Google has learned nothing from their mistakes.
As evidence their real name policy is still active. Contrast with Twitter where a lot of users have fake names. And yes, you can find hateful users on Twitter and I know of some folks that have been harassed, but the community I'm active in is very professional and civilized and the conversations have a much higher quality than what I've seen on Google+ or YouTube, even with their real names. Guess some people are assholes no matter what.
Also the Google+ API is still read-only. Which means you can only use Google's official tools for posting content. There's no way for example to cross-post on both Twitter and Google+. Apps like TweetDeck aren't possible for Google+.
Oh and Google Reader is still dead.
> Google doesn't want to mess up identity again, so that wouldn't be an issue
I'm sure they don't want to mess it up, but given that they are continuously messing up identity, I'm also sure that it will be an issue.
Now contrast Twitter's earnings per share with Facebook's, which does have a real name policy. This policy is 1 percent about harassment, and 99 percent about building an advertising market to sustain the thing once built.
Same logic applies to the read-only APIs. Unless you know a way to embed ads into the APIs, apps like Tweetdeck directly reduce income. This is why Twitter tried to lock down and revoke API access.
If anyone has been making mistakes here, it's been Twitter, who is now in such a poor financial position that, despite laying off a huge number of engineers, their best hope of avoiding Google Reader's fate is to be acquired.
I've worked on an advertising platform. This idea that those real names have value is basically a myth.
And speaking of Twitter's API, trying to revoke access is one of those decisions that irrevocably hurt them. The big reason for why Facebook succeeded while Google+ miserably failed is that Facebook is a platform.
The real name policy was revoked a couple of years ago. [1] I can only find some help pages on how often one can change the name and what to do if one wants to use a "first name" alone (the answer is to use a "." in the last name field and it won't be shown anywhere). Where does Google or Google+ require real names and since when? Do you have links to a re-reversal of that policy? I searched again, but couldn't find any.
No it's not. There's no requirement to use your real name in Google+ or YouTube. And if you don't like Google+ you can even delete it from your account.
>Also the Google+ API is still read-only. Which means you can only use Google's official tools for posting content.
So what? There's a good reason it's read only and that's to avoid the flood of spam that would flow in.
>Oh and Google Reader is still dead.
Yeah, like you ever used Google Reader. It was a seldomly used service that has now become the poster child for people looking to criticize all Google product announcements.
Is this true? Buffer allows you to cross-post to Facebook, Twitter and Google+.
The Google+ API is read-only, it says so in their own docs: https://developers.google.com/+/web/api/rest/
And if you want a service that has integration with everything except for Google+, there's IFTTT.
Really, the one thing that keeps YouTube going is how expensive it is to compete with it. Twitter doesn't exactly have that luxury.
Twitter's luxury is its existing userbase. Same for eBay, Paypal, and other near-monopolies.
Twitter's software is absolutely nothing special. You could have 95% of the core functionality in two weeks as a solo project. (Granted, it probably won't scale to 320m users right out of the gate ...)
The problem is that nobody's going to go and use your new Twitter-like service that has zero users. So if I built a Twitter clone, I'd probably get, at best, 100 very inactive users, no matter how great the service was.
Twitter is not for everybody and never will be. Twitter is for those who publish information and for those who are interested in shaping their own information consumption beyond the daily headlines plus family and friends spam.
If Google buys Twitter in the hope of creating a realtime Google for everybody they will fail.
I hope they decide to reverse their "no niches" strategy, because that strategy has been very damaging indeed.
I don't know exactly what the potential of Reader might have been. Maybe something between 1% and 3%? It's the same ballpark as Twitter in my view, but that is admittedly rather speculative. It's also not the point I was trying to make.
Twitter could absolutely be a valuable property, but it's never going to have the scale/reach of Google Search or Facebook.
Also, Twitter is unprofitable, but my understanding was that they were heavily trusted by the public.
I think you're substituting a particular group of Twitter users for the public - the general perception is Twitter is full of hateful trolls and management can't be bothered to control them.
Curious if you have any particular stories in mind.
Do you have some respectable polling data to support this claim? I also visit some of the biased websites that constantly beat that drum, but that doesn't mean this opinion is held by the general public.
It'd be great if Google bought them for one reason: see what they do with the censorship part. Will they continue picking off tags they don't like and open up the idea that Google is deliberately biasing things? Or will Twitter users suddenly see popular trends they never saw before?
1: The website is hostile to consuming content. If you scroll down a few pages of tweets then click an image or something, you lose your spot. Pressing back brings you to the bottom of the first "page" of tweets, not however far you had scrolled. Add in the slowness and wow, it's really quite a bad experience.
Frankly, I think there are some "lessons learned" that are critical and are relevant, but looking backwards only accurately tells you how to successfully create something in the past.
Google on the other hand has demonstrated that they have no idea how to compete in social. Buying Twitter gives them a property to play with at a discount.
Aren't self driving cars the next big thing anyway? Who cares what's on Twitter when you can sell ads in the car while I go from point a to point b.
Though to me it would make more sense if Twitter were a joint venture between various media outlets, sort of like how Hulu was funded initially. News Corp, Viacom, Disney, etc all buying large stakes in the company and taking it private to me is the best possible outcome.
In what ways?
[1] http://www.popsci.com/google-has-7-products-with-1-billion-u...
[1] http://www.theverge.com/2016/5/18/11685424/google-photos-upd...
You're spending too much time in the HN/Startup echo chamber. Google has no brand problem with public at large.
- Google learnt from its mistakes with Google+ and is eager to not repeat them
- The company is a very different one now from years ago
- Google doesn't want to mess up identity again, so that wouldn't be an issue
- Google mostly just wants a social graph
- Twitter is a bad public company that makes irrational decisions
- Merging Google engineering/leadership with Twitter might actually give direction and ease the financial pressure that seems to drive the company's poor engineering decisions