Re:Computer Vision: Algorithms and Applications (2010)
by stared on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @05:39AM
(#12588338)
The only one risky thing is that in computer vision right now things change each 6 months. So, one will never know which techniques are still state of the art, and which were outclassed by some ConvNets 4 years ago.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Computer Vision: Algorithms and Applications (2010)
by emanuelev on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @06:12AM
(#12588421)
Regardless the impact machine learning techniques are having on the field, I still think is valuable to know and understand what are the classic methods that they are allegedly replacing.
Re:Computer Vision: Algorithms and Applications (2010)
by rsp1984 on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @08:10AM
(#12588944)
It is actually not about "classic" vs. "modern". A lot of what's described in the book is as relevant as ever.
Mostly what's changed is that what used to be heuristics and hand-crafted features is now getting replaced by proper learned models. Also some generative models are getting replaced discriminative models since deep learning does a very good job in creating those.
Re:Computer Vision: Algorithms and Applications (2010)
by stared on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @06:50AM
(#12588577)
Sure. Just it's nice to know which pieces are:
- considered obsolete (e.g. complicated and nasty, and still outclassed by NNs),
- building blocks of current techniques,
- provided inspiration for current techniques,
- are still state of the art.
Re:Computer Vision: Algorithms and Applications (2010)
by rsp1984 on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @06:40AM
(#12588525)
A lot in the book is about geometry and Structure from Motion. It's an area that's becoming augmented but not superseded by Neural Nets. For example if you want to generate a 3D model from images you can't just throw a NN at it. Same for tracking etc...
Re:Computer Vision: Algorithms and Applications (2010)
by emanuelev on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @08:22AM
(#12589036)
Although that might change real soon. There are a number of ongoing works that attempt at using CNNs to estimate both geometry and movement.
Re:Computer Vision: Algorithms and Applications (2010)
by zump on Wednesday September 28, 2016 @03:22AM
(#12595980)
Got a link?
SLAM using SfM (from monocular vision) using Deep Nets would be huge. Would reduce the specifications for LIDAR in SDC's for example.
Re:Computer Vision: Algorithms and Applications (2010)
by Kenji on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @07:24AM
(#12588714)
Things like principal component analysis, eigenvalues and filtering are timeless and fundamental tools that won't go away in the near future.
Even if you don't go into computer vision - these have a wide range of applications, for example in sound or signal processing which are closely related.