News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by erlehmann_ on Sunday October 30, 2016 @08:49AM (#12829489)
Why do people do this? Is it only for fun? I would think that any GNU/Linux system could provide similar or better tooling and most likely results in a less painful upgrade process.
Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by adamors on Sunday October 30, 2016 @09:58AM (#12829807)
I actually switched to Hackintoshes from Linux PCs because the upgrade/install process is less painful. Used Ubuntu and Arch in the past, tinkering with the system was almost a daily thing.

Also, the UX/UI of OS X is just miles ahead of anything on Linux. Same for 3rd party software.

Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by toyg on Sunday October 30, 2016 @05:46PM (#12832537)
> the UX/UI of OS X is just miles ahead of anything on Linux.

I thought the same, but I spent the last few days surveying the field and it's not actually the case anymore. ElementaryOS and LinuxMint have top-notch desktop managers (Pantheon and Cinnamon respectively) and provide a really polished experience. After a few hours on Elementary in a VM, I am really tempted to format my rMBP and see if it can be my main OS going forward.

Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by erlehmann_ on Sunday October 30, 2016 @10:07AM (#12829849)
Referring to my other comment, could you quantify your UX/UX assessment? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12829832
Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by adamors on Sunday October 30, 2016 @02:05PM (#12831221)
To me it comes down to: sane default settings, ease of customisability and ability to discover stuff on my own. Add to this applications that just work™.

I still remember having to write a Bash script on Ubuntu to move the mouse every 2 minutes because the screensaver couldn't detect VLC was running in fullscreen. Or having to reboot because the audio driver crashed randomly.

Even xkcd has a strip about something similar https://xkcd.com/196/

Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by itchyouch on Monday October 31, 2016 @12:27AM (#12834310)
I think a lot of it has to do with polish. Linux GUIs can be beautiful, but the interactions with the UI tend to be functional first and stay that way.

I remember when compiz came out and it was supposed to make the UIs really pop with a good graphics card. It really bridged the gap a lot, but the physics in the animation lacked a bit of timing finesse. The animations weren't terribly clunky, but they lacked a certain fluidity with the interaction. When interacting with a mouse or finger, certain things like input speed wouldn't be taken account for. Like on MacOS, a fast moving mouse cursor travels more across the screen than a slow moving mouse cursor. When scrolling, moving the scrollbars faster increase the scrolling speed while slowing down the movements slow things down proportionately in a very intuitive fashion, while a similar concept on Linux may do something very similar, it doesn't quite hit the nail on the head. It usually requires adjusting ones input and getting used to the tool.

Even when the OS UI improved, individual applications also needed appropriate UI updates and UX. Since a lot of GUI apps were wrappers for underlying command-line utilities, they felt a lot like thinking in command-line mode for a GUI app or were unapproachable unless one came from a technical background.

But even for people who may only use a browser, when starting a browser, the default set of fonts in a given browser were usually not that great. Not sure how much it has improved now, but I think the main culprit lies in the font rendering settings and available fonts. Getting prettier fonts have improved slightly, but a lot of the system feel comes from these fonts, especially in things like menus. So reading a webpage in some standard sans-serif may be fine on Windows & Mac, but just look slightly off on Linux. Functionally, nothing was wrong, but maybe the text box slightly overflowed outside of a div that was sized well for MacOS and Windows, but not Linux.

Small things like these add up and make people feel like desktop Linux is just not quite there. I think Canonical has done a tremendous amount of work getting desktop Linux closer to being viable. This is coming from someone that's on 14.04 ubuntu. I haven't tried the lastest 16.x series, but I'm guessing it will get closer.

The other challenge outside of UI/UX improvements really is commercial support that comes along with 3rd party products. When you purchase some printer and you see there is included productivity software, it will 100% work on Windows, 20% chance there is a Mac port, and usually 0% chance that it has a Linux port/version. Even when you purchase something OS agnostic like a cable modem, there will be Windows/Mac Compatible logos, but no Linux Compatible sticker making one feel like desktop Linux is relevant or even a prudent choice for someone non-technical to use.

Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by yardie on Sunday October 30, 2016 @10:37AM (#12830020)
I've been a Mac user since the late 90s. Believe it or not you used to be able to get a Mac for under $1k. Usually, through student discounts and back to school sales. My last desktop Mac was a Powermac G4 tower. The next gen was the Powermac G5 with double the price! There was no upgrade plan going forward. $2500 was wildly out of my budget.

A few years later, after Apple released the first intel macs, I discovered the osx86 wiki, gave it a shot and it worked! I built a Hackintosh that was almost as powerful as a full MacPro, Intel Q6600, 16GB RAM, RAID10 HDD, for 1/3 of the price.

I've always enjoyed using a Mac since the System 7 days. But in this day and age paying >$1500 for a laptop just seems ludicrous. I'm typing this from a 2011 MBP. I anticipated purchasing a newer 2016 MBP. After this announcement I'll probably look into a refurbished rMBP.

Sadly, I believe the entry level xMac is never going to happen. the Mac mini gets no love, the MacPro gets no attention, the iMac gets and it appears the focus is mobile and laptops. So I'll be back on the OSX86 wiki making my shopping list and doing my research once again.

Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by erikbye on Sunday October 30, 2016 @12:23PM (#12830614)
You do realize a lot of people work with software like Adobe’s Photoshop, Premiere, Illustrator, After Effects, Ableton Live, Pro Tools, Cubase, Sonar, Final Cut, Avid tools++?

Do not even bother to mention Wine, or Linux native alternatives, because there are non that are good enough for most professional users.

Also, less painful? I spend less time installing and configuring a hackintosh system and upgrades than I do configuring and maintaining most Linux distros.

Making a stable hackintosh system these days is as easy as picking parts from something like OP’s post and following install and configure guides on the same site. Very little pain involved actually.

My preferred work environment is OS X/macOS as host and a Linux distro as guest.

I also prefer a hackintosh system to a Mac Pro for price/performance ratio, and the flexibility of selecting my own hardware and upgrading whenever I feel like it.

Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by mrtksn on Sunday October 30, 2016 @09:14AM (#12829599)
In some countries macs are ridiculously expensive for students and even for professionals and people just install MacOs on their already available PCs so that they can mess around with XCode or the tooling for web development. Sure you can have most of the tooling on Linux for example but the MacOs UI is much better than anything available for Linux distros.

Also, curiosity.

Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by erlehmann_ on Sunday October 30, 2016 @10:03AM (#12829832)
Could you quantify how you judge UI? I actually found that the OS X UI to be consistently less featureful and more cumbersome to use than most GNU/Linux stuff. Maybe I have different expectations regarding operating system features?

Take window management, for example: If I want my windows to fill exactly half the screen, have one window on top of all others or move them from anywhere (just not the title bar), last time I checked it was just impossible out of the box.

Package management is another thing where GNU/Linux excels. On Debian, I am usually just a single “apt-get” away from having exactly what I need. The UI for such tasks does not seem to exist at all on OS X without third party tools.

In practical terms, Apple delivering outdated GNU utilities that are by now nine years old is something that should not happen with a modern operating system. I have encountered a lot of (non-developer) Apple users who do not know this and then wonder why something does not work.

If you would explain what makes the “UI being much better” in your eyes, it might help us to understand why exactly we think differently (heh) here.

Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by mrtksn on Sunday October 30, 2016 @10:39AM (#12830027)
No I can't but for me it means that it always performs well no matter if I am watching video or messing on sublime text or I am on the terminal. Also, the terminal for me is only about the work I do and almost never about managing my computer because my computer works as expected.

My blood boils when I hear about linux on desktop because my experience always involved up keeping linux doing millions of easy things all the time just to make the thing run.

Some funny glitch when running Chrome? Oh that's because of the display driver, update it and you'll be fine but to update it you need to install some dependencies and to install these dependencies you need to add some repo. Oh great now the app that worked is no longer working because installing drivers somehow messed to the permissions of some folder, just run this command to fix the permissions and now you are all good. Remember that app that was crashing due to permissions? Yeah, it was due to a bug that is fixed on the new version now you need to run this command o undo the permissions change because the bug was fixed and now it's not working with the hack.

I like not maintaining my tools, I don't maintain my macbook except for installing updates when prompted and cleaning the screen and the keyboard every now and then. My uptime tends to be from OS update to OS update.

Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by redial on Sunday October 30, 2016 @11:07AM (#12830179)
Not op but this is my experience. I mainly use macOS but use Linux occasionally.

First, the argument against third party software to me is irrelevant, after all I use macOS and not, say iOS, because you can install these kinds of applications. Besides, from my point of view, almost all software on Linux is third party software anyway so I don't get the difference. For window management I install Spectacle and for package management I install HomeBrew and call it a day.

The UI to me seems superior because a) it looks better, b) it's more integrated with the system, and c) it doesn't bother me every 5 minutes trying to get my attention. I realize that looks are subjective but Linux has always looked "wrong", like it's unfinished; typography looks wrong, and the dimensions of the elements look wrong, some too big, some too small. Lately it has gotten better but still, the more deep you go, the less finished it gets. I guess one tends to like what one's used to. On my second point, macOS is the UI, not like on Linux where you can tell the Windowing System seats on top of the OS. It feels disconnected somehow, and as soon as something goes wrong, you are back on the terminal trying to hack your way back to stability. Lastly, macOS is not constantly begging for my attention. Windows is much more guilty of this than Linux is, but it still happens, showing you bubbles and messages for non critical tasks that ruin concentration. It also provides the information you need and very little else, the information is there if you want it, but it's not in your face. It gets out of the way, and lets me focus on the application and task I'm really interested in, not in managing the system.

And don't get me started on installing applications. Apt-get is fine if all you try to install is a low level package that is not dependent on anything else. As soon as things get more complicated you think about it twice before attempting to install something out of fear of it requiring a kernel recompile. In my opinion, dependencies and repositories are two words no normal user should be familiar with.

Of course, if you are a developer, or if you spend all day on the terminal I can see how your point of view might be different, or why you would care about your GNU tools being up to date. And I get how macOS might seem to someone coming from Linux, or even Windows, more limiting. But the truth is I don't care about the system that much, I want it not to bother me.

Lastly, and perhaps my strongest and more frivolous point, command-H to hide applications is the best shortcut ever. I haven't minimized a window in years.

Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by drinchev on Sunday October 30, 2016 @08:53AM (#12829510)
I doubt that. Sketch / Photoshop does not run on GNU / Linux as well as Safari.

These are a must for any front-end developer these days and personally although I like some window managers for X11, I can't afford to go that way, because they don't feel mature enough.

Not to mention iTunes, Photos and all the nice software that comes with OS X.

Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by X86BSD on Sunday October 30, 2016 @08:59AM (#12829543)
Also there is no dtrace on Linux.
Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by drinchev on Sunday October 30, 2016 @09:01AM (#12829554)
Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by e40 on Sunday October 30, 2016 @09:21AM (#12829634)
Because of the software we use. Lightroom and MS Office (please don't suggest Libre Office is good enough, it's not for legal and accounting documented exchange, as I had many spreadsheets that were broken on LO).
Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by erlehmann_ on Sunday October 30, 2016 @09:45AM (#12829748)
As a Lightroom user, how do you think Darktable compares to it for amateur and semi-professional use cases? http://www.darktable.org/
Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by jseliger on Sunday October 30, 2016 @11:01AM (#12830148)
I've tried and liked it, but it seems that it isn't really meant to replicate Lightroom's cataloguing functionality. I tried importing the 20 or 25K photos I have, which Lightroom cruises through (I've met people with hundreds of thousands of photos in their catalogues) and Darktable gacks. That's on a relatively recent 5K iMac too, so I don't think hardware limitations are the problem.

Right now Darktable seems to be more of an editing tool and less of a cataloguing tool.

Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by marmaduke on Sunday October 30, 2016 @10:23AM (#12829932)
MS Office 2013 runs fine on Wine! At least, I can confirm that the equation editing and change tracking stuff was worth the effort to set up Wine. If you have custom plugins 'n stuff, maybe it won't work well.
Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by scholia on Sunday October 30, 2016 @09:39AM (#12829717)
Of course, Lightroom and MS Office are available on Windows, and may include more programs ;-)
Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by e40 on Sunday October 30, 2016 @03:01PM (#12831573)
The discussion here is about Linux not Windows.
Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by scholia on Tuesday November 01, 2016 @06:28PM (#12850671)
None the less, my comment is true, and as a matter of fact, most PCs run Windows....
Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by mountaineer22 on Sunday October 30, 2016 @09:01AM (#12829552)
You can have a 32GB i7 running OS X for iOS or native app development for less than $1000.

UPDATE:

Oh yeah, you can upgrade the various components too.

Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by op00to on Sunday October 30, 2016 @09:15AM (#12829606)
How much do you need to put towards an attorney retainer for fighting the copyright infringement lawsuit Apple can bring against you? Does that count toward the less than $1000 price tag?
Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by extra88 on Sunday October 30, 2016 @09:56AM (#12829801)
Oh please, Apple has never gone after a user for making a Hackintosh for themselves.

Contract law, due to the user not abiding by the license agreement, is more relevant than copyright infringement. Apple gives the OS away freely and there's no copying act that you do for yourself that would be infringing (e.g. copy the OS to a Mackintosh's drive and you're still okay), it's only the use of the OS which is a problem and that's not a copyright problem, it's a license problem.

Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by mountaineer22 on Sunday October 30, 2016 @09:17AM (#12829617)
Please explain?
Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by op00to on Sunday October 30, 2016 @09:23AM (#12829640)
The only way to get a license for a modern MacOS is to purchase a mac. The license is nontransferrable, forever attached to the specific system purchased. It is a violation of the EULA and most likely Apple's copyright to install MacOS on systems that are not entitled for the OS, which is every system that's not a Mac.

In other words, you're violating Apples copyright by running MacOS on a Hackintosh, and Apple is well within their rights to sue you for damages. Defending these types of lawsuits are expensive.

Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by aptwebapps on Sunday October 30, 2016 @09:43AM (#12829739)
Breaking your OS's EULA is not the same as violating copyright. Not even close.
Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by adamors on Sunday October 30, 2016 @10:02AM (#12829828)
You are spreading misinformation. EULA is completely different from copyright and in a lot of countries EULAs are not enforceable.
Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by drinchev on Sunday October 30, 2016 @09:40AM (#12829726)
Technically speaking if I have a Mac mini and I plug 8 more gigs of non-apple RAM or another hard-disk I'm violating their EULA.

IMHO they did the copyright, because they don't want someone to put a stamp "MacOS X - tested" or something on their hardware.

Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by op00to on Sunday October 30, 2016 @09:51AM (#12829779)
I don't believe your assertion that upgrading Macs breaks the EULA. Can you explain this statement?

Does Apple really document how to break their EULA on their website: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT205041

Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by drinchev on Sunday October 30, 2016 @10:15AM (#12829891)
Precisely. So how do you explain Hackintosh then? If I upgrade the CPU of a Mac Pro, I am obviously running OS X on a non-apple hardware.

Or the other way around. If I take the HDD of a MacBook Pro and put it on my Hackintosh, am I violating the EULA?

So I think the line is so thin and you can argue about anything on that topic.

Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by mountaineer22 on Sunday October 30, 2016 @10:04AM (#12829837)
I saw this from your link:

"Removing or installing memory

You should not manually upgrade or replace the memory in these Mac mini models. Instead, contact an Apple Authorized Service Provider or Apple Retail Store to install memory for you."

Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by op00to on Sunday October 30, 2016 @10:26AM (#12829952)
Yes. Upgrading the memory on some older Minis requires you basically disassembling the entire machine. I've done it. It's not brain surgery, but it's also not as easy as turning the little circle thing on other Minis. Nowhere does it say it violates any license agreements, just that Apple doesn't suggest you do it.
Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by op00to on Sunday October 30, 2016 @09:32AM (#12829679)
Oh - I forgot to add, the $150,000 statutory damages for copyright infringement if Apple decides to make an example of you. Might want to put a few hundred $k away just in case.
Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by CPLX on Sunday October 30, 2016 @11:59AM (#12830475)
This is patent nonsense.
Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by Hydraulix989 on Sunday October 30, 2016 @01:12PM (#12830907)
Which doesn't prevent them from still being bullies (I'm assuming patent was a double entendre?).
Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by rcarmo on Sunday October 30, 2016 @12:16PM (#12830566)
The user experience completely blows Linux out of the water, and the tooling is superior because you can use ports from Linux/BSD _and_ native tools.
Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by jrcii on Sunday October 30, 2016 @08:57AM (#12829535)
Gnome and KDE are painful to use when you're used to Aqua, not to mention all the great Mac-only apps.
Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by toyg on Sunday October 30, 2016 @01:53PM (#12831140)
I've tried a few Linux distributions in the last few days, I suggest you try LinuxMint - it seems to be the less painful option. I'm not sure what desktop manager they use, but it's definitely better than stock KDE or stock GNOME.

For KDE, the best experience at the moment seems to be Neon, although I've not tried OpenSUSE.

Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by morganvachon on Sunday October 30, 2016 @09:54AM (#12829789)
Openbox + compton gets me the same smoothness as Aqua, and is much more configurable. You can make it look and feel 99% like Aqua, or you can go another direction and make it exactly what works for you instead of cloning another interface.
Re:Building a CustoMac: Buyer's Guide October 2016 by xufi on Monday October 31, 2016 @07:19PM (#12841845)
Can't disagree with that. The way it functions and the plethora of apps you get with it are good enough for me