Re:Is HTTP Public Key Pinning Dead?
by pfg on Tuesday September 06, 2016 @12:04PM
(#12436976)
That's an odd argument to make. You're essentially saying if you can't afford the most secure safe for your jewelry, just put it in a basket in front of your door instead of getting a cheaper safe that keeps most thieves out.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
By suggesting HPKP is only for sites worried about nation state adversaries means deploying SSL without HPKP which leaves the door open for adversaries to get a cert issued for your domain.
Right, I don't think you got my point. You don't always need the best option. CAs are far from perfect, but the threat model for a blog or a cat-sharing site is unlikely to include adversaries who are capable of compromising a CA (whether they're nation-state adversaries or not). SSL without HPKP is probably good enough for you in that case. Saying that the traditional CA system without HPKP is as bad as a plaintext protocol is silly.