This is a video game. You could be anything, do anything. Introduce mechanics that do not require the consumption of worlds. Lots of games have mechanics that don't require stripmining planets.
I read the tweets more as disappointment that we can't do something different in our creation. Just because the real world is built on consumption doesn't mean all art has to be.
Any transgressive or satirical piece of art could have this exact same critique leveled at it, but generally they don't because critics in other media have a more nuanced understand of the relationship between art and the artists intentions.
Correct. But because the real world is built on consumption, criticising creative expression for exploring that is at best invalid. What's going on with Polygon is that they're making this invalid criticism to further their political narratives.
> There is no way to create on these worlds
You needn't look at anyone's politics, pro or con, to wonder: in a world where the second best selling game of all time is Minecraft, how much sense is there in a galaxy-sized sandbox where you can't build anything?
In fact I find my brain tends to do the common human ego-centric thing and compartmentalizes the entire planet to only that which I've experienced.
Yet if I just land on a planet and tape the joystick to move my avatar forward... well I could go walk away and come back in six months to a year and see if I made it back to my starting position... and even if I recorded it to watch it at my leisure, my FOV will only cover a small fraction of the total surface area.
It's a gross exaggeration to suggest a single, lone character could "strip mine" an entire planet by themselves.
You need to gather enough radioactive isotopes to power your magical space plane and keep you alive and a few other elements to manufacture upgrades and that's about it. It's not like you're managing a global conglomerate with trillions of dollars of capital invested in machinery to extract every last mineral from the surface.
update
I think it says more about the people who interpret the mechanics this way than any statement Hello Games could be making by utilizing these mechanics.
Richards intentions were selfish, but completely understandable and relatable.
Joseph Campbell said it most succinctly:
"(All) life lives on life".[1]
[1] http://www.goodreads.com/quotes/801710-life-lives-on-life-th...
> What's sad is despite all our ingenuity, so many of our mechanics reinforce ideas and behaviors we know to be harmful.
Reality Check: You are a lifeform that feeds on the transition of matter from low entropy to high entropy states. We very literally consume worlds. We should try and do that in a way that doesn't undermine our own survival chances, and, as long as that doesn't interfer with the previous point in a way that minimises harm to other lifeforms that we consider useful or beautiful. No amount of virtue signalling and related posturing is going to change that fundamental reality.
It's very typical of Kuchera and Polygon to produce such badly thought-through moralising on videogames, but considering how closely the theme of the game runs to a fundamental physical truth of the human condition I find the criticism rather crass.