News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by sjwright on Tuesday August 09, 2016 @09:09PM (#12258820)
An important thing to realise about the Australian banking market is that we're already a world leader in the adoption of contactless payments using our credit cards. (And unlike the US, our floor limit is $100, which covers almost all transactions. When exceeded, most terminals just prompt for your PIN.)

I'm sure Apple Pay is great, but with an entire continent already familiar with tapping their credit card, tapping a phone doesn't seem like much of an improvement.

Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by cletus on Tuesday August 09, 2016 @09:41PM (#12258960)
I'm Australian but I live in the US now. I go back fairly often. Last year I tried out PayPass for the first time.

Contactless payments as implemented in Australia is (IMHO) a disaster. Here are the problems:

- No opt out. You couldn't get an ATM card without it. This led to various guides on drilling a hole in the RF antenna to disable it. Last I heard the ACCC was intervening to force the big banks to give consumers an opt out. Not sure if this has happened yet.

- Report your card stolen and the thief can still keep using PayPass. Why is this even possible in the modern age of the Internet?

- The burden of proof on unauthorized transactions is on the consumer. I seem to recall reading something from the T&Cs that claimed you could be charged a fee for a "false" (ie denied) claim and you could only claim unauthorized transactions once or twice a year.

- In the case of disputed transactions the merchant is on the hook for it leading some to not accept it.

Basically contactless payments in Australia are an effort by the big banks to not be responsible for fraud. There's no real benefit to consumers.

Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by cynix on Tuesday August 09, 2016 @10:02PM (#12259039)
> The burden of proof on unauthorized transactions is on the consumer.

The burden of proof for unauthorised transactions is _never_ on the consumer.

> In the case of disputed transactions the merchant is on the hook

It is always the merchant who's on the hook for disputed transactions. The banks/issuer is _never_ on the hook.

Contactless payment is literally just a more convenient version of magnetic/chip payment, with everything else being the same.

Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by rjvs on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @06:25AM (#12260626)
> The burden of proof for unauthorised transactions is _never_ on the consumer.

It's true that the merchant has to prove that the consumer made the purchase. However, the burden is still on the consumer, since they still have to service the transaction until the dispute process is resolved.

Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by sjwright on Tuesday August 09, 2016 @10:01PM (#12259037)
> Report your card stolen and the thief can still keep using PayPass.

That's the bank's problem, not yours.

> The burden of proof on unauthorized transactions is on the consumer.

Same as with chip + pin.

Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by bigB on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @07:26AM (#12260830)
You obviously have never had a contactless card stolen as absolutely none of what you have said is true, well except the opt out thing. You report your card stolen then pay pass will not work ( unless the merchant your using is "offline" which no merchant I know is. Burden of proof is actually on the bank not the holder and the banks are always more than happy to help. How do I know.....I live in Australia and have had my card stolen 2 times in 2 years and apart from a couple of days delay in getting a new card, there is no issue at all. Over here its actually reducing fraud as people dont see you use your pin number.
Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by iamshs on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @09:54PM (#12265903)
If a pin is used with stolen card, bank will refuse to credit the charges. It is not covered under fraud.
Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by mattchamb on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @07:50AM (#12260938)
I'm in New Zealand and I can disable and enable a number of individual features on my credit card through my banks phone app
Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by abalone on Tuesday August 09, 2016 @09:55PM (#12259016)
It's a huge improvement in security. You mentioned how the majority of contactless payments don't require a PIN. Apple Pay secures 100% of transactions with a PIN, made convenient with touch ID.

There are also behind-the-scenes protections against identity theft. E.g. if a merchant has a data breach, your Apple Pay card number can't be used to buy things online.

Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by dalore on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @04:58AM (#12260377)
Consumers are already protected, the security is more for the banks. Contactless was made to not require a pin for transactions under a certain amount. It's made for convenience, no one is using it to steals 1000s. And if someone is using it to steal they aren't stealing from joe blow but from the banks.

It's not identity theft they are protecting, but bank fraud. If a merchant has a data breach and my credit card details are used to buy things online without my authorization, that isn't identity theft, but bank fraud to the bank. Since all I have to do is say that transaction isn't mine and poof it's gone.

Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by rjvs on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @06:04AM (#12260567)
It's not just "poof it's gone" here.

In Australia, if you dispute a credit card transaction, it still counts against your limit and your required repayments until the dispute is resolved. This can take months and be more than inconvenient.

Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by CaptainZapp on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @06:32AM (#12260636)
Not so in Switzerland. At least not with my bank.

If I complain about a charge (which I will only do if it's truly fraudulent, or not possible to have been initiated by me) the amount is credited immediately while the bank is taking it up with the merchant.

That's exactly the way it should be and if this is not the case you should probably be pushing for stronger consumer protection laws.

Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by cujo on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @08:44AM (#12261214)
Not so in the US either, at least not universally. My credit card companies have followed this same pattern when there has been a dispute.
Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by tobylane on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @10:43AM (#12262118)
The motivation for moving to chip and pin is that the banks take this kind of risk away from the merchant.
Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by eon1 on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @01:53AM (#12259750)
Average Joe will pick convenience over security every time, unless it's such an absolute shambles that they actually fear (or have been convinced they should fear) using it. Not to mention the already-formed habit/association of "hey, I'm paying for this, better whip out my card".
Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by abalone on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @02:12AM (#12259816)
True, but Apple Pay is also at least as or more convenient than tapping a card. You (theoretically) don't ever have to enter PINs, you get a transaction confirmation on your own device, and if you have an Apple Watch you don't even have to pull anything out of your pocket.
Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by vilmosi on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @06:48AM (#12260689)
>>> You (theoretically) don't ever have to enter PINs,

But practically, for day to day expenses, it's not required.

>>> you get a transaction confirmation on your own device

As opposed to getting a confirmation on the terminal...

>>> and if you have an Apple Watch you don't even have to pull anything out of your pocket

I don't know if you're talking from experience, but those terminals are usually facing up and/or towards you. It's uncomfortable to bend your wrist like that.

Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by dpark on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @10:55AM (#12262203)
> if you have an Apple Watch you don't even have to pull anything out of your pocket

How is this PIN/touch ID protected, then?

Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by eric_h on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @11:09AM (#12262319)
You unlock the watch with a pin on the watch itself or touch id on your iPhone. It locks itself automatically when you remove it from your wrist.
Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by dpark on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @12:54PM (#12263176)
This doesn't seem very convenient. You scribble a PIN on your wrist or you pull your phone out of your pocket to use touchID?
Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by abalone on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @02:20PM (#12263778)
You only enter the PIN when you wear the watch to unlock it, not at the register.
Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by vilmosi on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @06:38AM (#12260659)
>>> There are also behind-the-scenes protections against identity theft. E.g. if a merchant has a data breach, your Apple Pay card number can't be used to buy things online.

Contactless cards work the same way. They don't send your card number, they send a token.

Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by germanier on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @08:52AM (#12261256)
Not necessarily. My German MasterCard and Visa cards don't use send the the full number. In fact, I think tokenization is a fairly recent addition to the standard.
Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by yalogin on Tuesday August 09, 2016 @09:28PM (#12258898)
The sales pitch for Apple pay is exactly that, you don't have to carry your cards since you will be carrying your phone anyway. If you are used to tapping your cards, then it will be easier to tap your phone as well.
Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by bpicolo on Tuesday August 09, 2016 @09:30PM (#12258915)
Credit card with a temporary battery life just doesn't cut it for me. Also, I bring my credit card in my running shorts pockets when running. Phone doesn't even come close to fitting, and even if it did would awkwardly flap around
Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by iamshs on Tuesday August 09, 2016 @09:40PM (#12258956)
I held same opinion as you, but then Apple Pay rolled out in Canada and I did a complete 180 after using it. It gives you freedom, as you never leave your home without your phone even while running.
Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by cynix on Tuesday August 09, 2016 @09:59PM (#12259025)
> you never leave your home without your phone even while running.

He literally just said he does leave his home without his phone while running.

Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by dalore on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @04:59AM (#12260381)
He should take his phone with him, how else will he track his fitness data and steps, and then twitter it as he does?
Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by hboon on Tuesday August 09, 2016 @10:33PM (#12259145)
Part of the pitch is it will also work with an Apple Watch, if the consumer has one, and will likely wear it while running.
Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by cynix on Tuesday August 09, 2016 @11:26PM (#12259327)
Doesn't the Apple Watch require the paired iPhone to be nearby in order to function?
Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by jeremy_wiebe on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @12:16AM (#12259477)
It does. AFAIK, the Touch ID from the phone authenticates Apple Pay transactions from the watch.

[edit] I stand corrected. Looks like the watch had a Secure Element also to store the pay info. It automatically locks if you take it off.

Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by hboon on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @12:15AM (#12259473)
No, the paired iPhone doesn't need to be around for a few features, including tracking activity and Apple Pay.
Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by mrweasel on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @05:57AM (#12260542)
>It gives you freedom, as you never leave your home without your phone even while running.

I understand that I might be a special case, but given the option, I would ALWAYS leave my phone at home. I hate that freaking thing.

Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by 2muchcoffeeman on Tuesday August 09, 2016 @09:55PM (#12259015)
Get a race belt!
Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by bpicolo on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @11:30AM (#12262477)
Hah. To be fair, I also don't want to take phone with me to be distracted by it. Running is exactly the time to undistract myself. :)
Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by asdfaoeu on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @07:20AM (#12260803)
But you can already do that with an Android phone with any of those banks...
Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by iamshs on Tuesday August 09, 2016 @09:37PM (#12258949)
Banks just want to create a cartel and oligopoly:- http://registers.accc.gov.au/content/index.phtml/itemId/1197...

Canada also has large penetration of contactless payments, as does UK and Europe. Australia is not unique in this sense. Every major Canadian bank has rolled out Apple Pay. Australia lacks in this area massively with every bank rolling out a shitty app.

Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by muro on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @05:41AM (#12260496)
Don't know about other banks, but the Commonwealth Bank app is nice.
Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by jedharris on Tuesday August 09, 2016 @10:13PM (#12259073)
I don't see your point. If the Oz banks are way ahead, why do they need to form a cartel? Your argument implies that Apple will fail to displace them. Maybe so. But then they are being silly acting threatened...

None of the banks need to sign up at all. No existing customers need to use Apple Pay. All this is entirely opt in. So why any fuss at all? Hmmm...

Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by rodgerd on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @04:02AM (#12260176)
> All this is entirely opt in. So why any fuss at all?

That has been the banks' position. Then Apple started asking politicians to force the banks to do business with Apple (on Apple's terms, of course). This is a counter-punch: we'll open up, but only if you do.

Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by MaysonL on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @11:14AM (#12262358)
The question is, I suppose, how many Apple customers will leave the cartel banks and change to ANZ Banking Group or any other banks which are supporting Apple Pay.
Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by asdfaoeu on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @07:21AM (#12260806)
The banks want to offer contactless payments on iPhones which they already do on Android.
Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by Alphasite_ on Tuesday August 09, 2016 @09:11PM (#12258828)
Honestly it's he same in most places but it's still convenient not to have to worry about your wallet.
Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by sjwright on Tuesday August 09, 2016 @09:25PM (#12258890)
It really isn't the same.

A May 2015 survey by RF Intelligence Group, called ‘Global Payments Evaluation Study’, based on 32,000 respondents in 16 countries found that 66 per cent of Australians are aware that they own a contactless payment card and 53 per cent have made a contactless transaction. By contrast, just 14 per cent of Americans own a contactless card and only 9 per cent have used one for a payment.

http://www.bpaybanter.com.au/news-views/why-do-australians-l...

Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by dalore on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @05:02AM (#12260390)
Australia had EFTPOS which was a way of using your debit card to buy stuff, way before the VISA network really took off.
Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by Alphasite_ on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @08:25AM (#12261103)
I don't live in the US, I mean in most developed economies contactless is fairly common place.
Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by kuschku on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @09:36AM (#12261573)
Well, take Germany. Every store supports contactless, but MasterCard refuses to offer EC Cards with contactless, and wants to move customers to credit cards (which earn them far more profit – over 20 times the transaction fee).

Oh, and we don’t get Android Pay either.

As a result, the experience is horrible. And for every single bit US corporations are to blame.

Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by sjwright on Tuesday August 09, 2016 @09:35PM (#12258941)
I still have to worry about my wallet because I need my driver license, I need an amount of cash, and I need my corporate swipe card. I would also need my physical credit cards for accessing ATMs and the small minority of merchants that don't have a contactless terminal. (A few places still only have chip+pin; one of my favourite coffee shops is cash only business.)

My wallet is very slim; it would be more hassle having to think about whether I needed it or not, than to just have it on me at all times.

Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by iamshs on Tuesday August 09, 2016 @09:43PM (#12258976)
As someone coming from Canada to Australia, and who held the same viewpoint; you just need to experience Apply Pay. Ozland seriously sucks now when compared to Canada for me regarding NFC payments. Idiots are trying to create a cartel here.
Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by sjwright on Tuesday August 09, 2016 @09:52PM (#12259006)
I've used and experienced Apple Pay. It's certainly convenient. Don't see how it's more convenient than tapping my credit card, an object I would still be carrying even if I had Apple Pay.
Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by eon1 on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @01:38AM (#12259699)
I'm genuinely curious; what is The Apple Pay Experience?

What sucks so bad about our current setup?

What is so hugely different about tapping your phone instead of a card that it could possibly convince me to go through 3-4 extra steps? I really don't get it.

Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by pilif on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @05:51AM (#12260528)
For me, Apple Pay has two advantages over a contactless card:

- it's only active after explicit user interaction. There is no way for somebody with an rogue device to steal money from me.

- conversely, there's no limit after which a transaction requires pin entry. Here in Switzerland, the limit for contactless cards is CHF 50 after which you have to still type in your pin. With Apple Pay, there is no limit.

Both of these make Apple Pay very valuable to me.

There's one more thing: I also have a contactless debit card (which I would love to be available on Apple Pay, but that's probably never going to happen) and the moment a reader detects more than one card, it refuses contacless operation.

By having the credit card on the watch, they are separated far enough from each other, so I can always pay contactless. This is a problem that would be fixable with better UX on the readers.

Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by semi-extrinsic on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @06:43AM (#12260677)
If explicit user interaction is a big deal, why don't banks make contactless cards with a thumb button you have to hold when swiping? Just a physical breaker in the NFC antenna circuit, it would be dead simple, as slim as you want, not need any power, and cheap.
Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by iamshs on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @09:52PM (#12265894)
1) No need to carry wallet when I was out in the field. 2) Stores do not get my card number and name. I always hated when something like even a restaurant would get my name. 3) If the card is reported lost and bank issues a new one, Apple Pay automatically updates before the card reaches me by mail. 4) It is additional security, as it asks for thumb verification before the payment.

There are no 3-4 extra steps involved at all. It is just taking phone out, as you normally do with card, and just tapping the thumb on home button.

Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by eon1 on Tuesday August 09, 2016 @09:29PM (#12258905)
Really? I had a discussion with an American about this a while ago and they seemed stunned at how easy and efficient tap'n'go sounded compared to what they had available. I mean, we're fairly behind in most things here, but if you tried to pay for groceries with a cheque, in 99.9% of places you would be (rightly) laughed out of the store.
Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by flukus on Tuesday August 09, 2016 @09:33PM (#12258928)
From what I understand (which could well be wrong), it's not uncommon for Americans to get literal pay cheques either.

Here we've had direct bank transfers for my entire adult life (15+ years).

Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by 6nf on Tuesday August 09, 2016 @11:54PM (#12259412)
I'm 37 in Australia and I've literally never had a chequebook in my life. I think one time I used a bank cheque for a real estate transaction but that was a decade ago.
Re:Apple says Australia's banks pose a security threat to iP... by nly on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @04:21AM (#12260242)
In the States its not uncommon to just have your card swiped in grocery stores and not even have to sign. Effectively they've just made the old insecure magstripe & sig system more convenient (and insecure).