News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Medical guidelines don’t include a diet low in carbohydrates by rayiner on Sunday September 11, 2016 @11:21AM (#12473783)
Of course they are. People continuing to get diabetes is how they get funding for their organization.
Re:Medical guidelines don’t include a diet low in carbohydrates by pdeuchler on Sunday September 11, 2016 @03:16PM (#12475082)
This is seriously messed up.

As I said in another comment, these organizations have serious problems that need remedying but they have almost no control over the underlying root causes of the US' diabetes epidemic. I wouldn't necessarily argue against a problem with leadership and a focus on fundraising, but there are thousands of people who work under these organizations who often give up promising careers and their own time and money to make a real difference in communities that are outright ravaged by diabetes. Focusing on orgs like JDRF and the ADA as the "bad guy" only exacerbates the obsession with managing the symptoms as opposed to dealing with the underlying causes (mostly socio economic, political, and ecological in my personal opinion).

If you really want to focus on organizations, lets talk about the FDA and the outright corruption and thievery between Medicare/Medicaid and insurance companies. In the medical industry "diabetes" is a codeword for "huge profits from captive, disadvantaged markets" and until we start addressing those issues no amount of reform in 3rd party orgs will do anything.

Re:Medical guidelines don’t include a diet low in carbohydrates by GarrisonPrime on Sunday September 11, 2016 @12:26PM (#12474097)
It's amazing how many people are ignorant of this logic, and go around wondering why big companies and governments always seem to be offering band-aids and aspirins, but never cures. :)
Re:Medical guidelines don’t include a diet low in carbohydrates by jcranmer on Sunday September 11, 2016 @12:59PM (#12474291)
By that logic, everyone peddling any kind of diet, including paleo or keto or whatever diet is the fad of the day, is insincere.

The actual truth of the matter is that nutrition is far more complex than any simple summary can give you. The data you get from nutritional and dietary studies is generally so poor in quality that you can find evidence for just about any assertion if you look hard enough.

Re:Medical guidelines don’t include a diet low in carbohydrates by luketych on Sunday September 11, 2016 @01:27PM (#12474452)
Oh come on.. Nutrition is not that complicated. It only looks complicated because we are looking too closely at the details, resulting in myopia. We are overthinking it. For hundreds of thousands of years people didn't even know what a nutrient was, and yet they ate properly and never got any of these western problems.

Reminds me of how our western science has overcomplicated studies on meditation and we are only now learning the benefits of it because our tools are finally sharp enough to our liking (fMRI).

We are lazy. We don't want to actually meditate to learn if it works or not. We just want to strap somebody into a machine without having to do the hard work ourselves. Our nutritionists are lazy as well. Would rather fund all these ridiculous research studies than experiment on their own bodies. Pathetic example of over measuring. Reminds me of how if all you have is a hammer then everything will start to look like a nail.

Re:Medical guidelines don’t include a diet low in carbohydrates by apathy on Sunday September 11, 2016 @02:38PM (#12474868)
> For hundreds of thousands of years people didn't even know what a nutrient was, and yet they ate properly and never got any of these western problems.

Part of the reason for this is that there was no surplus of cheap calories and many people died of trauma or infection prior to becoming susceptible to degenerative disease.

As recently as 1900, the primary cause of death in the United States was infectious diseases. All-cause age-adjusted mortality in the population has halved since then. I suppose we could reduce the role of degenerative and "Western" diseases rather dramatically by discontinuing antibiotics and sanitation, but recent trips to Cambodia and Zimbabwe have me wondering if that's really what you want.

> our tools are finally sharp enough to our liking (fMRI).

fMRI is a false positive generating machine. I've never seen shittier statistical analyses than I see in "neuroscience" (at least the mouse guys use controls).

Re:Medical guidelines don’t include a diet low in carbohydrates by jcranmer on Sunday September 11, 2016 @03:46PM (#12475252)
The plural of anecdote is not data. Yes, it's a pithy saying, but it's completely true. Scientific validity requires changing one variable, and only one variable, and seeing if there is an observed effect. The real world is noisy, and anything involving biology incredibly so, which means you need larger sample sizes to distinguish signal from noise. We also know that there is some degree of mental control over physiology--see psychosomatic disorders and the placebo effect--but controlling for that is fiendishly difficult when you can't double-blind the study.

Given the baseline potential for high statistical noise, biological studies in general tend to have poor rigor. fMRI, which you've cited, is notorious for giving problematic results (see the dead salmon study).

Re:Medical guidelines don’t include a diet low in carbohydrates by bobdole1234 on Monday September 12, 2016 @09:47AM (#12479616)
No, it really is that complicated.

There is also the fact that people in different stages of their health react to the same diet in different ways.

So, the diet that might be healthy at one point in your life, is what will sicken you at another.