News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by raverbashing on Monday July 04, 2016 @08:11AM (#12030226)
Well, to be honest it is.

In the same way English is (especially spoken one), "mistakes" from the languages that preceded it.

Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by jordigh on Monday July 04, 2016 @08:25AM (#12030277)
Sure, but the article is trying to reduce social stigma against linguistic varieties.

I have a long-lost-now-found sister who grew up in French Switzerland and in black culture in NYC . She's basicaly bilingual in both standard English and in AAVE (as well as Spanish and Swiss French). It's really interesting to hear her switch from AAVE with her rapper friends and coworkers to standard English with everyone else. She will conjugate verbs differently, which is the most obvious change to me, as AAVE has a richer verb system than standard English:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/African_American_Vernacular_En...

Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by michaelchisari on Monday July 04, 2016 @01:57PM (#12032082)
Most people who haven't been exposed to AAVE don't realize that it has rules, and grammar, just like Standard English.

That's why when people who don't speak AAVE try and "fake it", it doesn't sound right at all. It's not just an accent with some slang words thrown in.

Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by dudul on Monday July 04, 2016 @08:55AM (#12030411)
Cool link. It's interesting to see that it seems to be a dialect that is not based on geography, but based on race and income.

On a side note, as a non native English speaker, the double negative always sounds really awful to me :) You can call it dialect all you want, it just doesn't make any sense.

Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by tptacek on Monday July 04, 2016 @01:02PM (#12031797)
You should re-read the essay, which spends considerable time on the double negative. Ironically, not speaking English might make a reader more comfortable with double-negatives, which are, for instance, a feature of mainstream Italian.
Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by mikeash on Monday July 04, 2016 @03:11PM (#12032441)
French too, and you'd be hard-pressed to find a language more stuffy or proscriptive. How many languages have a 400-year-old state-sponsored committee whose sole purpose is to guide the language?

It's amazing how difficult it is for people to get past the trap of thinking that what's familiar is "correct."

Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by wnoise on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @09:55PM (#12040761)
I don't want to call these usages in any of AAVE, French or Italian (the ones I've seen usage of) double negatives. They're doubly marked, but it's just one negative.
Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by skywhopper on Monday July 04, 2016 @09:13AM (#12030525)
Lots of languages use multiple negative words to reinforce the negative meaning. Whether it makes sense depends on whether you interpret words like "not" as Boolean operators that "toggle" a binary value or whether you see them as indicators of a negative state that reinforce each other to serve as indicators of intensity or certainty. Since "standard" Engliah doesn't use "double negatives" anyway I feel it's more of a clever overloading than a logical paradox.
Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by halomru on Monday July 04, 2016 @09:47AM (#12030727)
With all other words relating to absence of negation English uses the "binary toggle" interpretation (which is only binary as long as the described concept is binary). For example "Nobody is never not doing it" is equivalent to "nobody is at least sometimes doing it" is equivalent to "everybody never does it".

Two negations on different parts of the sentence also don't reinforce each other: "not everyone is not doing it" if equivalent to "some people are doing it".

To me treating double negative as reinforcement of the negation is a weird, unintuitive corner case that doesn't fit in the broader framework of the English language.

Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by tptacek on Monday July 04, 2016 @01:05PM (#12031820)
You're of course welcome to present your own analysis on how negation and double-negation fit into the broader framework of the English language.

But be aware that these kinds of arguments bear striking similarities to the arguments we have about the singular "they", which someone on a message board will always seem to have ironclad logical arguments against, only to find their argument foiled by incontrovertible evidence of its acceptability in Standard English.

Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by unclenoriega on Monday July 04, 2016 @01:44PM (#12032013)
Treating multiple negation as reinforcement may be weird and unintuitive to you, but earlier English speakers would disagree. In fact, it is the "binary toggle" negation that is the impostor in English, having been grafted from Latin by 18th century grammarians.

http://www.macmillandictionaryblog.com/aint-nothin-wrong-wit...

Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by skywhopper on Monday July 04, 2016 @04:41PM (#12032883)
Double negatives as reinforcement fit just fine in several English dialects. Whether they do so in _your_ dialect is something you can judge. But any argument that depends on language features being "intuitive" or avoiding "corner cases" doesn't take into account how human language actually works. Double negatives would hardly be the most unintuitive feature of English.
Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by kaitai on Monday July 04, 2016 @03:19PM (#12032489)
Both assertions there are false. There are lots of loan words (are those mistakes?), new words (like internet -- a mistake?), plain disagreements (I am strongly in favor of the Oxford comma yet apparently intelligent people disagree), and different grammatical structures surviving from historical sources. Remember, there are Appalachian dialects based on Elizabethan English [1]. Should we all switch to that, since it's more "authentically" English? I bet they don't have words for half the foods you could eat in San Francisco.

Evolution is not always just by way of mistakes!

[1] http://www.wvculture.org/history/journal_wvh/wvh30-2.html

Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by PaulRobinson on Monday July 04, 2016 @08:35AM (#12030324)
To refer to these variations as a "mistake" is the problem.

The English I am using to write this comment would be incomprehensible to my great-great-great-great-great-great-grandparents.

The version we are using here is acceptable because it is the form that those in power have accepted. To assume a variation is incorrect because the elites have rejected usage of that version makes the argument extremely political.

Perhaps we should just accept it is an evolving language and vernaculars, dialects and variations are perfectly fine. If it is useful to a community to teach one of those in their schools rather than RP/Queen's English/Standard English, to decry that and insist it is wrong is to make a political argument about the right to identity as a community.

Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by zipwitch on Monday July 04, 2016 @09:16AM (#12030543)
>The English I am using to write this comment would be incomprehensible to my great-great-great-great-great-great-grandparents.

Not necessarily. For example, take this: "Harold is swift. His hand is strong and his word grim. Late in life he went to his wife in Rome."

That's grammatically complete and fully intelligible Old English. It would be perfectly readable to anyone from 1200+ years ago who had mastered the modern alphabet and spelling conventions.

Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by mcguire on Monday July 04, 2016 @11:35PM (#12034263)
But only if written; it's more unfamiliar pronounced: http://faculty.virginia.edu/OldEnglish/Guide.Readings/wave/p...

By the way, that's a made-up example from an Old English textbook. How about:

Lord's Prayer I (Exeter Book,10th c.) [....]g fæder, þu þe on heofonum eardast, geweorðad wuldres dreame. Sy þinum weorcum halgad noma niþþa bearnum; þu eart nergend wera. Cyme þin rice wide, ond þin rædfæst willa aræred under rodores hrofe, eac þon on rumre foldan. Syle us to dæge domfæstne blæd, hlaf userne, helpend wera, 8 þone singalan, soðfæst meotod. Ne læt usic costunga cnyssan to swiðe, ac þu us freodom gief, folca waldend, from yfla gewham, a to widan feore. (The Exeter Book, ed. Krapp and Dobbie 1936)

http://www.ruf.rice.edu/~kemmer/Words04/history/paternoster....

Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by Bromskloss on Monday July 04, 2016 @08:48AM (#12030382)
> To refer to these variations as a "mistake" is the problem.

But, surely, some variations are mistakes, whereas others might have come about as a deliberate and thought out breaking of an existing rule.

Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by skywhopper on Monday July 04, 2016 @09:16AM (#12030545)
Mistakes are possible but language variants with different rules are not "mistakes" no matter why the variation came about. Intentional thought or planning is behind about 0.5% of our standard English. Why hold other dialects to a higher standard?
Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by Bromskloss on Monday July 04, 2016 @09:25AM (#12030594)
> Why hold other dialects to a higher standard?

I'm not. I'm perfectly fine with saying that language A (be it well established or not) is language B with mistakes, even if language B itself came about through mistakes.

Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by skywhopper on Monday July 04, 2016 @04:35PM (#12032854)
"Mistakes" only in the context of language B. But if they are speaking language A, why would you even use the word "mistakes"?
Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by Bromskloss on Monday July 04, 2016 @05:17PM (#12033062)
I don't mean that everyone who speaks makes mistakes by doing so. I mean that the language came about through mistakes. That, in my view, makes it quite appropriate to say that language A is language B with me stakes.
Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by TazeTSchnitzel on Monday July 04, 2016 @08:53AM (#12030406)
Native speakers do make mistakes, but a persistent “mistake” which is an ordinary feature of how many people speak, is perhaps not such a thing at all.
Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by Bromskloss on Monday July 04, 2016 @09:26AM (#12030599)
It came about as a mistake, that's what I'm concentrating on.
Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by ebfbsf on Monday July 04, 2016 @09:49AM (#12030742)
But since you've already acknowledged that this is equally true of all dialects (that they form as a result of "mistakes") then why are you concentrating on it especially in regard to AAVE? Hmm...
Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by Bromskloss on Monday July 04, 2016 @10:21AM (#12030922)
> why are you concentrating on it especially in regard to AAVE?

What? It's what the post is about.

Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by dang on Monday July 04, 2016 @01:14PM (#12031862)
Let's not have middlebrow dismissals of entire branches of linguistics, please. I'm sure Pullum is more aware than you and I are of how language evolves via "mistakes".
Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by rmc on Monday July 04, 2016 @08:40AM (#12030343)
"mistake" is a loaded term, which includes a meaning of being wrong, and deserving of being erradicated; so much so that people don't use it for Standard English. But people who are using it for AAVE are intentionally trying to use the loaded meaning of "mistake"
Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by erehweb on Monday July 04, 2016 @09:48AM (#12030736)
Would you also accept "Standard English is AAVE with mistakes"?
Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by raverbashing on Monday July 04, 2016 @10:02AM (#12030815)
No because AAVE came from Standard English