- trust our employees b/c we're not beholden to people who insist we don't
- speak our minds b/c we're ok with losing customers who disagree with us (since they're the only people we're responsible to)
agree with you re: company runs without debt, tho. that's unrelated to their larger point.
Reconstruction/guessing line of thought: When profitable, you don't need to indebt yourself to stay afloat, hence less people/entities to account to, hence more freedom.
Running a company without debt is liberating; you have a dozen fewer things to worry about.
I enjoyed Rework but I find the canonical way they try to pass of these opinions increasingly distasteful.
My point is that without completely agreeing with it, the post still has value.
Spending money you haven't earned yet (either through an investor, a bank loan, etc.) can be a very good way to accelerate growth, and sometimes the only way to allow any kind of growth or even continuity. But I do think there is some truth to the cost of debt in having to deal with your creditors one way or another.
heh No I'm not (I have a mortgage). I'm using the banks money, and investing it to make a pretty handsome return. (I'm in the UK, property prices are doing pretty well).
Debt is useful to build big stuff. As far as I see it, 37signals aren't building big stuff, so they don't need debt.
If people had to actually write in all the 'qualifiers for smartasses' to avoid it, they would make pretty awful reading. The frustrating thing is, this reads like it's already been through some of that. He's very obviously not claiming some iron causality between debt and profitability. Just a relationship, in his case, possibly, consult your doctor before attempting.
It's not the purpose of the article and it would be a tangent to go off and explain this relationship. Again, if you were making a subtle epistemological argument about the relationship between knowledge and certainty, go chase down everything. This is a blog post about the joys of running a profitable business.
No one is going to build a business from a literalistic interpretation of a blog post.
But their SvN blog is the opposite: they post whatever strikes their fancy whenever they want. I prodded and he told me that there's no restraint on publishing -- any of their employees can post with no explicit pre-approval. He said that sometimes people will have him do a sanity check before posting, and he could only recall giving the thumbs-down once.
I connected the dots and posited that the blog acts as the release valve for the whole company's feature angst -- he didn't really have a response (and was tired of talking to my crazy ass), but he didn't have a rebuttal either.
I kid, I kid ;-)
Take this post.
Premise: Profits = Freedom.
Results:
Company runs without debt: unrelated to profits. Profitable companies can use debt as a tool, and they cite their lack of credit history as causing a problem! Debt free is not the same as profitable.
We trust our employees: this has everything to do with hiring and nothing to do with profitability. They can offer the benefits they list because they're profitable, but profit doesn't make them trust their employees.
We speak our minds: this is because they have controlling interest in the company, not because they don't have debt. Again, no relation.
This would be confusing as hell for someone that tried to build their business based on the advice in this post.