News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by PhilWright on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @12:11AM (#12215531)
There is nothing unique or special about being a programmer.

Programmers think they are undervalued and should get more. But guess what, nurses think they should get more as well because they are saving lives. Soldiers think they should get more for making us all safe. Police think they should get more for reducing the level of crime in society which benefits us all. Teachers think they should get more because they are educating the next generation of wealth creators. Everyone thinks they should get a little more of the pie.

How do you resolve this? (Hint: supply and demand)

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by ghshephard on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @12:22AM (#12215567)
Couple points - I didn't say there is anything unique or special about being a programmer from a skill perspective. Almost everyone who can graduate from high school can be taught to program, and put together useful applications. I tried to call that out when describing the difference between a day-day CRUD developer and platform developer.

But there is a distinct hierarchy of developers who can, for example, instinctively comprehend pointer-to-pointer data structures, or have walked through and mostly understand AoCP, or heck, can (quickly) write concise elegant code like this: http://www.cs.princeton.edu/courses/archive/spr09/cos333/bea....

One key difference between programming and teaching/soldiering/policing, is leverage. A single 100x teacher/soldier/police officer is limited in the impact they can have on the world, whereas a single 100x developer can write a platform/system that is used by 100s of millions of people.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by Frondo on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @01:22AM (#12215776)
I'd disagree about the 100x something-other-than-a-coder having a limited impact.

I'd call Florence Nightingale a 100x nurse, or maybe a 10,000x nurse, for the impact she had on the world:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Florence_Nightingale#Statistic...

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by ghshephard on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @10:50AM (#12218297)
Now we're talking about heroic icons. There are thousands, or maybe 10s of thousands of 100x developers. There is only one Florence Nightingale, Steve Jobs, Donald Knuth, Michelangelo, Einstein, etc...
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by baakss on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @01:53PM (#12219993)
You don't need to be a heroic icon to be more valuable than a 100x developer.

The 100x teacher who molds the mind of the kid/teenager/adult who eventually cures cancer is worth more than just about any single 100x developer out there right now, and you'll never know that person's name.

(Yeah, I'm aware there will be multiple different cures for different cancers, the point remains)

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by ghshephard on Thursday August 04, 2016 @03:08AM (#12223922)
It would be interesting to see if any great researcher could tie back their success to a teacher. My suspicion (based on nothing more than gut feeling) is that while a good/great teacher has some impact, that beyond a certain level it's 99.9% the individual and their environment/peers/parents/contacts, rather than any particular teacher.

Another way of saying this from a mercenary monetary point of view is that I don't think investing more than $250K/year on a K-12 teacher makes sense, though you might be able to make an argument that people who teach teachers might have greater leverage.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by PhilWright on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @12:33AM (#12215601)
I certainly agree that the spread in productivity between the best and mediocre seems to be huge in software development compared to most other industries. In fact, I cannot think of another one quite like it off the top of my head.

We do have certain other advantages though. We can create a start-up and potentially make a huge amount of money. This is a realistic possibility for a substantial percentage of good developers. Much fewer people from other industries have that kind of chance.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by rimantas on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @04:55AM (#12216612)

  > There is nothing unique or special about being a programmer.
Really? Take 1000 programmers and try to teach them skills nurses have. How many will be able to do the job well enought to be able to work at the hospitals? Now take 1000 nurses and try to teach them skills programmers have. Is the number suitable for profession work at sowftware companies be the same, as in the first case?

You can claim, that there is nothing unique or special in being theoretical physicist. But is that really true?

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by arrrg on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @05:44AM (#12216789)
Huh?

I’m in no way mentally prepared to be a nurse. That is something I suspect I would never ever be able to do. That has to do with skills (especially hard to learn skills, like interacting with people properly), it also has to do with being emotionally ready to do such a job. Especially a job like being a nurse is in my estimation not something you can just teach. You need people who are prepared, ready and willing to do the job.

I think very, very few of those 1,000 programmers would be ready to work in hospitals. I would not at all be surprised if you could find more great programmers among 1,000 nurses than you can find great nurses among 1,000 programmers. To me being a nurse is an extremely demanding job.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by louisswiss on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @05:26AM (#12216732)
I am a developer and have a very close friend who is a nurse. I am pretty sure I could teach her enough to do an entry level web dev job within 2-3 months, whereas there is no way I would be mentally or emotionally prepared to deal with working life as a 'real' nurse within that short amount of time, if ever.
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by geebee on Thursday August 04, 2016 @11:20AM (#12226090)
I couldn't agree with you more that nursing is a tough job that deserves excellent pay (though out here in SF, registered nurses do earn more, at the median, than software application developers, though this is a bit unusual and not the case in most areas). It would take a tremendous amount of time, training, and effort to turn a software developer into a registered nurse, no doubt.

I am pretty bummed to hear a developer speak so dismissively of what it takes to be developer. I'm not sure what you mean about an "entry level" web job, of course - if "entry level" entails no background or skills, then I suppose I could prepare someone in no time at all.

However - and I fully acknowledge this is just anecdote - after 15+ years in the field, I have yet to see the mythical simple CRUD app. I came into this field after a major in math with a CS emphasis and a MS in Industrial Engineering, during which I wrote a lot of code for various numerical analysis problems. I've written apps that need to build and solve linear programs with a few million variables and communicate results to analysis within one minute, which we felt was the maximum amount of time anyone would wait for an interactive tool designed to explore multiple supply chain scenarios. It is hardly a work of genius, but these were real CS and math problems, with a dose of programming optimization.

In many ways, those projects were considerably easier than the "CRUD" projects I've been on. Seriously. You have to gather business requirements from people who do understand their business, but aren't accustomed to explaining it in a way that works within the strict confines of computer code. You often have to work with existing code bases, deciding how much customization you can get away with before forking yourself into a maintenance hell (and you have to deal with that maintenance hell). You have to integrate with many different data sources, back and forth, over networks, many of which are obscure, poorly documented, and poorly maintained. You are pressured to provide estimates and deadlines for systems that you have no idea about (how long will it take me to alter a code base for an existing application to integrate with a data source that I haven't studied yet? Uh, a week?). You have to weave through existing data structures, code bases that involve intricate logic, uncover magic documents that nobody told you about, interview and talk to business analysts, test, design UIs or work with UI people... and often encounter an (at best) irritated look when you didn't meet your "estimates" that turned into deadlines.

I maintain that even the "simple CRUD" projects are difficult, stressful, and require a very high level of logic, coding ability, and the ability to communicate will with people at many levels of an organization.

If you truly believe that web dev is simple, of course you have every right to make that point. You shouldn't back of from saying what you think is the truth just because the truth is harmful to the reputation of developers.

What pains me is that I absolutely don't agree with you, I think it's a really hard job, and I think we developers really hurt ourselves when we trivialize our jobs this way.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by louisswiss on Monday August 08, 2016 @05:51AM (#12246502)
This is all very interesting, but has absolutely nothing whatsoever to do with my point. I am saying that both web dev and nursing can be very challenging, yet while everybody of college ability could learn enough web dev to function well in a junior position (and your description definitely wasn't a junior position at any of the companies I have seen), very few have the emotional and psychological strength to work as a nurse - especially given the difference in pay.

The world knows how difficult software development is - we don't need to put down other professions (which equally difficult yet in a different way)

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by geebee on Saturday August 13, 2016 @11:46AM (#12281866)
We're having this discussion in slow motion.

We're both looking at exactly the same words, sometimes people just reach different conclusions. You've said that we don't need to put down other professions, but consider your words about software development and nursing...

"I am pretty sure I could teach her enough to do an entry level web dev job within 2-3 months, whereas there is no way I would be mentally or emotionally prepared to deal with working life as a 'real' nurse within that short amount of time, if ever."

I do see that as putting down software development in order to build up nursing. Like I said, we're looking at the same words, so this is just a matter of perspective.

Perspectives sometimes vary because of experience. I actually don't agree, as a general condition, that the world knows how difficult software development is. Some of the world does, and some software development positions are clearly respected. But as a general statement? No, I really don't agree - I see too many developers working loud, distracting open offices, back visibility, methodologies that reduce autonomy and long term thinking the to micromanaged 24 hour "sprints", and a career path where "successful" people should term out before age 35.

I certainly wouldn't argue that this describes all dev jobs, but it sure does describe a lot of them. I do think that the kind of denigration of the field I'm hearing here does contribute to this.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by iopq on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @06:11AM (#12216886)
> How many will be able to do the job well enought to be able to work at the hospitals?

None of them, because programmers hate working with people so they'd all quit.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by Consultant32452 on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @12:41AM (#12215626)
That's why labor policy is so important. The guy digging proverbial ditches does indeed deserve more, but the market has been distorted by large corporations who lobby for lax enforcement of immigration law. On the other end of the spectrum engineers and programmers probably deserve more but the market has been distorted by large corporations who have lobbied for massive numbers of H1Bs or colluded with each other to keep poaching/salaries down in the valley.
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by twblalock on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @12:46AM (#12215645)
> The guy digging proverbial ditches does indeed deserve more

How do you know? Do you have some kind of special formula to determine what people deserve to be paid? Otherwise, it's just subjective.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by Consultant32452 on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @01:06AM (#12215728)
Because I have a basic understanding of supply and demand. I even explained how supply of labor was being distorted in my post at both the higher and lower ends of the job market. I think the more appropriate question is how do you not know?
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by twblalock on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @01:42AM (#12215858)
Ok, then what does a ditch digger deserve to be paid?

The answer is a number.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by Consultant32452 on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @02:00AM (#12215908)
http://www.nytimes.com/2013/02/17/magazine/do-illegal-immigr...

Labor economists have concluded that undocumented workers have lowered the wages of U.S. adults without a high-school diploma — 25 million of them — by anywhere between 0.4 to 7.4 percent.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by twblalock on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @05:28AM (#12216737)
This is the paragraph immediately following the sentence you quoted:

> The impact on everyone else, though, is surprisingly positive. Giovanni Peri, an economist at the University of California, Davis, has written a series of influential papers comparing the labor markets in states with high immigration levels to those with low ones. He concluded that undocumented workers do not compete with skilled laborers — instead, they complement them. Economies, as Adam Smith argued in “Wealth of Nations,” work best when workers become specialized and divide up tasks among themselves. Pedro Chan’s ability to take care of routine tasks on a work site allows carpenters and electricians to focus on what they do best. In states with more undocumented immigrants, Peri said, skilled workers made more money and worked more hours; the economy’s productivity grew. From 1990 to 2007, undocumented workers increased legal workers’ pay in complementary jobs by up to 10 percent.

Don't make it look one-sided.

Besides, you didn't tell me what you think a ditch digger should earn, which is what I asked. But that's fine, because you can't tell me, because you don't know. In fact, nobody knows. It is an unanswerable question. Much like determining what someone's "fair share" of taxes or benefits is, or their fair standard of living, it is impossible to determine the income they "deserve." There is no absolute standard for any of these things. The only way to know if someone is being fairly compensated is to compare their income to some kind of absolute standard -- but such a standard does not exist.

In the case of unskilled American workers, maybe their incomes are 0.4-7.4% lower than they would have been in the absence of immigrants. But that by itself does not tell us anything about fairness. Perhaps they were overpaid before the immigrants showed up -- after all, there were other people willing to do the job for less money, so what did the American workers have to offer that justified a higher salary for doing the same work? Again, in the absence of an absolute standard of what their income ought to be, it is impossible to know if they are fairly paid, underpaid, or overpaid.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by Consultant32452 on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @06:06AM (#12216860)
So your argument is that it's okay that we've made it worse for the people who already had it the hardest because the rest of the more wealthy people in the country benefitted from it? Sorry, but that doesn't make it better.

As for the rest of your post, my comment implied a context of the moral an legal framework currently in place in the US and most countries people would actually want to live in. But you're willing to dismiss major components of domestic and international law as well as the basic moral principles most of us live by with a vague existentialist argument about whether fairness even exists. We're not even debating the same thing, and what you want to debate isn't something I'm interested in debating.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by twblalock on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @06:15AM (#12216905)
> So your argument is that it's okay that we've made it worse for the people who already had it the hardest because the rest of the more wealthy people in the country benefitted from it?

Where did I write that? I included the excerpt from the article to demonstrate your intellectual dishonesty in selectively quoting a single sentence from an article that is positive about the effects of immigration. I did not make any moral judgments anywhere in my comment. Quite the contrary -- I argued that a moral judgment in this situation was not possible to make.

What legal framework have I dismissed which determines what someone deserves to earn, aside from the minimum wage?

We are debating the same thing. I'm arguing that your assertions have no basis. If you don't know what is fair, you cannot know if someone is treated fairly or not.

You have no basis for your claim that some people are paid less than they deserve to be paid, unless you know what they deserve to be paid, and can demonstrate that what they are actually paid is a lower number than what they deserve to be paid. That's not a vague argument. It is very clear. It's also not existentialist, and if you think it is, you don't know what existentialism is.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by Consultant32452 on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @07:10AM (#12217116)
I wasn't referring to philosophical existentialism. This is the definition of existential I was using, straight from google.com:

ex·is·ten·tial ˌeɡzəˈsten(t)SH(ə)l/ LOGIC (of a proposition) affirming or implying the existence of a thing.

Sure, okay, there's no absolute standard for fairness. So there's no point in discussing the article, because by what basis would you even discuss whether or not employers should be allowed to ask applicants for their previous income? By what basis should we determine whether we should have any labor laws? What is the absolute standard by which you determined that there should be a minimum wage, or what that minimum wage should be?

If we ignore the entire framework of the conversation and my original comment, then we're veering off into a place I don't find particularly interesting.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by twblalock on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @02:28PM (#12220263)
I didn't say that fairness does not exist, or that there are not standards for fairness for some things. I said there is no standard for determining the fairness of what someone is paid. There are plenty of areas of life where fairness can be determined.
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by stickfigure on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @02:58AM (#12216137)
...and increased the wages of otherwise poor Guatemalans, Mexicans, and their families by thousands of percent. Why exactly should I be opposed to this?
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by Consultant32452 on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @05:37AM (#12216765)
I don't think it's noble to be charitable with someone else's money, especially when that someone else is already at the poverty level.
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by stickfigure on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @10:34AM (#12218163)
Let me see if I understand this: In your worldview, allowing the brown-skinned person next door to bid on the same work that you are bidding on is equivalent to taking money from you?
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by twblalock on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @05:51AM (#12216816)
Poverty is relative. What we call poverty is a lot more comfortable, and safer, than the conditions the immigrants came from.

We haven't eliminated poverty in this country because we keep moving the goalposts.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by Consultant32452 on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @06:13AM (#12216899)
If you're concerned then send your own money, don't advocate policies that take it from our poorest.
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by twblalock on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @06:20AM (#12216934)
I never advocated a policy. Why do you think I did? You are reading a lot into my comments that isn't there.
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by Consultant32452 on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @01:53AM (#12215891)
The cumulative impact to low wage native workers is estimated between $99-118 Billion per year.

https://www.hks.harvard.edu/fs/gborjas/publications/popular/... (page 2)

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by alasdair_ on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @06:43PM (#12222084)
>The guy digging proverbial ditches does indeed deserve more, but the market has been distorted by large corporations who lobby for lax enforcement of immigration law.

Do gravediggers get paid relatively more than other kinds of jobs in countries where there is essentially no immigration for economic reasons? I doubt it.