Re:Case dropped against Simon Singh
by ErrantX on Thursday April 15, 2010 @06:31AM
(#1267471)
I hope the BCA is forced to bear the costs to Singh. I've been following this story closely and it was setting up to be a real triumph for free reporting and science etc.
Damn the BCA for chickening out of their drubbing early :(
Re:Case dropped against Simon Singh
by Luc on Thursday April 15, 2010 @07:06AM
(#1267508)
Rather heart-warmingly Google returns dozens of requests from people to contribute to his defence fund, but he has stated he will bear the costs himself:
"The reason that I have been able to fight this case is that I have the financial resources to do so. Three international bestsellers have provided a very comfortable cushion for trouble indirectly caused by 'Trick or Treatment?'. If I lose, then it will be a major financial blow, but my wife and I will be able to cope. Hence, I have asked myself if supporters should donate money to a more need cause, one that this will also help the cause of free speech and science journalism. I currently have two suggestions [...]"
Re:Case dropped against Simon Singh
by motter on Thursday April 15, 2010 @07:08AM
(#1267513)
Hopefully the additional attention this case has brought to Simon's work will translate into an increase in revenue from his books -- furthering the "cushioning" effect.
Re:Case dropped against Simon Singh
by kjuhygfgbhjnm on Thursday April 15, 2010 @02:40PM
(#1268556)
No because they didn't lose.
It's a standard technique for corps suing individuals, you string the person along for years as they rack up $100,000 in legal fees while your costs are for your own internal lawyers - and wait for them to go bust.
You drop the case before it goes to court so there is never any chance of you losing.
Re:Case dropped against Simon Singh
by kjuhygfgbhjnm on Thursday April 15, 2010 @06:34PM
(#1269138)
But remember the crackpots (sorry homeopathists) were the innocent victims here - the nasty journalist said they were a buch of frauds - so causing them to lose money and their patients to go untreated.
Re:Case dropped against Simon Singh
by rmc on Thursday April 15, 2010 @07:26AM
(#1267529)
If you are interested in more stories of bad science and medicine, then check out Ben Goldacre's site: http://www.badscience.net/ He has a book of the same name.
Re:Case dropped against Simon Singh
by miri on Thursday April 15, 2010 @06:50AM
(#1267488)
It's not quite as good as rationality winning hard, but still, it's not bad - and yes, the BCA should bear Singh's costs. And a change to British libel law would be nice, too.
Re:Case dropped against Simon Singh
by mantasradzas on Thursday April 15, 2010 @09:33AM
(#1267732)
IANAL, but wouldn't a win in a court create a precedent that could be used in similar cases? I am really happy about this turnuot, but the early retreat by the Chiropractic seems in part like an unfortunate turn of events, overall...
[...] the BCA has taken the view that it should withdraw to avoid further legal costs being incurred by either side.
A realisation that did not strike them until the prospect of an embarassing loss.
Damn the BCA for chickening out of their drubbing early :(
http://www.senseaboutscience.org.uk/index.php/site/project/3...
"The reason that I have been able to fight this case is that I have the financial resources to do so. Three international bestsellers have provided a very comfortable cushion for trouble indirectly caused by 'Trick or Treatment?'. If I lose, then it will be a major financial blow, but my wife and I will be able to cope. Hence, I have asked myself if supporters should donate money to a more need cause, one that this will also help the cause of free speech and science journalism. I currently have two suggestions [...]"
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barratry
They accused him of lying right? Can he not ask them to prove that.
Would be amusing (but I realise, sadly, unlikely)
Perhaps not legally (and so, yes, they probably won't be made to pay). But I think publicly they have lost on this.
If the aim was to ruin his reputation that doesn't seem to have worked and neither has trying to ruin him financially.
I would say Singh has won in every sense of the word but a legal ruling :)
There were some moves in this direction: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/8259814.stm
Check the site for why it's spelled that way.