News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Medical guidelines don’t include a diet low in carbohydrates by CPLX on Sunday September 11, 2016 @11:16AM (#12473753)
> Diet soda, although technically not containing carbs, prompts a similar insulin response to drinking sugared soda

Is there any scientific basis for this claim?

Re:Medical guidelines don’t include a diet low in carbohydrates by GarrisonPrime on Sunday September 11, 2016 @12:23PM (#12474089)
I don't have references on hand, but I can tell you that US medical schools are teaching: Artificial sweeteners do not appear to promote as significant an insulin response as digestible sugars do, however they appear to stimulate gluconeogenesis and lipogensis in a similar manner.

In other words, drinking diet soda may not by itself cause problems, but it will stimulate your body to absorb even more of the burger and fries you consumed with the soda (or whatever other metabolites you currently have circulating in your bloodstream).

I'm on mobile now with limited connectivity. I'll try to edit later with a link to a source.

Re:Medical guidelines don’t include a diet low in carbohydrates by nxc18 on Sunday September 11, 2016 @03:42PM (#12475229)
Thanks for the clarification. I was remembering what my doctor and some news articles told me a few years ago, both of which I'm sure gave dumbed down information.

The end result seems to be what I expected, just not the underlying cause. Regardless, it was a huge wake up call to not just treat diet soda like it was basically water.

Re:Medical guidelines don’t include a diet low in carbohydrates by aduitsis on Sunday September 11, 2016 @11:39AM (#12473867)
A 15-second google search reveals this:

http://www.marksdailyapple.com/artificial-sweeteners-insulin...

Some interesting links to pubmed there. Seems that aspartame does not affect insulin fwiw.

Re:Medical guidelines don’t include a diet low in carbohydrates by apathy on Sunday September 11, 2016 @02:33PM (#12474828)
Mark has a bit of an agenda. He is not nearly as full of shit as many others (to include many in academia) but he nonetheless has a financial conflict of interest due to the way he makes a living. I'm not saying he is wrong, but I am saying that you must think critically in the presence of COI.
Re:Medical guidelines don’t include a diet low in carbohydrates by bjterry on Monday September 12, 2016 @01:06AM (#12477326)
Mark Sisson's intellectual rigor is certainly higher than the average blogspam but not as high as the best diet bloggers in the paleo or fitness communities (e.g. Stephan Guyenet, Alan Aragon). That said, his biases would tend to go against artificial sweeteners, rather than towards them. In that article he suggests that you shouldn't eat them, even though he thinks the evidence of their insulin response effects is weak at best. If your point was that you should take all of his advice with a grain of salt, I definitely agree, since he promotes many things which have at most a marginal effect.
Re:Medical guidelines don’t include a diet low in carbohydrates by terhechte on Sunday September 11, 2016 @01:58PM (#12474655)
I also can't find the link right now, but there was a study recently which claimed that Stevia, in particular, did not cause an insulin response after consumption.
Re:Medical guidelines don’t include a diet low in carbohydrates by apathy on Sunday September 11, 2016 @02:32PM (#12474819)
The opposite, actually.

http://care.diabetesjournals.org/content/early/2013/04/30/dc...

Beware of small sample sizes in these sorts of studies. Until you get up into the hundreds or thousands, I personally would expect regression to the mean. Just FYI.

Re:Medical guidelines don’t include a diet low in carbohydrates by DrScump on Sunday September 11, 2016 @09:38PM (#12476661)
No.

that study used sucralose ("Splenda" et al) -- a completely unrelated, artificial sweetener.

Stevia is a naturally occurring plant extract which has steviol glycosides, having 150x the sweetness of sucrose (according to Wikipedia).

Re:Medical guidelines don’t include a diet low in carbohydrates by apathy on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:05PM (#12480860)
I'd edit the original, but some sort of a time limit has passed and I can't. Maybe it's better for people to see that I can't keep the two straight. This is particularly sad since I used to put Splenda in my coffee (since stopped, it's either sugar or nothing for me now) and had a stevia plant on my porch that a neighbor gave me. I couldn't ever get past the "off" taste of stevia, no matter how many times I tried, so eventually I gave up on that too.

Now I'm a little curious what happens to blood insulin when athletes fire down a stevia-flavored source of short chain carbohydrates prior to exercise vs. unflavored. When I have time I'll look it up. The nice thing about this (stevia vs. sugar or vs. artificial sweeteners) is that it lends itself naturally to a two factor design, "natural" vs. not and "real sugar" vs. not, orthogonally.

Anyways, yes, I was wrong about that and will probably fuck it up again in the future, although at least now I'm aware of the problem.

Re:Medical guidelines don’t include a diet low in carbohydrates by luketych on Sunday September 11, 2016 @01:42PM (#12474545)
I get annoyed when people stop a discussion dead in its tracks by asking for references like this, especially when they can easily look it up themselves if they actually cared about the answer rather than winning.

If you think about it, any molecule that isn't sugar but tastes like sugar will have a similar molecular shape to sugar. Hmmmm I wonder if this will fit into receptors in other places in the body, not just on the tongue. Maybe it will affect gut bacteria. Maybe even trigger other events within our bodies.

If we would stop and think with an open mind, many of these arguments would become discussions, and we wouldn't need to play the baby card by asking for proof.

Remember how long it took to finally get enough proof in order to show others how wrong our mainstream religions are? And even with all the evidence we have accumulated, still people say, "show me the proof. I'm a reasonable man." Bullshit.

Let's not fall into this trap again. Many of these questions can be answered without slow, hard science. We don't need to hit everything with the biggest hammer in our toolbox before we can move forward.

Re:Medical guidelines don’t include a diet low in carbohydrates by apathy on Sunday September 11, 2016 @02:26PM (#12474786)
> If you think about it, any molecule that isn't sugar but tastes like sugar will have a similar molecular shape to sugar.

I'm going to go out on a limb here and propose that you may not be a professional medicinal chemist.

Many theories conveniently support your position. Of course, many theories conveniently support the other side. How can we objectively determine who is right?

Well, let's look at (among many, many other experimental studies) http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25786106 which is a recent study of metabolic differences between self-reported aspartame sensitive and non-sensitive individuals. Double-blind, randomised crossover study -- the gold standard. Any differences in metabolic profile between either control/aspartame or sensitive/not? None seen.

However, perhaps all non-nutritive sweeteners are not alike. The same senior author as above ran a separate study in a small sample of athletic males where aspartame in addition to carbohydrates resulted in lower insulin response during exercise: https://jissn.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/1550-2783-9...

Meanwhile, and in a different (grossly obese, NNS-naive) population, sucralose (Stevia) appeared to do the opposite: http://care.diabetesjournals.org/content/early/2013/04/30/dc...

> Many of these questions can be answered without slow, hard science

Sure, if we don't care whether the answers are credible.

Proof by analogy is fraud. If we didn't need evidence to make decisions we wouldn't bother accumulating it.

Re:Medical guidelines don’t include a diet low in carbohydrates by buu700 on Sunday September 11, 2016 @02:58PM (#12474995)
> sucralose (Stevia)

s/Stevia/Splenda/ (stevia is entirely different from sucralose).

Re:Medical guidelines don’t include a diet low in carbohydrates by apathy on Sunday September 11, 2016 @05:21PM (#12475807)
Oh wow I fucked that one up. Thank you for correcting it.
[dead]
[dead]
[dead]
Re:Medical guidelines don’t include a diet low in carbohydrates by sctb on Monday September 12, 2016 @02:42PM (#12482477)
We've banned this account for repeatedly violating the HN guidelines after we've asked you to stop.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Medical guidelines don’t include a diet low in carbohydrates by jschwartzi on Sunday September 11, 2016 @01:52PM (#12474609)
I don't think "keeping an open mind" means accepting statements without evidence until they are debunked. Rather, it means that if evidence arises which contradicts your presuppositions, you must not ignore it.

But this all assumes there is evidence available. Is there?

Re:Medical guidelines don’t include a diet low in carbohydrates by brianwawok on Sunday September 11, 2016 @02:07PM (#12474694)
Google it. There is data. Not beyond refute. It's enough that I don't touch artificial sweeteners. Don't need them in my life anyway.
Re:Medical guidelines don’t include a diet low in carbohydrates by luketych on Sunday September 11, 2016 @02:01PM (#12474664)
What I am trying to say is that if we close our minds right away then we will miss obvious answers. We will tend to overcomplicate things and reach for our most-expensive tools.

I've read "scientific" articles that make use of the most cutting-edge statistical models in order to "prove" that something like "emotional intelligence does not correlate with success."

Ok, poor example, and I made it up. But there are many research articles out there that look impressive because of all the tools they throw at the problem. Under the surface these studies are bunk.

Re:Medical guidelines don’t include a diet low in carbohydrates by apathy on Sunday September 11, 2016 @02:31PM (#12474813)
> Ok, poor example, and I made it up.

Why does this not surprise me?

Outside of mathematics, there really isn't anything resembling proof. There is the weight of the evidence, and the weight of any substantive critiques of bias in said evidence. That's about it.

> But there are many research articles out there that look impressive because of all the tools they throw at the problem. Under the surface these studies are bunk.

On this we can certainly agree. However, the replacement for a bad study is a well-designed study, not some statistical hocus pocus (1) or "going by your gut".

If your position is sound, there will (at some point) be someone bold and independently-funded enough to torpedo the status quo with a properly designed experiment. It may not happen as fast as you'd like. But there is nothing that academics like better than turning their rivals' sacred cows into hamburger. Of this I can assure you.

(1) I am a statistician, both professionally and by graduate training. I have no qualms about dismissing poorly designed studies regardless of post-hoc jiggery-pokery. A shiny autopsy won't reanimate the corpse of a dead experiment.

Re:Medical guidelines don’t include a diet low in carbohydrates by luketych on Sunday September 11, 2016 @08:12PM (#12476387)
Again, you are cherrypicking any flaw you see and then attacking. For a logically-trained person you are misusing it. Being overly logical can become a negative when it is used to justify your already-held beliefs.

I do not care what you think at this point, this has already blossomed into a 1 vs 1, so anything said will just make both sides more justified in their position.

This is about onlookers. Hacker News is flawed in the same way that elections are flawed. Every user is given the same power of opinion. A losing strategy that will eventually begin to conform to the middle of the pack, condemning any opinions falling too far from the centre.

Apathy, I have to ask you. If you are getting all the votes, all the +1's, all the likes, would you ever think that maybe that is not a good sign?

Re:Medical guidelines don’t include a diet low in carbohydrates by apathy on Sunday September 11, 2016 @09:35PM (#12476648)
I wouldn't say that HN is flawed the way elections are, because non readers aren't affected by what goes on here (I hope).

You logic strikes me as specious -- the proximity of an idea to the mushy middle is orthogonal to whether it is correct. Great ideas are often met with violent opposition -- but shitty ideas are, too. If I thought most people on HN were in fact dumbasses, as most of the electorate often seems to be, I would go somewhere else. It's the least worst forum (save perhaps Metafilter) I've found so it's a place where I go to procrastinate.

My job is to write, so my natural impulse when I see something that seems easily dismantled is to get in a bit of practice.

Re:Medical guidelines don’t include a diet low in carbohydrates by luketych on Monday September 12, 2016 @04:42AM (#12478086)
Well then you are getting better at applying logic blindly.
Re:Medical guidelines don’t include a diet low in carbohydrates by asldjhcakjhc on Sunday September 11, 2016 @02:33PM (#12474826)
You can usually make up a bunch of conflicting stories about how some chemical will affect the body. For example, I could claim that there is an evolutionary basis for the body to assume that the taste of sugar means that food has been successfully obtained, and to react by being less conservative with calories, and reward us with a dopamine rush. Sounds like a great time to exercise!

Anyway, we can be lost in a sea of doubt with all our pet theories, or we can look at the available evidence.