Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015)
by bbctol on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @02:32PM
(#12790352)
Mutually beneficial exchanges can still be exploitative. You give me money, I don't shoot you, we're both better off. Whether or not capitalism is "fundamentally" exploitative depends a lot on definitions, but the issue of violence isn't limited to state actors, and the market can definitely coerce people.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015)
by tpeo on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @04:44PM
(#12791511)
That's a great example of a mutually beneficial but morally repugnant trade, but markets generally don't coerce people in this sense. Markets more often reach the fairest possible solution given an initially unfair situation (say, where one side has a gun and the other doesn't), and the fairness or unfairness of the whole thing depends on how property rights were initially allocated.
Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015)
by jomamaxx on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @02:39PM
(#12790429)
"You give me money, I don't shoot you"
That's not capitalism by any definition.
That's extortion and it was a well known practice thousands of years before we invented (or at least understood) capitalism.
I'd argue capitalism is not even an ideology, it's just a simple understanding of comparative value and how to go beyond zero-sum economics.
Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015)
by bbctol on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @02:46PM
(#12790499)
Oh, I know; my point was that the principle of mutually beneficial exchanges doesn't preclude an overall negative outcome. I don't know if capitalism is an ideology, but it certainly stems from a certain ideological framework (it's hard to have capitalism without belief in property.)
Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015)
by x1798DE on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @04:34PM
(#12791421)
I'm pretty sure that by definition it does prevent a negative outcome, since "mutually beneficial" generally means that each person is better off than before the trade, meaning there are positive payoffs on both sides - I'm not sure where exactly you get a negative from there.
In the example of "give me what I want or I'll shoot you", you could argue that "X prevents Y from being shot" and "Y gives X what he wants" is a benefit for both sides, but that ignores the first part, "X puts Y in a position where he is going to be shot" is not mutually beneficial, so the salient part of the example (the threat) is not actually an example of mutually beneficial exchange.
Re:Richard Stallman: How I do my computing (2015)
by bbctol on Tuesday October 25, 2016 @04:44PM
(#12791510)
Again, my point was that even if every exchange, in and of itself, is mutually beneficial, the overall society can still be unpleasant. But it should also be noted that mutually beneficial exchanges do not prevent negative results even directly, but merely improve the outcomes for those who are agreeing to the transaction; two parties can agree to an exchange that leaves them both better off than they were before, but harms a third party. Which doesn't even bring up that these exchanges are based on perceived benefit...