Re:Case dropped against Simon Singh
by kjuhygfgbhjnm on Thursday April 15, 2010 @02:40PM
(#1268556)
No because they didn't lose.
It's a standard technique for corps suing individuals, you string the person along for years as they rack up $100,000 in legal fees while your costs are for your own internal lawyers - and wait for them to go bust.
You drop the case before it goes to court so there is never any chance of you losing.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Where are barratry laws when you need them?
Re:Case dropped against Simon Singh
by kjuhygfgbhjnm on Thursday April 15, 2010 @06:34PM
(#1269138)
But remember the crackpots (sorry homeopathists) were the innocent victims here - the nasty journalist said they were a buch of frauds - so causing them to lose money and their patients to go untreated.
I'd love to see him counter sue for, I don't know, besmirching his good name.
They accused him of lying right? Can he not ask them to prove that.
Would be amusing (but I realise, sadly, unlikely)
They accused him of libel, actually. In the UK you can both be telling the truth and be guilty of libel. (Hence the hubbub there about libel reform)
Fair point; I forgot the precise bit they were suing over. :)
> No because they didn't lose.
Perhaps not legally (and so, yes, they probably won't be made to pay). But I think publicly they have lost on this.
If the aim was to ruin his reputation that doesn't seem to have worked and neither has trying to ruin him financially.
I would say Singh has won in every sense of the word but a legal ruling :)