1) You're always looking over your shoulder, and can't think about long term projects or work.
2) The first people out (frequently the weakest performers) are able to find jobs the easiest, but by the time the better employees are also let go, the market demand has been filled.
3) It encourages and environment of non-cooperation. Employees cooperate more when they think they'll see each other again. If it's "there's 3 of us here today, and probably only 2 in a few months" then there are multiple incentives to not compete.
Better to get it over with all at once wherever possible. Companies that need multiple rounds are usually either mis-run or in markets deteriorating extremely rapidly.
From my experience there's an easy way out of this: take control of your own career. Ask yourself: are these the conditions I want to work in? whats best for me; family; situation? Are there opportunities here while everyone else is looking over their shoulder?
The uncertainty will cause a lot of stress. As a red badge at Cisco some years back, layoff talks used to cause me serious anxiety, even though my parent company would just move me to another project.
The bigger problem with Cisco is that people speculate about layoffs and there are continual leaks. This really upsets employees, and causes considerable emotional pain for them.
Redundancies are absolutely best done as one-and-done.
Also, would this be a record number of staff laid off in one go 'by choice'? 14,000 is huge. Poor guys.
I was next.
Got fired at end of financial year, along with a couple thousand others. Had a new job before the day was out (another result of said anxiety).
Being laid off is termination without cause. You're just being let go as part of a workforce reduction.
Being fired because you are performing poorly in your job is, crazily enough, not "fired for cause" but simply "fired".
Being fired "for cause" usually makes one ineligible for unemployment income.
Being one of 14,000 employees let go because they chose to eliminate that entire half of the company doesn't necessarily mean anything. Being one of four engineers chosen to be let go from a team of 20 can say something about your skill level.
Have you ever actually been part of a company that did layoffs in chunks like you're suggesting? Experiencing that type of protracted wave of layoffs is not fun at all. In fact, it was down right miserable. Going to work each day with the threat of layoff looming over your head is an incredibly stressful experience.
You might consider that there is more at play than just a few executives getting greedy about dollars.
I can't fault them for not giving their all every day... I know for a fact I would instantly put in the minimal amount of work required after achieving tenure / seniority / whatever at a large organization.
This is not necessarily true.
It's more like - as you add people to the pile, you get diminishing marginal returns on value-added for each person yo add.
Trust me - older products that are hardened, and sold through established channels - those are where the juicy profits come from! Nobody wants to mess with that!
It means that the company has realized it's in a head-wind, and is cutting costs in order to deal with it. Layoffs are usually coincident with a re-structuring.
Ergo - layoffs mean 'the company is adjusting to new market realities' - which is what investors want to hear.
Layoffs usually happen after the 'crappy state' of a company has been priced into the stock ... so there's usually only upside.
Also - all things considered, a layoff simply means less cost and likely an uptick in profitability, which in a spreadsheet analysis gives a higher valuation.
Cisco is doing a major layoff because they have a new CEO who wants to wipe the board clean and start his term fresh. This is very cynical ... but often true.
Finally - some companies do layoffs long before they are truly necessary. It's 'house cleaning' for them. Cisco does this. Because Cisco is an otherwise strong company, a layoff is good.
This is not like a 'Yahoo layoff' wherein it's just sending people off a sinking ship. So - an otherwise 'strong' company doing kind of a 'ruthless' layoff is usually seen as a good thing in investors eyes.
Another explanation could be that massive layoffs has caused stock uptick in the past and therefore it makes sense to bet that the same thing will also happen this time. (Of course this only makes sense for those who are first to react to the news)
How about this famous short? Soros made a billion dollars.
https://priceonomics.com/the-trade-of-the-century-when-georg...
Did you see/read "The Big Short?"
CSCO will use it to refocus their efforts into more valuable services, which by itself will entail some level of hiring & investment, and if successful, they'll hire & invest more.
If you think this is an optimistic perspective, consider the alternative...CSCO continues employing people who aren't optimally productive for its goals, and ultimately the whole company runs into the ground and EVERYONE needs new jobs.
Layoffs are an unappealing and emotionally-charged but necessary part of the corporate lifecycle.
http://www.recode.net/2016/2/10/11587764/cisco-soars-on-15-b...
It's hard to picture, since that cash is going from one entity (CSCO) to a lot of different entities (the market), but obviously CSCO thinks the market can make better use of that capital than it can.
The only thing that could be worse than what they're doing, in my view, is if they fired all these people and sat on their cash, AAPL-style.
It seems more likely they'll keep the savings as a quick fix to make them look better to investors. As noted in the article, these rumors are coming out close to announcing their fourth-quarter results.
On a personal level, this sucks for those Cisco employees. But it's weird that the land of disruption advocates "wasting" money on unneeded labour. There isn't much sympathy for the taxi drivers Uber is harming.
Americans almost never use off-shore tax havens, because the IRS has no boundaries on chasing them down. US income is taxed globally, and the IRS will destroy you if you attempt to hide it from them and they find out, which they almost always do (they have direct or indirect access to nearly all global banking, financial transactions, stock transactions, bond purchases; they can also directly or indirectly get access to nearly all banks accounts in first world nations through treaties). There are very few countries where you can even attempt to hide your money from the IRS now, and most of those you'd be a fool to park money in.
I think the % of Americans doing the off-shore thing is very very low.
Now from a raw $$$ standpoint, perhaps it is a problem. Is 10% of wealth hidden offshore by the .1% of abusers? Or is it only 5% I doubt anyone knows for sure. I suspect it is less than the "legally" held offshore money using the double irish and other such accounting tricks.
I guess that depends on what you consider often. Because the money outside of tax-havens "doing work"in the economy is vastly greater than money hidden in tax-havens.
The lower barrier to entry of Uber means that there are more people competing for those taxi jobs, like people who can do it part-time. How many taxi-drivers did you know pre-Uber? I knew zero. Now I know multiple people who are, basically, taxi-drivers. (I'm making no claim as to whether this development is good or bad, it just is).
So yeah, they can "easily go work for Uber" as a contractor for less money. I imagine that the Cisco workers could do the same if they wanted to be contractors for less money.
Interesting to think those were the kind of jobs, and CISCO the kind of company, that once gave Silicon Valley its name. Makes you wonder how the market for software engineers, even adaptable always-learning hack-through-the-night-for-fun engineers, might look in 20 or 30 years.
[1] Read "(low-level networking systems) engineers", not "low-level (networking systems engineers )"
In my profession (banking), staff levels have been going pretty much consistently down since the financial crisis, as banks shrink or retreat from certain activities. But these are mostly bright, educated, business savvy people, who end up doing something else. For many it is a blessing in disguise, an opportunity (albeit in a brutal way) to move away from a shrinking industry to become their own boss or to work on the next big thing.
Imagine what a guy makes that's been at Cisco for 15 years? Now imagine what you can pay a recent graduate or H1B.
There must reach a stage in development where you're considered "too old" (sadly) or haven't kept up with the latest and greatest in trends.
What do you do then?? Project manage? Do all developers move into project management?
I see this mildly where I work where older developers are greatly valued (they're good!) but haven't kept up to date, eg. a lot of C++ is here, but nobody here (and I mean nobody) has any understanding of C++11, C++14 changes and are stuck in the C++98 ways. They even call C++11 "C++0x" still. This is different to the "learn the next fad" approach, as C++98/2003 deserve to go away.
MFC anyone?
With the push to Universal Apps (that nobody appears to be heeding), what is Microsoft's recommended toolkit for C++ in Windows now eh?
Here we are with > 2 million lines of C++, entirely MFC and COM.
Just imagine how much knowledge and experience these guys have and is effectively being lost by them being out of the workforce.
When you amputate a limb, you want to do it as quickly as possible.
When you throw the bathwater out, make sure you aren't loosing valuable resources.
the best case scenario is to be really smart and constantly drain the bathwater such that the baby doesn't even notice the level dropping. Keeping the baby focused on the new shiny thing helps.
It's the act of introducing the periodicity that damages morale so much.
I work at a place where we surgically remove deadwood, keep valuable people & tech. Those who have value feel valued.
As an aside I was with 3Com when they tried to go toe to toe with Cisco. 3Com did very much the same thing.. one major event was even called 'Catapult', senior management's intent was to launch the company forward, workers looked on with incredulity as over half the workforce lost their job in one day. 3Com never recovered.
I smell coolaid.
There's never 'layoffs' and never ever entire groups let go. Just regular PIPs for people who you think... 'no great loss'
I'll admit, doesn't scale to cisco though.
One person's income is another person's expense. Which communities do you speak of?
Looking for another job when there are massive cuts like this also degrades the salary they accept on their next job because of the competition.
I wish companies, if possible, throttled layoffs a bit more instead of large chunks like this, but that is unlikely as the board/CEOs are looking for a stock uptick when they do and don't want to drag it out to affect the market value (translation: their own pay / stock value/price).
We rarely look at the amount of money lost in communities when things like this happen but it would be nice if reporters put out the lost community dollars/salaries along with the layoff number. The Great Wage Stagnation continues in our consumer driven economy.