News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by bertiewhykovich on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @02:10PM (#12790152)
I admire Stallman's unworldly, unfettered commitment to his principles. It's difficult to live an ethical life, and twice as difficult to live an ethical life under capitalism. Stallman's manic devotion to assiduously following his own moral compass is, bizarre though its manifestation may be, something we should all aspire towards.

That being said, I'm perpetually frustrated by the boneheadedness of his ethical commitments. They strike me as ineffective and, more critically, unsound: it seems to me like Stallman ad-hoc transformed an (absolutely justified) distaste for closed-source software into a system of ethics by, fundamentally, adopting aphorisms as axioms. Whether this was done as a post-hoc justification for his depth of passion in this area, or whether it was just a gradual metastasis, I don't know.

Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by baldfat on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @02:39PM (#12790428)
I am a Theology/Philosophy degree holder. Academically speaking I am always amazed at how brilliant the man actually is. When i hear him speak in a more conversational manner I always think, "That guy thinks he just got RMS, but RMS actually knows the guy lost the logical/ethics/battle.

I still remember when The Linux Action Show interviewed RMS and Bryan Lunduke couldn't even wrap his brain around the ethics piece besides (I have to feed my family). RMS said get a different job if closed source is your job and explained his ethical system.

I disagree with RMS on most things but I do identify him as an intellectual genius above my own abilities. As crazy as he is we are so far better off in this world with RMS then a world without RMS.

Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by paulpauper on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @02:11PM (#12790155)
I always get a laugh reading his site... he has a lot of rules .. I think that his 'religion' that he imposes on himself
Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by racl101 on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @02:21PM (#12790248)
I also admire him but I think it's also funny he continues on this dogmatic existence.

I think he ought to let himself make mistakes, punch out for the day, crack open a brewski, kick back with an iPad, and listen to some classic rock, Google some porn on pornhub (incognito of course) and just take a load off.

Even if he started using closed source products in old age or, God forbid, did anything for profit or selfish reasons, he's still a good guy who made a difference in the world. His legacy lives on in his Copyleft, all those sweet GNU tools and Emacs.

But all the same life moves pretty fast. And if he doesn't stop and look around once in a while, he could miss it.

Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by bertiewhykovich on Wednesday October 26, 2016 @08:36PM (#12802027)
Taking a day off from your principles seems suspect, at best. (That's not to say that there's no way to justify doing so -- but it's difficult to conceive of what that might be.)

Also, I frankly doubt that Stallman's life would be improved by kicking back with an iPad and a beer and jerking it to Internet porn. Classic rock, maybe -- but there's no contradiction between that and his approach (as long as it's DRM-free).

Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by qntty on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @02:50PM (#12790543)
Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by Freak_NL on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @02:29PM (#12790323)
Do you need proprietary software or Apple devices to get the most out of life? I never got the impression the Stallman was missing out on something.
Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by bertiewhykovich on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @02:56PM (#12790605)
Yeah, there's probably something to be said for stringent limitations on the kinds of technology you can use as an antidote to ease of spending every waking moment looking at a screen. If I wasn't allowed to use Facebook, Twitter, Netflix, an OS with nonfree drivers, any DRMed media, and so forth, I'd probably spend a lot less time screwing around. I'd miss out on a lot too, of course, but the tradeoff may not be all that bad -- my life would, in all honesty, probably be substantially improved just by not having a smartphone to look at constantly.

That's a pragmatic assessment about lifestyle, of course -- it's not germane to the rigor of Stallman's ethics (or, more accurately, the apparent lack thereof).

Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by cakeface on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @02:14PM (#12790182)
There is in fact a religion called Stallmanism.

http://stallmanism.wikidot.com/

Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by tomcam on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @02:12PM (#12790163)
Why is it twice as different to live an ethical life under capitalism? And under what alternate systems is it easier to live an ethical life?
Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by bertiewhykovich on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @02:23PM (#12790262)
I want to be careful here to avoid asserting that there is a system that is known to be ultimately more ethical than capitalism under current global conditions. (Social democracy may fit the bill, but I'm not prepared to argue that here.) That, however, doesn't mean that capitalism is ethical, or makes it easy to live an ethical life. The mechanics of capitalism are fundamentally exploitative -- again, even if they are less objectionable than many alternatives -- and participation in a capitalist economy makes you party to this. Nearly everything that I do is inflected with some sort of abuse: my laptop contains lithium ion batteries that use cobalt mined in insane conditions, my commute uses oil that, in turn, funds the malignant gangster-kings of Gulf states, my sweater was sewn in factory conditions that endanger the lives of people whose only mistake was being born in the wrong place at the wrong time. (And this is to say nothing of the tremendous misery that occurs /within the United States itself/.)

Again, I am not here proposing an alternative to capitalism. But -- even if it was the best system around -- its abuses are monstrous.

Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by tomcam on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @02:33PM (#12790361)
Who forced you to use the laptop, to wear that sweater, or to live more than a walk away from your commute? And can I have a citation on the "tremendous misery" in the United States?
Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by danprisk on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @04:46PM (#12791522)
Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by btym on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @04:29PM (#12791388)
Nobody was forced, it's just the most convenient (cheapest, readily available, whatever). Only using truly ethical products is not going to be as convenient. Hence "difficult", not "impossible".
Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by mhurron on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @02:53PM (#12790572)
Well keep in mind that RMS lives his ethics because his ethics are about closed source and only closed source along with some lip service to resenting his ID being checked (he's happy to ignore it to get to his paid talks, so really pretty fluid there). His ethics are simply not impacted anything you listed.

So it's amazingly easy to live RMS's ethics when you're given money to talk about living your ethics and those ethics are not impacted by most of the world around you.

Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by wildmusings on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @02:26PM (#12790291)
>The mechanics of capitalism are fundamentally exploitative

No it's not. The mechanics are capitalism are fundamentally about mutual benefit. I give you money because having your product is worth more to me than having the money. You give me the product because having the money is worth more to you than having the product. Mutually beneficial exchange is the cornerstone of capitalism. At the end of the transaction, we are both better off.

That's not to say that there's not problems around monopoly and violence, but the latter is the failure of the state, not of the market. And monopoly is not exclusive to capitalism. Under alternative systems, everything is controlled by a monopoly (the state).

Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by bbctol on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @02:32PM (#12790352)
Mutually beneficial exchanges can still be exploitative. You give me money, I don't shoot you, we're both better off. Whether or not capitalism is "fundamentally" exploitative depends a lot on definitions, but the issue of violence isn't limited to state actors, and the market can definitely coerce people.
Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by tpeo on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @04:44PM (#12791511)
That's a great example of a mutually beneficial but morally repugnant trade, but markets generally don't coerce people in this sense. Markets more often reach the fairest possible solution given an initially unfair situation (say, where one side has a gun and the other doesn't), and the fairness or unfairness of the whole thing depends on how property rights were initially allocated.
Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by jomamaxx on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @02:39PM (#12790429)
"You give me money, I don't shoot you"

That's not capitalism by any definition.

That's extortion and it was a well known practice thousands of years before we invented (or at least understood) capitalism.

I'd argue capitalism is not even an ideology, it's just a simple understanding of comparative value and how to go beyond zero-sum economics.

Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by bbctol on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @02:46PM (#12790499)
Oh, I know; my point was that the principle of mutually beneficial exchanges doesn't preclude an overall negative outcome. I don't know if capitalism is an ideology, but it certainly stems from a certain ideological framework (it's hard to have capitalism without belief in property.)
Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by x1798DE on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @04:34PM (#12791421)
I'm pretty sure that by definition it does prevent a negative outcome, since "mutually beneficial" generally means that each person is better off than before the trade, meaning there are positive payoffs on both sides - I'm not sure where exactly you get a negative from there.

In the example of "give me what I want or I'll shoot you", you could argue that "X prevents Y from being shot" and "Y gives X what he wants" is a benefit for both sides, but that ignores the first part, "X puts Y in a position where he is going to be shot" is not mutually beneficial, so the salient part of the example (the threat) is not actually an example of mutually beneficial exchange.

Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by bbctol on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @04:44PM (#12791510)
Again, my point was that even if every exchange, in and of itself, is mutually beneficial, the overall society can still be unpleasant. But it should also be noted that mutually beneficial exchanges do not prevent negative results even directly, but merely improve the outcomes for those who are agreeing to the transaction; two parties can agree to an exchange that leaves them both better off than they were before, but harms a third party. Which doesn't even bring up that these exchanges are based on perceived benefit...
Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by jackmott on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @03:25PM (#12790873)
No true scotsman fallacy, activate.
Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by bertiewhykovich on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @02:31PM (#12790341)
That's a lovely notion, but even the most cursory clear-eyed look around you should pretty conclusively demonstrate that it's not true.
Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by perakojotgenije on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @02:47PM (#12790509)
>I give you money because having your product is worth more to me than having the money. You give me the product because having the money is worth more to you than having the product

That is just trade, not capitalism. You are mixing them.

Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by sbov on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @02:32PM (#12790351)
I assume you disagree with the statements "it's just business" and "duty to maximize shareholder value" then.
Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by tomcam on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @02:38PM (#12790419)
It all depends on context. In some cases I do, and in some cases I don't. However, one of the reasons I run my own business is to avoid compromises like that when possible.
Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by Koshkin on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @04:17PM (#12791286)
> ...mutual benefit. I give you money...

Actually, it's like this: I give you money because I want to make a profit and become richer. You work in order to survive.

Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by bertiewhykovich on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @05:41PM (#12791910)
This is empirically correct.
Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by witty_username on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @02:56PM (#12790611)
Capitalism is far from exploitative. It is based on mutually beneficial trades by both party's choice.

Maybe those people are working because it offers better pay than other jobs, even if the conditions seem bad to you? (this may not be true in all situations)

Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by symlinkk on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @02:19PM (#12790229)
I'm not the guy you replied to but I would say living ethically is difficult under capitalism because capitalism is all about competition, which incentivizes certain unethical behaviors: keeping secrets (closed-source software), sabotaging others (patent trolls, lawsuits), and taking away freedom from your customers (vendor lock-in, not using open standards).
Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by tomcam on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @02:35PM (#12790375)
What system does not incentivize unethical behaviors? Any system can be subverted to one's own benefit. This does not necessarily reflect poorly on the system.
Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by wildmusings on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @02:24PM (#12790269)
As opposed to life under communism? I have family that grew up under communism and they told me that everything is about stealing in that system. You get a job not because it pays more, but because it lets you steal more. You horde things that you're not allowed to. You steal steal steal, because no one can live well on the ration books. Unless you're part of the nomenklatura, in which case your official job is stealing.
Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by bertiewhykovich on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @02:30PM (#12790325)
I'm not defending the Soviet Union. I'm not even defending communism, nor proposing a concrete alternative to capitalism. But the fact that other systems have led to worse abuses absolutely does not absolve capitalism of its crimes -- even the least-bad criminal is still a criminal.

(And it's not clear that capitalism is, in fact, the best of the bunch: it's bizarre that Silicon Valley, a culture that is so dedicated to pushing the boundaries of the possible that curing death is a completely pedestrian ambition, believes that /this/ economic system is the real global maximum.)

Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by tomcam on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @02:35PM (#12790385)
If I understand correctly, what you are saying is that to be a capitalist is to be a criminal?
Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by Jtsummers on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @03:04PM (#12790679)
There is, perhaps, some implementation of capitalism which is not exploitative of people. We haven't found it yet.
Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by untoreh on Wednesday October 26, 2016 @10:24AM (#12796635)
capitalism trades work for capital in an infinite loop, as long as it is free to bargain as little work for as much capital it is exploitative. The only non exploitative capitalism is a non-liberal capitalism which limits the bargaining, but since greed and corruption go in tandem, whatever tries to govern capitalism, eventually becomes just another bargaining iteration for capitalism itself. therefore the only implementation of non exploitative capitalism is capitalism ruled by an incorruptible system, which is utopia, or maybe AI overlords.
Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by nzp on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @02:55PM (#12790594)
> I have family that grew up under communism and they told me ...

I guess that settles it.

P.S. Your family did not grow up “under communism” unless they grew up in Ukrainian Free Territory[1] or Catalan and Aragon countryside during the Spanish Civil War[2], which are the two only socio-economic entities in modern history to reasonably approximate communism. What your family grew up in is state socialist Bolshevik dictatorship. If you're going to get all worked up about ideological wars, you should at least learn what these words mean, instead of blindly reproduce vulgar, politically illiterate Cold War obfuscations.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_Territory

[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anarchist_Aragon

Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by wildmusings on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @02:59PM (#12790638)
Spare me the No True Scotsman fallacies. In the Communist Manifesto, Marx lays out the agenda:

1. Abolition of property in land and application of all rents of land to public purposes.

2. A heavy progressive or graduated income tax.

3. Abolition of all rights of inheritance.

4. Confiscation of the property of all emigrants and rebels.

5. Centralisation of credit in the hands of the state, by means of a national bank with State capital and an exclusive monopoly.

6. Centralisation of the means of communication and transport in the hands of the State.

7. Extension of factories and instruments of production owned by the State; the bringing into cultivation of waste-lands, and the improvement of the soil generally in accordance with a common plan.

8. Equal liability of all to work. Establishment of industrial armies, especially for agriculture.

9. Combination of agriculture with manufacturing industries; gradual abolition of all the distinction between town and country by a more equable distribution of the populace over the country.

10. Free education for all children in public schools. Abolition of children’s factory labour in its present form. Combination of education with industrial production...

Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by nzp on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @03:24PM (#12790865)
That you think this is a no true Scotsman fallacy just shows you have no idea what you're talking about and are just blindly ideologically raging. It's not a NTS fallacy, it's a words-have-non-arbitrary-meaning non-fallacy. The agenda you quote is about “Socialism“, or even more precisely “dictatorship of the proletariat”, the transitional period Marxists envision to precede communism. I'm not going to argue about that, I think history has shown how horrible of an idea it is. Communism is by definition a stateless (do notice how many times the state is mentioned in that agenda), classless society of free associations of producers and consumers with distribution and consumption based on “from each according to their ability, to each according to their need“ principle. Further reading: http://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/petr-kropotkin-the-wa...
Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by adrusi on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @02:26PM (#12790293)
It's probably easier to live ethically in a horticultural band that is relatively isolated from rival human groups. The noble savage myth can be a reality given an optimal environment.
Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015) by jomamaxx on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @02:37PM (#12790401)
I don't believe that his commitment to his supposed ideals is in any way 'moral'. I'd refer to his position that 'only free software is ethical' as simply wrong - and arrogant.

Yes - we can admire his tenacity, and some of the great things he's contributed.

Paradoxically, his 'ideals' have probably contributed to his personal ability to make these things, at the same time, his ideology is I think more than naive, it's just plain wrong.

I like Stallman, but I take him with a huge dose of salt.