News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by Throwaway23412 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @05:35PM (#12409092)
>Not only does this trolling for raise bait waste hiring managers’ time, but employees who are “won back” with a counter-offer are still more likely to leave the employer within the year, SHRM noted.

People often think that this phenomenon occurs because employers decide afterwards to fire the employee who has recently gotten that significant raise. From what I've seen anecdotally in /r/personalfinance, what really happens is that employees realize that they've been undervalued for an extended period of time. If a well-performing employee has been getting paltry 2% raises for months or years and their employer quickly matches an offer of double their salary, it leaves a bad taste in a lot of employees' mouths.

It makes me wonder if loyalty was ever really valued in past generations or if loyalty was really just some fanciful meme perpetrated by employers to keep costs down. I often hear that short periods of time spent at jobs is a negative signal to hiring managers but I seldom hear anyone actually point to it as the reason they weren't hired for a job.

Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by alistairSH on Thursday September 01, 2016 @07:21PM (#12409567)
I often hear that short periods of time spent at jobs is a negative signal to hiring managers but I seldom hear anyone actually point to it as the reason they weren't hired for a job.

Last year, we declined to interview several candidates who had jumped from job to job (many 6-12 month stints over many years, and not doing independent consulting/contracting).

We also discovered after several interviews that candidates who were jumping from one government contract to another regularly were often not being re-hired when contracts renewed/moved (because they were mediocre employees).

The best candidates we interviewed were typically staying at jobs 3-6 years. I assume this was long enough to do some real work, possibly over several projects, but not long enough to stagnate.

These were mid-career and senior developer positions in the DC area.

Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by phaus on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:02PM (#12409769)
>We also discovered after several interviews that candidates who were jumping from one government contract to another regularly were often not being re-hired when contracts renewed/moved (because they were mediocre employees).

This depends on the organization. Some government shops have an annual recompete for pretty much all of their contracts and ALWAYS go with the cheapest option, even if it totally fucks everything up and costs more in the long run. I worked for a government organization where every year we got an opportunity to re-interview for the same jobs at lower rates (with the company that underbid our old employer and put us out of with without even having employees of their own), in spite of the fact that our first line supervisors were happy with our work. It took me a while to get out of that hellhole. I'm glad no one held it against me when I applied for a non-contracting job. I've been in my current position for 2.5 years and I don't plan on leaving any time soon.

Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by alistairSH on Friday September 02, 2016 @02:57PM (#12415340)
Absolutely true, and if the resume indicated they were moving companies as contracts moved[1], that was fine. It was the short timeframe hopping from unrelated contracts that was a sure sign of incompetence.

1 - We saw some resumes that were grouped by contract or government agency rather than by actual employer for just this reason.

Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by sokoloff on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:15PM (#12409821)
I absolutely look negatively on a candidate who has never had a 2-year stint on their resume and has never gotten a promotion with the same company. It's not an absolute bar, but it's a negative signal for sure.

I'm not worried about job-hopping because of ambition that can't be met at a given company, but I am worried about incompetence that takes a while to ferret out and causes job hopping in that 9-18 month window.

Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by scarface74 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:51PM (#12409995)
I've been working professionally as a software developer for 20 years and I'm doing the same thing now I did 20 years ago - programming. Of course not at the same company. So I've never "gotten a promotion". If I'm lucky, I can go another 20 years without being promoted. I like development and I would die a thousand deaths if I had to be a manager. I would probably leave any company that forced a promotion on me.
Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by lacksconfidence on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:57PM (#12410016)
It perhaps depends on where you work, but here is one example of levels of promotion while still being a programmer and not a manager (at google):

Software Engineer 2

Software Engineer 3

Senior Engineer

Staff Engineer

Senior Staff Engineer

Principal Engineer

Distinguished Engineer

Google Fellow

Senior Google Fellow

Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by NateDad on Friday September 02, 2016 @12:02AM (#12410752)
Lots of places don't have formal categories. Canonical, the place I work now, just has "Software Engineer". Job titles are dumb. So, I have a different name beside my picture in the company directory? Great. Does that help me pay my mortgage? Does it make the people who work with me every day respect me any more or less? Nope.
Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by vizeroth on Friday September 02, 2016 @01:44AM (#12411098)
In my first job, 70+% of the work force within the division had the same job title, and any number on that title had a pay range associated with it that could easily cover many years of mediocre raises with little basis on performance. During the 10 years I was there, my job title changed twice, with the second change reverting to the previous title (including an associated pay increase for both title changes), because the division did not have enough work that they could give to someone with that particular title.

In my second job, I was a Software Developer 3 for 5 years with relatively good annual raises, and I worked on two different contracts in that time. The only way my title would have been likely to change would have been due to being hired onto a contract that required different titles (Web Developer or Software Engineer, for example), or to move up to a Lead Developer, which would have been somewhere between a developer and a manager. With that employer, moving from Developer to Lead meant that a Lead quit on your contract (and you interviewed for it) or you were hired onto a different contract as a Lead.

With my current employer, the numbers were removed from the job titles several years ago. For the most part, raises are even worse than they were with my first employer, and job-hopping internally is the only way most people can see a significant raise, regardless of merit. Promotions come from people in higher positions leaving, which seems less likely (except through retirement) than I've seen elsewhere, but you have to apply/interview for the promotion against internal and external applicants. Most of the people in this location which make more money with the same title have been hired in the 4 years since I started, and I make roughly 50% more than my co-worker with the same title who has held his job for over 10 years. On the good side, there are still a couple of other job titles I'm qualified to hold before I become a manager (though again I'm tempted with that Lead Programmer title which blends the roles). On the bad side, there isn't a lot of chance of vertical movement, so it's a struggle between the comfort of the known environment and the internal job search to see if anything interesting is posted.

Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by sjg007 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:24PM (#12409860)
Many companies are not fair with respect to promotions. And it depends on the strength of your manager.
Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by wott on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:59PM (#12410023)
What's a promotion? Is it a progression in job titles rank like Americans seem to fancy (junior/senior, engineer I/II/III, etc.)?

Because their was no such thing in the 2 countries were I worked.

Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by greenshackle on Thursday September 01, 2016 @06:00PM (#12409221)
> I often hear that short periods of time spent at jobs is a negative signal to hiring managers but I seldom hear anyone actually point to it as the reason they weren't hired for a job.

Would the candidate know it if that was the reason? Do hiring managers usually give truthful feedback or generic platitudes?

I'm genuinely wondering, it occurs to me now I've never been turned down after an interview, or fired.

Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by emodendroket on Thursday September 01, 2016 @06:50PM (#12409448)
No, it is extremely rare to share such feedback, because it opens the door to quibbling with your reasons.
Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by greenshackle on Friday September 02, 2016 @11:46AM (#12413813)
I figured they wouldn't.
Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by Spooky23 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:49PM (#12409984)
It's pretty dumb to give honest feedback.
Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by tibbetts on Friday September 02, 2016 @02:35AM (#12411283)
Or at least not helpful if it is things someone can't change. "You should work on your software engineering skills at a big company known for doing that well" is actionable in a way "changing jobs so often makes us worried it's a problem with you not them" is not.
Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by twblalock on Thursday September 01, 2016 @06:44PM (#12409415)
> I often hear that short periods of time spent at jobs is a negative signal to hiring managers but I seldom hear anyone actually point to it as the reason they weren't hired for a job.

In tech, I don't think job-hopping is frowned upon much at all. The most successful engineers and tech executives I know rarely spend more than two years at a company before moving on.

Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by Spooky23 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:54PM (#12410005)
Anyone that I've met like that is either a consultant or a shitshow.

Two years is about the timeframe where your mistakes and technical debt start to bite back. If people are moving up hopping like that, they're great self promoters.

Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by flukus on Thursday September 01, 2016 @09:23PM (#12410134)
I move on that often because the companies already have tonnes of technical debt.
Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by justinlardinois on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:53PM (#12409998)
I think it also depends on your definition of "job hopping." Sure, two years each at your last three jobs isn't frowned upon in tech, but six months each is.

I'm sure there are some industries that would raise eyebrows at two years, of course.

Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by rodgerd on Thursday September 01, 2016 @06:31PM (#12409360)
> it leaves a bad taste in a lot of employees' mouths.

So it should. I worked for a CTO who signed off on getting rid of a vendor with the rationale that the last-ditch radical license cut they offered, to keep the business, was adding insult to injury. "You've been screwing me for five years and now you want to make it better? You should have given me your best price from the start."

Why would employees be any different?

Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by sokoloff on Thursday September 01, 2016 @07:43PM (#12409671)
For me, the past is the past. If I'd been being underpaid and was now being overpaid, I'm going to focus on the latter not the former. It's not like I can go back and right the wrong (real or perceived) that was done to me, so I focus on now and forward.
Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by emodendroket on Thursday September 01, 2016 @06:49PM (#12409444)
In my case it was more like my employer was resentful and started curtailing all the aspects of the job that made me want to stay (suddenly becoming very strict about never working from home and being in at exactly the appointed hour when this had never previously been an issue, for instance).
Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by lj3 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @07:11PM (#12409528)
How people perceive value is a weird thing. Large raises suddenly makes some employers re-evaluate what they're getting for their money's worth. In their eyes, they're paying more money (sometimes a LOT more money) for essentially no change in work. That's profit out of their pocket and that makes them resentful. They don't look at new hires that same way, no matter what they cost, because they're getting an increase in workload for that spent money.

I don't at all agree with the above mindset, but I can easily see how somebody can look at it that way.

Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by wyclif on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:00PM (#12409759)
This is a big reason why I tend to think that it's almost always better (some qualifiers apply) to take a new job instead of trying to get a raise after your comp has been "anchored" by the company.
Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by justinlardinois on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:55PM (#12410009)
Of course. You're already got an offer in hand from a company that believes you're worth a certain amount of money; why go through the potential landmine of trying to convince your current company of the same?
Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by emodendroket on Friday September 02, 2016 @08:34AM (#12412573)
Well, the temptation is that you are happy with aspects of your job other than the pay. But I wouldn't do it again.
Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by wyclif on Thursday September 01, 2016 @10:45PM (#12410463)
Even when you don't have an offer in hand, it may very well be the case.
Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by tcoppi on Thursday September 01, 2016 @07:13PM (#12409537)
This is definitely an interesting aspect of human psychology that some places seem to be able to work around, like Google, which from what I understand is able to compensate their employees well relative to the market without them needing to job hop.
Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by emodendroket on Thursday September 01, 2016 @07:25PM (#12409587)
Among other things, Google is huge and so it's less personal.
Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by emodendroket on Thursday September 01, 2016 @07:25PM (#12409582)
It wasn't a for-profit business but there was definitely some sense that I was some young upstart who didn't know his place. Whatever, it's water under the bridge now.
Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by a3n on Friday September 02, 2016 @03:04AM (#12411414)
> or if loyalty was really just some fanciful meme perpetrated by employers to keep costs down.

That one. Employers who invoke loyalty and passion won't hesitate to unloyally drop if they're costing too much for the money taken in. Which is appropriate. But then they expect individuals to bear the "cost" of working for less at their business, than for more at some other business.

It is to laugh.

Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by mathattack on Tuesday September 06, 2016 @12:17PM (#12437080)
I've dinged folks pre-interview for having too many job hops. It's not an issue for junior candidates, but if I see someone who has 12 jobs in 10 years, and I know the goals of the position I'm hiring for are 2-3 years, I won't bother. The person could be great for a lot of things, but the track record suggests they're not the person for long term goals and objective. Or during an interview, it would be hard to ask, "Can you show me a goal that you worked towards over many years."

Anecdotally - someone getting increasing responsibility over many roles at a company is a great sign. The people that know them the best are promoting them and keeping them happy. Someone hopping too frequently, or keeping the same job with no switch over long (10?) year horizons is a bad sign. The latter could be a case of specialization so I'd still interview, but one needs to be careful.

To your point about loyalty as an excuse to underpay - my experience is Sort Of. When large companies like AT&T and P&G first had to do big layoffs, it did hurt the management teams. They weren't used to it, and were very generous. After a couple rounds, they got over it and got cheaper. (Severance packages almost always get worse over time, not better) And I saw many phone company employees hang on for 2 or 3 more years to get the company retirement party. On the one hand the company got to underpay them for several years just for them to "earn" a $300 party for some colleagues. On the other hand, perhaps the company didn't really need them the last few years, but still held them on.

Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by aidenn0 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @07:57PM (#12409746)
Since the pay at your next job is correlated with your past pay for a variety of reasons, I just assumed that the raise made it easier for the employees already thinking of leaving to get a higher paying job elsewhere.
Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by tcoppi on Thursday September 01, 2016 @06:57PM (#12409472)
> I often hear that short periods of time spent at jobs is a negative signal to hiring managers but I seldom hear anyone actually point to it as the reason they weren't hired for a job.

I have yet to stay at a job for more than ~2 years over my career, and I still get 2-3 recruiters a week pounding at my door for relevant jobs that would probably be a salary match or beat over what I currently have. So at least for me it hasn't hurt me yet.

Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by caminante on Thursday September 01, 2016 @06:48PM (#12409440)
OTOH, I've seen companies STILL overspending on loyalty. For example, super major oil companies are still obsessed with nurturing generalist managers who keep lateraling across divisions over a 40 year career.

Talk with their "career development experts," and you'd swear that you're dealing with a cult!

Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by h4nkoslo on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:36PM (#12409916)
Oil companies in particular have enormous fixed investments in particular bits of infrastructure with their own particular nuances, long-running relations with particular governments, etc. It actually makes sense to invest heavily in people who know where the bodies are buried.
Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by caminante on Thursday September 01, 2016 @09:14PM (#12410085)
Ha! Though, if that were the case, I don't see the benefits of the LATERAL advancements. You're just moving the morticians from one mortuary to another instead of leaving them in one place.
Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by h4nkoslo on Friday September 02, 2016 @01:26AM (#12411034)
You maintain favorable access to that information, and your people get to see different scenery instead of being stuck in one particular, usually crappy, locale.

"Hey Bill, back when you worked that field off of Malaysia - was the minister's son more of a whisky guy or a hookers guy? He's the minister now & he's causing trouble."

Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by vacri on Thursday September 01, 2016 @07:57PM (#12409745)
> has been getting paltry 2% raises for months

What a weird bubble we live in where a 2% raise of the course of months is dismissed as 'paltry'.

Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by Throwaway23412 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @09:38PM (#12410198)
Bubble? I thought I was being conservative in choosing 2% as a number. Yearly inflation in the past averaged over 2%. I'll admit that the past two years has seen record low interest rates, but 2% raises are hardly a recent phenomenon.
Re:When they don’t want new jobs, just more money by gpderetta on Friday September 02, 2016 @09:28AM (#12412850)
The wording of the original comment could be reasonably interpreted asdescribing a rise of 2% month. That's a pretty good rise rate!