I know the argument is often framed as open vs closed source ecosystems but I think and hope that ultimately having more options and more variety is good and interesting for us.
Windows, does deservedly get a lot of stick for it's past issues (windows rot etc) and present issues. However, I think ultimately what we learn from these scenarios is extremely beneficial for a lot of people.
As a Web Developer I hated IE 6. I still do. But, I have to admit that it taught me a lot. It taught me about the box-model. It taught me how to debug JS before the days of Firefox/Firebug. I know this was not by design or intention and I know this is easier to say in retrospect.
I can imagine a lot of people working in info-sec learnt a lot from the various failings of Windows and other platforms too.
I guess my point is don't be negative for the sake of it. If Windows is bad, I hope it improves. Same goes for all technologies. I'm a Chrome user but I still love to run Opera, Firefox and Edge now and then because I enjoy different experiences and love playing with new apps and features. I also have a Macbook for work and and and Ubuntu partition. I enjoy using them all.
Chrome has never actively tried to uninstall/remove competing browsers or corrupt your ability to reliably run them, I distinctly remember my own install of Windows 10 destroying my bootloaders set up by Linux and uninstalling applications automatically. Although it has show the ability to send as much information as it wants back home.
>If Windows is bad, I hope it improves.
I'm sure people in 2001 were saying the same thing about Microsoft and it appears they are emulating it again.
For me, it's that the system is completely closed and opaque, and there routinely isn't much I can do about it.
Not saying the other guys are perfect--far from it--but at least I can take a crack at changing things. Windows is the most closed-source OS I run (more so than OSX). When it doesn't do The Right Thing, I can get very negative.
And to your point, I feel I've learned much more from OSes that expose the internals and let me mess with them, than those that don't.
For your listed use case of gaming & document creation.
There are a lot of niche applications that are Windows only. All major CAD platforms, a decent chunk of FEA packages, hardware vendor software, etc. At the professional level, Windows still has quite the grip.
From a profession standpoint, I'm still tied to Windows because of Adobe's choice not to port to linux. Inkscape and Gimp are okay, but when you're the only one in the company running linux, what's the point?
And, for a game from 2006, you'll probably have to pray to the Windows-compatibility-mode gods at this point, too. I actually wouldn't be surprised, if it worked better under WINE...
That's just not true. I've got plenty of games from 2006 and earlier than run just as good as they originally did. Sure Oblivion crashes, but it did in 2006. Half-Life 2 runs pretty darn well. Company of heroes? Yep. Dawn of War and the expansions? Sure.
In fact, my overall gaming experience on windows 10 is far better than it was on windows xp and vista. Less overall crashing, and I never get bluescreens any more.
Windows still dominates on workstations, but that no longer locks people in like it used to. Some user-interfaces can be pushed onto the web or mobile apps. Suppliers further down the chain are now as likely to support Linux as Windows.
My employer is a hardware vendor, our software is turning out Linux-only for the forseeable future. Of course the office PC's for us an most of our customers are Windows, but this is workable because of all kinds of (mostly network based) interoperability that has grown up over the years.
Secondly, plugins - there are a heap of free and paid plugins that are Windows-only that I'm not sure will work in Linux (I know about being able to bridge them, but even 32/64 Windows bridges have issues!) - having said that I've not tried this lately, so hopefully there's been some good progress.
Third, and probably most intractably - it's a big enough ask to get school IT departments to support 'odd' software like Cubase; getting them to support Linux, alas, would be infinitely unlikely, so I'd still need a Windows PC to support my teaching work (which is my main income).
Thanks for the tip, though, I shall re-look into Bitwig again as it's on Linux, and then my GalliumOS Chromebook could become even more useful!
It's the applications that are key and if some application requires a Windows machine, that's what they buy.
Try installing Ubuntu on a brand new laptop. Its just not something a non technical user can deal with. I am sure a good share of us here on HN has, at-least one relative who calls us because the "internet is broken" imagine them trying to deal with something like ubuntu on a brand new computer.
I like to think this is partially our fault as consumers, we need to actually do more to demand hardware vendors to support Linux. Especially laptop manufacturers.
In my experience installing a friendly linux like Ubuntu is a lot more simple than installing Windows. Unless the hardware is very new the install will just work. If you want to play games you may have to play around with installing the latest video drivers from the vendor, but how is this any different from what you have to do on a Windows machine?
NX runs on Linux too.
Many run on Mac & Linux. Hell, AutoCAD runs on iOS & Android.
I think its difficult to know the vast amount of software that's user/business critical that's Windows-only and how many people will never run an OS that isn't pre-install on their computer. Even as a sysadmin/devops for over a decade, I'm still surprised how strong Windows is. Some of it is legacy inertia and some of it is merit. No one else is investing in gaming like MS does. No one else builds developer friendly tools that a very mediocre team of devs can be made productive with. No one else builds a dumbed-down office suite that even a high school drop out can be productive in. No one else markets to the business community like MS, etc, etc.
It also doesn't help the "year of the linux desktop" argument that Windows is losing to mobile, but Windows 10 includes many mobile concepts. In fact, as far as I can tell, its very much modeled after Android. I know grandma won't buy a Surface Pro, but it is now easier for her to go from Android or iOS to Win10 and not be scared or confused.
I think Windows has a long life still. Just because you don't like it, doesn't mean you can just wish it away. For segments that aren't the kinds of people who post on HN, its still very popular and that's ignoring its dominance in business.
Also I use two massive 27-inch screens at work. My co-worker Ubuntu boxes have difficulties driving them properly (probably driver issues, manufacturer's fault). Also text rendering is still subpar on Ubuntu.
Windows 10, IMO, provides many nice aspects in terms of UI experience. Not that I'm gonna start developing on Windows in any foreseeable future
Personally I don't use Windows anymore but it seems like it's going to take a lot of work to get rid of the Windows platform out of commodity IT.
Windows 10 upgrade push made me to realize that that time passed a long time ago. Last time I booted to Windows for other reason than playing a game was seven years ago. LibreOffice works well with MS documents and you can always use them from Google drive.
Windows has lost it's grip for good.