News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The 2016 Election by lhnz on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:19PM (#12728387)

  > We should all feel a duty to try to understand the roughly
  > half of the country that thinks we are severely misguided.
  > I don’t understand how 43% of the country supports Trump.
  > But I’d like to find out, because we have to include 
  > everyone in our path forward.  If our best ideas are to
  > stop talking to or fire anyone who disagrees with us,
  > we’ll be facing this whole situation again in 2020.
  > 
  > That kind of diversity is painful and unpopular, but
  > it is critical to health of a democratic and pluralistic 
  > society.  We shouldn’t start purging people for
  > supporting the wrong political candidate. 
  > That's not how things are done in this country.
This impresses me. That is exactly what I was trying to explain to somebody else in the other thread, and I was starting to feel like it was a position that nobody else held.
Re:The 2016 Election by gkoberger on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:22PM (#12728438)
Sam tweeted that this was his favorite article about the election: http://www.cracked.com/blog/6-reasons-trumps-rise-that-no-on...

It really does a great job of helping explain Trump supporters.

Re:The 2016 Election by sigil on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:27PM (#12728538)
If you found the Cracked article insightful, an even deeper discussion of this "dark matter" phenomenon ("I don't know anyone who supports candidate X, but I can measure their gravity, so they must be out there somewhere") is in this essay from Slate Star Codex.

"I Can Tolerate Anything Except the Outgroup" http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/09/30/i-can-tolerate-anything...

Re:The 2016 Election by michaelbuckbee on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:39PM (#12728759)
The article (and phrase) I found really helpful in understanding the split in support is:

"The press takes him (Trump)literally, but not seriously; his supporters take him seriously, but not literally."

http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2016/09/trump-ma...

Re:The 2016 Election by monk_e_boy on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:19PM (#12729282)
I'm not from the US, so take this as an outsiders view.

Clinton says different things in public than she does to her friends. She also flip flops. This is not trustworthy.

Trump is unpleasant, but at least he talks straight.

I think this could be the last election of its kind in the USA, a two party system that works to produce these two candidates? Someone (Facebook, google, twitter) will come up with a better way of informing the public how unfair the system is.

How is electoral reform view in the US? In the UK it is very popular and there is often talk of STV or something similar.

[edit] I am losing valuable imaginary internet points! Oh no! Here, this makes my point better than I can:

Only 9% of America Chose Trump and Clinton as the Nominees

http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/08/01/us/elections/n...

Re:The 2016 Election by k3n on Monday October 17, 2016 @07:52PM (#12730900)
> Clinton says different things in public than she does to her friends. She also flip flops. This is not trustworthy.

> Trump is unpleasant, but at least he talks straight.

You seem to imply that since Trump "talks straight", he doesn't flip-flop?

If that's what you're implying, it couldn't be more inaccurate; he has sharply contradicted himself countless times, straight-up denying things he's documented as saying (on TV, Twitter, etc.)

Re:The 2016 Election by Aloha on Monday October 17, 2016 @06:06PM (#12730228)
Clinton talks like a professional politician, Trump says whatever comes to mind at the time. I'm not sure I like how professional politicians talk, but I'm a little nervous that "comes to mind at the time" might lead us into a very bad place.
Re:The 2016 Election by chirau on Monday October 17, 2016 @08:58PM (#12731186)
Re:The 2016 Election by Aloha on Monday October 17, 2016 @10:46PM (#12731627)
Yeah - I do. Look at any politician with more than one term of anything under their belt and you're going to find similar problems. I'm voting for Gary Johnson anyhow.. not because I expect him to be more consistent, but because I very much want a viable third party.
Re:The 2016 Election by int_19h on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:53PM (#12729632)
Electoral reform is a hot topic, but what people usually mean by it is not a change in how the votes are counted. The most popular issue is campaign financing (with the current arrangement being that there's no practical limit a private party can pour into the elections, so long as they do the Super-PAC dance). Another big issue of concern is gerrymandering. For Democrats, the way their primaries function (superdelegates etc) has been in the spotlight.

As far as voting system itself is concerned, electoral college is the most common issue that is raised, and switching to national popular vote counting is the most common proposal to fix it. There's an ongoing attempt to do this from bottom up, by signing up enough states that they can basically impose this without changing the Constitution: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Popular_Vote_Intersta...

Things like STV for presidential elections, or MMP for parliamentary, are mostly under the radar - there are certainly people who are aware of them and push for them, but they're a very small minority, and the public is largely unaware.

Just to give you some sense of how these stack up, the only electoral issue that has been discussed at length in this political campaign by any of the major candidates (including primaries) is campaign finance reform. I haven't heard a peep about electoral college or proportional representation.

Re:The 2016 Election by monk_e_boy on Monday October 17, 2016 @07:12PM (#12730683)
Interesting. I work in education in the UK and the way we assess pupils is a relatively complex calculation based on a number of factors.

So schools, teachers, pupils and parents are all aware that attainment is a complex beast and requires an open, yet complex calculation.

Which leads me onto STV and other ways of counting votes, none of these are as simple as first past the post, but these are all far simpler than what we do in our schooling calculation. So I think people are ready to make voting a little more complex and a lot fairer. If we educate them and give them a chance.

Re:The 2016 Election by int_19h on Monday October 17, 2016 @11:21PM (#12731781)
I think it's mainly that there are other, more obvious problems to tackle before getting to STV etc. One thing at a time and all that.

Even those things are immensely complicated politically, because they would upset the existing balance between the parties, and in the current climate of extreme partisanship, whichever party is affected is going to pretty much automatically be against it. For example, if we switch from electoral college to national popular vote, it's pretty much guaranteed to give all future presidential elections to the Democrats, at least until GOP has a massive reform. Obviously, they're going to be against it. Similar issues arise with gerrymandering, and even such normally non-controversial issues as making voting easier (increasing registration periods and making the process easier, increasing advanced voting period, mail-in voting etc).

So I wouldn't expect any progress on that front until the present deadlock is broken. On the other hand, whatever new party will arise on the right from the ashes of GOP (or existing third party take over the spot), is likely to be in the minority for a while - and hopefully, that would motivate them to make electoral reform for a more proportional representation a prominent part of their platform. On the other hand, Democrats are likely to get more complacent and corrupt from a long uninterrupted stretch in power, and a few particularly nasty public scandals could be used to prime the voters for an upset election. So we'll get there; it'll just take time.

Re:The 2016 Election by tankenmate on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @12:08PM (#12735831)
I think in an era of the populace vehemently hating at least one politician that is running for office (whatever that office may be), and sometimes hating all the candidates a voting system that actively targets least regret should be used; such as condorcet voting, or full preference method.
Re:The 2016 Election by sanjeetsuhag on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:47PM (#12728878)
Re:The 2016 Election by Bartweiss on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:03PM (#12729093)
I feel like this deserves a link to the rebuttal. I'm not embracing it (or Jacobin), but it's a plausible indictment of Elegy. On a related note, it should be noted that the average Trump supporter earns more than the average white American. There's a more subtle grouping here than "rural poor".

[1] https://www.jacobinmag.com/2016/10/hillbilly-elegy-review-jd...

Re:The 2016 Election by Alex3917 on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:27PM (#12728534)
> It really does a great job of helping explain Trump supporters.

I think what we're seeing are the results of taking 6 trillion dollars that should have been spent building infrastructure for working class Americans and instead wasting it in Iraq.

Re:The 2016 Election by hacker42 on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:06PM (#12729123)
I think this is basically the major and effective meme/emotion that Trump plays into: Nostalgia. Thiel also voiced concerns about the state of the infrastructure at a GOP Convention. Nostalgia is a strong emotion and it is often based on false memories or weak comparisons. Sure, large parts of our infrastructure are worse than they were 50 years ago, but on the other hand we had very different problems back then. We used to consume goods that turned out to be toxic. Today almost everyone has access to extremely fast transportation via air travel. Almost everyone has access to the world's knowledge at any time. Medicine has improved a lot. "Make it great again" is the central lie and people are dumb enough not to question it and to believe his financial independence would make him a superior leader, when in fact he only displays characteristics that are opposed to the ones we should expect from a good leader, for example decency and intelligence.
Re:The 2016 Election by twoodfin on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:55PM (#12728985)
Holy moly that number keeps getting bigger.

The budgetary cost of the Iraq war was, according to the Congressional Research Service, $815 billion[1]. Even if you would rather model long-term or indirect costs, there was never, ever $6 trillion in the Federal budget over the corresponding period that could have been redirected to "infrastructure for working class Americans".

[1] https://fas.org/sgp/crs/natsec/RL33110.pdf

Re:The 2016 Election by ones_and_zeros on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:42PM (#12728798)
Without the war there would not have been 6 trillion dollars to spend...

I think Trump supporters are regular simple Americans who are looking around and seeing they haven't benefited from the economic prosperity at a rate equivalent to their output and are facing an all out assault on their labor via neo-liberal policies adopted by both major parties. Neither party is going to point back at themselves and Trump has seized their support by blaming common scapegoats and tapping in to populist racial, gender and religious discrimination. Democrats have and do do this too, ie "super predators", etc.

Re:The 2016 Election by bryanlarsen on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:13PM (#12729220)
It's a great article, but only describes a very small minority of Trump supporters. The median household income of a Trump supporter is $72,000, well above that of the median voter, or the median Clinton supporter.

http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/the-mythology-of-trumps-...

Re:The 2016 Election by noobermin on Monday October 17, 2016 @10:08PM (#12731495)
That surprises me greatly. I'm assuming that the fact that the poor themselves don't vote anyway skews the medians of voters up anyway, as they hint at in that article. What a way to dash "established facts."
Re:The 2016 Election by pnathan on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:38PM (#12728735)
For a more formal look at this, I'd suggest looking at Sarah Kenzidor's work over the past year. She's a journalist in St. Louis with a PhD in... sociology? (I think?), specializing in the Uzbekistan country & regime. She's brought that knowledge to bear on the Trump campaign and has spent a lot of time trying to explain to the 'coasts' Why Trump. Her book on this is called the "View from Flyover Country". I haven't read the book, specifically, but I've read most of her articles on the matter since the spring.
Re:The 2016 Election by Yhippa on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:55PM (#12728988)
That article is rough around the edges but very insightful. I keep this in mind a lot. I think to just go ahead and label all Trump supporters as idiots or degenerates is very unproductive. There is some message that speaks to the people left behind that maybe the Democrats are ignoring.
Re:The 2016 Election by whybroke on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:13PM (#12729214)
>The vast majority of possible careers involve moving to the city, and around every city is now a hundred-foot wall called "Cost of Living."

It's impossible to over emphasize how core to the problem this is. From social mobility to resentment of the "elites" and a dozen others.

Re:The 2016 Election by enjo on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:36PM (#12728699)
I spent my high school years in rural Arkansas (after living a more urban existence for most of my life). This article does a fantastic job of articulating exactly what I've observed.
Re:The 2016 Election by findjashua on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:10PM (#12729178)
The Guardian also published a really good article explaining how blue-collar workers are hurting because of their jobs being off-shored, and how Trump's promise to end free-trade agreements and bring those jobs back to the US is the biggest reason behind his appeal:

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/mar/07/donald...

Re:The 2016 Election by morgante on Monday October 17, 2016 @10:12PM (#12731515)
It doesn't do a good job of explaining why someone like Thiel (or my well-off friends) support Trump. They're city people with lots to lose.
Re:The 2016 Election by SonicSoul on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:49PM (#12728906)
i found this article enlightening as well:

http://www.stirjournal.com/2016/04/01/i-know-why-poor-whites...

Re:The 2016 Election by Aloha on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:35PM (#12728675)
You made the comment I was going to make. Though I would have included the following too:

> The way we got into a situation with Trump as a major party nominee in the first place was by not talking to people who are very different than we are. The polarization of the country into two parallel political realities is not good for any of us. We should talk to each other more, not less.

When it comes down to it.. its become clear to me at least that a large percentage of the country simply put, is not 'getting ahead' - the anger that drove the Trump and Sanders campaigns is very real and must be solved if we are to prosper.

Re:The 2016 Election by int_19h on Monday October 17, 2016 @05:04PM (#12729747)
> We should talk to each other more, not less.

It's a nice sentiment, but it implies that both sides have walked away from the middle more or less equidistantly, and the way to fix it is to walk back. The reality is that American left is still mostly center-left, while the American right has been steadily radicalizing over the past two decades.

Study after study shows the same thing: the average right wing voter today is more prone to groupthink (i.e. believing in party orthodoxy of the day), more likely to select news & information sources pandering to his agenda regardless of their adherence to truth, and views political opponents more negatively.

(This isn't to say that any of these behaviors are exclusive to the right - of course not, and the existence of HuffPo etc is the evidence to that. What's different is how strong and widespread it is.)

So for the left, walking back to the middle is not going to solve this, since the other guy walked much further away. To "meet them in the middle", you'd need to cross over to the right, to the point of abandoning the core platform values that have been there for a very long time. That's not going to happen.

This is a self-correcting problem, though. The side that goes on a quest for ideological purity at the expense of practicality, inevitably diminishes its own ranks by repeatedly purging those deemed as not pure enough (and on every iteration, the criteria become tighter and tighter). You can see this in practice - if you ask some Republican voters, more than half of their own party are "RINOs". And there's a positive feedback loop here - the smaller the party gets, the harder it is for it to hold onto political power, and the less incentive for someone who wants to actually do something (which requires power) to join or stay.

So that bubble is well on its way to bursting, and the best way to resolve matters is to help it along the way. Once it bursts and the right deals with the fallout, then we can talk about meeting in the middle etc.

Re:The 2016 Election by noobermin on Monday October 17, 2016 @10:20PM (#12731538)
>middle more or less equidistantly, and the way to fix it is to walk back. That supposes that there really is only one degree of freedom. For example, both Trump and Sanders were for protectionism.

EDIT: added quote to clarify what I'm saying. My point is the model isn't quite right, a better way to explain it is rather than points on a spectrum, there are policies that we might place on a spectrum but that different movements have no problem adopting. Both the Sanders and Trump campaigns are for protectionism and anti-globalism. Trump in my opinion pretends to also be anti-elitist while Bernie is somewhat close to that too. These groups don't really care about where on the spectrum we end up, it's mostly that we have policies that they think will help them eventually.

Re:The 2016 Election by int_19h on Monday October 17, 2016 @11:06PM (#12731715)
The unfortunate reality of the present US political system is that in inter-party politics, there's only one degree of freedom. Other fights have to be fought on the inside to get anywhere, in the primaries etc. And if your side wins, then you take the entire party for the ride along with yourself in national politics.
Re:The 2016 Election by Aloha on Monday October 17, 2016 @08:14PM (#12731001)
The right is further along in their process than the left is. But it is starting on the left.
Re:The 2016 Election by int_19h on Monday October 17, 2016 @11:04PM (#12731710)
Yes. On the left, though, it's not an irreversible process yet. It can still be contained.

On the right, it ran away a long time ago.

Re:The 2016 Election by soccerdave on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:50PM (#12728932)
There is most likely a large portion of voters that are also voting 'against' Hillary. The only realistic vote against Hillary is unfortunately a vote for Trump.
Re:The 2016 Election by noobermin on Monday October 17, 2016 @10:21PM (#12731542)
There are two other candidates who have a +1% popularity.
Re:The 2016 Election by mashmac2 on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:38PM (#12728740)
>its become clear to me at least that a large percentage of the country simply put, is not 'getting ahead' - the anger that drove the Trump and Sanders campaigns is very real and must be solved if we are to prosper.

The key there is that they _feel_ like they're not getting ahead - a very different thing than not actually getting ahead, and much more dangerous.

Re:The 2016 Election by Bartweiss on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:09PM (#12729174)
A lot of them actually aren't, though, by any reasonable metric.

Health? Number of close friends? Lifespan? Addiction rate? Income? Unemployment rate? Labor participation rate?

By any of those metrics, life in a lot of rural-red communities is getting worse, and has been for years. I'm aware of the "better but it feels worse" pattern - crime rates are the prime example - but it's far too glib to say that covers everything. Inconvenient as it is, sometimes you have to actually improve things to make people feel better.

I suspect that most people will not accept any definition of 'ahead' which leaves them sicker, poorer, lonelier, and dying younger. And I don't think there's any reason that they should accept it.

Re:The 2016 Election by Aloha on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:38PM (#12729510)
On some level I feel like my country is unwinding, like somehow over time we have developed these parallel economies and social institutions, and now we don't know how to talk to ourselves anyhow.. and it scares me. The fact that one side can't see the other is struggling is an example of this.

There is another observation I have too - and some point everyone became offended at everyone - when I was younger, merely having a different opinion was never offensive, now in certain circles, it sure appears to be. (HN may be one of those circles)

In the end.. we need to remember time doesnt stop when this election is over - the morning after we're all still gonna wake up and get on with business - I fear the level of vitriol may be damaging the fabric of my country.. and that makes me nervous.

Re:The 2016 Election by maxsilver on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:47PM (#12728883)
Don't just assume they only feel like they're not getting ahead.

A large majority of these folks are in actual fact falling far behind, and that fact is not easily observed in many of the metrics people often use for measurements (like 'household income', and 'unemployment')

Re:The 2016 Election by Tactic on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:44PM (#12728826)
This sounds like the type of thing that is being advocated against. Telling a large section of the country that what they feel is not true. I'm not certain from what vantage that statement could ever accurately be made.

I certainly wouldn't try this tact with your significant other.

Re:The 2016 Election by ryanSrich on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:24PM (#12728471)
It's definitely not a popular position. Just take a look at Twitter and you'll see people from both sides nearly calling for the death of the other. While not super surprising I've seen little discussion around the fact that your chances of being fired for supporting one of the candidates (you can guess who) publicly are pretty good. Especially when you work in the tech field.

Which to me is really interesting because it shows a side of politics that I've personally not seen before. This election has permeated all institutions and if you're not on the right side you're going to have a bad time.

Re:The 2016 Election by ebilgenius on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:32PM (#12728616)
It's hard to have moderate, rational discussions in 255 characters
Re:The 2016 Election by mikeevans on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:47PM (#12728882)
Even harder in 140.
Re:The 2016 Election by douche on Monday October 17, 2016 @05:33PM (#12729982)
People are starting to throw firebombs at each other. It's only been one incident so far (that I'm aware of), but it's not a good trajectory.
Re:The 2016 Election by GlennS on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:41PM (#12728778)
Perhaps its a popular position with quiet adherents? "The level-headed majority."
Re:The 2016 Election by Swizec on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:27PM (#12728536)
> you'll see people from both sides nearly calling for the death of the other

Not to sound too tinfoilhatter, but this is exactly what you would want the masses to behave like as a politician. Neither candidate gives two shits about you me or anyone who isn't part of the ruling elite, they're just in it for the power.

Re:The 2016 Election by the_duke on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:34PM (#12728655)
It's exactly how populists want the voters to think and behave.

They nurture and encourage distrust, anger, aggression. And use it to fuel enthusiasm and support for themselves.

You see this pattern often in history.

When holding an elected office, this kind of separation is a big problem, because it necessarily seeps into political entities (parlaments, senates, congress) and makes collaboration hard.

Re:The 2016 Election by postcarnival on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:51PM (#12728938)
when you find out that the your own party has lied to you... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5IuJGHuIkzY
Re:The 2016 Election by Swizec on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:36PM (#12728692)
Isn't it curious how this sort of deep strife only flares up during elections?
Re:The 2016 Election by spdustin on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:57PM (#12729012)
I don't believe that the occurrence of an election is itself causation at work.

The reason it seems that way, to me, is the same reason that abused women tend to step out of their shame when they see other women doing it, or when their anger is kindled into a flame that exceeds their fear. People feel empowered when they realize they're not alone (edit: and someone they identify as a peer has given a voice to their own beliefs, experiences or feelings)

Sometimes, that feeling of empowerment makes them speak up. Sometimes it makes them lash out. It's an unfortunate coincidence that a presidential candidate is directly responsible for catalyzing both groups of people into responding so passionately today.

Realistically, I believe that the electorate has felt disenfranchised (using the more general "deprived of a voice" definition) for many years now, and for various reasons. A republic such as ours can never have an electorate that, in its entirety, feels like their voices are heard. I don't know how to help that; I don't think anyone does.

Dividing the electorate further isn't the solution for any leader. Inciting them to illegal or violent behavior isn't the solution either, unless you aim to dismantle a democratic republic.

I've always felt "us-vs-them", and I believe everyone has, because my peer group has ideals different from others. So we find other groups that share them, and we try harder to be heard, or to exert the influence that the framework of our republic grants to us (i.e. voting) or that society grants to us (i.e. boycotting).

But I do not believe the election itself has caused a divide, it's the candidates (yes, one more than any other, but all have contributed) whose rhetoric has amplified a divide that was there all along.

Re:The 2016 Election by Swizec on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:23PM (#12729337)
Thank you for putting it into more and clearer words than I did.

You're right, the divide has always been there. That's why it always flares up during elections - it's only during elections that the divide is useful to the people who stoke it. Candidates benefit from their electorate being loud and vocal and at arms with the other electorate. It drives press, it drives news, it brings people out to vote. All things correlated with winning an election.

Once an election is won, the game changes. Then it's all about unity and compromise and understanding one another. Because that's what those in power need to stay in power.

Unless of course somebody wants to force an early election or worse. Then all bets are off.

Now, I can't say for a fact that this is how the cycle works in the US. But I've seen it play out numerous times in my home country (Slovenia) where for a period of more than a decade since I started observing, I don't think we had a single government last the entire 4 years. It's a big part of the reason why I left and came to the States.

And I find myself once more in the midst of elections driven primarily by shit up stirring. Perfect.

Re:The 2016 Election by spdustin on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:36PM (#12729477)
> And I find myself once more in the midst of elections driven primarily by shit up stirring. Perfect.

All I can say is this: you're not wrong that the media coverage of our candidates amplify their voices, which empowers their supporters to amplify theirs as well. And you're not wrong that this election cycle has more shit-slinging than any other in my memory. It's thus made me more than a little uncomfortable, as an American, to ponder what others think of our society. It's embarrassing to me, it truly is.

But here is hope, and even thought you've arrived just in time for this circus of an election, I hope you can find the will to believe that the future is not doomed. Not because the leadership requires unity and compromise, but because once the spotlights shining their attention-focusing beams are turned off, there won't be such a contrast with the more rational among us. I believe many people will have learned that the isolation between ideological extremes doesn't help to move us forward as a society. And many will try, in their own quiet and subtle ways, to effect a positive change.

I'll be honest though: I believe these things not because there is a preponderance of evidence to support them (there's some, but this election cycle is unprecedented) but because I have to believe it to have the energy to try and effect that positive change.

Re:The 2016 Election by 551199 on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:36PM (#12728691)
SNL writer Chris Kelly 'How bout instead of an “I Voted” sticker, everyone who votes Trump gets to wear a scarlet T for the rest of their lives?'[0]

Person thinks 40% of people are crazy, racist, hates women etc. Maybe the person who thinks that is the one not understanding the situation.

Clinton: Read Wikileaks, study Clinton Foundation (Haiti) Trump: Read news from both sides msm and Breitbart & similar. Scott Adams blog gives you some sense what is going on.[1]

[0]http://archive.is/NiRJ4 [1]http://blog.dilbert.com

Re:The 2016 Election by SonicSoul on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:05PM (#12729114)
Scott Adams blog has turned into sensless propaganda.

From what I can gather by reading below[0] he does not like Clinton raising taxes. The rest of his points are such insightful gems as:

"I don't know the best way to default ISIS .. negotiate trade policies .. neither do you but you probably think you do... Given the uncertainty about each candidate – at least in my own mind – I have been saying I am not smart enough to know who would be the best president. That neutrality changed when Clinton proposed raising estate taxes"

what kind of convoluted logic is this? since we as voters are not sure how to fix all these problems that somehow makes these candidates equal? and tax policy breaks the tie?!

Then he regurgitates the usual Trump arguments about Clintons health. And then cites Trumps superior persuasion skills. His comments have been "temporarily disabled" so no way to respond to this nonsense. I've lost all respect for this guy

[0] http://blog.dilbert.com/post/150919416661/why-i-switched-my-...

Re:The 2016 Election by cookiecaper on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @09:33PM (#12740274)
Adams is very responsive on Twitter and he hosts daily Periscope streams where he takes questions. He disabled the comments on his blog because they were being swarmed with racism and spam. I'm sure if you write a counterpoint and tweet it at him, he'll at least see it.
Re:The 2016 Election by flukus on Monday October 17, 2016 @11:47PM (#12731899)
Scott Adams is a contrarian first and foremost.
Re:The 2016 Election by chris11 on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:47PM (#12728877)
Thinking there is a possibility someone is crazy, racist, or sexist is definitely reasonable if that person is stating they agree with a crazy, racist, sexist. I'd wonder if someone was racist if they supported David Duke.
Re:The 2016 Election by 551199 on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:31PM (#12729412)
Hillary Clinton's 'friend and mentor' was KKK member Robert Byrd.[0]

Using the same logic all democrats are now x.

[0]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p4wo9nqWrwE

Re:The 2016 Election by chris11 on Monday October 17, 2016 @05:07PM (#12729777)
Right, and if we were talking about people with Hillary's or Robert Byrd's record then I would decide that they weren't racist.

Hillary's record has shown a strong commitment to civil rights activism. Robert Byrd did do some horrible things, but he changed and apologized. The NAACP actually honored him after his death. Supporting the the KKK would prevent me from voting for any politician. But Robert Byrd actually changed. https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/post-partisan/wp/2016/0... http://thegrio.com/2010/06/28/the-evolution-of-robert-byrds-...

Whereas Trump has a history of racism. There have been accusations going back years, and his public statements support those accusations. He accused a federal judge of not being able to be impartial because the judge was Mexican. And David Duke is still a leading white nationalist, and said that voting against Trump is treason to your heritage.

People can change, but you can't claim they have changed if they've ignored what they did in the past and have not done anything different.

Do you think that Hillary is just as racist as Trump? And are you voting for Trump because you actually want him as president, or because you think Hillary's worse?

Re:The 2016 Election by Torgo on Monday October 17, 2016 @07:06PM (#12730649)
The judge was a member of a group affiliated with La Raza, it was not because he "was Mexican."
Re:The 2016 Election by dragonwriter on Monday October 17, 2016 @07:17PM (#12730702)
Trump specifically attributed it to Curie's "Mexican heritage" when he made the comment. The organizational link is an after-the-fact rationalization. (And, also, mostly false; that is, he's a member of a lawyers group with "La Raza" in the name, but that group isn't connected at all with the advocacy group -- the National Council of La Raza -- that right-wingers who don't recognize that "La Raza" as a name element is about as distinctive and unique as "People's" think of us the organization called "La Raza".)
Re:The 2016 Election by 551199 on Monday October 17, 2016 @05:23PM (#12729911)
> chris11 Whereas Trump has a history of racism.

"Last December, after the council refused to lift the restrictions, Mr. Trump filed a lawsuit in U.S. District Court in Palm Beach, alleging that the town was discriminating against Mar-a-Lago, in part because it is open to Jews and African-Americans. The suit seeks $100 million in damages."[0]

Like back in 80's when Trump was fighting for blacks and jews. Read the wikileaks. Clinton campaign's gameplay memo is to create Trump is 'crazy racist' narrative through media.

[0] http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB862335923489989500

Re:The 2016 Election by rayiner on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:05PM (#12729113)
Counterpoint: many of the founding fathers were crazy sexist racists, yet we still hold their other opinions in quite high regard.
Re:The 2016 Election by hiddencost on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:25PM (#12729356)
That was 240 years ago. We recognize the value they added and understand them in their historical context.
Re:The 2016 Election by rayiner on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @12:42AM (#12732156)
That's a popular misconception, like "everyone thought the world was flat before Columbus reached America."

The immorality of slavery was recognized hundreds of years before the founding of the US. It was abolished in France in the 1300s, in Sweden in 1335, etc. It was never really legal in England and that fact was recognized in 1706, about 40 years before Thomas Jefferson was born. The founders' condoning slavery was a deeply immoral political expedient that was recognized by many as immoral even contemporaneously.

But that's besides the point. The fact that the founders were individually contemptible people doesn't mean their ideas were wrong. You can agree with many of the things Thomas Jefferson said without personally condoning slavery and rape.

Re:The 2016 Election by cookiecaper on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @09:39PM (#12740310)
The founders were not "individually contemptible" because they couldn't destroy the institution of slavery at the same time they created an independent American nation. In fact, everyday slaveholders were not automatically "individually contemptible". Involvement in widespread cultural norms like slavery should not, in itself, be seen as a personal character indictment.
Re:The 2016 Election by susan_hall on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:14PM (#12729224)
No "we" don't. Not all of us. Many of us hold the Founding Fathers in deep contempt. There is now DNA evidence showing that Thomas Jefferson raped Sally Hemings. That means that all of Thomas Jefferson's writings, including the Declaration Of Independence, needs to be re-evaluated and perhaps put aside.
Re:The 2016 Election by douche on Monday October 17, 2016 @07:12PM (#12730682)
If we're going to look at historical figures through modern lenses and discredit their works if we find they don't measure up to our modern morality, we're not going to have much left. It's more than likely that Socrates, Plato, or Aristotle engaged in sexual acts with young boys, for instance - in our world, these philosophers would be on a list and couldn't live within 500 yards of a school, let alone found one, but in theirs, pederasty was common, accepted, and even lauded.
Re:The 2016 Election by r_smart on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:22PM (#12729322)
I'm intrigued. How could DNA provide evidence of rape?
Re:The 2016 Election by xhedley on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:56PM (#12729664)
DNA provides evidence of paternity of Sally Heming's children. Which appears to be that the father was Sally Heming's owner Thomas Jefferson. Sally Heming may have been head over heels in love with Thomas Jefferson. But on the balance of probability I would guess there might have been coercion (hence rape) from a slave owner to a slave. Evidence, not proof.
Re:The 2016 Election by int_19h on Monday October 17, 2016 @05:10PM (#12729807)
Hypocrisy of Jefferson's personal conduct doesn't change the validity (or lack thereof) of the logical arguments he made in his writings. If they held to rational scrutiny before, they still do after.
Re:The 2016 Election by gspetr on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @05:30PM (#12738913)
You've presented us with a logical fallacy:

http://allthetropes.wikia.com/wiki/Hitler_Ate_Sugar

Re:The 2016 Election by r_smart on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:21PM (#12729301)
It would depend on which position of Duke's they were talking about. If they say they agree with his stance on race, then yes, they're a racist. If they agree with his stance on tax policy (I assume he has one), then no, there's no evidence that person is a racist. EZ-PZ.
Re:The 2016 Election by evo_9 on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:16PM (#12729243)
I agree it's an impressive summary for sure.

However, how does one bring forward the 43% that appears to agree so strongly with Trump there isn't really any common ground to have a reasonable discussion around? How do you go about working with someone that is uneducated, and often proud of this fact, raised to believe all other races are a blight against life as they know it, and often are proud of this, truly believe global warming/climate change is a hoax? Etc etc.

I'm not trying to be coy, I just think that fundamentally those that support Trump are different. My father is a huge fox news watching old-school Italian. He is a die-hard Trump supporter. He isn't educated, he isn't interested in learning why Trump is wrong. He isn't ever going to change his mind and when (hopefully) Trump loses, will be part of the 43% calling the election 'stolen'.

I love the man, he is my father after-all, but I have noticed that he (a life-long Republican) simply doesn't have empathy for others the way I do. When I ask him would he rather have more homeless or no homeless, his first reply back was 'well how much is it going to cost?'. And this is how 'they' think, there is a distinct difference in how he, and i suspect most 'hardcore conservatives' view human life (unless of course it fits their pro-life agenda, then of course they are suddenly lovers of 'life' above all else). Money is more important to them, it always will be, and the idea of helping others is never going to be acceptable (unless, maybe they find themselves in a situation where they need help).

I'm sorry to be so negative about this but I'm quite a bit older than most around here and in my experience it's a losing battle to try to convert anyone to a more reasonable position. The only thing that seems to help is more eduction, more exposure to diverse cultures, and generally not focusing only on one self above all else. But then look at Thiel, and then you have to wonder if it's something more.

Empathy and Personality Disorders: http://www.healthyplace.com/personality-disorders/malignant-...

Re:The 2016 Election by 551199 on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:44PM (#12729541)
> However, how does one bring forward the 43% that appears to agree so strongly with Trump there isn't really any common ground to have a reasonable discussion around? How do you go about working with someone that is uneducated.

That someone isn't uneducated just because she/he doesn't align with one's thinking.

The Economist: Where Donald Trump’s support really comes from:

'However, averaging out his support in all state primaries (where exit polling is available) shows that richer and better educated voters form as big a part of Mr Trump’s support base as those at the lower end of the income and education scales.'[0]

[0]http://www.economist.com/blogs/graphicdetail/2016/04/daily-c...

Re:The 2016 Election by Locke1689 on Monday October 17, 2016 @06:33PM (#12730424)
That article is from the April primaries. Donald Trump's demographic support is much different now.
Re:The 2016 Election by douche on Monday October 17, 2016 @07:16PM (#12730698)
Source? I'd legitimately be interested to see how it has changed. I haven't seen much movement in my particular bubble; it's the same people now as back then.
Re:The 2016 Election by Locke1689 on Monday October 17, 2016 @11:01PM (#12731695)
The Washington Post[0] has it broken down by demographics since June. As you can see, as of October 13th, Trump's only lead in education is among voters who have completed "some college", with Clinton having a huge lead among those with college degrees and postgraduate degrees. She even has a narrow lead among those with a high school education or less.

[0] https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/politics/2016-electi...

Re:The 2016 Election by r_smart on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:27PM (#12729379)
>How do you go about working with someone that is uneducated

This is a myth. [0]

>with someone that is uneducated, and often proud of this fact, raised to believe all other races are a blight against life as they know it, and often are proud of this,

>I'm not trying to be coy

I can assure you no one is about to accuse you of that :) [1]

[0]: http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/the-mythology-of-trumps-...

[1]: https://www.google.com/search?q=define+coy&oq=define+coy&aqs...

Re:The 2016 Election by Locke1689 on Monday October 17, 2016 @06:34PM (#12730428)
Link [0] States that they're not lower-income, not that they're educated.
Re:The 2016 Election by r_smart on Monday October 17, 2016 @07:05PM (#12730646)
Indeed. How does education and income correlate though? We're talking about millions of people here, not a handful, so the chances of it being a bunch of above median high school drop-outs seems exceedingly unlikely, no?
Re:The 2016 Election by xorgar831 on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:33PM (#12728643)
This is what demagogues do, they raley and gain power through uniting groups of people over fear. The extreme political tactics by the GOP lead to the scenario we have today, and Trump is building off of what the GOP laid the groundwork for over the past 40-50 years.
Re:The 2016 Election by postcarnival on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:55PM (#12728984)
lot of accusations but maybe there are reasons that half the country believes in what he's saying? we've had more terrorist attacks, more foreign policy disasters, and more cultural and racial unrest in the past few years than in modern times yet you shut down the conversation by attributing it to "fear" as if people don't have a right to be fearful... nice
Re:The 2016 Election by spdustin on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:13PM (#12729211)
I don't mean to troll here, but I've never gotten anyone to give evidence of these claims. I'm an open-minded person, and evidence speaks loudly to me to change my mind. I fear that there are many who won't allow evidence to change their mind unless their feelings are acknowledged and compensated for first, and I think that's a difficult circumstance to manage and get past, because often that acknowledgement is seen as an endorsement.

I've tried to find evidence supporting these claims on my own, only to discover that there have been fewer terrorist attacks in the last, say, 16 years than in the years before, and better economic standing for minorities in the same period versus before then. I've been able to find a slow but consistent improvement to the overall quality of life of Americans by any objective measure I could discern. It's still subjectively and objectively bad for some groups, but even there, I can only find evidence of a slow but consistent improvement over time.

What am I missing? If I and others can understand that, maybe we can make a difference.

Re:The 2016 Election by postcarnival on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:46PM (#12729565)
I too look for evidence and I have to be careful not to put emotions in front of rationale but one thing that strikes me about the rise of isis and the ensuing terrorist attacks from Europe to California is the media coverage. I honestly feel like the same media that is actively trying to destroy Donald Trump also can't get enough of him. Do you remember when all of those journalists were having their heads cut off? Or the many bombings and attacks after? The media created the term "ISIS" and blanketed 24 hour news cycles with it. The same has happened for the police shootings. You may be able to say that based on the numbers things are looking up, but if you turn on the TV the past few years you wouldn't know that. I also think that is why many Trump supporters are sick of the "media". They've been spoon-fed a teaspoon of fear a day and now that they chose their candidate whom they feel will lead them to higher-ground and that same media tells them they're racist/bigot/stupid for supporting him, they no longer trust media outright.
Re:The 2016 Election by xir78 on Monday October 17, 2016 @07:02PM (#12730623)
There are no more than in past decades, and if it really was the case then you'd take a stay calm and approach vs trying to panic an entire country.
Re:The 2016 Election by ZenoArrow on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:09PM (#12729171)
> "This is what demagogues do, they raley and gain power through uniting groups of people over fear."

Which candidate are you referring to? Both major candidates are aiming to pick up votes by spreading fear of the other candidate. I'd argue that's pretty much their strongest argument at this point.

Re:The 2016 Election by mtgx on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:30PM (#12728575)
What I don't understand "even more" than that (literally, by the numbers) is how 49% of the country is registered independent and yet keeps voting Democrat and Republican. Worse yet, 76% of the country "wants to see alternatives" in the debates...but still keeps voting Democrat and Republican.

Even if people agree to buy into this whole "this election is special" premise, I think people would be well within their rights to riot in 2020, if they hear one more time that that election is special, too, and they must once again vote Democrat ("because who else are they going to vote for?!")

Because when elections become "special" all the time, it means they really aren't. And it means the problem is systemic, and it's that systemic issue that needs to be addressed before voting against any particular candidate. Otherwise, these problems are never going to end. "Fix Democracy First" - as Lessig once believed (like until earlier this year) before he also started thinking that people should just shut up and vote for Clinton already.

Re:The 2016 Election by jgroszko on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:42PM (#12728796)
Any first past the post system like we have will trend towards a two party system as people vote strategically for the most tolerable mainstream candidate. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s7tWHJfhiyo

It's interesting to see people calling for more alternatives and more viable political parties in the US. It's not clear to me that having more political parties would be better since many European countries, where more parliamentary style representation is common, is also dealing with their own xenophobic and nationalist movements.

Re:The 2016 Election by masklinn on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:53PM (#12728967)
> Any first past the post system like we have will trend towards a two party system as people vote strategically for the most tolerable mainstream candidate. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s7tWHJfhiyo

FPTP also greatly increases the effect of gerrymandering, especially in single-member constituencies.

Re:The 2016 Election by MBCook on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:38PM (#12728744)
Let's say I was independent and lived in Ohio or some other swing state. What choices do I have?

* Vote Dem, have a reasonable chance at my pick winning

* Vote Repub, have a reasonable chance at my pick winning

* Vote other, have no chance at my pick winning.

In an ordinary election you may be willing to do #3 to 'send a message', etc. But in THIS election almost everyone seems to agree that one or both of the candidates are horrible and will ruin everything. So if you go #3 then you get no say in which major party candidate will win. I'd much rather have A win than B, even if I liked some third party more (right now I don't anyway, they're pretty crazy this year too).

I'd want my vote to count, and I don't think it would unless I voted major party.

As it is my vote won't count, because the outcome of my state is not in question at all.

Re:The 2016 Election by ZenoArrow on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:17PM (#12729252)
> "But in THIS election almost everyone seems to agree that one or both of the candidates are horrible and will ruin everything."

I'd argue that's why it's a great chance to vote third party. Both major candidates are terrible choices, and quite frankly even though people say Hilary is less terrible than Trump, I don't buy it, just look at her track record. If you vote third party in this election, you might not win this time, but you can start laying the foundation for a strong third party to emerge in future elections.

Re:The 2016 Election by int_19h on Monday October 17, 2016 @05:13PM (#12729827)
> If you vote third party in this election, you might not win this time, but you can start laying the foundation for a strong third party to emerge in future elections.

Assuming that there are future (fair) elections.

I have serious concerns about that if Trump is to become the president.

I've heard many people on the right having the same concerns about Clinton.

Re:The 2016 Election by ZenoArrow on Monday October 17, 2016 @07:38PM (#12730827)
Improvements to the fairness of elections won't come from those who benefit from the status quo, it'll come from those at the grassroots level. Boosting the electoral performance of third party candidates builds confidence that grassroots movements can make a significant political impact.

As for whether Trump or Clinton would actively block fair elections, that wouldn't surprise me, but I wouldn't put it past either of them (Trump's already made it clear he wants to make it easier to manipulate the press, and Clinton was clearly willing to engage in underhand tactics to get the Democratic nomination). If you're of the same mindset then it makes no sense to vote for either of them, as it appears neither are interested in engaging in fair elections.

Re:The 2016 Election by int_19h on Monday October 17, 2016 @11:02PM (#12731700)
> rump's already made it clear he wants to make it easier to manipulate the press, and Clinton was clearly willing to engage in underhand tactics to get the Democratic nomination

I would dare say that these two things aren't equivalent.

Clinton "rigging" the primaries didn't involve preventing people from speaking out, or excluding them from voting. It was mostly about the system itself being "pre-rigged" by design, so to speak, and then some coordination with the DNC behind the scenes. All bad juju, but not the kind of thing that causes lasting damage compared to the current state of affairs. Compared to Democrat "machines" of the old, it's practically peanuts - and the country and its political system survived those.

OTOH, Trump's talk about expanding the libel laws and otherwise targeting the press, if implemented to its logical completion, would take a lot of time to dig out of. That's not even taking into account his threats to "investigate" his political opponents if elected.

Re:The 2016 Election by ZenoArrow on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @02:47AM (#12732594)
> "Clinton "rigging" the primaries didn't involve preventing people from speaking out"

Some would argue that there's evidence that she is engaged in that activity:

https://m.reddit.com/r/conspiracy/comments/4wa5ue/clinton_bo...

Whether you want to believe this or not is up to you, but I'd suggest doing a bit of research before dismissing it.

Re:The 2016 Election by MBCook on Monday October 17, 2016 @05:33PM (#12729981)
Whoever wins I'm VERY interested to see what election/campaign/voting reform laws get proposed or passed.

Do people try to make tax returns a requirement? Birth certificates? Do we move to a more federal election system so it's not 50 states + 1000s of counties deciding how elections are run? Do presidential powers get reigned in a bit?

Much of that may require amendments, but I have a feeling we're going to have the discussions.

Re:The 2016 Election by MBCook on Monday October 17, 2016 @05:34PM (#12729989)
So that's the tradeoff. Would you rather that the X party might get a seat at the table next time or would you rather that you do your best NOT to elect the person you don't want by voting for their opponent.
Re:The 2016 Election by ZenoArrow on Monday October 17, 2016 @07:48PM (#12730876)
I'd take the first option. Look at the shitshow that's been unleashed by continuing to vote for the lesser of two evils. We'll only stop things getting worse by making politicians earn our votes, rather than winning by default by being slightly more palatable than the other candidate. Voting with your conscience means you want to hold your politicians to higher standards, and whilst that might not have an immediate impact, it is the type of action that can make a noticeable difference over time.
Re:The 2016 Election by douche on Monday October 17, 2016 @07:31PM (#12730768)
If Teddy Roosevelt couldn't break up the two-party system, I'm not sure anybody can[1]. Political parties aren't even necessarily about policies at this point, I'm afraid; they seem to have turned into badges of identity such as religions once were. We're not quite there yet, but calling oneself a Republican or a Democrat is starting to feel like identifying as Lutheran vs Catholic during the wars of religion in the 16th century. For an example of how awful that kind of dynamic can go, particularly with an extra-radical fringe element stirring up populist sentiment, I would suggest Dan Carlin's podcast on happenings in the city of Muenster in that era[2]. It's thought-provoking.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Progressive_Party_(United_Stat...

[2] http://www.dancarlin.com/product/hardcore-history-48-prophet...

Re:The 2016 Election by jedmeyers on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:34PM (#12728662)
With the current one-tier election system, you will severely cripple the chances of your second best candidate to win, if you vote you your first choice independent candidate.
Re:The 2016 Election by foota on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:35PM (#12728674)
Perhaps it's because the two leading independent candidates have terrible policy proposals? (Not to say that both major party candidates have great proposals, either)
Re:The 2016 Election by ZenoArrow on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:18PM (#12729267)
Tell me what you know about Johnson and Stein's policy proposals.
Re:The 2016 Election by foota on Monday October 17, 2016 @05:32PM (#12729974)
Johnson thinks we should eliminate income taxes and replace them with high consumption taxes and Stein thinks we should cancel student debt. I've admittedly cherry picked some things I don't like.
Re:The 2016 Election by Uhhrrr on Monday October 17, 2016 @08:58PM (#12731184)
Like Europe's VAT? Hardly a wild, crazy idea.
Re:The 2016 Election by duaneb on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:33PM (#12728640)
What third parties? Would you rather have the libertarians or green party? Maybe a party or candidate with even less of a track record?

Neither offer a sane way forward.

Re:The 2016 Election by scaryspooky on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:24PM (#12729344)
I keep seeing this argument, and just because you disagree with libertarian principles doesn't make them more "insane."

Dismissing in such a negative way well thought out view points because they don't match your world view is counterproductive to having good policy discussions.

Re:The 2016 Election by duaneb on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:27PM (#12729369)
To me, they are insane. I don't know what to say. They don't bring much to the table I take seriously. I like some of the principles, but it's not a coherent platform.

Ironically, the same complaints apply to both the libertarian and the Green Party, though I have more beef with Jill Stein than the platform itself.

Re:The 2016 Election by int_19h on Monday October 17, 2016 @05:15PM (#12729847)
The important part is that both support major electoral reform that would enable third parties in general to be viable and to get proportional representation. If they can actually pull it off, I couldn't care less about the rest of their platform - the country can survive 4 years of libertarians or greens, it's seen much worse.

The catch is that said reform requires constitutional amendments, and these are gated on the states, not on the federal government (obviously, ratification requires state legislatures, but the states can also call for a constitutional convention, regardless of what the feds think).

So supporting third parties on the federal level is pointless from that perspective. If you just want electoral reform, vote third party for state legislature.

Re:The 2016 Election by josho on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:18PM (#12729273)
I'm surprised that more Americans don't spoil their ballot. Imagine if 20% of the ballots cast were spoiled. That would certainly wake up the media & politicians to the problems inherent in this 2 party system.
Re:The 2016 Election by Waterluvian on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:26PM (#12728514)
Precisely. It doesn't mean that their perspective is guaranteed to be rational or free from ugly ideas. But it's a valid perspective.
Re:The 2016 Election by kybernetikos on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:31PM (#12728607)
What does validity mean in this context?
Re:The 2016 Election by darksaints on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:45PM (#12728859)
Not gonna put words into someone else's mouth, but here it is from my perspective: We come to the opinions we have based on the experiences we have, and everybody has different experiences. Equally as true is the opinions that don't form due to the experiences we don't have.

One example I have from someone I disagree with. It was a rich kid about to fully take over his father's company via inheritance, who agreed vehemently with trickle down economics. From his perspective, he created jobs (I'd at least agree with that much). The way that he created jobs was by investing resources on new profitable projects that required labor. In his perspective, how could he ever create more jobs by constraining his resources? He couldn't, but that is exactly the point (someone else creates the jobs, not him). He couldn't see the alternative of government enabling new jobs because the entire sum of his life experience portrayed government as a barrier to investment, not as an enabler of opportunity. The simple fact that he never had to rely on the government as an enabler of opportunity blinded him to the possibility that it could use his resources more efficiently than he could.

I'd consider his opinion falsifiable, but his perspective valid. I would never in a million years be able to tell him his perspective was wrong.

Re:The 2016 Election by kybernetikos on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:25PM (#12729354)
For 'valid' to mean anything interesting there has to be the possibility of something not being valid. If the criteria for 'valid' is merely that 'someone thinks it' then it's starting to sound like it's not a useful distinction to make.
Re:The 2016 Election by darksaints on Monday October 17, 2016 @05:10PM (#12729810)
The distinction being made isn't valid vs invalid, but rather perspective vs opinion. An incorrect opinion does not invalidate the perspective that helped form it, and the perspective is still worth understanding if you want an actual solution to a problem instead of just the self-righteous satisfaction of being right.
Re:The 2016 Election by kybernetikos on Monday October 17, 2016 @05:28PM (#12729942)
I'm completely in favour of understanding why people think what they do - apart from anything else, it's almost impossible to persuade them of anything different if you don't start from a position of sympathy.

In order to give you the opportunity of gaining a position of sympathy with me; one of the reasons I was asking about 'validity' is that it sounds formal and logical, but it doesn't seem to be being used in a formal and logical sense.

I think you're using it to say that we shouldn't dismiss perspectives, even those that have a high correlation with incorrect opinions (even though I'd struggle to define 'perspective' except as a bundle of opinions). While the intention seems admirable enough, I still find myself wishing for a bit more precision over what exactly is being said: obviously experiences aren't invalidated by the person experiencing them having false opinions, but the opinions formed from those experiences can absolutely be false, and occasionally even in the strict formal, logical sense invalid. If we're not talking about experiences (since the argument is almost never about what the other party experienced, but rather about what it means), and we're not talking about opinions, then I'm not sure what we're talking about at all.

Maybe I should just take this as a shorthand for describing a useful attitude to take rather than a description of something in the world, i.e. saying 'it's worth understanding why people think what they think, even if it's wrong, rather than dismissing it out of hand', and then I could agree with it.

Re:The 2016 Election by Waterluvian on Monday October 17, 2016 @06:47PM (#12730524)
Thanks for the comments. Yes, this deserves more explanation.

I mean "valid" essentially as a truism. It's a valid perspective because people are able to hold that perspective.

What makes it important to point out, in my opinion, is that it doesn't matter how irrational or ugly or wrong that perspective is, it can't simply be dismissed because it is such. That makes us incapable of fostering an environment in which all parties can grow their perspectives.

My wife's pregnant and she often has incredibly irrational fears. She will even point out that she has no logical underpinning for feeling a certain way. But she does feel that way. Her perspective, no matter what doctors tell her, is that there's so many things that may go wrong. And that's valid. Instead of, "well, if you know it makes no sense to feel that way, then stop feeling that way, right?" we work to understand what might be causing it and use what levers and knobs in life we have to eliminate those fears.

If we dismiss certain perspectives as being an invalid state for one to be in, we close doors on addressing it.

I'm not really much of a writer or persuasive voice, so I hope you're able to pick up what I'm trying to convey. Heck, maybe I'm just using words wrongly. I've been known to cromulate that from time to time.

Re:The 2016 Election by travis-d-ray on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @03:13PM (#12737716)
I'm not the one to whom you're replying, but FWIW, I think you did fine.
Re:The 2016 Election by kapitza on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:39PM (#12728757)
> That's not how things are done in this country.

Tocqueville, almost 200 years ago, begs to differ:

"I know of no country in which there is so little independence of mind and real freedom of discussion as in America.... in America the majority raises formidable barriers around the liberty of opinion; within these barriers an author may write what he pleases; but woe to him if he goes beyond them." [1]

What's changed this year isn't that Americans are being purged for having the wrong political ideas. That's been happening not for 200 years, but well over 300. Roger Williams, anyone? [2]

What's changed this year is that the major candidate of one of the main two parties holds beliefs that would get any normal American purged. Added to this is the velocity of change: 50 years ago, most normal Americans held these same beliefs. (Heck, not 10 years ago, both Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton were swearing up and down that "marriage is between a man and a woman.")

So you're seeing two processes: an increase in the speed at which America's governing class can evolve its beliefs, and a decrease in their ability to drag the rest of America along with them. No surprise that the latter group wants to respond to an existential threat with an existential threat.

[1] http://dailyprincetonian.com/opinion/2001/10/alexis-de-tocqu... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roger_Williams

Re:The 2016 Election by wu-ikkyu on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:43PM (#12728817)
>within these barriers an author may write what he pleases; but woe to him if he goes beyond them.

This has been more recently termed as the "Overton Window"

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overton_window

Re:The 2016 Election by Aloha on Monday October 17, 2016 @06:12PM (#12730268)
Yeah, I can see this - and the overton window for various parts to the political spectrum no longer match up.
Re:The 2016 Election by labster on Monday October 17, 2016 @03:46PM (#12728867)
> 50 years ago, most normal Americans held these same beliefs

Most Americans 50 years ago would be stunned that someone who has been married three times, and who has been caught on tape saying he wants to cheat with other women, is still running for President. That alone would be disqualifying.

Re:The 2016 Election by sidlls on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:13PM (#12729216)
Um, JFK begs to differ.
Re:The 2016 Election by sparky_z on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:18PM (#12729263)
"Most Americans" at the time had no idea about JFK's personal flaws in that regard. If they had, I can't imagine he would have reached the point of being nominated.
Re:The 2016 Election by Aloha on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:33PM (#12729438)
The change is.. we know far more about our leaders than perhaps we should. No one is, has ever been, or will ever be, as saintly as our ideals require.
Re:The 2016 Election by Houshalter on Tuesday October 18, 2016 @12:32AM (#12732119)
I don't think that's true actually. The media had a policy on not reporting on candidates infidelity. People didn't think it was relevant to politics and that it was a cheap way of attack. As far as I can tell reporting on and outrage over sex scandals has only become more popular over time. Our culture is much more sensitive to it now, instead of the reverse.
Re:The 2016 Election by bdamm on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:22PM (#12729321)
Quite the contrary. The affairs were mostly secret up to the point he was elected president, and he was only married once.
Re:The 2016 Election by burkaman on Monday October 17, 2016 @04:03PM (#12729081)
I get why you're using examples from centuries ago, but I don't think those alone can prove your point. Tocqueville might have been right 200 years ago, I have no idea, but I strongly disagree that his statement is true today.