News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by seibelj on Monday August 01, 2016 @12:11PM (#12203551)
> On the desktop, Brave provides a 40% to 60% speed increase, and a 2x to 4x speed increase on mobile devices. Mobile users see a direct reduction in both battery and data plan consumption. Brave also protects users with privacy and security features such as HTTPS Everywhere to encrypt data traffic, fingerprinting shields, phishing protection, malware filtering, and script blocking.

Maybe this is a good enough argument to get people to install it. But I seriously doubt you will get people to voluntarily pay money, which is slowly paid out as they surf the web, when the alternative is a free browsing experience with a standard ad blocker.

Also, all of their listed benefits to users is accessible on all other major browsers now with existing extensions.

Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by Paul-ish on Monday August 01, 2016 @02:02PM (#12204522)
I think we need to think two steps ahead here. Say everyone starts using ad blockers and disables flash. Then what? Websites still need to make money.

In this case Brave is betting that websites will want to ask for money from their users, but that each website maintaining their own subscription service is not viable. Maybe large websites like WSJ can get people to subscribe, but most probably cannot. Do you want to be subscribed to every website you ever read a single article on?

I think Brave in this case is positioning themselves to be the middle man. They want to become an essential layer that sits on top of the ISP. If their vision of the future turns out to be accurate, being the first mover here will be very profitable.

Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by onion2k on Monday August 01, 2016 @04:30PM (#12205665)
I think we need to think two steps ahead here. Say everyone starts using ad blockers and disables flash. Then what?

Websites die out.

We're only 30 years in to the web, and only 20 or so of those where advertising has been a workable system for funding an online business. In business model terms that's still very much in the "proof of concept" stage. Arguably the concept has been proven only to work when users have no way to block it. When they can block it and still view the media they often choose to do so, which means the business model fails.

This is true everywhere. The hayday of TV advertising was 40 years ago but now people have demonstrated a preference for subscription services that don't carry adverts (Netflix etc). Ad-funded print newspapers and magazines are dying because they don't offer something that many readers want, so their advertising model falls apart because they don't have the scale necessary to make it work. Radio seems to be bucking the trend somewhat as commercial radio is actually bouncing back, but that may be due to the costs falling dramatically.

Now it's online advertising lead businesses time for a reality check. 10 years ago online businesses could make a great deal of money by showing adverts to users who came for the content, but with the rise of social and the contraction in ad revenue they can't really continue. Maybe the answer is subscriptions (eg paywalls). Maybe it's micropayments (eg Brave). Or maybe, and this is what I'd bet on for the overwhelming majority of websites, it's just death. Everyone moves their content to Youtube and Facebook.

Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by eberkund on Monday August 01, 2016 @05:24PM (#12206134)
Websites die out.

No, a certain portion of websites will die out. There is a huge portion of website that do not make any or very little profit from advertising.

Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by bgun on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @12:09AM (#12207794)
This. The cost of serving even a fairly large website is within a hobbyist's budget and trending toward zero.
Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by onion2k on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @01:33AM (#12207973)
The technical side of a web business has always been cheap. Even 20 years ago you could pay the hosting costs of a huge site for the less than the salary of a junior dev. The content production side (writers, designers, film makers, media, marketing, etc) is where 99% of the costs lie.

It may well be the case that the future of the web is a return to sites built and run to host content produced by the site owners themselves instead of paid writers, but considering very few bloggers even come close to earning a living through their work now I doubt it.

Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by nugget on Monday August 01, 2016 @02:45PM (#12204852)
You can't reliably adblock vertically integrated sites like Facebook and Google search who sell and serve their own ads on their own domains. There's a scenario wherein monetization as we know it dies for the majority of long-tail sites and content creators migrate en mass to the large platforms in order to survive. Not a great scenario to think about if you love the decentralized nature of the early web but a plausible scenario nonetheless. There a few startups out there trying to "defeat" adblock by allowing smaller sites to mimic the vertically integrated nature of the largest platforms, and counterintuitively the web might be much better off in the long run if they succeed.
Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by anexprogrammer on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @02:03AM (#12208040)
Really?

ublock and even adblock seem to cope quite well with both. I haven't unintentionlly seen a Google search ad in a decade, or any Youtube ads. In the case of FB they block 95%+ - periodically a few ads seem to slip through for a day or two at most.

So what do you call reliable?

Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by MichaelGG on Monday August 01, 2016 @02:49PM (#12204891)
So what's Bitcoin have to do with it? Seems like that's a gimmick. Just provide a normal refillable/subscription account, then pay out the websites. Isn't that what Flattr or some such company already does? Onboarding customers with Bitcoin is a sure way to avoid making money. You could pay out on the backend with BTC but that's a minor detail.

With current Bitcoin you can't even do micropayments. So they're almost certainly looking at doing some grouping and batch pay system anyways.

Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by Animats on Monday August 01, 2016 @03:59PM (#12205418)
Yes, and they take a 15% cut for doing so.

(Bitcoin was supposed to support disintermediation, but it hasn't worked out that way. So was the Internet, yet now half of all traffic goes through Google or Facebook.)

Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by wyager on Monday August 01, 2016 @03:02PM (#12205003)
> With current Bitcoin you can't even do micropayments.

False. https://bitcoinj.github.io/working-with-micropayments

Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by tveita on Monday August 01, 2016 @03:59PM (#12205420)
This seems to be a protocol to coalesce multiple payments between a single sender and receiver, provided that the sender is willing to commit money up front. It does nothing for the case where a single sender wants to send one-time payments to multiple receivers, nor the case where many individual senders want to send to one receiver. In those cases it would only add overhead.

In the case of Brave it doesn't help them much since there is no real-time requirement, so they could accomplish the same by increasing the time between payouts. With some engineering they should be able to support literally thousands of users before they need to take everything off-chain.

Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by lmm on Monday August 01, 2016 @03:57PM (#12205406)
That still requires 2 transactions for every (user, site) pair. On a network that can do 10 transaction/second total. It might be usable for certain classes of micropayment, but certainly not for a "every website I visit" scenario.
Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by mikeyouse on Monday August 01, 2016 @05:09PM (#12206014)
I agree, but 10TPS is actually about 4x as many as Bitcoin can handle. It's more like 2.7TPS with actual usage:

https://www.quora.com/How-many-transactions-per-second-shoul...

Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by Ar-Curunir on Monday August 01, 2016 @03:54PM (#12205383)
There are a few ways to do bitcoin micropayments. There's lightning payment channels, probabilistic micropayments [PassShelat 15,16].
Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by HairyGing3r on Monday August 01, 2016 @03:11PM (#12205072)
There are a few developments trying to crack down the micropayment Holy grail
Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by gorhill on Monday August 01, 2016 @02:41PM (#12204827)
> Then what?

If one agree with ads as a mean to fund specific sites, then they should just whitelist themselves these sites they think should receive advertisement revenues?

I don't get the idea of bringing in even more 3rd parties in between users and publishers.

Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by Paul-ish on Monday August 01, 2016 @02:45PM (#12204846)
That is too much friction, it creates a non-monetary transaction fee that is too high. People don't want to think hard about whether each article (or even website!) is worth reading before they read it. I think this is why Netflix and Spotify is successful.
Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by Mahn on Monday August 01, 2016 @12:33PM (#12203756)
It doesn't make much sense to be honest. I've heard about this browser a few times now and I still have no idea how is it supposed to gain traction. The performance/bandwidth benefits of less shitty ads can be had by simply disabling flash and using an ad blocker, and otherwise average people just aren't going to care to switch. As far as I can tell the only reason investors threw $7M at them is because Brendan Eich is involved.
Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by jcoffland on Monday August 01, 2016 @12:57PM (#12203976)
I don't see how there is any honesty in watching ads. You seem to be implying that I, as an Internet user, have agreed to view ads in return for content and that I'm being dishonest by not viewing the ads.

I believe the reverse is true. Content providers promise content via hyperlinked text instead they dishonestly deliver content plus ads, something I did not agree to.

Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by st3v3r on Monday August 01, 2016 @03:06PM (#12205040)
I cannot agree to this. Your entire premise rests upon the idea that these people are creating content for you for free. That you are entitled to someone else's work for free.
Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by curioussavage on Monday August 01, 2016 @09:43PM (#12207345)
NO, the entire premise rests on the FACT that the site owner IS sending the content to me for free. No entitlement there. Just reality. Now if they put up a pay wall and I start whining to you that is entitlement. Very different things if you think about it.

Now the obvious thing to say is - "well people won't pay to see the content" And to that I will respond by thinking: "hmmm, does the content really have any value then?"

Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by st3v3r on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @10:58AM (#12210416)
If it doesn't have value, then why do you insist on viewing it? Once again, you're stating you're entitled to their content instead of simply going to another site.
Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by jcoffland on Monday August 01, 2016 @04:00PM (#12205431)
Is my attention worth nothing? Are my contributions in the form of comments without value? Regardless I never agreed to view ads in trade for access to content and to be completely fair it was not offered to me in this way.

The usual offer is along the lines of "hey click this link you will like what you find there." This is a far cry from, "view these ads and we will provided you with content."

Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by st3v3r on Monday August 01, 2016 @08:04PM (#12207021)
"Is my attention worth nothing? Are my contributions in the form of comments without value?"

Pretty much. You can't pay rent with "attention". It's just like the people that try to get designers to do work for free because of "exposure".

"Regardless I never agreed to view ads in trade for access to content and to be completely fair it was not offered to me in this way."

Yeah, you kinda did. This is the implicit agreement of the internet. If you don't like it, that's fine; there's nothing wrong with that. The point at which it does become wrong is, instead of going to some other website that doesn't do this, you continue to view the content, draining their bandwidth and resources, as though you are entitled to the content. If you don't want to view ads, go to sites that either offer content on a subscription basis and pay that, or on a donation basis.

Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by jcoffland on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @07:22PM (#12214206)
> This is the implicit agreement of the internet.

Says who. The Internet was here before the corporations got ahold of it. And as a matter of fact, so was I.

If someone puts up something in a public space I have every right to view it in the way I please. That includes not looking at parts of it.

Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by sp332 on Monday August 01, 2016 @01:08PM (#12204080)
I want to support the sites I visit but I really dislike ads. I subscribe to a few but it would be a pain to set up individually for every site. Other people are also worried about being tracked online. This lets you conveniently support sites as you browse, without being tracked.
Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by icebraining on Monday August 01, 2016 @01:10PM (#12204103)
I wonder how can they pay the site you visit without tracking your visits to those sites.

EDIT: apparently they use Anonize, that's interesting.

https://anonize.org/assets/technology.html

Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by sp332 on Monday August 01, 2016 @01:18PM (#12204170)
Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by ryanSrich on Monday August 01, 2016 @02:17PM (#12204640)
I don't doubt that some people would love to have this browser. I just fail to see how you build a billion dollar market around it.
Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by zimbatm on Monday August 01, 2016 @02:12PM (#12204600)
But why not just make a browser extension like everybody else? Surely adoption would be easier as well.
Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by sp332 on Monday August 01, 2016 @02:13PM (#12204610)
Most mobile browsers don't support addons.
Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by etatoby on Monday August 01, 2016 @08:40PM (#12207147)
That's why Firefox mobile is the best browser for Android.
Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by azakai on Monday August 01, 2016 @04:29PM (#12205646)
> The performance/bandwidth benefits of less shitty ads can be had by simply disabling flash and using an ad blocker, and otherwise average people just aren't going to care to switch.

I think the point is that average people wouldn't know how to get an ad blocker, but would notice the massive perf benefits of having one.

A browser whose entire focus is on adblocking is therefore exactly what they would appreciate: out of the box, it works great.

Of course for us tech people here, installing an ad blocker is easy, so it seems a little silly. But we are a tiny fraction of the market.

Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by drusepth on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @04:17PM (#12213026)
Definitely seems that way to me. For those of us that intentionally don't use ad blockers, I see literally no reason to use this browser over anything else. I see lots of reasons (extensions, comparability, compatibility, support, etc) _not_ to use it, though.
Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by silverwind on Monday August 01, 2016 @01:54PM (#12204458)
Wouldn't it be great if that money went into the Servo [1] project? We wouldn't have to rely on blocking content to speed up browsing.

[1] https://servo.org/

Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by dingaling on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @02:09AM (#12208062)
Servo only speeds-up browsing if you have a fairly recent GPU that supports it. Otherwise it doesn't run.
Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by dman on Monday August 01, 2016 @12:54PM (#12203942)
Disabling javascript takes it one step further.
Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by forgotpwtomain on Monday August 01, 2016 @01:00PM (#12204004)
Which breaks HTTP DELETE since HTML5 doesn't have support for it..
Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by dman on Monday August 01, 2016 @02:51PM (#12204909)
I dont care about brokenness - allowing arbitrary sites to run javascript / store cookies has begun to feel like running windows without a password in the 90s. When things break, I now stop using the website. In rare cases I add it to a whitelist.
Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by PeCaN on Monday August 01, 2016 @02:46PM (#12204857)
How so?

  <form method="post" action="...">
    <input type="hidden" name="_method" value="DELETE"/>
  </form>
has been the standard workaround since like… 2005, if not earlier, and works quite fine without JavaScript (assuming your server-side supports it, and most or all common frameworks do).
Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by forgotpwtomain on Monday August 01, 2016 @02:56PM (#12204945)
That's a workaround only if the server forges the value of '_method' into method via. Middleware
Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by PeCaN on Monday August 01, 2016 @03:34PM (#12205235)
> assuming your server-side supports it, and most or all common frameworks do
Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by MichaelGG on Monday August 01, 2016 @02:51PM (#12204901)
Seriously, who cares? POST /deleteThing. Done.
Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by dieselz on Monday August 01, 2016 @12:23PM (#12203659)
> But I seriously doubt you will get people to voluntarily pay money

I've always been curious about this. I'd definitely pay $25/mo if it was distributed amongst the websites I visit. Bonus points if it would distribute it more heavily to the smaller sites than the bigger ones.

Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by jerf on Monday August 01, 2016 @12:27PM (#12203705)
By the time you're done manifesting that concretely, you've nearly got Patreon. Yes, it's not quite identical, but, for instance, once you accept that the site still has to opt-in it ceases to be magic.
Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by icebraining on Monday August 01, 2016 @01:11PM (#12204113)
Or Flattr.
Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by nailer on Monday August 01, 2016 @01:53PM (#12204447)
Or window.payment which Chrome and Safari are already implementing (using Apple Pay and Google Wallet respectively).
Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by rhino369 on Monday August 01, 2016 @01:53PM (#12204455)
If this was required to view sites, I'd definitely pay it. But I also wouldn't go out of my way to do it.

I'm sure the right business could pull it off, but I don't think it's going to be voluntary donations.

Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by mdrzn on Monday August 01, 2016 @12:25PM (#12203681)
Also, "Brave provides a 40% to 60% speed increase" compared to WHAT? They may even be comparing it with Internet Explorer 6 for all we know.
Re:‘Bitcoin Browser’ Brave Raises $4.5M, Readies for 1.0 Launch by sp332 on Monday August 01, 2016 @01:06PM (#12204072)
Compared to the same browser with tracking enabled. https://brave.com/#faster