He at first put in a lot of effort, but eventually he was just coasting through ahead of his classmates. He attributes it to the drilling he put in initially.
Now, doing many exercises is a different thing! one that I encourage! In most textbooks, exercises range in difficulty and approach. I write math problem sets for students, and I build them to go from mechanical to sophisticated. The last few problems involve proofs, applications, links between different areas of mathematics and statistics.
Students in my class who just do probability drills will not be able to do the last problem on the problem set. They don't have any practice at problem-solving in this context. Students who do all the exercises, and more, can do amazing things.
It's this kind of teaching that makes good robots and terrible mathematicians. (Thankfully I'm neither the former not the latter.)
Do you have any research to support that? Because from what I've seen we currently think that drilling does nothing to help with understanding, and that one of the problems people have with maths is applying the wrong technique to a problem because they don't understand the problem.
> You'll never understand even relatively simple things like complex analysis or Fourier transform just by reading about it
Very few 8 year olds are grappling with fourier transforms.
First kids need to be drilled to pick up the basics such as tables of multiplication, the understanding comes afterwards (for some). This is how maths has been taught for ages, but not so long ago common perception under teachers changed: people started thinking, wouldn't it be better to teach kids the ideas and the reasons why basic math rules work, even better, let them discover those rules them by themselves, and get rid of those mind numbing drills?
After a couple of decades, the common perception has switched again: the answer is 'no' [1]. To be able to grasp the ideas behind math rules, your brains have to get familiar with the basic concepts first. And that just takes time and practice. When those basic concepts are engraved in your brain, only then are you able to start playing with them and build higher abstractions.
Learning complex mathematics is not any different.
[1] http://educationbythenumbers.org/content/kumon-worksheet-sty...
As an aside, no one is saying that there is no place for practice in math teaching. What they're saying is that it needs to be balanced with time spent actually learning the concepts and exploring on your own rather than just practicing and drilling. From the article:
"Similarly, 96 percent of American students’ work fell into the category of “practice,” while Japanese students spent only 41 percent of their time practicing"
Those students still spend just under half their time practicing, which is still significant, just not the overwhelming majority of their time as in the case of American schools.
W&R proved 1+1=2 in their axiomatic system. It wasn't done to prove once and for all that 1+1 is in fact 2, but to show that their system produced mathematical truths. The truth of 1+1=2 was already assumed and understood since they were kids, and that's why it was necessary that their system also produce it.
Of course PM was obliterated by Godel shortly after.
Eventually you get pretty good, but there is just no substitute for good repetitions with a good coach correcting your form and technique.
Then you scrimmage where you put those into practice perhaps at a slower pace and get a chance to be creative, and then you put them into a game where things happen full speed. And after the game you evaluate what went well and what didn't.
It baffles me that anyone thinks mathematical learning (or any other) can be done any other way. Reps matter.
A.) For the obvious not everyone learns the same way
B.)Drills and practice are important, but being able to actually apply your math skills is also important. I remember in high school when there were math word problems so many people HATED them. These were people in honors/college level classes and they struggled to actually apply the math to situations. Find how fast the train is moving, how long the ladder is, and Geometry proofs all made many of them get confused. They didn't understand the point of the math they knew.
Personally, I got SO bored with drills/memorization. And personally for me, that if that's the -only- method of learning used it's awful for long term retention. The math skills that I've retained the longest were taught in several different ways-- a mix of drills/practice, visualization, mixing it with other types of problems so that I could see how the puzzle pieces fit together, etc. I understand the point of what I'm doing, it's not just some abstracted concept that I happened to write 50 times.
I agree that past a certain point you'll have to accept abstraction, but especially in early years up until probably Algebra, it's a useful skill to be able to use math in the real world. Seriously, I've met so many people who can't calculate a tip, understand fractions enough for simple cooking, do their budgeting, or begin to understand economics and taxes enough to be even decently informed citizens.
That's because you're lazy. I know you really genuinely think you aren't, but you are... I'm dealing with this same mindset in my 13-year-old son right now. That's like saying you want to get in shape, but the repetitious method of lifting weights up and down is just SO boring.
There's more than one way to do things. That said, drills are important. You do have to practice at some point. But if it's the -only- thing that's used, as it is in some classes I've taken, it's boring and harder to retain the information. And in my personal experience, I've seen that sticking with -only- that method can sometimes be counterproductive. It's avoiding the depth of understanding needed for actually applying the math.
However, I do think that examples and applications help a great deal. Sometimes, a mere description of first principles doesn't do it for me, and then, when I see an actual example, I suddenly understand it and the theory along with it.
But i agree that the key is practice. At university, where the pace picks up dramatically, you figure out that going to the lecture is not as important as finishing the assignments. Always finish the assignments.
regions where math levels are higher due to parents pushing for it.
"proper" americans are great in design, marketing and sales. mix the two systems and you get SV.
In talking about how Japanese teaching methods are better than American teaching methods, it states: "Similarly, 96 percent of American students’ work fell into the category of “practice,” while Japanese students spent only 41 percent of their time practicing."
They might try something that looks similar with word problems, but that is a far cry from the majesty of investigating the world with simple arithmetic. The problems they come up are contrived and students are no fools. Problems must come from within, not be handed to people.
Drilling vs understanding is not an either..or. Most learning starts with messing around, trying to figure something out. It is slow and will be painful if the interest is not there. At some point, understanding is sufficient with a foundation in place and then drilling comes in to get a mastery, but what "drilling" is and needs to be will vary from person to person. Too little, and the speed fails to materialize inhibiting understanding of higher level concepts. Too much and it gets boring shutting off critical interest.
All of this suggests that teaching mathematics in a one-size-fits-all is difficult. Also, imagine trying to grade 120 guesstimations for weeks on questions the students come up with. This is the essential difficulty of our current teaching mindset, namely the single authoritarian figure blessing or cursing the work of others.
The key to true learning is excitement and motivation and little external judgement. Interested people will largely self-correct with a few subtle pointers here and there.
Even at the level of Fourier transforms, most students probably fail to understand the problem. So how can it possibly make sense? Math is about working around hard problems, but the teaching of mathematics leads one to believe that there are simple algorithms to apply and we are done.
A lower level example of this is Newton's method. Solving f(x) = 0 in their experience (quadratic formula) is easy and graphing shows the zeros anyway. What is the problem it solves? But what if you just give them a graphical piece of the curve and ask where they think a zero is? Then the problem becomes clear and the solution can make sense. Then it gets translated into steps (draw a line that fits well, find its root, find out what it looks like around there, repeat). And then to master it, one can do a number of drills.
Good luck doing this, however, with people who do not care one iota about it and live in a culture where the majority of Americans have disdain for math (probably born out of a mixture of shame of how poorly they did in math class and bitterness that this most wonderfully human tool for exploring the world has been denied them).
Other fields deal with concepts more or less mapped to the real world. Physics is about real world, more or less (right until you get to quants, then the level of abstraction rises dramatically). Same goes for biology, and even computer science in general. There, you can rely on words, which usually convey meaning.
In math, you can't rely on words. You'll never understand even relatively simple things like complex analysis or Fourier transform just by reading about it -- words are never enough to transfer the knowledge to you. You need to play with it, solve actual problems, understand in practice how various "moving parts" are related to each other, and then accept the naming convention (which is almost an afterthought, born as a mean of reference, not as a way to describe things). Therefore, relentless practice and solving abstract problems (a lot of them) is the only way to teach (or learn) mathematical concepts.
Some teachers want to make math more accessible with bringing it "down to earth", mapping mathematical concepts to more concrete problems. It is theoretically possible, and I was a supporter of this approach until very recently. However, math just doesn't work this way. Math is pure abstraction; linking the abstractions to earthly affairs too early shuts down mathematical thinking (creates biases that prevents applying mathematical insights to other fields that are different from the one learned).
Mathematical abstractions cannot be transferred by words and formulas alone; they need to be internalized by practice and drilling.