News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by viraptor on Thursday April 22, 2010 @05:34PM (#1286538)
Why would a high-end retail store care? They sell some product. They might be unwilling or unable to enter some market - and this guy does it for them. The retail store still receives the money and people who get the product are aware of the fact that they paid more than they would at the shop.

I still don't get why this practice is unacceptable. The shop doesn't seem to lose anything here.

Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by Perceval on Thursday April 22, 2010 @07:42PM (#1286807)
Think about it in terms of concert/sporting event ticket sales. Everyone hates scalpers. They aren't real fans, they're not going to go see the act/game. They know when all the ticket sales are going to be, since their entire life revolves around getting tickets, and they know all the pre-sales and other ways of snapping up tickets. They buy tickets in huge blocks when possible, use intermediaries and partners to buy more tickets to get around any limits.

When you, the fan, get around to buying tickets for the event you find that they're all sold out already (except for the nosebleeds). But you can get tickets on Craigslist for 3x the face value of the ticket from some guy who bought several large blocks for the sole purpose of re-selling them with a huge markup.

Maybe the venue shouldn't care if re-sellers are buying up all the tickets, but it sure makes for a shitty experience for their actual market (i.e. the people showing up for the event). It also limits the venue's ability to control supply and demand because they no longer have any direct say over the market price for their good/service.

So both fans and the venues seem to be worse off, while the middle man makes a big profit by artificially restricting supply.

The guy in the article exhibits the same type of buying behavior that a scalper would: buying more iPads than a normal individual would require and then reselling them at a markup. Apple doesn't have any way to tell that he's trying to extend their market abroad to people that can't purchase an iPad locally. But I'm pretty sure they have the same view toward a middleman that concert venues would. And the local customers trying to get an iPad when supplies are scarce are also going to be frustrated that one individual is making (effectively) block purchases.

One of the cardinal rules of good business is to cut out the middleman. That seems to be what's going on here.

Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by viraptor on Thursday April 22, 2010 @08:46PM (#1286891)
Actually, I think the scalpers are right on some level. If they can sell the tickets at x3 price, then the real price of that ticket is x3 the original price. It only means that the vendor could do the same and get them all sold out anyways. If they really want to stop this process, it's enough to issue only tickets assigned to a name and check IDs at the gate - this way you cannot buy the ticket before you know who is it for - which means if person X can buy a ticket for me, I'm able to buy it for myself from the source.

But limiting scalpers is basically the same as EULAs and DRM - they're regulating what you can do with the thing you just bought. They're making life harder for normal users, while those who gain money by ignoring the system keep earning money.

Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by bena on Thursday April 22, 2010 @09:49PM (#1286984)
But the only reason there is a demand at 3x the price is because the tickets are believed to be scarce because the scalpers bought all the tickets to sell at 3x the price because when the tickets are sold out at the venue it gives the illusion of scarcity.
Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by vetinari on Friday April 23, 2010 @02:49AM (#1287481)
They would not be able to do that, if there was no audience willing to buy it at 3x price.

Just think about it: scalper buys all the tickets and tries to sell it for triple price. Nobody buys it. Concert starts, it is empty and the scalper end up with expired tickets in his hands.

Does that happen? No, because people are willing to pay triple price.

Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by jamii on Friday April 23, 2010 @10:15AM (#1288065)
Alternatively, the scalper sells half the tickets and makes a 50% profit overall. The concert sits half-empty and thousands of fans miss out unnecessarily.
Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by viraptor on Thursday April 22, 2010 @10:00PM (#1287009)
At some price 'X' you won't find any more people wanting to buy the tickets - and the race stops there. Even if they're scarce, people won't be interested in tickets costing more than 'X' anymore, or you'll be able to do only X+5% so it's not worth the time.

But if you sell the tickets assigned to a name in the first place, there is no issue anymore. As long as venue sells "blank" tickets, they basically say they don't care if anyone is reselling them at much higher prices.

Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by BrandonM on Friday April 23, 2010 @10:37AM (#1288132)
If X is $250, you realize that 5% is $12.50 and is almost certainly worth the time?
Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by msg on Friday April 23, 2010 @12:40AM (#1287289)
If there was an auction for the tickets the price would be driven up too. Shows do sell out in minutes and not just because of scalpers.

Imagine an auction that increased ticket prices until just before the show began. Now stop imagining it and recognize that it's exactly the same as sold out shows plus scalpers.

Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by eru on Friday April 23, 2010 @06:53AM (#1287749)
Yes, the concert-organizers should really just have an auction for the tickets in the first place. This way no-one can complain about high prices, since the fans bid them up to that level in the first place.

For extra ethical browny points, the sellers could donate (a fraction of) everything taken in above a certain `fair-price' point to charity.

Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by tbrooks on Thursday April 22, 2010 @08:03PM (#1286836)
I think the ticket analogy is a little loose. Once tickets are sold out, there are none left to buy but from the scalpers.

Apple will make more iPads if they sell out. The supply is almost limitless.

Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by SandB0x on Thursday April 22, 2010 @09:09PM (#1286918)
"Extra dates added, by popular demand"
Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by gridspy on Thursday April 22, 2010 @09:32PM (#1286947)
However in this very article the author talks about the iPad stock shortages.
Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by praptak on Friday April 23, 2010 @03:36AM (#1287536)
Temporary ones, resulting in a lifetime ban.
Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by DrJokepu on Thursday April 22, 2010 @05:43PM (#1286560)
Because they feel that shopping experience is part of their brand and people buying their "high-end" products in large quantities just to sell them elsewhere would hurt the brand on long term. Don't forget that Apple is very careful about its brand and image.

I'm not saying I agree with this practice, that's just the reason this is disallowed.

Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by mnemonicsloth on Thursday April 22, 2010 @05:53PM (#1286591)
they feel that shopping experience is part of their brand

You're right, but say it like you mean it. They treat your opinion of their company as their property.

That's what having a brand means.

Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by dasil003 on Thursday April 22, 2010 @10:57PM (#1287103)
No it's not. It's more like a softer version of anti-slander than it is like they own your opinion. Are they going to send you a threatening letter if you don't like them?
Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by glhaynes on Friday April 23, 2010 @12:08AM (#1287230)
Is "attempting to influence it through their policies" equivalent to "treating it as their property"?
Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by philwelch on Thursday April 22, 2010 @11:24PM (#1287146)
"Property", or "responsibility"?
Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by poikjhgvfgbnm on Thursday April 22, 2010 @06:15PM (#1286653)
You don't just buy an Apple iProduct - you embrace the Apple lifestyle. That's why iPads come with adoption certificates, simply handing over money for one would devalue the whole experience of transferring the love from Jobs to you.
Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by rapind on Thursday April 22, 2010 @07:42PM (#1286806)
I'm on my third mac (I just can't find a comparable product to a MacBook Pro), but the whole apple lifestyle stuff is a big turn off for me.

If I could get a comparable laptop (obviously by my own preferences) then I'd jump ship in a heartbeat, just so I didn't have to feel like I was part of some Apple fanboy club.

Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by wtallis on Thursday April 22, 2010 @08:54PM (#1286897)
I'm pretty sure that the majority of Apple customers feel that way or at least aren't interested in any kind of "Apple lifestyle". The proportion of Apple customers who are true fanboys is probably no higher than the fraction of Dell customers who are gamers with too much money and completely unrealistic opinions about the relative merits of AMD vs Intel and Nvidia vs ATI. The stupid rich Apple fanboys get more disdain than the stupid rich gamers because the Apple fanboys are more ostentatious and the gamers [ab]use technical terminology that makes them sound less subjective.
Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by alextingle on Friday April 23, 2010 @04:13AM (#1287577)
I gave up on my PowerBook 12" last year. It had pretty good software, but the hardware was really disappointing. I've bought a Lenovo Thinkpad, put Ubuntu on it and I'm very very happy.
Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by roc on Friday April 23, 2010 @11:30AM (#1288311)
I've long told my friends that the single biggest drawback of Apple products is the supposed "lifestyle".

The attitude? not my thing. The people in the stores? not my people. Even the places they locate the stores are not my kinda places.

Unfortunately, they have great products I really enjoy and their service is phenomenal.

Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by sshconnection on Friday April 23, 2010 @06:22AM (#1287718)
Please god let this be a troll. I just threw up in my mouth a little bit.
Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by dmn001 on Thursday April 22, 2010 @06:05PM (#1286626)
I would also add that the opportunity of selling extra iPad accessories, insurance and/or warranty is only possible instore, and not from a reseller. This would hurt Apple due to the lost revenue.

I still have the view though that if someone has the money they should be able to buy it and a lifetime ban is not really ideal.

Also a CNN article I read recently means the limit of 2 isn't stopping the trade in Hong Kong: http://www.cnn.com/2010/TECH/04/08/ipad.hong.kong.china.sale...

Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by pyre on Thursday April 22, 2010 @08:07PM (#1286841)
> I would also add that the opportunity of selling extra iPad accessories, insurance and/or warranty is only possible instore, and not from a reseller. This would hurt Apple due to the lost revenue.

If a retailer is unable or unwilling to enter a market, why should they be able to artificially ban anyone in that market from obtaining their product?

Take this outside of the context of Apple here. If Universal decides to release a DVD in the US, but wait 2 years to release that same DVD in the UK, should they be allowed to ban people in the UK from trying to obtain the US version? Trying to artificially create segment markets to suit your business goals like this goes against the entire idea of a global marketplace.

If anything, Apple is losing that revenue because they are 'unable and/or unwilling to enter that market,' not because someone isn't in the store shopping for their iPad. The argument that Apple is losing money over this is like the argument that the media industries make when they claim that every download is a lost sale.

Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by pbhjpbhj on Thursday April 22, 2010 @09:54PM (#1287000)
>should they be allowed to ban people in the UK from trying to obtain the US version? Trying to artificially create segment markets to suit your business goals like this goes against the entire idea of a global marketplace

Indeed, they resort to technical means to effectively "ban" people (region codes). IMO the reverse situation should arise that the companies are prevented from imposing artificial segmentation by any means if they wish to retain copyright protection.

Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by whatusername on Thursday April 22, 2010 @09:49PM (#1286987)
You've never heard of http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DVD_region_code

I'm not saying it's right - just that it's not new.

Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by pyre on Thursday April 22, 2010 @10:02PM (#1287012)
That's exactly why I used that example. Plenty of people think that DVD region coding is unfair and wrong, so I don't understand how this is any different.

Saying that this guy somehow 'wronged' Apple is like saying that someone who buys DVDs outside of their region code (and uses a region-free dvd player) is somehow 'wronging' the movie studios.

Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by Gormo on Friday April 23, 2010 @11:46AM (#1288363)
Lost revenue from not selling accessories and warranties to people who wouldn't have otherwise bought the original product in the first place?

This only makes sense if the base product is a loss-leader, and all of the margins come from the upsells. Best Buy may work this way, but I'm pretty sure Apple makes a profit selling even the barest iPad configuration.

Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by tedunangst on Thursday April 22, 2010 @05:54PM (#1286593)
Why they care: I was recently shopping for a camera. The one I wanted was supposed to retail for about $900. But it's new and popular, so it's selling for $1100 (or out of stock). I've decided that's too much, so I'm considering other options.

If the only message I got was out of stock, I'd probably wait. But upon learning that the price is actually $1100, that triggered a different psychological response, and now I'm looking for something cheaper. Something from a different manufacturer.

So sure, in the short term, they are selling all they can. But in the future, when they have more capacity, they just lost a sale.

Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by jessriedel on Thursday April 22, 2010 @06:03PM (#1286617)
That only explains why companies want to limit the ability of customers to resell their product, not why companies should be allowed to do this.
Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by codyrobbins on Thursday April 22, 2010 @06:18PM (#1286661)
Are you serious? They don't need your permission to do this—it's their product, they can implement whatever sales policies they like. They don't have any responsibility to defend the practice, it's their prerogative. But even if it wasn't, they simply don't want middle men marking up their products and taking a cut, while at the same time depleting their in-store stock. I don't blame them.
Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by dhimes on Friday April 23, 2010 @08:21AM (#1287847)
they can implement whatever sales policies they like

A small nit here but it's important to point out that this is Not Quite True. Over the past hundred years we've worked out some rules about what sales policies companies are allowed to have. For example, you can't deny sales based on race, you can't deny sales (wholesale) because a store sells a competitive product also, and so on. It might be that in the global market place these rules need to be revised.

Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by fleitz on Thursday April 22, 2010 @06:50PM (#1286728)
Apple doesn't want middle men marking up their product? If that is so then how come I can buy an Apple product from Best Buy for the same price as from the apple.com? Is Best Buy selling these items for the same price they paid for them?

I believe Best Buy is what one would call a middle man.

Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by derefr on Thursday April 22, 2010 @09:04PM (#1286908)
> Is Best Buy selling these items for the same price they paid for them?

As far as I know, yes, they are. They make money on Apple products purely off of in-store warrantees and accessories. If you consider this, their store product layout starts to make a lot more sense: they have a huge Apple logo, tons of accessories prominently displayed, and then the actual products hidden on a bottom shelf.

Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by codyrobbins on Thursday April 22, 2010 @09:37PM (#1286964)
Again—seriously? You can't compare one of the country’s largest electronics retail chains with a guy buying up iPads by the dozens and selling them on a gamer forum. Selling through Best Buy is clearly a strategic partnership that’s been negotiated as a component of their larger retail strategy. The guy buying iPads is not. Sure Best Buy's a middle man, but the point is that Apple can do whatever they want. There is no discussion about whether they should be allowed to do it or not. The fact that they bring on Best Buy as a middle man doesn't mean they somehow have to let this guy skim some cream off the top too. They haven't released the iPad overseas yet and what he’s doing is in direct contradiction to their launch plans.
Re:Banned from buying iPads... for life. by a-priori on Thursday April 22, 2010 @08:33PM (#1286870)
Or perhaps Apple marks up the online store similarly to the markup that retail stores do?