It's funny to think that this was exactly what I was thinking when I'd been working for 10+ years in my early thirties looking for a house after they'd skyrocketed in value the previous few years. Inflation had eaten away at any savings I'd made, gas lines were a recent memory as well as several recessions one after the other. Oh, this was in the early 1980s.
I get it. I've got kids coming into this economy and I'm worried for them. I also get that there are a lot of people my age who really are self-centered a-holes and consistently vote to keep the pie moving up toward them.
What I think we need is massive infrastructure investment funded by both current taxes (to get the people with money to pay) and low cost debt (so the beneficiaries of the investsments can pay) to kick the hiring structure down to the people that can do those jobs.
Politically, to a large voting bloc - disenfranchised Millenials - I think it could pull some water (not to mention stir up encouragement from the older population that "those dang kids" are doing something good with their time). People would have to go where the work is, more than likely, but that's a trade-off. Unfortunately a great deal of the "low interest debt" seems to be funneling into equities and buy-backs, only worsening the transfer of wealth to investor classes rather than working classes, at a time when, really, it doesn't make sense to do that.
Your neighbors who took those zero interest rate loans and are living "the life" going on vacations and buying new cars... it's all a big show, and it looks grand from outside, but they're probably experiencing all kinds of stresses that you don't. These are the kinds of people who keep the psycho-pharma complex profitable.
I'm 59. I don't remember doing that. (And are we actually broke?) I do remember voting. Everyone I voted for said one thing to me, and did what they were told by their donors and the MIC.
I hope I live long enough to see what the currently upcoming generations get blamed for in their old age.
Any time there is a budget deficit, there is borrowing. The borrowing is done against future earnings by future taxpayers. Now it seems to me that if money is borrowed and not paid entirely back within a generation, then those who borrowed have essentially stolen wealth from their children and grandchildren.
That's (if the unit of analysis is "us", as in the country, rather than the government itself) arguably loosely analogous to one piece of one's personal debt exceeding 100% of annual income, and not at all the definition of being broke.
> Is there any sort of plan to repay that debt in a lifetime? No, not really.
That's having long-term structural debt, which, again, is nothing like being broke.
> A lot of people would consider that broke.
I don't really think that's true. The government is neither unable to pay its current obligations (it occasionally approaches choosing not to do so, but is nowhere close to being unable to do so).
If a generation inherits a better world than they leave to their kids, I don't think they get to blame how hard it would have been to have done better. The buck's got to stop somewhere.
And having failed to do little but enrich themselves, at the very least your generation can stop talking about lazy and entitled the younger generation is. The hypocrisy is staggering.
Those nominated for the Supreme Court come from a short list of federal judges and other legal wonks. No average voter has any idea of the name of any of these people. Therefore, they cannot be said to be voting on a candidate based on their Supreme Court picks, except in the most liberal/conservative sense.
Case in point: Merrick Garland. He was on everyone's short list, including mentions by Republican leaders as a candidate who could be confirmed by the Senate. But the average voted hadn't heard his name before he was nominated by Obama.
It's really the political class that sold us out to privatization and globalization. That's where the buck stops. It happened regardless of who was voted in. Both parties were captured, and 3rd parties are not a realistic option in our system. We are /not really/ a democracy.
"Whoever is responsible, it's not me and my friends!"
> No average voter has any idea of the name of any of these people.
"I would like to not do any research, because taking responsibility is hard"
> the average voted hadn't heard his name before he was nominated by Obama.
Which is fine. The average voter knew (or should have known) what Obama stood for. What Bush stood for. What Clinton stood for. And so on. They could've then reasonably inferred what kind of judges they'd pick. And by looking at the age of SCOTUS judges, you have a good guess when replacements happens.
The only judge where you could've made the case is surprising given who nominated them is Scalia - he tipped a bit further on issues than Reagan.
Merrick is right in line with everything Obama ever stood for. Nobody is surprised that Obama would nominate a centrist with slight liberal leanings. The particular name might be unknown, but the choice isn't.
> It's really the political class that sold us out to privatization and globalization.
That political class didn't come into life fully formed. People voted for them, and shaped the direction of politics. And they're there because of money in politics. Which points us right back at the Supreme court, via Buckley vs. Valeo. (and Citizens United vs. FEC)
(Not to mention that many people liked the initial effects of globalization and privatization. It's not like nobody voted for NAFTA, e.g.)
To the extent that's true, its the result of major party primary elections and other processes and the decisions voters made in those (including the decision to stay out of them.)
I can understand that many people did not / would not show up, though. That's a problem...
Her/his point was, I think, that, even people in a democracy, have very little control over what policies are followed. And that you will see that happening to you, too.
> If any generation had the power to change things how things ended up today, it was yours. To pick one example: all the supreme court justices who presided over the Citizens United case were appointed during your prime years.
The laws overturned in Citizens United had only been on the books a scant few years, and those laws made exercises of free speech illegal.
Whether or not big money in politics is a problem, the Citizens United decision was decided in favor of free speech moreso than in favor of dark money, and it's quite likely that if you voted for the presidents who appointed the majority justices in citizens united that you also voted for the guy whose law was overturned by it. Ergo, casting it as a one-side versus the other form of complicity does not work.
That sounds like demonizing a whole anonymous group based on personal perceptions.
You specifically, unlikely.
Your generation brought in Reagan. Your generation (along with Gen X) pretty much has run the government since 2000. The great shift to the right was largely your doing and would never have been sustained if your generation wasn't what it was. :/
http://www.people-press.org/2015/04/30/a-different-look-at-g...
You brought the country so far to the right your generation actually flipped from R to D. It was truly quite the amazing transformation from relative sanity to batshit crazy. It completely obliterated balance in this country.
http://www.vox.com/2016/7/25/12256510/republican-party-trump...
> “Goldwater’s nomination in 1964 was a historical disaster for the conservative movement,” Roy tells me, “because for the ensuing decades, it identified Democrats as the party of civil rights and Republicans as the party opposed to civil rights.”
For better or worse, your generation and Gen X has to own the shift to the right in this country because you are largely the generations responsible for it. That rightward shift has gutted everything the Millenials depended on to climb economically from schools to infrastructure to rational tax policies.
Generation X was under 18 when Reagan was elected.
You speak to your friends, you do what you can within your life, you support justice and oppose actual evil (not sloganed evil). You respect respectful people of all politics. You play with your kids and hope for the best.
You need to realize it isn't personal against you.
If a majority of a group vote in favor of X, they bear some responsibility for it. Particularly when they don't rebuke it after the fact.
> People have a right to speak, and to vote for their direction. Sometimes people win, sometimes people lose. Sometimes things go really badly, but we can't all be President or members of Congress.
Obama and HRC were (economic policy wise) 60s Republicans. Modern Republicans are basically Reagan-derivatives.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/posteverything/wp/2015/11/05/...
> One moment in the third Republican presidential debate encapsulates everything terrible about baby boomers and the way they’ve pillaged the U.S. economy. It came from Sen. Marco Rubio of Florida, a Generation Xer, who offered the standard line — you can hear it from the mouth of almost any American politician today — on how to keep Medicare and Social Security solvent. Rubio defended the idea that future workers will need to retire later or receive fewer benefits from those safety-net programs than current retirees. “Everyone up here tonight that’s talking about reforms,” he stipulated, was “talking about reforms for future generations. Nothing has to change for current beneficiaries.”
I don't feel the need to be polite about it when elected politicians are comfortable stating their plan to "reform" the system is to screw me and people my age in favor of another group of people.
Actually, if Trump wins, they'll get blamed for Donald Trump. Each and every one of them. :)
I am very glad many older Americans can make it. Taking care of the non-working elderly Americans is mostly a chore that I see in both my day job and my family's own history.
One true benefit of being an older worker is you don't ever have to put up with any BS at your job. I work now at the most hated retailer and love it, but will quit the minute I stop liking it. I will move on to the next part time job. When I was in the tech scene I never had the choice to leave because the pay was too good. But as an older dude, the freedom from saying "Screw you employer" is better than power or prestige
The data tells us that almost all of the new jobs created since the recession have gone to those with at least a college education:
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-06-30/americans-...
There you can view your statement.
Can anyone point me to some well argued work that squares the above 2 sentences? I'm an immigrant to the U.S. myself, so I'm not anti-immigrant per se, it's just that some things have left me scratching my head.
A large number of workers are needed in the US to do low-wage tasks - pretty much so their employer can profit from their labor - and some of the issue is that illegal immigrants wouldn't be counted as part of the labor force (because they aren't supposed to be here), but in theory, they are displacing the opportunity for Citizens to do those jobs.
The issues are more complex than I describe, and they certainly will apply to skilled labor too (ex: nurses to care for an aging population). One of the major contentions is that companies, in reality, post jobs with requirements that are high (10+ years! X, Y, Z skills!) but offer a salary or compensation that is way, way below market value. This means that technically yes, the company can not find a qualified candidate to do the job, because they have targeted people who would be willing to do it for much less just to, well, have an opportunity to get into the US.
It is very backwards for the US to be "anti-immigration" as a general concept (it's the foundation of the nation!), so how the arguments get twisted make it hard to figure out in some ways. This explanation is simply my perspective using my observations and stuff I read, so it is not peer reviewed or anything like that!
Which is why I said "real unemployment." The official rate may be 6% but the real rate may be 20% (if we were to count the people who have given up and are now on welfare).
All our problems are laid at the door of land price ramping.
Anecdotally, I know an astounding number of people over 55 that still hold a mortgage. Hell, I've known people who retired with a mortgage.
So I'm guessing that in many cases they're a cashier because if they don't work they'll lose the house.
Heck no! Stop working, start dying.
The thing to do here is to sell the house and move to a lower COL area, like all the HN threads that mention SF housing advise.
Or for that matter, tell that to the person who already lives in Bumphuck, IN. My wife has high school friends in situations like that. There is no cheaper place to live, but that mortgage still needs to be paid.
IMO, a lot of this has to do with housing subsides keeping people near city's who don't need to be near city's. If your rent has not kept up with inflation for the last 20+ years then why move? You don't have any equity to liquidate and rent control is keeping the price stable so just stay.
http://www.zerohedge.com/sites/default/files/images/user5/im...
Anecdotally I've seen more and more 60+ workers doing line-level gigs like cashier or low-skill retail than ever. I think there's an undercurrent of discrimination against youth, actually, in that the 55+ group will be dependable and complacent because they need to work and therefore will show up to work.
In the modern US economy, longevity in one firm or role is actually bad for a young person's career! There are no pensions to earn. There are limited annual raises that are lower than inflation. On and on and on.
I'd be a lot more sympathetic to the plight of the elderly in such a position if they weren't, you know, basically kicking away the ladder they used to climb to the top, spend the country broke, and then continue to vote entitlements while passing a faux-future of success demanding everybody get a Bachelor's to even be a Secretary answering phones. This whole system is so broken pointing it out sounds extreme or mean, but it's just obvious to me over these past 15+ years of working.
I just got my SS statement the other day, and was extremely proud to see that every year I was eligible to work, even if I was going to school / college / etc, I did work. Not a single year without an above the board job. I don't think a lot of Millenials will be able to come anywhere near it, and I don't think it's entirely their fault. End of my $0.02 that is really worth about 1/8 of that...