News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by tomp on Saturday August 06, 2016 @11:48AM (#12238477)
I always thought that the LHC "nightmare scenario" referred to accidential creation of a black hole... Well, looks like different people have different ideas of what a "catastrophe" means :)
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by yk on Saturday August 06, 2016 @03:07PM (#12239424)
No one in the physics community did take the creation of a black hole serious not even as a nightmare scenario. (First you have to create it, which requires large extra dimensions or a similar deformation of gravity at short scales, then it should not just evaporate immediately, which appears^1 to involve a breakdown of quantum field theories close to a black hole. Then there are additional arguments, but we already assumed that we do neither understand gravity nor quantum theory at the TeV scale, so all bets are off. We may as well assume that the LHC wakes Cthulhu.)

By contrast, the nightmare scenario here is really the worst kind scenario under the assumption that we have a good idea about physics at the TeV scale. We do not learn anything, and even worse the LHC is the wrong machine. With a light Higgs and no additional particles, a slight upgrade to the LEP, the predecessor of the LHC, would have found the Higgs in 2005 and would be a much better machine to study it in detail.

^1 Hawking radiation (and its close relative Unruh radiation) are basically the only two effects which involve both gravity and quantum field theory anybody has any kind of believe in.

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by zymhan on Saturday August 06, 2016 @03:50PM (#12239586)
So does this mean that maybe we made the right call not building the Super Conducting Super Collider?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superconducting_Super_Collider

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by T-A on Saturday August 06, 2016 @09:13PM (#12240620)
Not necessarily. The (design) collision energy of the SSC was 40 TeV, about 3x the LHC's. So it is still conceivable that it could have found something genuinely new which is out of the LHC's reach. I guess Lisa Randall is getting really worried now [1].

[1] https://www.edge.org/response-detail/23840

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by talideon on Tuesday August 09, 2016 @07:13AM (#12253752)
Good and useful work has come out of the LHC, enough to make it more than worthwhile. It's just that some of the big hopes don't seem to have panned out.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by tlrobinson on Saturday August 06, 2016 @12:03PM (#12238558)
I was going to write this exact comment, but then I realized if that "nightmare scenario" came true I probably wouldn't be here to write the comment...
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by adrianN on Saturday August 06, 2016 @12:12PM (#12238594)
It would take a long time for a tiny black hole to feed enough to be a problem.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by dlss on Saturday August 06, 2016 @12:24PM (#12238650)
I looked this up, and according to the most entertaining source I found (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8nHBGFKLHZQ) the result of a tiny blackhole would basically be a gigantic nuclear explosion (it would evaporate rather than continue forming) -- so a big problem immediately, but not one that would prevent me from reading about it here in the US.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by aardvark179 on Saturday August 06, 2016 @12:40PM (#12238724)
Yes, if physics behave accordingly the way we expect it would evaporate almost immediately, but it would be a tiny explosion because they'd only be a tiny amount of energy there in the first place.

The more fun version would be where black holes do not evaporate, at which point it will still be a very long time before it's a problem, we need to worry about Andromeda crashing into our galaxy and the sun becoming a red giant first.

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by foobarian on Saturday August 06, 2016 @12:48PM (#12238755)
That kind of timescale often makes me wonder, how do we know there aren't millions of tiny black holes all throughout the planet slowly growing?
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by manarth on Saturday August 06, 2016 @01:38PM (#12238994)
And pertinently, if there were, is the timescale fixed, or are there externals events that might speed it up?

The Sun's dying and will become a red giant (about 5 billion years to go), but it's luminosity is currently increasing, so our rock will become a scorched Earth in around a billion years. Then there's the potential for meteors, climate-change, antibiotic resistance, or millions of tiny black holes to do us off first (how quickly do black holes grow, anyway?)

Colonising other planets and other solar systems seems the only viable solution to the long-term survival of the human race.

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by ferrari8608 on Saturday August 06, 2016 @01:26PM (#12238940)
We don't, but I haven't seen any around.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by zymhan on Saturday August 06, 2016 @03:51PM (#12239592)
Maybe they're just hiding in the dark.

Or maybe they are the dark.

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by adrianN on Saturday August 06, 2016 @12:41PM (#12238732)
It can only explode as much energy as you put in though. The particles the LHC collides don't have all that much energy.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by facorreia on Saturday August 06, 2016 @12:21PM (#12238631)
My thoughts exactly: if the title was accurate, we wouldn't be hearing about it.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by Dylan16807 on Saturday August 06, 2016 @12:52PM (#12238777)
There are more energetic particles hitting the atmosphere, so that's not a nightmare that ever really made sense.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by danielmorozoff on Saturday August 06, 2016 @12:58PM (#12238812)
I think this was meant to be ironic.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by ansible on Saturday August 06, 2016 @11:56AM (#12238521)
Yah, that's what I thought when I saw the title. It was quite an interesting article. There is so much distaste for the standard model out there (from me too, I suppose). There's got to be a better explanation... but maybe there isn't.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by protomyth on Saturday August 06, 2016 @12:26PM (#12238656)
I would imagine that some people believe being "lost" is a greater catastrophe than being dead.

Personally, I'm in the it's all good unless you create a black hole, explosion, or gateway to someplace we don't want to visit or want visitors from.

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by manarth on Saturday August 06, 2016 @01:41PM (#12239014)
As long as we've got Gordon Freeman and a crowbar, we're all good.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by protomyth on Saturday August 06, 2016 @04:31PM (#12239760)
I sometimes wonder if modern SciFi and games have actually kept up with the lessons they have already added to the collective culture over the years. If CERN suddenly had velociraptors pouring out of some gate they created, what would the real world reaction be? I'm betting it wouldn't be blind panic. I get the feeling the Swiss could handle it themselves.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by mcguire on Saturday August 06, 2016 @05:19PM (#12239985)
"Oh, lord, not Scenario 12c(a)! And on the Friday before a 3-day weekend!"
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by dhimes on Saturday August 06, 2016 @12:58PM (#12238815)
I always considered it to be if the LHC made a new super-stable state of matter and everything falls into a new ground state. Yikes!
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by superswordfish on Saturday August 06, 2016 @11:50AM (#12238482)
Clickbait is clickbait.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by mmmBacon on Saturday August 06, 2016 @01:18PM (#12238902)
In the context of physics this is not clickbait. It is an actual nightmare for physics because they have spent years and billions building this extremely complex machine. The fact that they are not seeing new physics means that they did all this work to verify the existence of a single particle. Beyond that they are not discovering anything new. It's a nightmare because it tells you that even if you build a bigger more powerful machine you may not see anything new. If you aren't going to see anything new, you can't justify building it. Also the machine required to see new physics might have to be so large that it's not practical to build. It means the end of the road for this kind of particle physics. It also means that theoretically we've been at a dead end for a long time.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by fsloth on Saturday August 06, 2016 @12:23PM (#12238642)
No, it's not clicbait. This is an accurate description of the current scenario from the point of view of her discipline. Although, I suppose it's not that obvious if one is not familiar with physics.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by archgoon on Saturday August 06, 2016 @11:52AM (#12238494)
This isn't clickbait. Do you see any ads on this page?

This is an accurate characterization of the worst outcome (that doesn't involve space aliens) that scientists were worried about when the LHC launched.

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by csydas on Saturday August 06, 2016 @11:59AM (#12238534)
Well, more so, they have a pretty clear definition of what they mean by "nightmare scenario"; it would have nice to have their claim much earlier in the article followed by the rest of the history, but I really wouldn't call it clickbait. But I can really see why it's considered a "nightmare" given what the article is suggesting. Like, clickbait is shitty, but this case really isn't. It is eyecatching though.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by mcbits on Saturday August 06, 2016 @12:26PM (#12238657)
I'd say "see what happens next!" is clickbait even if the page has no ads and actually does show what happens next. When "nightmare scenario" turns out to mean "not much has happened", that's at least borderline clickbait. But at least the article was substantive. I don't think people would hate sensational headlines so much if the content lived up to expectations.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by csydas on Saturday August 06, 2016 @12:54PM (#12238790)
I do understand what you're saying, in that overt eye-catching and curiosity tweaking headlines that are intentionally misleading are bad and certainly clickbait.

In this instance, however, I think it's more of a question of there being a big question as to "what is the nightmare scenario"; each part of the article is relevant to this question, explaining the state of the particle physics and the build up towards the apparent disappointment with the results from the LHC research.

Nightmare scenario is being fairly specific here; it's not really in the same field as "See what happens next" or "You won't believe what happens" in my mind since those have no substance or real connection to their content. This article headline is very attention grabbing, since we're not sure what the LHC Nightmare Scenario is. However, the article substantiates the title. It provides the author's reasons specifically why the current status of LHC research is in a nightmare scenario.

The title is provocative, yes, but I feel that conflating provocative with "Clickbait" is disingenuous. Some of the most famous headlines in history have arguably been clickbait by that metric, yet they're not held to the same scrutiny.

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by archgoon on Saturday August 06, 2016 @02:13PM (#12239145)
> since we're not sure what the LHC Nightmare Scenario is.

I disagree. I believe that the intended audience of this article, people familiar with what the LHC has been up to, what it's goals were, who are keeping up with current events, like knowing that the diphoton bump has vanished, would immediately recognize what the article would be about. I did at least. It seems completely unfair to say "This article doesn't cater to HN" and then accuse the author of engaging in sensationalistic clickbait, especially when HN doesn't trust submitters to provide more context in headlines.

This lack of context is because, it appears, most HN readers are more familiar with the actual clickbait headlines from media outlets proclaiming "Mini Blackholes may destroy the earth!", "Strangelets could destroy the earth!", "The LHC will start the Zombie Apocalypse!", than the actual concerns of scientists. Again, this seems monstrously unfair that actual clickbait has set the conversation, and people who actually are talking about the actual 'nightmare scenario' are now accused of clickbait.

Not all nightmares are about monsters chasing you. A lot of them are showing up to class in your underwear, or trying to find that report that you know should be on the table. I would not be surprised that several physicists have in fact had actual nightmares of this exact scenario.

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by csydas on Saturday August 06, 2016 @02:21PM (#12239211)
I'm a little confused as to whom specifically you're responding to.

I'm not sure where the idea of "this article doesn't cater to HN" and the following accusation comes from in relation to the thread that was being discussed.

I do agree with you that it's unfair to call it clickbait, that there's a large difference between a provocative headline and a clickbait headline. Personally I'm not familiar enough with the going-ons of the LHC to really comment intelligently on the research, so I have and will hold off on that.

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by archgoon on Saturday August 06, 2016 @02:28PM (#12239246)
I was responding, perhaps my misinterpretation, to your assertion that it was unclear what the 'nightmare scenario' was. I asserted that if you had been following the recent developments of the LHC (or had some idea as to what the worst case scenario was), there would be no ambiguity as to what this article was about. The reason why this is the case is that this article was not written with the HN crowd in mind.

The primary response to this article, given the comments, is "what do you mean you're not talking about black holes" rather than an actual discussion of the ideas of the article (the failure of "naturalness" and "beauty" to make predictions for the LHC). Which leads me to conclude that HN is not a good place to talk about this (since most people are complaining that the , as we're arguing about the most boring, superficial part of the article.

My statement that people are complaining about "This article doesn't cater to HN", is my summary of the idea that 'I am not familiar with the context associated with the headline, and to me it sounds sensationalistic, and therefore it is clickbait, and the author should have picked a better title'. You obviously, are not advocating that position.

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by csydas on Saturday August 06, 2016 @03:32PM (#12239518)
Ah, yes, I was projecting my own ignorance out to the general audience when I said that it was "unclear what the nightmare scenario was", as I think a lot of people really didn't follow LHC news well enough to know what the nightmare scenario would be. This is the source of the confusion, and I should have been more clear.

The rest I believe you and I are in agreement over. :)

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by pharrington on Saturday August 06, 2016 @02:01PM (#12239089)
The LHC is a multi billion dollar project designed specifically to help physicists build physical models that are more accurate than what currently exists. Countless man-years have been devoted to its operation. Apparently, the only thing it has done is confirm what we already knew decades ago. The nightmare scenario is the waste of billions of dollars and a decade of your life, with no alternatives in sight. Remember, the article is from the perspective of a theoretical physicist. This stuff is her life.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by Johnny555 on Saturday August 06, 2016 @03:03PM (#12239403)
the only thing it has done is confirm what we already knew decades ago

I thought it confirmed what we thought we knew (and is the only way to confirm it), so that doesn't seem like wasted money.

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by GrumpyYoungMan on Saturday August 06, 2016 @03:09PM (#12239432)
It would be more precise to say that it didn't show us anything we didn't already know (other than the Higgs). There are various indications that the Standard Model is not the whole story but the LHC gave no hints whatsoever on what directions to explore next. In that sense, it was wasted money.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by mynewtb on Saturday August 06, 2016 @12:18PM (#12238620)
Clickbait does have to have ads, it's the sensationalism as incentive to click.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by Johnny555 on Saturday August 06, 2016 @11:55AM (#12238516)
I do - that "Support my writing" box in the corner with a Paypal link.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by archgoon on Saturday August 06, 2016 @11:58AM (#12238530)
And I'm sure that her primary motivation when writing the title was to get donation clicks.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by Johnny555 on Saturday August 06, 2016 @12:30PM (#12238673)
I don't know anything about her motivation, but you asked if there were any ads on the page, so I pointed out that there is one.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by TeMPOraL on Saturday August 06, 2016 @12:07PM (#12238570)
It isn't really clickbait, though it sure feels like one. There's a clear definition of LHC "nightmare scenario" in the article, and it apparently wasn't made up for the article itself. I agree with 'csydas though, it would be better if the meaning of that term was explained earlier in the text - but maybe the regular audience of this blog already know what it means.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by whamlastxmas on Saturday August 06, 2016 @12:09PM (#12238576)
I personally sort of assumed it wasn't a black hole since I was still alive and existing to read the headline.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by Ma8ee on Saturday August 06, 2016 @03:37PM (#12239547)
I think most people that has followed particle physics for the last few years had a quite good idea already from the headline what the post would be about.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by beezle on Saturday August 06, 2016 @11:54AM (#12238504)
Bee's blog is about as far from clickbait as you can get,
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by zackya89 on Saturday August 06, 2016 @02:18PM (#12239179)
what is clickbait, is the comment section where people only read the headline, and think of black hole as the nightmare scenario. Just read through the blogpost, must be one of the rare ones, as the commenter above me as well explained so eloquently this is nightmare scenario, there is no new guidance and particle physicists are not going in other directions they still waiting to see some sort of super symmetry or some kind of evidence of string theory, the field is lacking new ideas.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by afarrell on Saturday August 06, 2016 @12:45PM (#12238745)
a black hole created from component of the LHC wreak all the of the havoc caused by the gravitational force of something with the mass of of....a rather large piece of lab equipment.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by Dylan16807 on Saturday August 06, 2016 @01:00PM (#12238827)
The scenario at hand is the particles colliding into a black hole, not spontaneous conversion of the equipment.

A black hole with the mass of a big chunk of equipment would be enormously deadly. Ten megatons per pound, assuming it evaporates. Most of the planet collapsing into it if it doesn't.