Despite the hype, the Web just isn't all that impressive as an information resource. The static, publicly accessible HTML text on the Web is roughly equivalent in size to a million books. The UC Berkeley Library has 8 million volumes, and the average quality of the Berkeley library content is much, much higher! If 10% of the material on the Web is ``useful,'' then that means there are about 100,000 useful book-equivalents on the Web, which is the size of good public library. The actual figure for ``useful'' is probably more like 1%, which is 10,000 books, or half the size of an average mall bookstore.
http://people.ischool.berkeley.edu/~hal/Papers/japan/index.h...
I'm leaning strongly toward curation via tagging, using standard ontologies, and vetted through designated / qualified experts for top content. A mix of crowdsourcing and expertise seems most viable.
Quasi-related -- a rant on Pocket suggesting improved "tags" functionality (I swear there's another, better, though I cannot find it in the usual places).
Also youtube is an amazing resource that books can't compete with.
Tags and ontologies also can't compete with search, Bigquery and data lakes.
Currently, the predominant business model for commercial search engines is advertising. The goals of the advertising business model do not always correspond to providing quality search to users. For example, in our prototype search engine one of the top results for cellular phone is "The Effect of Cellular Phone Use Upon Driver Attention", a study which explains in great detail the distractions and risk associated with conversing on a cell phone while driving.... It is clear that a search engine which was taking money for showing cellular phone ads would have difficulty justifying the page that our system returned to its paying advertisers. For this type of reason and historical experience with other media [Bagdikian 83], we expect that advertising funded search engines will be inherently biased towards the advertisers and away from the needs of the consumers.
Including in my tagging schemas for Pocket are quality indicators. I've been using an arbitrarily selected ranking scale of "a-1, a-2, ... a-5" to indicate quality (higher is better), and also tagging items with keywords indicating negative attributes (usually "bullshit", though others apply).
Being able to group classifications by reputation of author or publisher is also a key element. While there are hazards in argument from authority, there are frequently benefits both to recognising expertise and identifying non-credible or impeached sources. If a source routinely pursues some objective rather than the truth, you might tend to question its value.
PageRank essentially relies on the implicit reputation vetting of links, using link sources as a basis for quality assessment. It's useful but also limited. And as noted, the bias toward advertising and specific gain (see also Celine's 2nd Law, from Robert Anton Wilson's "Illuminatus" trilogy) raises issues.
I've been doing significant amounts of research, much of it online, but much also tracking down published book and article sources (most of those through illicit download sites -- really the only way the information can be obtained reasonably), and what I'm finding is that the noise associated with online data is just boggling.
Books, it turns out, compete exceptionally well with YouTube. Ultimately they compliment one another. Sometimes I want to read, sometimes I want a lecture or demo. Both have their place.
Excessive data ultimately isn't illuminating.
Yes, online search can be useful at finding out, say, what's happening right here, now (transit applications are a huge one), or within a given social circle, but both of those are domains in which an exclusion scope is set which rules out virtually all available results -- you're looking for information about a specific location and time, or concerning a specific group of people.
When it comes to general information, "reliable sources" dwindle. If you're looking for some established authority or text, you're left with the specific sources. If it's news, typically you're going to want some vetted news source -- and yes, that includes informally vetted sources on Twitter or YouTube. One of the most annoying things about both sources are the crap leaches who instantly show up to clog any trending keyword topic with crap content. That shit's got to get stomped hard.
For new and developing information, ways to broadly pre-filter and bubble up quality content are an interesting problem and one I'm actively working on. Community rather than broadcast methods strike me as more viable.
Also, I wouldn't imagine there to be any sort of IP to such an idea, as the sites listed belong to other people/companies.
Yahoo had a form that allowed you to submit your site to be added to the directory. You included the URL and categories you would like to be listed in. It would then be evaluated and added by a Yahoo employee. It was one of the first things I would do after creating a new web site in the early 90s.
So in a way, with something like the way Netflix replaced explicit star-ratings based recommendations with viewing-history based recommendations, we are still looking for curation but in a subtler, more algorithmic way... same with Google PageRank and Facebook Newsfeed for that matter. Maybe algorithmic filtering is just curation at scale.
1. Deleting from history any "poison" content -- generally, stupid shit -- "that corner of YouTube" stuff, helps.
2. I've largely abandoned logged-in use of YouTube for numerous reasons. Its app is all but unusable due to pre-roll ads. (Tasteful banners I can stomach.). Routinely purging all history, and/or resetting device ID helps.
3. Purposeful and directed use of YouTube, or, frankly, any other service, is best. Search for what you're interested in and read/view that. Much of my use is autodidactic and informational. There's actually a wealth of information online now, if you can filter out the crud.
4. Being able to blacklist the stupid shit channels would help a hell of a lot. If I could personally banish to the depths of Hades any channel that posted stupid crap, things would be markedly improved.
#3 is my usual mode for initial watching, but I'm prone to go with suggestions from that when I'm watching. Sometimes, even with best intentions, it gets messy.
Number 4, that would be most excellent. :D
(I've also noticed that, well fed and pruned, YouTube's suggestions actually tend toward useful these days, though that's with exceptionally aggressive pruning.)
Yet another option is to use youtube-dl to download and play content locally. I do this pretty much exclusively on desktop, and find it quite helpful.
So nowadays what you'd previously look up in something like dmoz you now just search for in Google.
When I'm doing market research or looking for certain types of information, being aware of forums like HN is more productive.
Long term the movement of everything behind walled gardens like Facebook will make it worse.