king when it comes to upgrading across major releases.

I've been using Debian since v1.3 and have upgraded I-don't-know-how-many machines across major versions. I've got production servers running Debian 8 right this moment that were running Debian 6 when they were installed.

With regard to RHEL, I always reinstall from scratch instead of attempting upgrades. I think they're a lot better about upgrades nowadays but I still remember, very clearly, the day when attempting an upgrade was just asking for trouble.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by pdimitar on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @11:59AM (#12959828)
Why are you getting downvoted for stating facts? Baffling.
Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by cptskippy on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @03:33PM (#12961946)
My feeling is that a lot of people around these parts use Linux as their desktop environment and think that just because it works for them, then it will work for everyone else. What they fail to realize is that if they're reading HN comments then they're probably above average when it comes to computer prowess and they're not reliant on someone else to support their computer needs.

I've been using Linux in various forms for over 15 years in all forms including daily driver desktop, daily driver laptop, HTPC, foisting it upon my children via netbooks, custom router firmware, Raspberry Pi development, custom ROMs on cellphones, home server hosting, cloud hosting, NAS appliances, development VMs, and production VMs. I tried use the desktop environments really hard for about a decade and constantly founding myself wondering why certain tasks had to be so hard. I always chalked it up to inexperience or unfamiliarity and pushed forward but then my job required me to use OSX. I quickly realized that it was the Linux desktop envs and not me. It was also around this time my kids started using computers more heavily for school and the Linux netbooks I provided them just couldn't cut it. Surprisingly they were able to use Nexus 7 tablets for their school work with relative ease.

I still use Linux daily but never on the desktop. CLI or nothing.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by pdimitar on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @06:28PM (#12963262)
That's precisely my experience and preference -- CLI and servers (all the kinds you enumerated although I didn't do some of them) and please let's just stop there.

Linux desktop is just not there in terms of "set it up in 15 minutes and forget it unless you want to heavily modify it". Of all OS-es Linux has the biggest potential to be the ultimate desktop system but alas, not just yet.

Thank you.

Re:Fix Windows 10 Privacy by stinos on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @10:24AM (#12958728)
> they are only getting better

they sure are: difference in e.g. desktop usability with like 15 years ago is huge. You can finally install something from cd and have it up and running including audio/network/automatically mounting pendrives/... without having to touch a config file. Usually. But the problem seems to be in the getting better: I'd rather just have it good enough already right now. Too often it does, for me, as a desktop, still not feel quite right yet and still too buggy. 15 years ago a lot of things Windows just worked and now they still do and a bunch of nice stuff was added (ok crap was added as well) and for what I do with it I have close to 0 problems. I just wish I could say that everytime I try any of the distros you mention.