News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Colorado Voters Accept Right-To-Die Measure by trosi on Thursday November 10, 2016 @06:45AM (#12919589)
> The measure requires that people "make two oral requests, separated by at least fifteen days, and a valid written request to his or her attending physician." It also requires that people be capable of taking the medication unassisted

Why the last requirement? Seems to me like a lot of terminally ill patients wanting to die might not be self-sufficient

Re:Colorado Voters Accept Right-To-Die Measure by roflc0ptic on Thursday November 10, 2016 @08:30AM (#12920144)
My dad is in the early stages of dementia and has repeatedly said he'd prefer to die than live on as a husk of a human.

Interestingly, he's got one of the weird dementias, called "primary progressive aphasia", which is slowly robbing him of the ability to speak. There are cognitive deficits as well, but the main issue is that he has trouble formulating sentences. So if we lived in Colorado, when he actually wanted to die, he would be unable to fulfill these requirements.

Also interestingly, part of his motivation is explicitly monetary: he wants his life savings to go to his family, not a nursing home.

This experience has reaffirmed my position in favor of right-to-die, but it really is a complex issue. If gran-gran doesn't want to go to the gas chamber, there should be stringent protections in place to keep her family from sending her there.

Re:Colorado Voters Accept Right-To-Die Measure by cc438 on Thursday November 10, 2016 @01:50PM (#12923068)
>"Also interestingly, part of his motivation is explicitly monetary: he wants his life savings to go to his family, not a nursing home."

That sentiment may seem strange to most people but I think it's more than just a logical conclusion, it's an emotional one as well.

We recently lost one of our family's matriarch's (grandmother-in-law) after her long battle with a failing cardiovascular system. After one particularly difficult evening, she realized her time was about to come and asked her husband to stay by her side while she passed in their home. Unfortunately, her end did not come easily and a relative convinced my grandfather-in-law to call an ambulance when she went into respiratory arrest as it was shockingly painful to watch. She was taken to the hospital and placed in the ICU where she was stabilized but only at the footstep of death's door. The miracles of modern medicine managed to keep her borderline comatose body alive for almost a month in the ICU before the family could come to agreement on sending her to hospice.

That month in the ICU cost almost everything they had worked their entire lives for and was intended to be passed down to their children and grandchildren. Two lifetime's worth of hard work and thoughtful planning went to cover the cost of just one last month of "life".

My point in sharing that story is that the true cost of that month isn't measured in dollars and cents, it's measured in the loss of the legacy they had worked so hard to build. Neither of them viewed their estate as something as simple as "money". Instead they saw it as things like "college tuition for the grandchildren", "a wedding gift to help the grandkids start their married life", "land my ancestors have lived on for generations", and "one last vacation for the whole family". That's what I mean when I saw they lost their legacy and why it's as much or more of an emotional decision than a cold calculation of financial realities.

Re:Colorado Voters Accept Right-To-Die Measure by JshWright on Friday November 11, 2016 @09:57AM (#12931137)
While I am absolutely in favor of "right to die" laws, there are already tools in place to cover situations like those of your grandmother-in-law. If someone does not want to be kept alive artificially, they should obtain a Do Not Resuscitate order[1]. This serves as an expression of the patient's wishes, and would supersede the relative who wanted the ambulance called.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Do_not_resuscitate

Re:Colorado Voters Accept Right-To-Die Measure by seanp2k2 on Friday November 11, 2016 @06:06AM (#12929637)
When you consider situations like this, it makes total sense why hospitals would have every incentive to fight for "the right to life" and "foster a culture of life" and oppose right-to-die / assisted suicide.
Re:Colorado Voters Accept Right-To-Die Measure by JshWright on Friday November 11, 2016 @09:58AM (#12931143)
While I can't speak for "hospitals". I can tell you that doctors are very much in favor of "do not resuscitate" directives, which would have prevented the scenario described above.
Re:Colorado Voters Accept Right-To-Die Measure by jobu on Thursday November 10, 2016 @01:04PM (#12922664)
> So if we lived in Colorado, when he actually wanted to die, he would be unable to fulfill these requirements.

Colorado's law is fairly specific to those that are imminently terminal (6 months or less), so most forms of dementia do not qualify.

I'm terribly sorry for what your father, your family, and you are going through. I wish I had some words of comfort, but really there is nothing good about where dementia will take him or your family.

I went through a fairly similar experience with my father who had PSP (Progressive Supranuclear Palsy - http://www.psp.org/). Early on in the disease he was aware of his mental decline and expressed a desire to end his own life. Everyone was concerned and the doctors ended up putting him on antidepressants. If only we had known how bad things would get...

There are many forms of dementia, and nearly all of them involve a horrible quality of life at the end.

My brothers and I joke about taking up skydiving in our retirement and packing our own parachutes. If our mental acuity declines to the point where we pack the chute wrong, then at least it would be a quick end.

Re:Colorado Voters Accept Right-To-Die Measure by osi on Thursday November 10, 2016 @12:05PM (#12922098)
interesting. makes me wonder if he were to write it out on paper would that still be ok? since i'd say the spirit of that requirement is the person is still able to express their desire unambiguously
Re:Colorado Voters Accept Right-To-Die Measure by roflc0ptic on Thursday November 10, 2016 @12:26PM (#12922311)
My concern there - what if he changes his mind and is unable to communicate it? I happen to know the guy pretty well, and this is a decades-old position that I seriously doubt will change, but "take my word for it" isn't a really compelling burden of proof.
Re:Colorado Voters Accept Right-To-Die Measure by prirun on Thursday November 10, 2016 @06:33PM (#12925713)
I don't think people change their mind on this kind of decision. For example, I could list in the document (written when healthy) that if I am unable to clearly communicate my wishes either verbally, by blinking, or whatever, maybe for more than X days, then I prefer to err on the side of dying.

A big advantage of having this written (and binding!) is that it takes the burden off of family to make the decision. Many people cannot make this kind of decision for others when they are incapacitated.

Re:Colorado Voters Accept Right-To-Die Measure by yesiamyourdad on Thursday November 10, 2016 @08:59AM (#12920373)
I understand that the dying process is unfamiliar territory and none of us know how we're going to go or what the path will be like.

My father died a couple years ago after a long decline. He would have passed the verbal request criteria, but he had a long history of saying unambiguously that he did not want extraordinary measures to prolong his life, and he consistently refused medications and medical care in the last 10 years of his life.

However, hearing him say things like "If I knew how to end this, I would" was one of the hardest things I've ever heard, because he was not the type to give up.

In the end, he declined rapidly in the course of a couple weeks and passed away on his own. There's some peace to knowing that even though it was a really hard road, he went out basically the way he wanted - without being plugged into a bunch of machines, without medications, in his own time and his own bed.

I'm glad we didn't indulge his last minute desires for the easy way out. I really hope Coloradoans will make good decisions, but I know that sometimes they won't.

Re:Colorado Voters Accept Right-To-Die Measure by zimpenfish on Thursday November 10, 2016 @06:58AM (#12919670)
Presumably it's to stop people "helping" their elderly relatives who, perhaps, have a nice big house or millions of pounds.
Re:Colorado Voters Accept Right-To-Die Measure by yesiamyourdad on Thursday November 10, 2016 @08:38AM (#12920216)
I've spent way too much time in assisted living homes the last 5 years. There aren't that many of the rich elderly people. More likely their families want to avoid paying thousands of dollars a month in care costs.
Re:Colorado Voters Accept Right-To-Die Measure by zeveb on Thursday November 10, 2016 @10:55AM (#12921435)
> More likely their families want to avoid paying thousands of dollars a month in care costs.

Is killing the elderly in order to save a lot of money much more moral than killing them in order to inherit a lot of money?

Re:Colorado Voters Accept Right-To-Die Measure by Retric on Thursday November 10, 2016 @11:39AM (#12921908)
Normally debts don't get inherited without consent.

This, is more about shifting this debt to the kids or kicking them out of the facility. Further, they are not going to get 'better' the facility's are focused on keeping patents alive to extract as much money from the family as possible not because the elderly actually want to suffer as long as possible or necessarily benefit from the care.

PS: Funeral homes are also setup to prey on people suffering a loss. It's a sick business.

Re:Colorado Voters Accept Right-To-Die Measure by 91bananas on Thursday November 10, 2016 @11:25AM (#12921750)
Is it moral that they're just humans that got sick, and they are burdened to pay the ridiculous cost of care that they don't want?
Re:Colorado Voters Accept Right-To-Die Measure by hx87 on Thursday November 10, 2016 @10:42AM (#12921299)
Based on how often that happens, as opposed to people in pain who want to die but aren't able to take their own medication, I'm willing to risk that happening. Being forced to stay alive in pain is every bit as bad as being forced to die.
Re:Colorado Voters Accept Right-To-Die Measure by 1123581321 on Thursday November 10, 2016 @11:37AM (#12921884)
Murder is still considered worse than torture by most people, so it's appropriate that our laws reflect that.
Re:Colorado Voters Accept Right-To-Die Measure by hx87 on Thursday November 10, 2016 @01:07PM (#12922680)
Given that the choice is between "torture leading to death" and "death", our laws are wrong.
Re:Colorado Voters Accept Right-To-Die Measure by elthran on Thursday November 10, 2016 @07:00AM (#12919676)
If the first 2 requirements have been met, clarifying the intent of the person wanting to die, then surely the physical assistance at this point shouldn't be an issue in that situation?
Re:Colorado Voters Accept Right-To-Die Measure by zimpenfish on Thursday November 10, 2016 @07:04AM (#12919698)
Coercion isn't unknown. Although the two oral requests would probably help to avoid that a little bit.
Re:Colorado Voters Accept Right-To-Die Measure by Shivetya on Thursday November 10, 2016 @08:06AM (#12920006)
so are those requests being done while limiting who can be on hand to witness? I would expect a member of the hospital, state representative, and their doctor, would be sufficient. Having a family member on hand might be detrimental unless they ask for them separately
Re:Colorado Voters Accept Right-To-Die Measure by arethuza on Thursday November 10, 2016 @07:18AM (#12919762)
Maybe it is to protect the people who might be administering the medication from criminal and/or civil litigation?
Re:Colorado Voters Accept Right-To-Die Measure by undersuit on Thursday November 10, 2016 @01:55PM (#12923108)
>Why the last requirement?

Why the oral requests? Are signers of ASL not able to take their life under this requirement? Would a terminal patient that had their vocal cords or tongue removed not be able to make the requests?

Re:Colorado Voters Accept Right-To-Die Measure by Joeboy on Thursday November 10, 2016 @08:48AM (#12920290)
I guess legalizing actually poisoning somebody is just a step further than legalizing selling a poison.
Re:Colorado Voters Accept Right-To-Die Measure by InitialLastName on Thursday November 10, 2016 @11:23AM (#12921733)
I agree... all these prescription drugs are a huge problem for our society.
Re:Colorado Voters Accept Right-To-Die Measure by Joeboy on Thursday November 10, 2016 @12:02PM (#12922080)
I'm being downvoted despite what seems like a straightforward and reasonable comment, and I don't understand your response at all (is it sincere or sarcastic?). I wonder if I'm being misinterpreted somehow.

The Right to Die is a controversial and emotive topic, so legislation is likely to be a gradual process. Colorado's voted to legalize one aspect, the sale of life-ending medication. Legalizing physically administering it would require a different measure, which may or may not happen at some later point.

Re:Colorado Voters Accept Right-To-Die Measure by philipkglass on Thursday November 10, 2016 @01:39PM (#12922966)
The downvotes (not by me, BTW) are for using emotive language that criticizes by implication without advancing an actual argument.

Consider this description of veterinary euthanasia: "I guess that legalizing poisoning pets was a natural outcome of allowing vets to buy poisons." If you used that language I think that most people would infer that you strongly object to veterinary euthanasia, but you haven't made an argument why it should be illegal to hasten the end.

Re:Colorado Voters Accept Right-To-Die Measure by Joeboy on Thursday November 10, 2016 @01:52PM (#12923087)
Thanks for the explanation. I thought I was just speaking plainly. I am in favour of the right to die (subject to details obviously).
Re:Colorado Voters Accept Right-To-Die Measure by InitialLastName on Thursday November 10, 2016 @05:23PM (#12925075)
I misunderstood what you wrote as a reference to the last major libertarian/progressive agenda piece that Colorado legalized, which is sometimes (with weak justification) characterized as legal poison. Not my downvote, but it's possible others had the same response.
Re:Colorado Voters Accept Right-To-Die Measure by Joeboy on Thursday November 10, 2016 @07:34PM (#12926240)
Ah, total cross purposes. Not what I meant at all.