News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by twblalock on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @01:42AM (#12215858)
Ok, then what does a ditch digger deserve to be paid?

The answer is a number.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by Consultant32452 on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @02:00AM (#12215908)
http://www.nytimes.com/2013/02/17/magazine/do-illegal-immigr...

Labor economists have concluded that undocumented workers have lowered the wages of U.S. adults without a high-school diploma — 25 million of them — by anywhere between 0.4 to 7.4 percent.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by twblalock on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @05:28AM (#12216737)
This is the paragraph immediately following the sentence you quoted:

> The impact on everyone else, though, is surprisingly positive. Giovanni Peri, an economist at the University of California, Davis, has written a series of influential papers comparing the labor markets in states with high immigration levels to those with low ones. He concluded that undocumented workers do not compete with skilled laborers — instead, they complement them. Economies, as Adam Smith argued in “Wealth of Nations,” work best when workers become specialized and divide up tasks among themselves. Pedro Chan’s ability to take care of routine tasks on a work site allows carpenters and electricians to focus on what they do best. In states with more undocumented immigrants, Peri said, skilled workers made more money and worked more hours; the economy’s productivity grew. From 1990 to 2007, undocumented workers increased legal workers’ pay in complementary jobs by up to 10 percent.

Don't make it look one-sided.

Besides, you didn't tell me what you think a ditch digger should earn, which is what I asked. But that's fine, because you can't tell me, because you don't know. In fact, nobody knows. It is an unanswerable question. Much like determining what someone's "fair share" of taxes or benefits is, or their fair standard of living, it is impossible to determine the income they "deserve." There is no absolute standard for any of these things. The only way to know if someone is being fairly compensated is to compare their income to some kind of absolute standard -- but such a standard does not exist.

In the case of unskilled American workers, maybe their incomes are 0.4-7.4% lower than they would have been in the absence of immigrants. But that by itself does not tell us anything about fairness. Perhaps they were overpaid before the immigrants showed up -- after all, there were other people willing to do the job for less money, so what did the American workers have to offer that justified a higher salary for doing the same work? Again, in the absence of an absolute standard of what their income ought to be, it is impossible to know if they are fairly paid, underpaid, or overpaid.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by Consultant32452 on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @06:06AM (#12216860)
So your argument is that it's okay that we've made it worse for the people who already had it the hardest because the rest of the more wealthy people in the country benefitted from it? Sorry, but that doesn't make it better.

As for the rest of your post, my comment implied a context of the moral an legal framework currently in place in the US and most countries people would actually want to live in. But you're willing to dismiss major components of domestic and international law as well as the basic moral principles most of us live by with a vague existentialist argument about whether fairness even exists. We're not even debating the same thing, and what you want to debate isn't something I'm interested in debating.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by twblalock on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @06:15AM (#12216905)
> So your argument is that it's okay that we've made it worse for the people who already had it the hardest because the rest of the more wealthy people in the country benefitted from it?

Where did I write that? I included the excerpt from the article to demonstrate your intellectual dishonesty in selectively quoting a single sentence from an article that is positive about the effects of immigration. I did not make any moral judgments anywhere in my comment. Quite the contrary -- I argued that a moral judgment in this situation was not possible to make.

What legal framework have I dismissed which determines what someone deserves to earn, aside from the minimum wage?

We are debating the same thing. I'm arguing that your assertions have no basis. If you don't know what is fair, you cannot know if someone is treated fairly or not.

You have no basis for your claim that some people are paid less than they deserve to be paid, unless you know what they deserve to be paid, and can demonstrate that what they are actually paid is a lower number than what they deserve to be paid. That's not a vague argument. It is very clear. It's also not existentialist, and if you think it is, you don't know what existentialism is.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by Consultant32452 on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @07:10AM (#12217116)
I wasn't referring to philosophical existentialism. This is the definition of existential I was using, straight from google.com:

ex·is·ten·tial ˌeɡzəˈsten(t)SH(ə)l/ LOGIC (of a proposition) affirming or implying the existence of a thing.

Sure, okay, there's no absolute standard for fairness. So there's no point in discussing the article, because by what basis would you even discuss whether or not employers should be allowed to ask applicants for their previous income? By what basis should we determine whether we should have any labor laws? What is the absolute standard by which you determined that there should be a minimum wage, or what that minimum wage should be?

If we ignore the entire framework of the conversation and my original comment, then we're veering off into a place I don't find particularly interesting.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by twblalock on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @02:28PM (#12220263)
I didn't say that fairness does not exist, or that there are not standards for fairness for some things. I said there is no standard for determining the fairness of what someone is paid. There are plenty of areas of life where fairness can be determined.
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by stickfigure on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @02:58AM (#12216137)
...and increased the wages of otherwise poor Guatemalans, Mexicans, and their families by thousands of percent. Why exactly should I be opposed to this?
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by Consultant32452 on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @05:37AM (#12216765)
I don't think it's noble to be charitable with someone else's money, especially when that someone else is already at the poverty level.
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by stickfigure on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @10:34AM (#12218163)
Let me see if I understand this: In your worldview, allowing the brown-skinned person next door to bid on the same work that you are bidding on is equivalent to taking money from you?
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by twblalock on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @05:51AM (#12216816)
Poverty is relative. What we call poverty is a lot more comfortable, and safer, than the conditions the immigrants came from.

We haven't eliminated poverty in this country because we keep moving the goalposts.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by Consultant32452 on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @06:13AM (#12216899)
If you're concerned then send your own money, don't advocate policies that take it from our poorest.
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by twblalock on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @06:20AM (#12216934)
I never advocated a policy. Why do you think I did? You are reading a lot into my comments that isn't there.
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by Consultant32452 on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @01:53AM (#12215891)
The cumulative impact to low wage native workers is estimated between $99-118 Billion per year.

https://www.hks.harvard.edu/fs/gborjas/publications/popular/... (page 2)