News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple iPhones Found to Have Violated Chinese Rival’s Patent by patrickaljord on Friday June 17, 2016 @10:31AM (#11922819)
Chinese brands get constantly harassed by Apple lawyers in the US about patents. Now that China is an important market for Apple, I find it hard to feel sorry for Apple getting a taste of their own medicine.
Re:Apple iPhones Found to Have Violated Chinese Rival’s Patent by vvanders on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:48AM (#11923323)
Yup, used to work for HTC and some of the bullshit that Apple used to pull still pisses me off to this day.

Remember the whole "click on a phone-number launch dialer" patent? We pulled the feature in the US phones, following the letter of the law since we lost the suit(back when Apple was going for Mfgrs instead of Google).

Apple filed an injunction with Customs right as we went into a huge marketing push for one of our devices. We had millions of phones sitting on the docks while FTC "investigated". 4-5 weeks later it was found that we hadn't violated, Apple never paid any fines and we had a ton of pissed off customers who couldn't get phones.

http://www.wired.com/2012/05/apples-patent-win-delays-shipme...

Re:Apple iPhones Found to Have Violated Chinese Rival’s Patent by uremog on Friday June 17, 2016 @02:50PM (#11924733)
But really how could a patent officer think such a thing is worthy of a patent?
Re:Apple iPhones Found to Have Violated Chinese Rival’s Patent by WildUtah on Friday June 17, 2016 @04:22PM (#11925313)
Patent examiners don't have discretion. The special patent court (CAFC) is filled with patent lawyers that decide cases based on their own personal interest in a more expansive patent system. Except where the Supreme Court reviews their cases, they have total power to set precedents and those precedents always favor trolls over creators and innovators.

http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2012/09/how-a-rogue-appea...

Re:Apple iPhones Found to Have Violated Chinese Rival’s Patent by stcredzero on Friday June 17, 2016 @04:33PM (#11925369)
I've traded comments with those guys on reddit. They live in a completely different reality. And people said Steve Jobs had a "reality distortion field." He had nothing on those guys.
Re:Apple iPhones Found to Have Violated Chinese Rival’s Patent by vec on Friday June 17, 2016 @04:58PM (#11925513)
Do you have any examples? I completely believe you, but I'd love to know exactly which flavor of mass delusion we're dealing with.
Re:Apple iPhones Found to Have Violated Chinese Rival’s Patent by stcredzero on Friday June 17, 2016 @06:01PM (#11925820)
I'd have to do some search-fu in my reddit comment history. What I remember of it, is that the trolly-vagueness of patent claims is entirely necessary for the system to work as well as it does, and that the patent system is a well-honed machine essential to the proper functioning of our economy.
Re:Apple iPhones Found to Have Violated Chinese Rival’s Patent by oblio on Friday June 17, 2016 @06:18PM (#11925908)
Re:Apple iPhones Found to Have Violated Chinese Rival’s Patent by aserafini on Friday June 17, 2016 @04:03PM (#11925215)
Agreed, this should never have been a patent.
Re:Apple iPhones Found to Have Violated Chinese Rival’s Patent by 3pt14159 on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:35AM (#11923246)
...Shouldn't they?

China is great in many ways, but it's IP / Copyright protection is abysmal and is used by the state as propaganda / propaganda control.

Portray China negatively in a film? Oh look, no sales the few theatres that are showing it have the scenes altered and of course don't pay royalties.

Neutrally portray China? Oh look about 1% of the royalties you were supposed to get.

Portray China positively? Blockbuster Chinese release. Unprecedented sales, collect nearly 80% of the royalties you were supposed to.

They have the same Real Politik handle on technology. They're not going to respect American Patents until it suits them. Not to say we're blameless; but if it is too asymmetrical I could see the west imposing levies to rectify the imbalance.

Re:Apple iPhones Found to Have Violated Chinese Rival’s Patent by progressive_dad on Friday June 17, 2016 @03:29PM (#11925007)
The US needs to set some ground rules with our Chinese rivals...

Start with requiring occupancy of all homes held by foreign nationals, trusts or investment groups, or you pay enormous property tax increases.

Then you require all US businesses selling consumer products to staff at least 1 US resident inspector for each stage of the supply chain from raw goods to finished product. If the host country doesn't like it, then you can't do business with that host country. This inspector may be called before Congress to answer personally (with jail time) for any human rights abuses not reported in the supply chain.

Re:Apple iPhones Found to Have Violated Chinese Rival’s Patent by sheepleherd on Friday June 17, 2016 @04:00PM (#11925199)
Yeah but the world is not a pretty place, at home we have monopolistic unicorns, and abroad we have unfair business practices... I'm not shedding any tears for Apple, screw'em.

Even if the US is a relatively "clean" place to do business today, when we were the up and coming upstart, we stole plenty of ideas from abroad, and even within: the whole reason synecdotal Hollywood is in literal Hollywood is, movie producers snuck out there from the East Coast so they could infringe on Edison's film patents and get away with it.

Relatively poorer economies are never going to sit by and let large foreign industries dominate their economies if they can do anything about it. And we shouldn't expect relatively poorer economies to have deeply embedded free market economists explaining the theory of comparative advantage to every populist politician.

Re:Apple iPhones Found to Have Violated Chinese Rival’s Patent by progressive_dad on Tuesday June 21, 2016 @12:50PM (#11947127)
If demanding humane working conditions is globally anti-competitive call me Mr. Monopoly.
Re:Apple iPhones Found to Have Violated Chinese Rival’s Patent by dragontamer on Friday June 17, 2016 @04:30PM (#11925347)
> The US needs to set some ground rules with our Chinese rivals...

Unlikely to work. China knows what works in their country. I think the TPP approach where we just lay ground rules with people who actually respect us (ie: Singapore, Malaysia, Vietnam) and try to get these countries to work with us instead of China... this is a better approach.

I mean, what is the US supposed to say to China? Stop doing things... in your country? That we don't like?

It's China's country. They can do whatever they want. Especially since US Companies are so enamored with the hope of making profits over there.

Re:Apple iPhones Found to Have Violated Chinese Rival’s Patent by progressive_dad on Friday June 17, 2016 @10:16PM (#11926694)
I'm just tired of hearing, "but we didn't know working conditions were so bad!" from US owned businesses. You damn well should have.
Re:Apple iPhones Found to Have Violated Chinese Rival’s Patent by yompers888 on Friday June 17, 2016 @03:59PM (#11925194)
On the first point, can't that be achieved by the municipality which (presumably) also assesses those property taxes? That just seems like an issue of the city needing to not whore themselves out to foreign speculators in the name of growth.

On the bright side, I've heard from some realtors that the previously-common occurrence of Chinese nationals patrolling for houses to buy with cash has dropped off substantially in 2016.

Re:Apple iPhones Found to Have Violated Chinese Rival’s Patent by xienze on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:31AM (#11923218)
Hmm I feel quite the opposite here. China has a, um, less than stellar record when it comes to prosecuting Chinese companies that engage in IP theft and patent infringement. But then they want to get high and mighty when the shoe is on the other foot...
Re:Apple iPhones Found to Have Violated Chinese Rival’s Patent by Razengan on Friday June 17, 2016 @03:21PM (#11924954)
"Own medicine?" Have you somehow missed China's bizarre and BLATANT copying and ripoffs of just about every single popular product on the planet for the last two decades?

I live in a third-world country, where it has become almost impossible to get basic stuff (tools, lights, everyday household items) that doesn't break down after a month thanks to cheap Chinese knockoffs shamelessly muscling every other company off the local market. Almost nobody wants to stock "genuine" brands.

Even if I wasn't an Apple fan I would be rooting for them here; they seem to be the only company big enough to fight back against China's crap.

Re:Apple iPhones Found to Have Violated Chinese Rival’s Patent by Razengan on Saturday June 18, 2016 @02:07AM (#11927309)
"Almost impossible" may be a slight exaggeration in a few major cities here, but otherwise the frustration still holds true.

The worst part about this glut of Chinese products is that there's no one to complain to; nowhere to get customer support from, and you can't easily know who to avoid either because one company may make essentially the same thing in a hundred different guises with slight visual variation but the same lack of quality or safety control.

As for all the imitations, I don't even know why they do this. Why pretend to be a popular brand (sometimes with a slightly different logo and/or a typo in the name) instead of selling your own product and identity? Why make people the world over have to be consciously vigilant about avoiding Chinese imitations? What are they hoping to prove?

Back in the 80s and early 90s, "Made in Japan" became a synonym for quality and people sought out products with that written on them. China may have made their name globally relevant but to the general public it has become synonymous with shoddiness.

Re:Apple iPhones Found to Have Violated Chinese Rival’s Patent by ryao on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:21PM (#11923998)
Is it possible that the 100C was based on iPhone 6 mock ups that leaked and the Chinese company copied it to get it to market first?

This would not be the first time this happened:

http://www.androidauthority.com/goophone-sue-apple-china-112...

Re:Apple iPhones Found to Have Violated Chinese Rival’s Patent by WildUtah on Friday June 17, 2016 @04:29PM (#11925341)
That's how design patents work in the USA, also. If you can get secret designs from a competitor and patent them first, you can then wait for the product to become popular and sue.

And design patents are not considered to require examination as to content in the USA. They're just approved if the forms are filled out correctly.

And if any part of the design of a product (even just one rounded corner on a $700 phone) resembles a patented design, you're entitled to 100% of the profit ever made on that product in the USA. China is nowhere near that shifty.

Re:Apple iPhones Found to Have Violated Chinese Rival’s Patent by NEDM64 on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:30PM (#11926928)
Doesn't need to.

It's very different from the 6, and Apple has launched the iPod Touch in 2012, which is practically identical to the 2014 iPhone 6.

Re:Apple iPhones Found to Have Violated Chinese Rival’s Patent by ellyagg on Friday June 17, 2016 @02:17PM (#11924444)
Is there a name for a logical fallacy where actions are claimed to be morally equivalent if merely their shapes are the same and regardless of the details?
Re:Apple iPhones Found to Have Violated Chinese Rival’s Patent by sker on Friday June 17, 2016 @02:53PM (#11924760)
False equivalence: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_equivalence

I see it all the time on the Internet:

- Atheists are "just as bad as" [insert religious group with millennia-old history of atrocities.] -- Just because they both try to convince you of something.

- Politician A is "just as corrupt as" Politician B. -- Nevermind that A just gave his cousin a job, while B gave away $500B in contracts to his sponsors.

Re:Apple iPhones Found to Have Violated Chinese Rival’s Patent by nxzero on Friday June 17, 2016 @10:46AM (#11922918)
Not hard to believe, but would it be possible to provide an example or two of Apple winning a patent claim in court via a ruling in China? I would find it hard to believe the for a valid claim that just because a company is Chinese that it would have any impact on a case in the America.
Re:Apple iPhones Found to Have Violated Chinese Rival’s Patent by sangnoir on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:24AM (#11923171)
While not a Chinese company, I remember Samsung winning an ITC import ban of Apple products. Obama promptly overturned/vetoed the ban[1]. I do not doubt for a second that american institutions (especially the executive) do what is best for "American Interests"

1. http://www.fastcompany.com/3015243/where-are-they-now/obama-...

Re:Apple iPhones Found to Have Violated Chinese Rival’s Patent by jdmichal on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:03AM (#11923019)
I read it as, the Chinese companies (or their US subsidiary) get sued in US courts for US patents. With that reading, I'm not sure your request makes sense.
Re:Apple iPhones Found to Have Violated Chinese Rival’s Patent by wahsd on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:09AM (#11923066)
That's a rather imbalanced perspective. China has grown not through organic development and innovation, but through global, state sponsored, commercial espionage; and in a country where the state is inextricably linked to even the "private" corporations.

I'm no fan of Apple's ways sometimes, but it's like comparing a borderline unscrupulous business to an organized crime outfit.

It would not surprise me one bit if this whole "patent violation" is nothing but a sham to fool people like you into believing there's some legitimacy behind efforts to sabotage Apple taking over the market from Chinese firms / state control.

Re:Apple iPhones Found to Have Violated Chinese Rival’s Patent by pinaceae on Friday June 17, 2016 @10:58AM (#11922993)
oh these poor, poor chinese knock-offs that get harrassed, harrassed! by apple lawyers.

now where is the iphone produced again? it's a chinese phone sans the IP (designed by apple in cali).

Re:Apple iPhones Found to Have Violated Chinese Rival’s Patent by umanwizard on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:22AM (#11923155)
The iPhone is assembled in China, but all the really complicated parts (screen, radio, processor, ...) are made elsewhere.
Re:Apple iPhones Found to Have Violated Chinese Rival’s Patent by 20andup on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:29AM (#11923209)
Quite condescending. Definitely not what I expect from a post on hacker news. There was no mention that these companies created Chinese knockoffs. On the other hand, I see it as a patent dispute by predatory companies.
Re:Apple iPhones Found to Have Violated Chinese Rival’s Patent by blisterpeanuts on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:06PM (#11923836)
>> Now that China is an important market for Apple, I find it hard to feel sorry for Apple getting a taste of their own medicine.

Even if the plaintiff is a patent troll, or merely an obscure company with a bogus patent? Even if this "patent tribunal" ruled incorrectly because of bias toward the domestic company? Even if the tribunal had been bribed by the company (pure speculation, but bribery is how you get things done in China's bureaucracy)?

I don't tend to have emotions one way or the other about these kinds of commercial and legal disputes, but corruption and patent trolling seems a lot more likely than big evil Apple stealing the innocent Baili Co.'s intellectual property and getting their comeuppance.