News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Who does that server really serve? by TeHCrAzY on Monday March 29, 2010 @06:33PM (#1227731)
I really dislike the image Stallman pushes of the FOSS movement. I stopped reading after "(referred to as “Digital Rights Management” in their propaganda)." set the likely tone for the rest of the article.
Re:Who does that server really serve? by javert on Monday March 29, 2010 @06:52PM (#1227771)
Same.

Proprietary software can't "take away your freedom" under any meaningful definition of "freedom".

Re:Who does that server really serve? by wmf on Monday March 29, 2010 @07:00PM (#1227787)
I don't agree with RMS's politics, but the fact that you don't consider positive freedom to be meaningful (even though a large fraction of the population apparently subscribes to it) probably says more about you than about RMS.

(If anyone doesn't know what I'm talking about: http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/liberty-positive-negative/)

Re:Who does that server really serve? by ez77 on Monday March 29, 2010 @07:58PM (#1227899)
Using your own source, "Positive liberty is the possibility of acting — or the fact of acting — in such a way as to take control of one's life and realize one's fundamental purposes."

Must one's (everyone's?) fundamental purposes include having all software available by law? If so, that's a mightily counterintuitive notion of freedom, be it positive, negative, or else.

Re:Who does that server really serve? by tbrownaw on Monday March 29, 2010 @08:07PM (#1227917)
It has nothign to do with positive vs. negative freedom; the set of "things you can do" when you have only open software available is a strict subset of "things you can do" given that same open software and also the alternative of closed software. Closed software can only limit your freedom if its existence inhibits the availability of open software.
Re:Who does that server really serve? by javert on Tuesday March 30, 2010 @12:30AM (#1228384)
This is an overly simplistic take on what I was getting at.

For example, it could be said that proprietary software increases the "positive freedom" of proprietary software developers. So then what's wrong with them releasing proprietary software? Isn't that what they should do, if it works best for them---makes them the most money or whatever, and thus increases their "positive freedom"?

One of the big problems with RMS is that he just throws out terms like "freedom" without stating what he means, giving a moral justification, and showing how they can be applied correctly.

Re:Who does that server really serve? by esspem on Monday March 29, 2010 @07:03PM (#1227790)
Proprietary software does take some of your freedom away due to government granted monopoly (copyright). For example, you are forbidden to to make a copy of it.
Re:Who does that server really serve? by thwarted on Monday March 29, 2010 @07:40PM (#1227856)
The government granted monopoly (copyright) is what gives open source licenses, like the GPL, their power. Depending on the exact license, you aren't allowed to make a copy of non-proprietary software either. Copyright doesn't say you aren't allowed to make a copy, it says that the owner of the copyright is allowed exclusive exploitation of the work, which is sellable/transferable to other parties, and is often restricted based on conditions -- with proprietary software, these conditions are usually only money changing hands.
Re:Who does that server really serve? by esspem on Monday March 29, 2010 @10:16PM (#1228161)
As far as i understand, GPL license is a "hack" for living in copyright world, until the abolishment of copyright.
Re:Who does that server really serve? by thwarted on Tuesday March 30, 2010 @01:56AM (#1228511)
Yes, this is called working within the system to subvert it. It applies copyright like no one else conceived of, at the time the GPL was created, to achieve an ends other than "make money".

If there was no copyright, or copyright is abolished, would there be a need for the GPL?

Re:Who does that server really serve? by rick888 on Monday March 29, 2010 @08:52PM (#1228002)
The GNU license requires all forks to also be open source. This means that I won't be able to add open source software to my proprietary application without all of my changes also being given out for free.

The Free Software Foundation also sues companies in court for not complying with their license. This doesn't really sound like anything different than the current copyright system.

I would not want to live in a world where I am forced by law to give out the source to my software.

Re:Who does that server really serve? by RyanMcGreal on Monday March 29, 2010 @09:18PM (#1228047)
>I would not want to live in a world where I am forced by law to give out the source to my software.

No one's forcing you to use GNU licenced software in your proprietary application.

Re:Who does that server really serve? by rick888 on Monday March 29, 2010 @09:33PM (#1228073)
It's interesting you say that considering Stallman's entire rant is about proprietary software that he has the freedom to just not use.
Re:Who does that server really serve? by RyanMcGreal on Monday March 29, 2010 @09:38PM (#1228079)
He has the right to believe that more free software would make the world a better place and to try to convince others of this.