There is no possible way it can convert into a sprawling metropolis when the muni "lines" all share one basic tube and one path. It's a joke.
New York works because even when the president is in town you can get from downtown to uptown in 15 minutes on an express train. I can barely move 10 blocks in SF in that same time at 5pm.
I think the tech activity will move elsewhere in 30 years.
It was very forward-thinking of local governments to create these parks and open spaces back when the there was no demand for the land.
The City Council just voted 45-0 against rezoning an Inwood project that would have allowed for 3 measly more stories of housing on a building that can as of right have 14 stories. God forbid if we actually have to build real amounts of housing, preferably non-subsidized. As a NYC resident and market-rate renter, I'm sick and tired of paying for everyone else's rent when they will not lift a finger to help alleviate my burden.
On top of that, the power of the NIMBYs is significantly stronger in the outer boros than it is in Manhattan (especially Queens and Staten Island). Once you reach city limits they are all powerful (Nassau, Suffolk, Westchester).
Then there's Chris Christie's killing of the ARC project and the worrying lack of new transit capacity. It's most acute over the Hudson, but the pending doom for Williamsburg highlights the mass transit system's lack of resiliency outside of core Manhattan.
I don't want to get too political especially on local politics which is probably not of much interest to most HN readers, but Bloomberg left BdB use a very solid economic position and a couple of ambitious transit plans in the works or almost finished (7 extension, east side access and 2nd ave). Since BdB has become mayor he started a war with the governor and his only proposals for new transit projects are frankly dumb (the trolley down the east side of the East River and the new ferries).
This is literally every place I've ever lived, both big and small. Everyone wants to be the last person to move to a place.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Proposition_13_(197...
Sure. But at what cost? And paid by who? And for how long?
When we're preserving someone's memories of SF from 1965 at a huge cost to everyone who has the temerity to be under 45, it may be time to maybe possibly consider a re-evaluation of the balance of costs and benefits.
If preserving things for your parents means a hundred working-class families get pushed out by rents rising because your parents' memories require no new housing built, the balance of policy exhibits significant opportunity for improvement.
The past is important, but it's not healthy for the future to be enslaved to the past. Your parents, too, are a trend that will change.
Do you think the people protected by prop 13 deserve to be protected and the people living in apartments in the Mission don't? What about anyone moving to the area now and getting hammered with $3k+ rent?
Prop 13, by itself and in isolation, is not a bad thing. In SF specifically and the Bay in general, it has had very nasty and pernicious knock-on effects that harm everyone. It's pushing out the people who made the area what it is - the very people prop 13 is supposed to protect!
In short, I agree with you. Pushing people out of their homes is not cool. We should pursue policies that don't cause people to be pushed out of their homes.
Second, prop 13 has contributed to the current insanity by created a privileged group that acts to protect their privilege. They protect their privilege by becoming ferocious NIMBYs and other means. This means that housing for people not currently covered by prop 13 is more expensive than it needs to be.
Changing prop 13 is not sufficient to fix an insane rental market, but we really should consider a potential re-examination of a policy that has helped push a great many people out of their homes. Pushing people out of their homes is not cool. We should consider maybe doing less of it.
Your analysis would be correct in a context where both supply and demand for housing are constant... and also assuming that maintenance costs never, ever change. However, prop 13 helps to discourage land sales and new construction, resulting in a supply that grows much more slowly than demand. This drives prices up, especially in areas like the Bay that have been under-building housing for decades. Higher prices results in landlords incentivized to find ways to throw out rent-controlled tenants and outright prices out many working-class families.
Also the costs of things like building upgrades and plumbers can sometimes go up year-to-year.
In short, keeping property taxes fixed to 1970s-era for grandma with multi-million dollar property results in people getting pushed out of their homes. This is perhaps just a bit less than ideal.
http://static6.businessinsider.com/image/5342ef126da811ef6ab...
Most of this probably heavy romanticizing on my part but nonetheless, the general awareness of ones place in the world must be much stronger if you grow up in NYC, compared to other parts of the world.
Not that they're stupid, there's nothing north or east of SF, and NYC is very far away. Much dilution on what an actual global city is.
New York definitely has its NIMBY crowd, and people will scream about development in certain places under certain situations, but on the whole it seems to be an entirely different culture towards growth. As a longtime NYC resident, my feeling at least is that everyone here basically agrees on the premise that they are going to live in a giant, incredibly dense, tall, interconnected city that looks like a city. People might lament loss of historic buildings, get annoyed by the aesthetics of cookie cutter towers, or get seriously concerned at lower income people being ignored by builders, but we do get that we live in a big city.
From the outside, it seems like the Bay Area is completely schizophrenic. San Francisco has obvious big city problems that seem largely unaddressed. The Valley is completely dominated by automobile-scale planning with a way of life based on four story office parks surrounded by parking lots, a fundamentally broken model. And the people with real money seem to want to continue some fantasy that everyone is living in a bucolic nature preserve rather than the choked up global megacity that clearly surrounds them.
I have little doubt that NYC will, in fact, just get much much bigger over the next 20 years, and will generally have the same fundamental structure and urban fabric. The Valley on the other hand seems like it's going to need to change course.