Is there any scientific basis for this claim?
In other words, drinking diet soda may not by itself cause problems, but it will stimulate your body to absorb even more of the burger and fries you consumed with the soda (or whatever other metabolites you currently have circulating in your bloodstream).
I'm on mobile now with limited connectivity. I'll try to edit later with a link to a source.
The end result seems to be what I expected, just not the underlying cause. Regardless, it was a huge wake up call to not just treat diet soda like it was basically water.
http://www.marksdailyapple.com/artificial-sweeteners-insulin...
Some interesting links to pubmed there. Seems that aspartame does not affect insulin fwiw.
http://care.diabetesjournals.org/content/early/2013/04/30/dc...
Beware of small sample sizes in these sorts of studies. Until you get up into the hundreds or thousands, I personally would expect regression to the mean. Just FYI.
that study used sucralose ("Splenda" et al) -- a completely unrelated, artificial sweetener.
Stevia is a naturally occurring plant extract which has steviol glycosides, having 150x the sweetness of sucrose (according to Wikipedia).
Now I'm a little curious what happens to blood insulin when athletes fire down a stevia-flavored source of short chain carbohydrates prior to exercise vs. unflavored. When I have time I'll look it up. The nice thing about this (stevia vs. sugar or vs. artificial sweeteners) is that it lends itself naturally to a two factor design, "natural" vs. not and "real sugar" vs. not, orthogonally.
Anyways, yes, I was wrong about that and will probably fuck it up again in the future, although at least now I'm aware of the problem.
If you think about it, any molecule that isn't sugar but tastes like sugar will have a similar molecular shape to sugar. Hmmmm I wonder if this will fit into receptors in other places in the body, not just on the tongue. Maybe it will affect gut bacteria. Maybe even trigger other events within our bodies.
If we would stop and think with an open mind, many of these arguments would become discussions, and we wouldn't need to play the baby card by asking for proof.
Remember how long it took to finally get enough proof in order to show others how wrong our mainstream religions are? And even with all the evidence we have accumulated, still people say, "show me the proof. I'm a reasonable man." Bullshit.
Let's not fall into this trap again. Many of these questions can be answered without slow, hard science. We don't need to hit everything with the biggest hammer in our toolbox before we can move forward.
I'm going to go out on a limb here and propose that you may not be a professional medicinal chemist.
Many theories conveniently support your position. Of course, many theories conveniently support the other side. How can we objectively determine who is right?
Well, let's look at (among many, many other experimental studies) http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25786106 which is a recent study of metabolic differences between self-reported aspartame sensitive and non-sensitive individuals. Double-blind, randomised crossover study -- the gold standard. Any differences in metabolic profile between either control/aspartame or sensitive/not? None seen.
However, perhaps all non-nutritive sweeteners are not alike. The same senior author as above ran a separate study in a small sample of athletic males where aspartame in addition to carbohydrates resulted in lower insulin response during exercise: https://jissn.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/1550-2783-9...
Meanwhile, and in a different (grossly obese, NNS-naive) population, sucralose (Stevia) appeared to do the opposite: http://care.diabetesjournals.org/content/early/2013/04/30/dc...
> Many of these questions can be answered without slow, hard science
Sure, if we don't care whether the answers are credible.
Proof by analogy is fraud. If we didn't need evidence to make decisions we wouldn't bother accumulating it.
s/Stevia/Splenda/ (stevia is entirely different from sucralose).
But this all assumes there is evidence available. Is there?
I've read "scientific" articles that make use of the most cutting-edge statistical models in order to "prove" that something like "emotional intelligence does not correlate with success."
Ok, poor example, and I made it up. But there are many research articles out there that look impressive because of all the tools they throw at the problem. Under the surface these studies are bunk.
Why does this not surprise me?
Outside of mathematics, there really isn't anything resembling proof. There is the weight of the evidence, and the weight of any substantive critiques of bias in said evidence. That's about it.
> But there are many research articles out there that look impressive because of all the tools they throw at the problem. Under the surface these studies are bunk.
On this we can certainly agree. However, the replacement for a bad study is a well-designed study, not some statistical hocus pocus (1) or "going by your gut".
If your position is sound, there will (at some point) be someone bold and independently-funded enough to torpedo the status quo with a properly designed experiment. It may not happen as fast as you'd like. But there is nothing that academics like better than turning their rivals' sacred cows into hamburger. Of this I can assure you.
(1) I am a statistician, both professionally and by graduate training. I have no qualms about dismissing poorly designed studies regardless of post-hoc jiggery-pokery. A shiny autopsy won't reanimate the corpse of a dead experiment.
I do not care what you think at this point, this has already blossomed into a 1 vs 1, so anything said will just make both sides more justified in their position.
This is about onlookers. Hacker News is flawed in the same way that elections are flawed. Every user is given the same power of opinion. A losing strategy that will eventually begin to conform to the middle of the pack, condemning any opinions falling too far from the centre.
Apathy, I have to ask you. If you are getting all the votes, all the +1's, all the likes, would you ever think that maybe that is not a good sign?
You logic strikes me as specious -- the proximity of an idea to the mushy middle is orthogonal to whether it is correct. Great ideas are often met with violent opposition -- but shitty ideas are, too. If I thought most people on HN were in fact dumbasses, as most of the electorate often seems to be, I would go somewhere else. It's the least worst forum (save perhaps Metafilter) I've found so it's a place where I go to procrastinate.
My job is to write, so my natural impulse when I see something that seems easily dismantled is to get in a bit of practice.
Anyway, we can be lost in a sea of doubt with all our pet theories, or we can look at the available evidence.
I don't understand what this means for a non-diabetic. Are they measuring your A1c? How are you "controlling" your blood sugar?
Secondly, even if you're not building fat your body still needs insulin.
Everything other than that and it no longer fits that category.
If you are educated and/or wealthy with diabetes[0], the odds are you have a good endocrinologist and/or are disciplined about diet and exercise. In these cases, given you're not an extreme case, your diet is largely based on consistency. It's not necessarily low or high carb diets (although the extremes obviously create complications), it's about keeping your insulin input consistent. This means you have to keep your "carb" (diabetes isn't all about carbs, but they are the biggest factor in your diet) to exercise ratio relatively consistent, so those that exercise a lot or have high metabolisms often still have high carb diets after diagnosis. The real killer with people who have the wherewithal to manage their diabetes is blood glucose swings, and the swings to the low end are quite a bit more dangerous than those to the high end. You have much less wiggle room for "lows"... using general numbers, a "healthy" blood glucose reading is ~120, a low is <60, and a "high" is >200. While that difference may seem small, a reading of 40 is much more dangerous than a reading of 220, as 40 presents a decent risk of loss of consciousness and other very serious, immediate complications while 220 may cause some long term damage if not controlled but mostly manifests as mental fatigue or irritability. To drive my point home, a reading of 400 is very bad, but quite fixable without professional medical help. A score of 30 or below is serious cause for an itchy 911 trigger finger, and might mean death if the patient has already lost consciousness.
All this is to say: Even in the best case, low carb diets are only for diabetics with a very good A1C and highly controlled and managed diet/exercise/insulin ratios.
Now consider that the vast majority of people with diabetes (see footnote again) are poor, genetically predisposed to obesity, and uneducated. Asking them to manage their diabetes in the first place is hard enough, much less asking them to make substantial lifestyle changes to eat healthily. These people are going to have high carb diets whether they like it or not. Given the dangers of lows on top of this, the responsible thing is to keep them consistent, recommend higher carb diets, and just hope you can help them manage their condition in other ways to the point of maybe not having limbs amputated, losing their sight, or dying at a middle age.
Most of all, though, this is a huge testament to how poorly we're taking care of the diabetes epidemic (yes, it's an epidemic) sweeping our nation. You can point to socio-economic issues, political issues, ecological issues, and so on, but the end result is we are abandoning and failing millions of people with a serious, chronic illness. Organizations like JDRF and the ADA do have serious problems, but at the end of the day they have very few avenues to actually affect change while the root causes still exist. Thus we end up managing symptoms and trying to minimize damage. Sad state all around.
[0] I'm going to blur the line a bit between Type 1 and 2 here. Of course, it's important to note that treatment and management varies wildly between the two but there are good general rules of thumb that apply to both, so i'll stick to those in order to make my point simpler
It also amazes me how people associate some dishes to sodas. For example, at lunch with my colleagues (I'm in France), I observed that when they eat a pizza or a burger, they order a soda. But if they eat a salad, they order a bottle of water!
(I don't like sodas so my opinion is probably oriented)
It's still delicious. Water is still disgusting. I don't drink diet soda because it tastes terrible. Stevia sodas taste worse. But I'd be ecstatic if there was a drink which tasted like soda without the negative effects.
So, yeah, I'm confused over what led you to write your first line given your last line. It's because it's utterly delicious to many of us.
Used to drink 5 mountain dews a day. Havent had one in 10 years now. Much happier.
The guy on that video is well known by Quackwatch. He is a vegan evangelist, and also teaches that proteins are not required in the diet.
It's motivated nonsense.
If anything is nonsense, it's your statement. Can you explain where he suggests such a thing?
http://qz.com/523255/the-us-meat-industrys-wildly-successful...
Eating a diet based heavily on animal products is almost as stupid as smoking cigarettes. If we didn't have so many wonder drugs keeping people who make bad choices alive, it would be obvious by now. Luckily, drug companies and meat peddlers don't have to worry because the propaganda is working... as evidenced by all of the ignorant comments here.
But the link doesn't say much. Very similar arguments are used to discredit climate science ('big climate science') vaccinations ('big pharma') and things that do need discrediting ('big tobacco'). An argument like that has little signal, but it does allow people who are already convinced to post-hoc rationalise their position.
http://healthyeating.sfgate.com/average-fat-intake-sad-11370...
If a pure vegan diet worked for you and your gut bacteria, that's great. It's a challenge for a lot of others.
...and guess who's the bigger culprit for inducing insulin production. Hint: It's not fat.
Regarding the NY Times article itself - it is the usual incoherent nonsense, citing how "USDA began recommending a high-carb, low-fat diet" as if to imply Americans then started eating whole plant foods, instead of added sugars and refined carbohydrate. Ignored also are the many studies pointing out low-carb diets are not satiating and promote weight gain and death (1, 2, 3, 4, 5), which is obvious to anyone who has had an unbiased look into Atkins "nightmare" diets [11]. Who wrote the article? None other than a "director" at an organization paid for by Laura and John D. Arnold, which have substantial ties[6] to animal agriculture industry (Another poster in this thread linked to a website trying to discredit Dr. Greger which the Arnold Foundation also paid for.)
The low-carb ideologues will vehemently deny the current scientific consensus that we should derive a majority of our calories from carbohydrate (7, 8), citing flawed, biased or outright retracted research, akin to deniers of anthropogenic climate change, which is not ironic given animal agriculture also happens to be the leading cause of climate change (9). The long - and the short of it - is that humans are natural plant eaters; whole plant foods are most appropriate to our physiology (10). I, for one, am sick of the carbophobic low-carb propaganda.
. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/7498104 2. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20820038 3. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25246449 4. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19828712 5. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20820038 6. http://www.politico.com/story/2015/10/the-money-behind-the-f... 7. http://www.fao.org/docrep/w8079e/w8079e00.htm 8. http://www8.nationalacademies.org/onpinews/newsitem.aspx?Rec... 9. http://www.worldwatch.org/node/6294 10. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d5wfMNNr3ak 11. http://www.atkinsexposed.org/
1. This doesn't analyze low-carb vs. high-carb diets, it's just a study of satiety indices. The lowest satiety index foods were all high in carbs, as one would expect (croissants, cake and donuts were the bottom three) as were the highest satiety index foods (boiled potatoes). There were only 4 items on a list of 38 items that would be considered acceptable low-carb foods if you were trying to hit the keto subreddit's 20g low-carb diet (cheese, eggs, steak and fish). Everything else had a high amount of carbs, with the next highest protein foods being yoghurt, baked beans and lentils, which all contain significant amounts of carbs.
2. This study compares a low-carb animal diet to a low-carb vegetable diet, and therefore does not address the topic you described.
3. See the prior point.
4. This study compared saturated fat to monounsaturated fat, and thus does not address the question of low-carb vs. high carb diets in particular.
5. This link is a duplicate of 2, so see point 2.
As I said in another comment, these organizations have serious problems that need remedying but they have almost no control over the underlying root causes of the US' diabetes epidemic. I wouldn't necessarily argue against a problem with leadership and a focus on fundraising, but there are thousands of people who work under these organizations who often give up promising careers and their own time and money to make a real difference in communities that are outright ravaged by diabetes. Focusing on orgs like JDRF and the ADA as the "bad guy" only exacerbates the obsession with managing the symptoms as opposed to dealing with the underlying causes (mostly socio economic, political, and ecological in my personal opinion).
If you really want to focus on organizations, lets talk about the FDA and the outright corruption and thievery between Medicare/Medicaid and insurance companies. In the medical industry "diabetes" is a codeword for "huge profits from captive, disadvantaged markets" and until we start addressing those issues no amount of reform in 3rd party orgs will do anything.
The actual truth of the matter is that nutrition is far more complex than any simple summary can give you. The data you get from nutritional and dietary studies is generally so poor in quality that you can find evidence for just about any assertion if you look hard enough.
Reminds me of how our western science has overcomplicated studies on meditation and we are only now learning the benefits of it because our tools are finally sharp enough to our liking (fMRI).
We are lazy. We don't want to actually meditate to learn if it works or not. We just want to strap somebody into a machine without having to do the hard work ourselves. Our nutritionists are lazy as well. Would rather fund all these ridiculous research studies than experiment on their own bodies. Pathetic example of over measuring. Reminds me of how if all you have is a hammer then everything will start to look like a nail.
Part of the reason for this is that there was no surplus of cheap calories and many people died of trauma or infection prior to becoming susceptible to degenerative disease.
As recently as 1900, the primary cause of death in the United States was infectious diseases. All-cause age-adjusted mortality in the population has halved since then. I suppose we could reduce the role of degenerative and "Western" diseases rather dramatically by discontinuing antibiotics and sanitation, but recent trips to Cambodia and Zimbabwe have me wondering if that's really what you want.
> our tools are finally sharp enough to our liking (fMRI).
fMRI is a false positive generating machine. I've never seen shittier statistical analyses than I see in "neuroscience" (at least the mouse guys use controls).
Given the baseline potential for high statistical noise, biological studies in general tend to have poor rigor. fMRI, which you've cited, is notorious for giving problematic results (see the dead salmon study).
There is also the fact that people in different stages of their health react to the same diet in different ways.
So, the diet that might be healthy at one point in your life, is what will sicken you at another.
Having recently made changes to my own eating, which still includes carbs but at a much less extreme amount, I'm amazed at the differences. I don't have diabetes and the doctors say my blood sugar control is very good, but the energy differences I feel before and after eating high carb food is insane.
Diet soda, although technically not containing carbs, prompts a similar insulin response to drinking sugared soda- the result is a blood sugar drop and a loss of energy that makes me want to eat and do nothing; not the best for weight loss.
I would like to see more attention given to what insulin really does: prompt your body to store blood sugar as fat. No wonder filling our bodies with sugar and then using insulin to 'remove' it is a bad idea.