News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is HTTP Public Key Pinning Dead? by jb613 on Tuesday September 06, 2016 @11:32AM (#12436713)
> 2. Don't HPKP your blog. Don't HPKP your cat-sharing starting. Key pinning is a good thing, but it doesn't need to be universally deployed.

Just to be clear, this is equivalent to saying don't bother with SSL for your blog or cat-sharing site (because without pinning someone else can get a cert for your blog/cat-sharing site).

> the ability for sites with low security requirements to opt out of HPKP.

opt out?! It's off by default.

> Remember, the threat model for HPKP isn't fraudsters or trolls; it's state-level adversaries.

Again, by saying HPKP is only for high security sites (now you're saying only for those threatened by state-level adversaries) you are essentially saying SSL is useless for everything less.

Re:Is HTTP Public Key Pinning Dead? by pcl on Tuesday September 06, 2016 @11:57AM (#12436921)
> > the ability for sites with low security requirements to opt out of HPKP.

> opt out?! It's off by default.

I think tptacek meant that a site owner should be able to explicitly declare that nobody should be able to pin a key, so that nobody can hijack the site in the future.

Re:Is HTTP Public Key Pinning Dead? by nsgi on Tuesday September 06, 2016 @12:55PM (#12437395)
An opt-in would make more sense, since people using HPKP are those that know the most about it. Just like an opt-out, it would have to be via a different channel than HTTP headers.
Re:Is HTTP Public Key Pinning Dead? by jb613 on Tuesday September 06, 2016 @12:20PM (#12437103)
Fine, but take note that leaves the door open for others to get a cert for your domain.
Re:Is HTTP Public Key Pinning Dead? by pfg on Tuesday September 06, 2016 @12:04PM (#12436976)
That's an odd argument to make. You're essentially saying if you can't afford the most secure safe for your jewelry, just put it in a basket in front of your door instead of getting a cheaper safe that keeps most thieves out.
Re:Is HTTP Public Key Pinning Dead? by jb613 on Tuesday September 06, 2016 @12:19PM (#12437098)
By suggesting HPKP is only for sites worried about nation state adversaries means deploying SSL without HPKP which leaves the door open for adversaries to get a cert issued for your domain.
Re:Is HTTP Public Key Pinning Dead? by pfg on Tuesday September 06, 2016 @12:35PM (#12437239)
Right, I don't think you got my point. You don't always need the best option. CAs are far from perfect, but the threat model for a blog or a cat-sharing site is unlikely to include adversaries who are capable of compromising a CA (whether they're nation-state adversaries or not). SSL without HPKP is probably good enough for you in that case. Saying that the traditional CA system without HPKP is as bad as a plaintext protocol is silly.
Re:Is HTTP Public Key Pinning Dead? by jb613 on Tuesday September 06, 2016 @12:50PM (#12437359)
You are underestimating 1) the number of CA's embedded in your browser, 2) how easy it is to get one of those CA's to issue a cert for someone else's domain.
Re:Is HTTP Public Key Pinning Dead? by bulatb on Tuesday September 06, 2016 @11:56AM (#12436912)
I think "opt out" means opting out of being able to be pinned, not just choosing not to pin. Instead of pinning a certificate, you might pin "This domain will not be pinning a certificate before $date."
Re:Is HTTP Public Key Pinning Dead? by jb613 on Tuesday September 06, 2016 @12:21PM (#12437112)
Fine but then you're leaving open the possibility for others to get a cert for your domain.
Re:Is HTTP Public Key Pinning Dead? by vfaronov on Tuesday September 06, 2016 @11:36AM (#12436751)
Not bothering with TLS for a blog is likely to be a good idea.
Re:Is HTTP Public Key Pinning Dead? by jb613 on Tuesday September 06, 2016 @11:41AM (#12436797)
That's outdated thinking. Look around at the efforts in past ~year for getting SSL everywhere. Non-SSL sites already suffer Google PageRanking[1] (maybe you want Google visibility for your blog or cat-sharing site), other consequences are not far off.

[1] HTTPS as a ranking signal: https://webmasters.googleblog.com/2014/08/https-as-ranking-s...

Re:Is HTTP Public Key Pinning Dead? by KMag on Tuesday September 06, 2016 @01:00PM (#12437424)
Well, TLS (allong with access controls) for his sing-along blog would have really helped Dr. Horrible stay ahead of the authorities.

In all seriousness, though, there are plenty of blogs where which page a user visits might, for instance, out a gay teen via gateway logs, hint about a private health issue, etc.